The health-oriented market: a lifestyle model, empirical test, and implications for market segmentation strategy.
Bahn, Kenneth D. ; Granzin, Kent L. ; Wright, Newell D. 等
INTRODUCTION
Despite the emphasis given these issues in the marketing
literature, consumers of today are faced with more than just the task of
having to make product and brand choices in the marketplace. More
basically, they have to choose from among the many alternative
lifestyles available to them (Kraft & Goodell, 1993). Because their
choices of products and brands reflect their basic lifestyle,
consumers' selection of a particular lifestyle alternative
underlies their consumption patterns (Drug Store News, 1996).
Accordingly, their basic lifestyles hold direct implications for the
marketers who seek to serve these consumers (Loro, 1992).
The notion of people choosing a lifestyle like they would choose a
product may be the very basis for developing segmentation strategies.
Lifestyle segmentation is certainly not a new concept, but the segment
of persons that chooses a lifestyle bases on the confluence of nutrition
and physical fitness behaviors is relatively new and little empirical
support has found its way into the literature. The present study
proposes a participation model that encompasses a healthy lifestyle by
incorporating both nutrition and physical fitness and demographic and
psychological antecedents. Studies involving segmentation have focused
on many topics and abound in the marketing literature. Leutzinger and
Hunnicutt (1996) applied marketing concepts to worksite health promotion
programs; Wyner (1996) considered response function as a new
segmentation variable . Thus segments were defined on the basis of
similar responses; some sort of meaningful behavior. Brown (1992),
identified three distinct segments based on fitness behaviors; while
Dimance and Samdahl (1994), suggest that consumption of leisure is a
subset of broader patterns of consumption housed in consumer behavior.
Sandor (1994) found that attitudes toward health and toward food could
be used to segment markets successfully; Thompson and Kaminski (1993)
found that lifestyle with other variables could be used to segment on
the basis of service quality expectations. Further, O'Connor and
Sullivan (1995) found brand preference segmentation produces more
interpretable and managerially useful segmentation results than
benefit/attributes desired. Thus, many person-based variables have been
used to segment desirable markets. The present study compliments this
body of literature by offering a new conceptual model that considers
lifestyle choice in the participation of nutrition and physical fitness,
and lastly, providing an empirical test.
One basic lifestyle that has gained increasing attention from
consumers, scholars, marketing practitioners, and society as a whole is
that pattern of activities that reflects an explicitly healthful orientation (Kraft & Goodell, 1993; Taylor, 1991). In the positive
vein, these activities can be viewed as an attempt to develop and/or
maintain "wellness," a state of emotional, intellectual,
physical, occupation, social, and spiritual well-being (Leafgren &
Elsenrath, 1986). Wellness is attained by making certain choices
relevant to exercise, nutrition, health knowledge, health care delivery,
physical and mental health, and personal safety (Duffy, 1989; Kraft
& Goodell, 1993; Moorman & Matulick, 1993). In particular,
persons who actively seek wellness do so by choosing activities, and
consequently the products and services to support them, that importantly
emphasize their concern for nutrition and physical fitness (Kraft &
Goodell, 1993). If persons shape their lifestyle to feature appropriate
participation in these two broad types of behaviors, they can benefit
both their physical and their psychological functioning. With respect to
physical benefits, nutritionally correct consumption can supply body
organs and tissues with proper nutrients; increase blood flow; and
reduce weight, stress, cardiovascular disease, cancer, and
osteoporosis-related problems. Proper exercise can promote strength,
stamina, and an attractive body form; maintain normal cardiovascular
functioning; produce good cholesterol; increase metabolism; and burn
excess calories (Blair, 1988; Cooper & Offer, 1990). The
psychological benefits of a health-oriented lifestyle include desired
body image; greater self-esteem, assertiveness, autonomy, confidence,
motivation, achievement, internal locus of control; a positive
orientation to life; and improved well-being (Sonstroem, 1988; Oman
& McAuley, 1993). For this reason, those persons who pursue a
health-oriented lifestyle constitute a major market, one that can be
profitably served if the appropriate marketing strategy is used (Kraft
& Goodell, 1993).
This study investigates specific demographic and psychological
characteristics of persons that lead to participation in a particular
lifestyle that focuses on nutrition and physical fitness behaviors. To
this end, this study examines the process of influence leading to a
health-oriented lifestyle, a pattern of activities that manifests strict
requirements for nutritional food alternatives and an active, often
dominating pursuit of physical fitness. This is a study of the process
leading to participation in nutrition and physical fitness related
activities. This study is clearly about individuals and not groups, but
has implications for marketers that develop strategies based on
individuals with similar behavioral patterns. These individuals with
similar behavioral patterns, form potential market segments.
