New requirements facing the training of engineers for economic gobalization.
Cus, F. ; Balic, J.
1. Introduction
Employment structures change in correlation with the social
progress and the fact that machines are replacing humans; the number of
manual workers drops, while the functions of control, management and
organization are multiplying, which results in strengthening the need
for mental capacities of employees at all levels. In industrialized
countries scarcely even a quarter of employees actually work in
industry. The transition from the industrial into the service society is
in full progress and is taking place at full speed. Radical structural
changes are taking place in technology, economy and society.
Those structural changes are characterized by:
* complexity of technical and economic processes
* internationalization and globalization of production and markets,
* strengthening of competition due to relocating research and
production into cheaper environments,
* ambivalent attitude of society towards technology and ambivalence
of technology itself.
Is the Engineer of tomorrow only a technician? New traits of
structural changes impose new activities on employees because of
accelerated innovation burdened with higher-quality and cheaper
production and improved offer of services. This is enabled by
reorganization of hitherto management structures and work in companies.
This trend is oriented away from the horizontal and vertical stable
structure to open, flexible and user friendly organization systems. The
hierarchy is reduced, the decision competences are taken to the
operational level and the work areas are professionally and functionally
interconnected.
2. Employers Understand Quality as the Knowledge and Skills of
Graduates
However, the quality of training has a completely different meaning
for students. In their opinion quality is to be focused on industrial
development and preparation to reach a certain position in the society.
Changed orientation in companies' work and decision processes
also impose changes on engineers because of training profiles and their
employability [2]. As a consequence of those structural changes other
skills apart from professional capacities are required from engineers:
* team work (skill and readiness for interdisciplinary cooperation
in work an decision-making teams),
* methodological competences (skill and readiness for systematic
and connected thinking and action),
* social competences (integration of social, political, economic,
ecological and ethical dimensions of engineering planning and acting in
the development and implementation of techniques) and language
competences, mobility and flexibility (capacity of living in
internationally structured professional and work environment).
All this imposes the need for radical changes of education
structure, selection of study contents and learning methods as required
by the Bologna reforms of the existing education system. Education,
formal and informal, must serve the society as a tool for strengthening
creativity, development and expansion of know-how and science; knowledge
and teaching must be accessible to all.
In Slovenia attention must be paid in order to avoid
'politicisation' of the educational and cultural values and a
drop in the government's interest in economic modernisation.[1] If
that should happen, the universities and colleges would become merely a
tool of the political struggle and appendix of the government apparatus.
3. Economic Globalization has Set In
As the globalization process is ever nearer to the entire
population of the planet without restraint, the awareness increased that
"my neighbour may not be similar to me". Many people might be
alarmed by that fact, since it ruins the stable traditional idea of
neighbourhood, community and nation, devastates the strongly established
ways of relations between human beings and makes ethical diversity
something commonplace.
On the one hand, economic globalization links the producers and
consumers of different continents and areas into a functional relation.
Today's world economic companies are organized in such a way that a
single product can contain components made in a dozen factories in as
many countries. The managers and employees in those companies often
spend more time cruising between these countries than on leisure in the
company of family and friends like the adventurous seekers of happiness
in the past. It would be erroneous to claim that the present
restructuring of the world economic relations does not affect the
personal views and values of all those involved from the unskilled
worker at the assembly-line in a poor country to the user of a product
whose label indicates that it has been made in a remote country. On the
other hand, the rapid growth of communication networks, particularly the
audio-visual media, brings into the homes of millions of people what was
previously a set of unconnected events from remote places, from
metropolitan neighbourhoods to city slums and remote villages, like, for
example, the Asian " tsunami".
Though the former industrial economies are in fact in the process
of deindustrialization and are transferring a great deal of production
capacities into foreign countries, mass immigration of culturally
different people from other countries exerts an increasing pressure on
traditional labour markets and on the social tissue of the host
countries. Slovenia must accept those processes and must be aware that
it is caught in the wave of globalization too.
4. Drawbacks of the Present Training of Engineers
Today at the faculties of mechanical engineering a great number of
young people are preparing themselves either for the scientific work or
for specialized employment. Faculties must continue to be the source
quenching the thirst of knowledge of more and more people regarding in
their curiosity of mind the sense of their existence. In Germany the
following problem areas have been spotted in the implementation
framework of engineering study reforms :
* students lack information about the study process, the system of
universities and colleges, communication and behaviour in scientific
activities of universities,
* overstressed isolated factual knowledge to the detriment of
skills and exercises of methods of learning and work, problem solving,
and presentations,
* strong professional egoism of teachers and lack of coordination
of study contents in study programs,
* tight deadlines imposed on students in terms of required tasks,
group activities or work duties. lack of communication between all
participants of the scientific environment about targets, contents and
organization of studies.
