U.S. Economic Forecasting: GE vs. The Fed.
NAME PREDICTION David Resler In response to your survey, I would opt to Chief Economist, attend the next GE Board meeting. GE is Nomura Securities arguably the most diversified corporation in International, Inc. the world and its board members include leaders from industries such as food products, paper, and auto parts that are less important to GE's operations. In contrast, the District Bank presidents do not seem to have better data on ALL businesses which can be gleaned from public sources. The exception, of course, is their information on the banks in their district, but that information would be generally less useful to forecasting than the up-to-the minute assessment one could hear at a GE Board meeting. Susan M. Phillips The Federal Reserve's twelve regional Dean, School of presidents. After listening to their comments Business & Public in FOMC meetings, I came to respect the breadth Management, George of their knowledge and critical analysis of Washington industrial, agricultural, financial and service University & former sectors, often coming from conversations with Federal Reserve CEO's or sector leaders, and surveys and Governor. regional studies. After such a session, I always felt I had a better understanding of the breadth, depth, and diversity of economic conditions affecting various parts of the country. Matthew Spiegel I would pick the Fed officials. Interest Professor of rates and the money supply have a lot more Finance, Yale to do with the overall economy than nearly School of anything else. Management. Robert Dederick Of the two, I'll take the Fed Executive VP & presidents--but Alan Chief Economist, Greenspan's private thoughts The Northern are my real choice. Trust Company. Richard N. Cooper For the near-term future direction of the U.S. Maurits C. Boas economy, I would prefer to listen to the Professor of private thoughts of the twelve regional International Federal Reserve presidents. They sit on Economics, the Open Market Committee, and their job, Harvard inter alia, is to track developments in University. the U.S. economy. They poll their respective regions and draw on competent staffs to form their judgments. General Electric's board meeting, while drawing on much practical experience, would be too parochial, too focused on GE's next strategic acquisitions and dispositions to rely on for an overview of the U.S. economy. Gary Hufbauer GE, of course. Both the Fed and GE Reginald Jones span the U.S. economy. Both the Fed Senior Fellow, and GE have a superstar: respectively, Institute for Alan Greenspan and Jack Welch. International But GE has far stronger contacts in the Economics. global economy, and the experience of its board far exceeds the Fed. Murray Weidenbaum I'd go for sitting in on a GE Board meeting, Chairman, Center mainly because of the global orientation for the Study of of the company and the board. American Business & Mallinckrodt Distinguished University Professor, Washington University. Rudolph G. I'd choose to listen to the Federal Reserve Penner presidents. They know what people like Senior Fellow, those on the GE board are thinking AND The Urban they know what people on the Federal Institute. Open Market Committee are thinking. Mike Englund I would opt for the Fed officials. The Chief Market conduct of monetary policy has a more Economist, measurable effect on the U.S. business Standard & cycle over the short run than the decisions Poor's of an individual firm or industry. MMS International. Over the long run, neither Fed policy makers nor business executives have significant inside information, so their long-run perspectives are of only limited value beyond the publicly known set of opinions of all the world's experts. If I was going to gain value by "listening in," I would want to obtain actionable "inside" information which would likely only be of short-run significance and which, preferably, would be about the near-term course of monetary policy if my interest was in the overall economy. Stanley F. My choice would be General Electric. Druckenmiller Chairman, Duquesne Capital Management.