COMPONENTS OF A HEALTH-ORIENTED LIFESTYLE
This study investigates the influence of several antecedent influences on consumers' performance of these two most beneficial
activities that constitutes a health-oriented lifestyle. It presents a
new model in a new context and tests the proposed model that integrates
constructs from many different disciplines in order to get at the crux of persons' lifestyle choices. The model integrates psychological
constructs such as concerns, attitudes, and knowledge to explain
persons' behavioral involvement in nutrition and physical fitness.
Previous models performed bivariate analysis while the proposed model
looks at the influence of all the variables in the model as a process
and not piecemeal. Further, the present study considers marketing
implications from the standpoint of how to develop viable segments based
on similar behavioral patterns with respect to nutritional food choices
and physical fitness activities.
Nutrition
Previous research involving from nutrition from a segmentation
approach has examined persons' ability to respond cognitively to
different formats for nutrition information (Rudell, 1984). Researchers
have also examined the influence of persons' nutrition-related
attitudes on restaurant patronage (Granzin & Bahn, 1988), and the
effect of their knowledge of nutrition issues on their food choices
(Barr, 1986; Signorielli & Lears, 1992). Additional research has
emphasized persons' processing of information about nutrition,
focusing on their use of nutrition information on grocery labels in
making brand choices (Jacob, Chestnut & Silberman, 1977; Russo,
Staelin, Nolan & Metcalf, 1986), in different store settings, and by
persons with different demographic profiles and different levels of
nutrition knowledge (Assam & Bucklin, 1973; French & Barksdale,
1974; Lenahan, 1973; Haralson et al., 1992). This research has found
consumers to have a relatively low level of knowledge of nutrition
(Jacoby et al., 1977; Haralson et al., 1992).
These studies have generally focused on either persons' use of
information or on how their concern for nutrition influence their
specific choices (e.g., brand selection) in the marketplace. In the
process, this research has neglected the part played by nutrition in
persons' broader lifestyle patterns of behavior. Of course, other
academic areas, such as the field of nutrition itself, have contributed
to our knowledge of persons' involvement with nutrition. For
example, nutritionists and dieticians now warn people not merely to
restrain their total intake of calories, but to also assess the fat
content associated with these calories (French, Jeffery & Wing,
1994; Sobal, Revicki & DeForge, 1992). They also warn people to
exclude large amounts of animal fats, simple sugars, and sodium from
their diets (Haralson, Sargent & Schuchter, 1992, Walton, 1987).
Therefore, reflecting generally-accepted knowledge, the present study
considers positive involvement in nutrition to reflect low intake of
salt, fat, and simple sugars; and high intake of complex carbohydrates,
fiber, fruits, vegetables, fish, and poultry (Kirk & Gillespie,
1990; Walton, 1987). In an attempt to fill a gap from the existing
knowledge of nutrition, Moorman and Matulich (1993) studied the
influence of health knowledge and income on positive health behaviors
and found empirical support. Although the gap has been somewhat
narrowed, knowledge concerning amore integrated process model of this
health-oriented lifestyle as not been attempted. The proposed research
seeks to fill this gap and contribute empirical findings that should
shed new light on these persons' who seek healthy alternatives in
food and exercise choices that dominate their life.
Physical Fitness
For this study exercise choices is the operationalization of
physical fitness. Exercise is those physical fitness activities designed
to develop flexibility, muscular strength, stamina, and cardiovascular
functioning. Exercise has received considerably less attention from
marketing scholars than has nutrition, despite its centrality to
persons' health-oriented lifestyle. Research outside the field
marketing indicates why exercise should be a foundation component of a
model based on a health-oriented lifestyle (Sonstroem, Harlow &
Joesphs, 1994; Tappe, Duda & Ehrnwald, 1989; Duda & Tappe, 1989;
Dishman, Sallis & Orenstein, 1985). Because lifestyle as a way of
living comprises persons' characteristic pattern of behaviors
(Veal, 1991), exercise activities join with nutritional food habits to
define persons' complete health-oriented lifestyle (Lee, 1993;
Marcus, Eaton, Rossi & Harlow, 1994; Rabinowitz, Melamed, Weisberg
& Tal, 1992; Verhoef, Love & Rose, 1992). The only study
investigated from a marketing perspective was conducted by Kraft and
Goodell (1993) and was published in the health care marketing. They
sought to discover the characteristics of the health conscious consumer
by identifying different lifestyle choices that may aid a persons desire
to live a more healthy life. They propose that persons who engage in
particular wellness activities such as health environment sensitivity,
nutritional awareness, physical fitness, stress management and
self-responsibility will have a higher quality of life and lifestyle.
