Thinking, Fast and Slow.
Sutton, Geoffrey W.
THINKING, FAST AND SLOW. Daniel Kahne man, Farar, Starus and
Grioux, New York, NY, 2011. Pp 499, Hb., $30.00. ISBN 978-0-874-275631.
Kahneman's analysis of thinking is close to a metatheory of
human nature. In highly readable prose he explains how numerous
psychological experiments document the interplay of two ways human
brains process and act upon the myriad of stimuli encountered in daily
life. Many reviews have extolled the brilliance of the book and its
Nobel-prize winning author. My skeptical bias against excessive public
endorsements was on high alert until I began to read. My copy has so
many notes that it was hard to condense them for this review. I must
confess this was one of the best psychology books I have ever read. I
hope to show why readers of JPC will benefit from Kahneman's
insights.
Daniel Kahneman is Eugene Higgins Professor of Psychology Emeritus
at Princeton University and Professor of Psychology and Public Affairs
Emeritus at Princeton's Woodrow Wilson School of Public and
International Affairs. His work with Amos Tversky on decision-making
earned him the 2002 Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences. If Amos had not
died in 1996, he would have shared the prize. I have included two
primary references (Kahneman & Tversky, 1984; Tversky &
Kahneman, 1974) cited by the Nobel committee as examples of research
articles you may wish to obtain.
Return to the title for a moment. The four words aptly describe the
way we think and the sequence matters. Fast thinking is the norm. We
quickly orient to the sound of a loud bang. If it's July 4th in the
USA, we easily attribute the BOOM to a partying neighbor rather than
some mischief-maker. On a drive we speedily process a garish image and a
few inviting words written large on a billboard. Almost without
thinking, we detect a hurt facial response in a partner and quickly
search available memory for an answer to the internal prompt, "What
did I say?" The second concept in the title is slow thinking. Slow
thinking is that arduous process most of humanity avoids most of each
day. It is the thinking that requires cognitive effort to focus
carefully on a set of stimuli whilst ignoring other internal and
external distractions so we can search memory and employ other resources
to solve a problem. Sometimes the problems are not incredibly difficult
but the answers do not quickly arise in our consciousness like recalling
our telephone number or slowing down and scanning more carefully when
guiding our car into a narrow parking slot.
The components of the thinking process appear to be organized into
these two major systems, simply labeled System I and System II. System I
is automatic and works well enough for most daily activities. As
Kahneman points out, it's not practical to be vigilant all day.
System II seems to engage as needed to address more complex situations.
The effort required by System II does not come easy and seems to slow
down not just thought, but the entire person as we might interrupt a
walk to formulate an answer to an unusual question. This story of
thinking unfolds in 38 chapters organizing diverse dimensions of
condition into five parts: Two Systems, Heuristics and Biases,
Overconfidence, Choices, and Two Selves.
Most of us seem to get along pretty well most of the time. But
there are those moments when mistakes are costly. Truth is, many
decisions are adequate but hardly based on refined decision-making
models that employ logical analyses or even well-defined probability
models. Heuristics and biases appear to account for the link between
thinking and human behavior. Our propensity to respond based on
available cues in our environment or memory, to assess situations based
on plausible causes, and erroneously predict behavior can lead to
significant difficulties for individuals, groups, or even nations. Part
II offers a broad review of these cognitive errors.
Overconfidence is the essence of Part III. People tend toward
excessive optimism and overconfidence. We experience illusions of
understanding and validity. We are prone to excessive and often
misplaced trust in experts. In Part IV, Kahneman reviews choice theory,
which he explains using everyday examples. We leave this part of the
narrative better equipped to detect factors apt to lead us astray. In
Part V, Kahneman offers a helpful review and leaves us with thoughts
about life.
It is easy to see how Kahneman's work would be of interest to
academicians and researchers. But the implications for psychotherapists
are far reaching and illustrate how hard it is to interrupt error-prone
cognitive-behavioral patterns to apply some new cognitive frame or
employ a new behavioral response. Rituals and responses often labeled as
spiritual or religious appear to be System I responses except when
interrupted by troubling experiences that place our scripts on pause and
induce a search for resources. An awareness of biases and the role of
heuristics and overconfidence are relevant to clinicians, clinical
supervisors, consultants, and clients. There's a time for System I
and a time for System II.
References
Kahneman, D. & Tversky, A. (1985). Choices, values, and frames.
American Psychologist, 34, 571-582.
Tversky, A. & Kahneman, D. (1974). Judgment under uncertainty:
Heuristics and biases, Science, 185, 1124-1131.
Reviewed by Geoffrey W. Sutton (Evangel University/ Springfield,
MO).