Such problem areas are also present in our university education
system. Fortunately, having thoroughly analysed the situation in the
country, we are attempting to reform the existing system into a system
comparable to Europe and compatible with nearby universities. Many
experts point out that university reforms are viewed with mistrust. In
this area almost all attempts have been made, but the results only
rarely meet the expectations. It seems that in many countries numerous
consecutive and contradictory attempts of reforms only increased the
resistance of university systems to changes. Nevertheless, the changes
in European countries are gradually continuing in the direction of the
Bologna processes, somewhere faster and elsewhere more slowly [3],[4].
5. New Requirements for University Education
Any engineering activity needs a combination of theory and practice
in proper ratio. While in research the theoretic abstract handling of
set problems is in the foreground, the accent in production, assembly,
maintenance, technical sale and service is more on the practical
concrete domain. Talent, inclinations, capacities and skills are
expressed in similar ways differently.
The university system must consider professional practice as well
as the element of students' talent. For economic success it is very
important that all positions in innovation process are occupied by
competent and motivated engineers. The requirements of the degree of
education must be extended to education profiles. Experience shows that
different degrees of education are hardly feasible in the unified form
of university or faculty. Therefore, overall equal-right but different
handling of education is needed in higher technical and university
programs.
The differentiated system of engineering education in Slovenia with
different degrees inside the faculties meets these requirements and
works with all advantages and disadvantages. However, it is most
important that the students finishing both forms of education find jobs
in their field, appropriate for their degree of education [6]. However,
the economic and technological achievements will lose their true
importance if the humanistic and cultural traits do not become the
central ingredient and target of development attempts. In the 21st
century, when the industries are oriented more towards technology and
the human society towards knowledge, the human capital, as developed
with the assistance of education and training, will take on an
increasingly important role.
6. What are the New Contents Requirements of Engineering Education?
Engineering comprises different activities and workplace
characteristics . It depends on various factors, such as the
professional sphere, the employer, company size and other factors
requiring specific knowledge and skills of employees. This variety must
be covered by engineers' basic education [7],[8],[9]. The basis of
engineering education is the spectrum of mathematical-scientific and
technical bases. That basic knowledge is key to understanding natural
phenomena and to applying their principles in technology. They represent
the foundation for the superstructure of the deepened knowledge in the
individual areas of application. A large extent of bases would
preferably allow professional communication with engineers and
scientists from other fields. Interdisciplinary and non-technical
contents receive additional importance. Those contents complement and
complete the professional education of engineers facing complex tasks
for which the technical knowledge and capacities are not sufficient.
In that way engineers reach their market value in the professional
activities. He is capable of solving problems and managing projects
creatively, of behaving cooperatively and highly socially with managing
and communication competences so that responsible, humane and
environment friendly behaviour is encouraged. However, the mere
mastering of the bases of engineering does not yet bring professional
success. To cope with the requirements of professional practice
engineers must deepen their knowledge in a certain technical sphere and
need special knowledge of problem solving methods. Due to the increased
complexity of modern devices and systems overall, it is required to have
insight, systematic thinking and the capacity to communicate at system
level with all project participants. The engineers are expected to cope
with increased requirements to understand the theory because of
increasing complexity of design, manufacture and sale of technical
systems and processes.
The association of German engineers (VDI--Verein Deutscher
Ingenieure) recommends further development of the existing structures of
engineering training. Roughly, they recommend the following structure of
engineering education: 30% mathematical-scientific, 30% technical, and
20% interdisciplinary contents, and another 20% deepened professional
knowledge. The basic knowledge is the foundation for the required future
professional mobility of engineers. However, the renovation and any
proper reform of university education must be a result of deep and
deliberate judgement and understanding of special circumstances and
requirements important for any special situation. Relevant decisions
must be made in common agreement by providing proper answers between all
participating sides in the framework of the medium-term process of
changing university training.
7. Which Crucial Requirements Does an Engineer Face Today?
It goes without saying that engineers must be extremely qualified
to master their narrow professional sphere [9],[10],[11]. Across that
sphere it is crucial that they are able to work in teams. Their thinking
must be logical so that they are able to handle and incorporate in their
work the interdisciplinary topics from environmental protection and
economy which are on the edge of the narrow specialization. They must
understand the assumption of "globalization", which is
important for the growth of the company, they must learn foreign
languages and be ready to work abroad.