The present study supports these findings and seeks to extend them by
developing a broader based perspective on a healthy lifestyle, that is a
wholistic approach that not only incorporates awareness and beliefs, but
also many behaviors that constitutes a healthy approach to life. This
study presents an extension of the previous research published in the
physical fitness literature. It seeks to accomplish this by
investigating the process of influence on persons' lifestyle using
the notion that this lifestyle comprises those activities persons select
to gain both physical and psychological benefits from consumption of
nutritional food choices and physical fitness activities.
Research Questions
On this basis, these research questions emerge: (1) what is the
influence of consumers' psychological involvement in nutrition and
exercise on their health-oriented lifestyle? (2) to what extent are
these twin components of the process of influence on lifestyle
interrelated (i.e., do consumers concentrate on only one of these
components, or do they integrate the two)? and (3) what is the role of
other personal characteristics, represented here by demographics, in
this process of influence?
PREVIOUS RESEARCH IN THE AREA OF A HEALTH-ORIENTED LIFESTYLE
Given the dearth of consumer research involving the influence of
nutrition and exercise on consumption-related behavior, but not as a
process or without lifestyle choice considerations, it is fortunate
other scholarly fields have examined this issue. In fact, some scholars
have modeled certain aspect(s) of this process of influence (e.g.,
Becker & Maiman, 1975; Blair, 1988; Gottleib & Baker, 1986;
Homer & Kahle, 1988; Lau, Hartman & Ware, 1986; Pender, 1982,
1987; Pender & Pender, 1986; Sonstroem, 1988; Weitzel, 1989).
Especially pertinent to this study, the broader behavioral literature
supplies support for selecting certain psychological constructs to
include in the process of influence proposed to lead to a
health-oriented lifestyle. For example, many scholars have linked
attitudes toward nutrition and physical fitness with either nutrition-
or and exercise-related behaviors (Anderson & Shepherd, 1989; Hollis
et al., 1986; McIntosh et al., 1990; Verhoef et al., 1992; Harris et
al., 1992; Storz, 1983). Empirical support has also been found for the
association of desired appearance and body image with nutritional food
choices and participation in physical fitness activities (Witte et al.,
1991; Casper & Offer, 1990; Davies & Furnham, 1986; Dishman
& Gettman, 1980; Duda & Tappe, 1988; Ganely, 1989; Hayes &
Ross, 1987; O'Connell & Velicer, 1988; Walton, 1987). Another,
more recent study that looks at the process persons use to make choices
about health orientation was performed by Tudor and Carley (1995). They
found that more affective components rather than cognitive components of
the decision process aided persons in their choice to use a long term
health care facility. This studied decision process is analogous to the
decision process investigated in the present study to uncover the flow
of influence of nutritional related food behaviors and physical fitness
behaviors.
A PROPOSED MODEL OF THE INFLUENCES ON A HEALTH-ORIENTED LIFESTYLE
The proposed model describes the process of influence on a
health-oriented lifestyle, shown to flow from left to right in the
Figure presented here. Support for the proposed linkages comes from
previous research in a number disciplines where nutrition- and physical
fitness-related behavior have been investigated. To keep the present
study empirically manageable, the model features ten variables that
represent seven basic constructs, with the Demographics construct split
into four sub-constructs a la Moorman and Matulich (1993). The
characteristics are constructs/variables that are elements of the flow
of influence that constitutes the process in question. Each of the
constructs in the flow of influence plays a part in the total process
and has implications for developing strategy aimed at specific segments
of people. It influences subsequent variables in the process. Some
constructs come before others; thus they are antecedent to their
subsequents and present challenges to marketers trying to cater to
persons with similar attitudinal and behavioral patterns.
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
This section introduces and provides the rationale for the
constructs of the model and their proposed interrelationships. The mode
of presentation is to discuss each construct of the model in turn and,
for the endogenous constructs, to propose causal influences from
antecedent constructs. These proposed relationships are subsequently
stated as formal hypotheses for empirical investigation.