At the management level engineers must be ready to take risk, they
must permanently ask themselves different questions, promote
materialization of new ideas, be familiar in time with the dynamics and
instability of new technologies and provide overall solutions with the
capacity of clear public justification, and have the capacity of
communicating with experts and non-experts, since the dialogue with
society is more and more emphasized. All the above mentioned demands and
properties cannot be acquired during their studies, which are becoming
shorter and shorter. To that end, additional training is necessary as a
complement to the university study. In spite of that the university
programs will have to be adapted to the "soft factors". It is
estimated that in the future more and more people with computer
knowledge will be available. The companies whose power will be outside
the computer spheres will be preferred: the power to eliminate
conflicting matters, cultivate mutual relations within the company and
with other companies, enhance personal responsibility of the employees,
collaboration and increase of trust between superiors and employees,
maintain maximum motivation, integrate employees into the
decision-making process in order to meet the company's targets and
allow participation in success. All that will be incorporated into the
study courses of the future. In addition to their technical competences,
engineers will also master the "soft factors". To train and
qualify such "globally thinking and creative engineers" is an
important competitive task of faculties of mechanical engineering.
Engineers of the future will not be only "technicians",
they will be responsible for the "whole". This is a challenge
for young people wanting to help to organize our world. The work of an
engineer is an interesting, tense and responsible task.
8. Engineers Promote Technological Changes
The society consumes what the engineers have produced. only a few
engineers follow exclusively their ideals and imagination. Most
engineers have some target which is incorporated in the society whose
needs they satisfy by manufacturing products to serve people.
Engineers with greater innovativeness promote technological
changes. Sometimes these are hardly traceable changes, the next time the
idea born causes abrupt changes. Who changes technologies? The answer
is: the society receiving engineers' results. If the society were
satisfied with what it had, engineers would be unemployed. Engineers
should have control over technical sciences; they should recognize if a
new product is good or bad for people and their environment. Do
engineers always act in that sense and eliminate the novelties which
might do harm?
Today, engineers face the objection that they cope with the market
pressures by turning a blind eye. The one they turn blind is the one
that that should pay attention to the environment and ecology.
So, today we are at the stage of changes when our society imposes
accelerated development in two directions. Both should be done by the
engineers. The consumer follows the path of novelties hoping to gain
better facilities, more comfort, and pleasure.
Thus we vividly jump from novelty to novelty and more and more
loudly and audaciously call for the next "trick" of the
technical blessing. The first direction requires technical development,
while the second direction establishes that someone has to dispose of
the waste. To follow both directions engineers are needed who meet the
market needs and cause as little waste as possible [12].
Up to what speed of technological changes will it be possible to
define the profile of an engineer who could meet the different demands
of our society? What base of knowledge and capacity must an engineer
have to be able to choose the way leading into the future?
9. Engineer Should Follow Interdisciplinarity
The profile and spectrum of an engineer's activity cannot be
like decades ago, since today our life is marked by three crucial
changes:
* Our society relies completely on technology. Without technology
today's mankind would hardly survive.
* Technical development has made such advances that the
advancements in technology can no more be supervised. The world is
flooded with technical information which cannot be unequivocally
evaluated any more.
* Today, it is already clear to us that our handling of technology
will ruin the base of our existence, our environment.
Therefore, it would be misfortunate if future engineers were to
lead us to rapid technological changes, even though they were the
pioneers who technically shaped the society. The present time requires
another profile of engineers.
primarily, engineers must be able to generalize. Mastering an
individual technique up to the smallest detail is not useful, and may
even be dangerous, if it is not linked with related techniques.
Independent technologies do not exist! To be able to permanently
recognize the crucial contact points in today's flood of
information, engineers must acquire a solid basis for comparison. That
basis consists of the wide basic knowledge and general education.
Engineer have the role of pioneers. They must foresee, consider the
past and provide covering; in a word, they must be mindful. That also
means that they must not carelessly or even euphorically grasp any
attractive technical novelty appearing on the horizon. They must know
who will follow them, since among their followers are not just people
who not know much about technology, but also thinking humanists and
financially strong contemporaries. Therefore, engineers must be able to
lead.
Engineers must recognize technologies useful or harmful to
humanity. They must be constantly aware of the consequences of their
doings.tThey must not allow anything or anybody to turn them away from
the development path they were botn to. Technology is not a sphere of
knowing, remaining in the head, it is not philosophy. The target of
technology is always practical application. Engineers must be brisk
enough to be able to follow technological changes. If they are too slow,
the society escapes them with random technologies. To be quick and
mobile, engineers must not carry heavy ballast. Erudition without true
knowledge, prejudices or science not connected with the basic knowledge
can only be an obstacle.
The centre of engineers' work must not be one-sided picking-up
of knowledge, since their activity must be primarily intended for the
responsible transfer of his knowledge into practical application. In
this sense engineers are different from theoretical scientists. If
engineers restrict themselves to mere acquiring of knowledge, they may
soon end up as a technical archivist hardly contributing to
technological changes.
Engineers must be capable to get an idea of hierarchy of problems
in the context. It is not sufficient that they only recognize the
technological context. It also means: engineers' thinking must be
system-based, so that they can classify what is in the foreground, with
respect to its importance.
Engineers must have team work skills not to get lost on the wrong
path. Due to the extent of today's technological events the time of
the so-called "engineers-hermits" has gone.
Engineer must address the problem. They must not be opportunists
and take the easy way out, even if no one is looking but instead assume
their responsibility towards the society.
Engineers must be time-conscious. Work-shy and less burdened
engineers often do not pay attention to enough in detail and do not
finish in time.
Though technology develops rapidly, engineers must rest at least
with one foot on the ground. Engineers who have left the ground of
reality often do not land where our society needs them.
Engineers must have enough courage to reject a new technique and
revive an old one, if that is better for the human society. Engineers
must never support the blind belief that the newer technique is always
the best. The time-neutral flexibility of thinking will be more and more
important in the coming years. In the future engineers will have to be
more ready to solve problems with the simplest tool. They must never
rely on the idea that the newest technology is always available. Still,
they should always know how to light a fire if electricity fails!
Engineers must work methodically and systematically, they must not
rely on their instincts. However, it is also wrong, if engineers use
methods and procedures thoughtlessly and without feelings.
Engineers must never adopt "finalism". They must always
take into account that other engineers, too, will work on the same
matter. They also should not invent technologies bringing hardly
solvable problems of waste matter disposal.
Engineers must believe in the future. They must not show
unjustified optimism and create unrealistic atmosphere of technical
feasibility.
The sooner the technology changes, the farther into the future the
responsible engineer's thinking must reach. At present speed of
development we are making progress with quick steps and where will the
micro-, information, bio- and other technologies take us to?
Intercepting the accelerated technological development in the whole
sphere of technology, engineers will become more important.
Engineers will be able to do that in the future if they form their
professional identity continuous professional development [14].
Complementary education and post-graduate studies must become an
integral part of engineers' lives!
10. Organization of Study According to the Bologna Processes
The hitherto form of the undergraduate study in Slovenia was
changed with the new law on university education [13]. The Bologna
processes impose reforming of engineering professions according to the
formula 3 + 2 + 3.
Undergraduate studies will last three years and master studies will
last two years. The Slovene government has confirmed that students can
now enrol in programs which have switched to that type of study. The
faculties' responsibility is to organize studies that will enable
students to finish successfully within the prescribed period. The
studies must motivate students for success and have great importance in
obtaining proper education. of course, there are many internal
university, social and personal obstacles often prolonging the study
period.
Special motives are necessary for engineering professions. Some
students recognize them in time and successfully fulfil all study
obligations. Regrettably, there are many students who "try to find
themselves in the engineering profession" and find out after a
certain period that this is not their future, and then switch to other
studies.
The Faculties are introducing the tutor-system studies, where the
students can freely cooperate with the tutor who helps them on their
study path during the year. Regrettably, experience shows that students
do not cooperate actively enough.
In order to adhere to the targets of the Bologna declaration it is
primarily necessary in Europe to reform the existing curriculum to
shorten the studies. It is well known that university education cannot
avoid the constraint and necessity with which the need for university
reforms is introduced at the political level in order to meet all the
requirements of the economy. Actually the national system of university
education has become so differentiated and complicated (with respect to
structures, programs, students and financing) that it is hard to discern
the clearly separated categories. In the changed circumstances some
faculties will have organizational, financial and personnel difficulties
for introduction of Bologna education processes [14]. Renovation and any
proper reform of the university education must be the result of deep and
deliberate judgment and understanding of special circumstances and
requirements important for any special situation. That must be decided
by consensus by means of proper agreements between all participants in
program implementation .