Demographics as an Exogenous Construct
The flow of influence begins with demographics. Demographics and
specifically the four measure of demographics chosen in this study
constitute the basic person and are not generally influenced by
psychological constructs or behavior, but are usually the influencing
constructs. Numerous previous studies have associated demographic
variables with various forms of involvement with nutrition and physical
fitness. While many such variables could be included in the model, to
permit an empirical test of the proposed integrated model found in the
Figure, this research concentrates on a limited, but representative set
of four demographics (sub)-constructs: marital status, gender, age, and
what is here termed success. Success as achievement in life has been
considered in various ways by researchers. This study uses education and
occupational prestige to concisely represent success.
Exercise Attitudes as an Endogenous Construct
Conceptually, the construct of exercise attitudes represents
consumers' cognitive and evaluative involvement in exercise-related
issues. The literature reports that consumers who have higher
socio-economic status have higher involvement in exercise-related issues
(Firebaugh, 1989; Rudman, 1989; McAuley et al., 1991) in particular, a
higher attitudinal involvement (Hope, 1988; Ferguson et al., 1989;
McAuley et al., 1991). Thus, the model proposes that more successful
persons hold supportive attitudes toward exercise-related issues. More
formally,
H1: More positive exercise attitudes are linked with greater
success.
Nutrition Knowledge as an Endogenous Construct
Nutrition knowledge represents the beliefs consumers hold about the
nutritional content of available food alternatives. Researchers have
linked various demographics, including those here considered reflective of Success, with knowledge of nutrition. Specifically, previous research
shows persons with higher income and education have more knowledge about
nutrition (Kirk & Gillespie, 1990; Moorman & Matulich, 1993;
Schafer & Schafer, 1989). Other research has learned that women are
more knowledgeable about nutrition issues (McIntosh et al., 1990;
Prohaska et al., 1985). Additionally, it follows that since women,
generally, have greater concern for the family, they should also be more
knowledgeable about food-related issues. Thus, previous research and the
above argument suggest:
H2: Greater nutrition knowledge is associated with (a) greater
success, (b) female gender, and (c) married marital status.
Thus, both of these psychological constructs are included in this
study because they have been successfully shown to influence behavior.
Attitudes and knowledge are certainly antecedents to behavior and felt
important in this study because of its focus on integration.
Exercise Benefits as an Endogenous Construct
The construct presented in the Figure is Exercise Benefits. This
construct is included in this study because of its importance in
describing the many reasons why persons may choose physical fitness as a
lifestyle choice. The popular press has indicated on several occasions
the benefits from a frequent exercise. Previous studies have linked
various demographics with interest in obtaining such benefits from
exercise as stamina, strength, cardiovascular health, peace of mind,
stress reduction, and stronger self-image (Hope, 1988; McAuley,
Courmeyer & Rudoplh, 1994; Oman & McAuley, 1993). Scholars in
Clinical Psychology, Nursing, Social Psychology, Sports Studies,
Education, and Sports Medicine have empirically linked higher education,
occupational status, and income with a stronger desire to obtain these
benefits from regular exercise (Blair, 1988; Gottlieb & Baker, 1986;
Pender, 1982; Pender, 1986; Pender & Pender, 1986; Sonstroem, 1988).
Further, older persons are more likely to emphasize philosophical
benefits (Rudman, 1989), both mental and physical health-related
benefits (Duda & Tappe, 1989; Koslow, 1988), and the intrinsic role
of mastery over one's body (Summers, Machin & Sargent, 1983).
Thus, a marketing perspective is needed in that application of these
many other disciplines leads to the offering og products and services to
facilitate benefits sought from exercise activities.
Research has also linked general attitudes toward physical fitness
with emphasis on fitness benefits. These studies have shown that persons
focus their fitness-related attitudes on those specific benefits they
can derive from exercise; for example, on less stress and tension
(Gephardt & Crump, 1990; Hendrix, Ovalle & Troxeller, 1985;
Brown & Siegel, 1988), greater physical strength and stamina, more
attractive appearance and body image, and reduced cardiovascular disease
(Ferguson et al., 1989; Godin & Shepherd, 1986; Rea, 1987). Duda and
Tappe (1989) linked more favorable attitudes of middle-aged and elderly
exercisers with their greater recognition of the health benefits of
participating in a regular exercise program. On this basis, the model
posits that stronger emphasis on the benefits of exercise stems from
greater success in life, being older, and viewing exercise more
favorably.
H3: Greater Exercise benefits relate to (a) greater success, (b)
older age, and (c) more favorable exercise attitudes.