11. University Education and Changeable Market
Over the last decade, university education in a major part of
Europe was in a crisis. Structural adaptations and political changes
affected the income of universities and colleges. With unemployment of
graduates and brain drain the trust in university education has been
shaken. Excessive enrolment in social sciences has led to unbalanced
relation between groups of graduates entering the labour market. As a
result, graduates as well the employers are disappointed--particularly
with the knowledge quality offered by universities.
Also in Slovenia the increase in the number of the enrolled
students and the number of institutions affected the growth of expenses
for university education; the latter faces, of course, the extraordinary
difficulties with mass enrolment [15]. For a long time, there has been
no mass enrolment in engineering professions. Lately, renewed interest
and absence of the tendency towards enrolment dropping can be noticed.
If Slovenia wants university education to be one of the principal
driving forces of economic development and at the same time a guardian
and generator of knowledge, then concrete action will be necessary when
switching to the Bologna model of study. Such action includes
particularly investments into research, since it is very important that
universities retain the research potential in their areas of competence.
on the other hand, only these institutions have a position allowing them
to fulfil their traditional role necessary for scientific progress. That
position is guaranteed by their intellectual freedom, freedom of
discussion and independent evaluation of achievements.
Research activity in social as well as in natural sciences must, of
course, be independent from political and ideological pressures, but it
must contribute to the long-term development of society. Scientific
research must avoid the traps of the narrow-minded academic approach and
hermetic thinking, particularly in an environment where the need for
technological progress is especially high. on the other hand, the
quality of science must not be sacrificed in favour of immediate
productivity, since science is a universal and long-term value.
12. Role of Scientific and Technological Knowledge in Society
If the economic trends in Slovenia are oriented towards high
technologies, faculties will be compelled to intensify scientific and
technological training in answer to the requirement for experts who
would be familiar with with cutting edge technologies and be capable of
controlling ever more complex systems.
Since at present there is no reason for the supposition that trends
will change, faculties must continue satisfying the requirements and
continue adapting specialized study courses to social needs. That task
is difficult and must not be underestimated. Division of knowledge by
separate sciences does not always meet the market needs and the
institutions with best achievements are those which have developed
flexible and cooperative forms of teaching without boundaries between
sciences. Training of engineers in Slovenia is a common heritage,
therefore at the present stage of development it cannot be left to
market laws, since education is a basic human right and a universal
human value.
Today, many scientific universities in Europe face the problem of
whether the best students should be pointed in the direction of research
or industry [15],[16]. Slovenia must try to impose flexibility of the
education system to retain ample university education in order to
suitably prepare engineering graduates to enter the labour market. That
dimension must be retained at the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering. In
the future, our region will still structural change and the latest
information shows that the demand for mechanical engineers is on the
increase again. This represents new challenges for the Slovene faculties
of mechanical engineering in forming curricula in accordance with the
Bologna processes. One of the main objectives of the education reform of
mechanical engineers and probably the best way to implement it is
involving all stakeholders into the decision making process. . Triple
target: equal rights, adequacy, and excellence must be considered.
Searching for coordinated linking of those targets is the key
responsibility of those participating in planning and implementing the
Bologna process in training of engineers.
13. What Can Education do for Engineers?
What is essential in the technical education can be justified only
with autonomous thinking processes. If only traditional knowledge is
offered, what is essential for the future only rarely breaks through
into the foreground. Interpretation of knowledge is desirable. In
training of engineers we must continue to support effectiveness.
Wide general and basic education must strengthen technological
mobility. This will build a more solid basis for the interdisciplinary
activity and for intercepting new technologies. The prerequisite for
interdisciplinary activity is the capacity to work in team. The
engineers must acquire the capacity for team work already in the time of
training by group and joint work. However, the engineers must be capable
to act independently any time, but they must not be brought up as
solitary wolves. We must abandon the idea that we will educate
"ready-made" engineers. Much of what was imparted in
undergraduate education must find its place in complementary education.
As the applied knowledge soon becomes obsolete, if must be quickly
replaced. More than ever today's undergraduate education must
concentrate on the best possible concepts for later complimentary
education.
Undergraduate education Primarily must allow mastering of processes
leading to solutions applicable in practice. It must not be limited to
general bases.Technical applications resting on natural laws can be
interpreted and selected. That fact is more and more important in the
accelerated technical development. Education may have ready conventional
answers, but it should no longer present ideal formulas which would be
binding, since they risk missing what is essential.
It may be concluded that education helps the engineer to form his
profile, but it can also hinder it. Attempts to convey the profile often
fail--although they are introduced by prolongation of the study period,
since the changes in today's technologies are underestimated and
engineers, able to act, are not equal to storages of knowledge in
practice. Education may accompany the engineer who will only become
engineer. As companions we must not forget that we are accompanying
someone who walks alone. He should not be pulled or pushed, but only
accompanied - we should give him what the needs on his path and not
more. The companion must also know that he, who will tear himself away
from him, will have to find his path independently. The companion has
other tasks. He must lead other passers-by to the profession of the
engineer past the reefs.
Our civilization, relying on technology, will survive only, if our
society is populated by more people i.e. engineers who know the
technology well. In case of lack of engineers accelerated technological
changes will not lead to solutions our environment urgently needs.
Therefore Slovene university and college education is called for to
take part in that social responsibility and offer study programs in
accordance with the new development paradigm. Today's range of
curricula in Slovenia and at German universities and colleges is too
specialized, broken and remote from reality from the point of view of
the observers from industry [16],[17]. Therefore engineering education
in Germany is an important topic of reforms, which with the new law
passes into internationalization.
Though their engineers are already renowned worldwide today, the
German curricula lack attractiveness to foreign students. Whoever wants
to be successful in the global world of education will have to adapt to
the market demand. Today, most orientations of the Anglo-Saxon model,
which is internationally compatible and features the degrees
"Bachelor", "Master" and "Ph. D.", are
wanted; they are also envisaged by our law. German economy compels
universities into accelerated reforms in order to increase the demand of
students from East Asia [18]. These represent their future clients,
collaborators and/or "ambassadors" of medium-sized
enterprises.
Slovenia should learn much from such thinking! Slovenia has adopted
the relevant laws on universities [19]. That is a unique opportunity to
quickly correct the flaws in our university education. Unfortunately,
this has not been done so far and we will be forced again to adopt quick
and incomplete solutions.
14. Quality as Change
This attitude is concentrated on the participants in education, on
their acquisition of new skills and knowledge. Looking at different
definitions of quality we can see that there is no correct or uniform
definition. Quality, thus, is not an unequivocal and uniform term, it is
rather defined in terms of more than one kind of quality. It is
necessary to consider a series of different interest groups having
different starting points, values and expectations and, consequently,
different ideas of the purpose and targets of university education.
Therefore, there are different ideas of what quality in university
education is [20].
In the opinion of experts for evaluations of the university
education quality is a relative and multidimensional concept.
Verification of quality is relative with regard to various targets the
university education has or measuring it is relative with regard to
different aims of different participants. In university education there
are many interest groups with different requirements concerning quality
of university education. Therefore, we cannot speak of one, but of more
qualities. In university education there are as many definitions of
quality as there are interest groups. It is necessary to distinguish the
quality requirements expected by e.g. students, academic personnel,
employers or government. For the government the quality of education
implies that the students finish their study at reduced costs within the
prescribed time with a diploma of international standard [21].Employers
understand quality as graduates' knowledge and skills. To the
contrary, in the opinion of students, quality is associated with
individual development and with preparation to reach a certain position
in the society. Education must be associated with students'
personal interests. However, the education process must be organized in
such a way that students can finish their studies within the prescribed
time. Academic circles will define the quality as academic qualification
based on satisfactory transfer of knowledge, satisfactory study
environment and proper combination of researches with teaching [22].
Different interest groups conceive quality differently. Thus,
quality is relative and its definition depends on the interest group.
However, even within those groups there are sub-groups defending
separate interests. The complicated question can be solved by
considering the criteria of different groups and their judgement of
quality rather than by a single definition of quality. Such solution
allows and admits the right of different groups to their different
perspectives. Due to different concepts of quality of university
education the final answer will probably never be reached. There is no
ideal system of quality verification and assurance acceptable for all
sides.. The balance between these concepts will always be unstable.
External evaluation of university or college institutions covers:
* strategy, organization and management of institutions, record
keeping and quality management,
* education--study activities,
* scientific--research, artistic and professional activity,
* university teachers and workers, scientific workers and
collaborators,
* administrative and professional--technical workers,
* students at the institution,
* rooms, facilities for educational and scientific research,
library,
* financing of educational/study and scientific research and
professional activities,
* cooperation with the social environment at the regional, national
and international level.