Nutrition Concerns as an Endogenous Construct
Nutrition concerns represents persons' interest in gaining
proper nutrition and receiving its benefits; more specifically, their
anxiety and apprehension about such nutrition-related issues as fat,
cholesterol, and dieting. Previous research links demographics with
these concerns, showing that persons with lower socio-economic status
suffer from more eating disorders and the resulting stress and tension
(Ganley, 1989; Kulik & Mahler, 1987), while those with higher SES
experience greater internal locus of control in health-related
activities (Abella & Heslin, 1984). Females express greater concern
about their body image and appearance than males (Casper & Offer,
1990), and adolescent females are more anxious about their body shape
(Davies & Furnham, 1986). Notably, women feel a greater concern than
men about nutrition issues (McIntosh et al., 1990; Prohaska et al.,
1985). Further, Nayga (1997) found that black, female, higher educated
and non-working main meal planners generally perceive nutrition as more
important than do others and place more emphasis on nutrition in
providing meals.
The model also proposes that knowledge of nutrition influences
these concerns. Granzin and Bahn (1988) found a link between restaurant
patrons' beliefs about nutrition and their concern for the type of
benefits they received. This linkage has been further supported
empirically by various other behavioral studies that show increased
knowledge about, nutrition stimulates persons' concern; e.g,
regarding their nutrition intake (Storz, 1983; Anderson & Shepherd,
1989; McIntosh et al., 1990; Signorielli & Lears, 1992; Trent,
1992).
The influence of exercise benefits on nutrition concerns issues
from the recognition that Americans' interest in physical
well-being is largely focused on their concern for an attractive body
image; specifically, their fear of being overweight (Lau, 1986; Davies
& Furnham, 1986; Storz, 1983). As to health-oriented segment
continues to mature, those persons who see benefits of exercising also
are concerned about what they eat. For example, many popular programs
are endorsed in mass marketed magazines prescribe that people should
both exercise and watch their food intake to insure a health-oriented
lifestyle as well as maintain proper weight levels. Therefore this link
is included in the proposed model because as persons choose the time of
lifestyle that best fits themselves, they are by nature concerned with
the aspects that constitutes their choice. Thus, the model found in the
Figure posits those most concerned about nutrition are more successful,
married, female, older, more knowledgeable about nutrition, and more
desirous of the benefits of exercise.
H4: Nutrition concerns increases with (a) greater success, (b)
female gender, (c) married marital status, (d) older age, (e) greater
nutrition knowledge, and (f) greater exercise benefits.
Exercise Behavior as a Criterion Construct
Exercise behavior comprises a variety of activities explicitly or
implicitly chosen to support persons' ability to (1) perform
strenuous physical activity with vigor and without excessive fatigue,
and (2) demonstrate physical activity traits and capacity that are
consistent with minimal risk of developing hyperkinetic diseases. In
general, exercise supports one's general good health and one's
capacity to feel good, look good, enjoy life, work efficiently, and
handle life's emergencies and for these reasons are included in
this research as one of two criterion variables. Exercise behavior
reflects a variety of behavioral choices. For example, among other
indicators, participants' exercise regimen may be defined by the
number and type of activities habitually pursued (Gottlieb & Baker,
1986; Rowland, Franken & Harrison, 1986; Stephens, Jacobs &
White, 1985), or by the frequency and duration of participation (Deeter,
1988; Duda & Tappe, 1989; Rowland, Franken & Harrison, 1986).
Previous studies demonstrate that demographic characteristics
influence participation in physical fitness activities. Persons with
higher SES (Rea 1987) and occupational prestige (Stephens, Jacobs &
White, 1985) are more likely to exercise regularly. Verhoef et al.
(1992) found married women exercise less than single women, but that
married men exercise more than single men. Other research found males
participate more regularly in exercise activity and for longer periods
of time (Doyle, 1989; Ferguson et al., 1989; Firebaugh, 1989). Younger
persons are more likely to run/jog (Doyle, 1989), and physical activity
generally decreases with age (Stephens, Jacobs & White, 1985),
although the influence of age varies with the activity (Doyle, 1989). A
study that segmented the fitness market into three distinct groups was
performed by Brown (1992). His three segments were classified as Winners
who believe that staying physical fit will enable to to stay ahead in
their business careers. The second group, Dieters, are mainly interested
in weight control and physical appearance and exercise to obtain this
goal. The third segment, Self-improvers, see exercise as a way to feel
better. Further, Brown (1992), related specific demographic
characteristics of each segment. Winners are younger, Dieters are older
and female, and Self-improvers are more likely to be single.