For evaluation of cooperation with the social environment at the
regional, national and international level the following criteria are
applied:
* University has established successful cooperation at the
regional, national and international level. It promotes cooperation with
other university institutions, companies, organizations and professional
associations and with other important interested participants in the
environment.
* University features integration of all those interested into its
activities in the educational, scientific-research or professional
areas.
* Curricula and other educational activities of university reflect
the needs of economy and noneconomic activities; it cooperates in
planning and monitoring the educational activity of the university.
* Scientific research and professional work of the university are
associated with development projects and researches for economy and
non-economic activities.
* University takes part in the exchange of students, teachers and
collaborators, scientific workers and collaborators within Slovenia and
abroad.
15. Conclusion
Faculties of mechanical engineering also must carry out
differentiation and orientation of curricula efficacy so that they can
be a generator of economic development [23]. We are aware that the
structure and extent of responsibility of the faculty are influenced by
the changes in the political, social, economic and technological
environment of the faculty. We must forget the idea of giving engineers
during their study all the knowledge they might need later on,
particularly because engineering knowledge becomes obsolete in some
technical spheres within a few years.
Targets of modern academic education stress high flexibility of
curricula, mobility of students and teachers, introduction of crediting
system of study and/or set of courses, integration into European
research projects, etc. Competition forces faculties of mechanical
engineering into a struggle for students where they apply marketing
strategies, to improve in program planning, offering study advice, and
promoting their services. To increase attractiveness and scientific
prominence it is necessary to determine the value of graduates on the
labour market, quality of tutors and lecturers, quality of student life,
values and mission. Today faculties of mechanical engineering are
traditionally scientific faculties, where basic research is predominant:
free selection of the type of research, orientation towards future,
multidisciplinary approach. The target is top European quality. Support
is necessary at all levels for numerous projects of cooperation between
university and economy, including teachers and students and bringing a
series of educational advantages.
16. References
Albers, A., Matthiesen, S., Neue Modelle fur die
Ingenieurausbildung. Das Karlsruhe Lehrmodell, (New models for
engineering education. The Karlsruhe teaching model) ASEE--The American
Society for Engineering Education,
http://www.asee.org/papers-and-publications,
http://www.asee.org/conferences-andevents/conferences
CUS, Franc, Analysis of monitoring quality in Slovenian higher
education area. 29th International Conference on Organizational Science
Development, 24-26 March 2010, Portoroz, Slovenia : proceedings
CUS, Franc, BALIC, Joze. Bases of changes of university education
and education tasks of University of Maribor for global society. XVIII
skup Trendovi razvoja "Internacionalizacija univerziteta ",
Trend 2012, Kopaonik, 27.02-01.03. 2012, zbornik radova (proceedings),
Novi Sad, 2012, str. 13-16
CUS, Franc, BALIC, Joze. QA system in Slovenia and quality
assurance practices on the University of Maribor. XV skup Trendovi
razvoja, Trend 2009, (collection Development Trends) Kopaonik, 02-05.
03. 2009, zbornik radova, (Proceedings). Novi Sad, 2009, str. 110-115
CUS, Franc, BALIC, Joze. The Bologna process beyond its initial
deadline in 2010--Bologna What's next?. XVII skup Trendovi razvoja
(collection Development Trends) "Evropa 2020: Drustvo zasnovano na
znanju", (Knowledge-based society) Trend 2011,Kopaonik,
07-10.03.2011.Zbornik radova (Proceedings).2011, str. 22-25.
CUS, Franc, BALIC, Joze. The Bologna process beyond its initial
deadline in 2010 Bologna --What's next?. XVII skup Trendovi razvoja
(collection Development Trends) "Evropa 2020: Drustvo zasnovano na
znanju",(Knowledge-based society) Trend 2011, Kopaonik,
07-10.03.2011. Zbornik radova (Proceedings).2011, str. 22-25.
CUS, Franc, KOPAC, Janez. Vzpostavljanje sistema zagotavljanja
kakovosti pri izobrazevanju inzenirjev32. posvetovanje Orodjarstvo in
strojegradnja 2010, Ljubljana, 6.-7. Oktober 2010. zbornik posvetovanja.
Ljubljana: GZS, Zdruzenje, 2010, str. 73-79, (Establishing a system of
quality assurance in education inzenirjev32. consultation Tool and
Machine 2010 Ljubljana, 6th-7th October, 2010. conference proceedings.
Ljubljana: Chamber of Commerce Association, 2010 Die Zukunft exzellenter
Ingenieurausbildung (The Future excellent engineering education)
"Next Generation Engineering Education" (8.6.2011)
February 2005, www.vdi.de/nc/ueber-uns/vdi-vor.../ak-e-m/? ... pdf
http://www.digbib.ubka.uni-karlsruhe.de pdf
http://www.sbfi.admin.ch/dokumentation/.../index.html? pdf
Ingenieurausbildung in der Schweiz, INGCH setzt auf FH- und
ETH-Ingenieurinnen und Ingenieure (Engineering education in Switzerland,
INGCH relies on FH and ETH engineers)
http://www.ingch.ch/pdfs/m_17.03.2010.pdf
Kafer Gerhard, Ingenieurausbildung in Osterreich, e & i
Elektrotechnik und Informationstechnik, (Engineering education in
Austria, E & I Electrical and Computer Engineering), November 2006,
Volume 123, Issue 11, pp 493-494
Kiener, U., Zukunft Engineering, Eine Expertenbefragung in der
Schweiz im Auftrag des ETH-Rates und des Bundesamtes fur Berufsbildung
und Technologie, Winterthur 2005, (Future Engineering, a survey of
experts in Switzerland on behalf of the ETH Board and the Federal Office
for Professional Education and Technology)
Kurzfassung der Thesen und Empfehlungen zur universitaren
Ingenieurausbildung. Diskussionspapier fur das prasidium der DFG,
erarbeitet unter der Federfuhrung von Vizeprasident Eigenberger,
(Discussion paper for the Bureau of the DFG, prepared under the auspices
of Vice President Berger own)
Molzahn, M., Bachelor & Master oder Diplomingenieur ?
Ingenieurausbildung im Wandel, Vortrag bei der Qualitat der
Ingenieurausbildung sichern und weiterentwickeln, (Bachelor & Master
or Diploma Engineering? Engineering Education in Transition,
Presentation at the Safeguard and develop the quality of engineering
education)
Qualitat der Ingenieurausbildung. Betrachtungen aus Industriesicht.
Sonderdruck aus Arbeitmarkt Elektrotechnik Informationstechnik (Quality
of engineering education. Views from industrial point of view. Reprint
from the labor market Electrical Information Technology) 2012/13,
www.zvei.org/ ... /Qualitaet%20der%20Ingenierausbildun.., pdf SEFI--La
Societe Europeenne pour la Formation des Ingenieurs--The European
Society for Engineering Education, The European Journal of Engineering
Education published by Taylor and Francis is the official journal of
SEFI, http://www.sefi.be/ VDE--Empfehlung zur Ingenieurausbildung mit
gestuften Hochschulabschlussen, (Recommendation for Engineering
Education stepped university degrees)
http://www.vde.com/de/Karriere/Ingenieurausbildung/Documents/Empfehlunggestuft eIngAusb2.pdf
VDI NACHRICHTEN, Berufsprofile, Funktionsbereich (Professional
profiles, functional area) "Engineering im Anlagenbau" Montag,
1. Juli 2013, http://www.ingenieurkarriere.de/
VDI, Neue Wege in der Ingenieurausbildung, Grundung des
"David-Gilly-Instituts fur Lehre, Forschung und Kommunikation im
Bauwesen" (New approaches in engineering education, founding the
"David Gilly Institute for Teaching, Research and Communication in
Construction) in Cottbus,
www.vdi.de/nc/bildung/.../3.../weitere-poster/? pdf
VDI-Arbeitsgruppe Engineering & Management im VDI Bezirksverein
NordbadenPfalz Mannheim, 15, (VDI Working Group Engineering &
Management Association Northern District of VDI Mannheim
Baden-Palatinate, 15)
Werde Ingenieur "Made in Germany", Die TU9, eine Allianz
der fuhrenden Technischen Universitaten in Deutschland, wirbt weltweit
um talentierte (Become an engineer "Made in Germany", The TU9,
an alliance of the leading technical universities in Germany advertises
worldwide for talented)
https://www.study-in.de/de/--222 1
www.dfg.de/.../universitaere ingenieurausbildung kurz.... pdf
www.dfg.de/.../universitaere ingenieurausbildung kurz.... pdf
www.dvt-net.de/.../Qualitaet_der_Ingenieurausbildung.p ... pdf
Authors' data: Cus, F[ranci]; Balic, J[oze], University of
Maribor, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Slovenia, franc.cus@um.si,
joze.balic@um.si
DOI: 10.2507/daaam.scibook.2013.29