Numerous studies have linked more supportive attitudes about
physical fitness with greater participation in exercise (e.g., Crawford
& Eklund, 1994; Duda & Tappe, 1988, 1989; Dishman, Sallie &
Orenstein, 1985; Ferguson et al., 1989; Field & Steinhardt, 1992;
Godin & Shepherd, 1986; Slenker et al., 1984). For instance, Deeter
(1988) showed attitudinal commitment to explain participation in
exercise.
Researchers have also shown that persons who require certain
benefits of exercise participate in the physical activities held to
provide these beneficial outcomes (Dishman, Sallis & Orenstein,
1985; Duda & Tappe, 1988; Godin & Shepherd, 1966; Weber &
Wertheim, 1989). This relationship has emerged for (1) various general
benefits (John & Miaoulis, 1992; Maehr & Braskamp, 1986),
specific benefits such as self-image, appearance, and a positive outlook
on life (Dishman, 1982; Dishman, Ickes, and Morgan 1980; Dishman and
Ickes 1981), (2) diverse activities, such as jogging (Slenker et al.,
1984), and (3) various classes of exercisers, such as arthritic patients
(Ike, Lampman & Castor, 1989) and adolescents with insulin-dependent
diabetes (Campaigne et al., 1985). Taken together, these studies suggest
participation in exercise increases with achieving success in life;
being single, male, and younger; holding favorable attitudes; and
recognizing the benefits of exercise.
H5: Exercise behavior increases with (a) greater success, (b)
single marital status, (c) male gender, (d) younger age, (e) more
favorable exercise attitudes, and (f) stronger exercise benefits.
Nutrition Behavior as a Criterion Construct
Nutrition behavior as proposed in the Figure, represents the choice
of nutritional food alternatives for consumption (e.g., vegetables,
fruit, and whole wheat bread), regardless of the consumption context.
The basic issue is the relative frequency with which consumers make
nutritional choices from various types of food that may differ
considerably in their nutritional content. Functionally, consumers may
encourage a healthy body and mind by eating more of nutritional,
beneficial foods and/or by eating less of non-nutritional, harmful
foods. Because nutritional food choices is at the core of a
health-oriented lifestyle it is of central focus to this study and
becomes the second of two criterion variables.
Researchers have associated demographics with food selection,
showing that persons with higher education and higher income, higher
occupational prestige of the household head, female gender, married
status, and older age are more likely to choose more nutritional food
alternatives (Amstutz & Dixon, 1986; Armstrong, Lange & Stem,
1990; Berger & Leigh, 1989; Block, Rosenberger & Patterson,
1989; Brown, 1992; Granzin & Bahn, 1988; Hayes & Ross, 1987;
Hollies et al., 1986; Kirk & Gillespie, 1990; Mathios, 1996; Moorman
& Matulch, 1993; Peterkin, 1986; Schafer & Schafer, 1989;
Schlosberg, 1987; Trent, 1992).
Previous behavioral research in this context has linked beliefs
with behavior. For example, Amstutz and Dixon (1986) and Ippolitio and
Mathios (1990) found that expanded education and nutrition programs
increase participants' knowledge(Moorman & Matulich, 1993;
Maehr & Braskamp, 1986) about nutrition, which knowledge
subsequently influences purchase and consumption of more nutritional
food alternatives in positive fashion. Other research has associated
nutrition beliefs (Anderson & Shepherd, 1989) and, more
specifically, knowledge of nutrition (Barr, 1986) with the choice of
healthful food alternatives.
Research has also found concern for nutrition related to
nutrition-related behavior. For instance, Contento and Murphy (1990)
found dieters who are more concerned about changing their body image are
more likely to choose nutritional food as a way to lose weight. Lau,
Hartman, and Ware (1986) showed persons' strongly held values
involving health-related issues (which, by inclusion, should entail their nutrition concerns) affect their health-oriented behaviors.
Further, research has positively linked the symbolic health concerns
emulated in body image and appearance with nutritional food choices
(Walton, 1987; Hayes & Ross, 1987; Casper & Ganley, 1990;
Skinner et al., 1991). In sum, previous research supports the
proposition that persons who follow more nutritional food habits are
more successful, married, female, and older; also, they know more about
nutrition and are more concerned about gaining nutrition.
H6: Nutrition behavior increases with (a) greater success, (b)
married marital status, (c) female gender, (d) older age, (e) greater
nutrition knowledge, and (f) stronger nutrition concerns.
Exercise Behavior and Nutrition Behavior as Complementary Concepts
The Gestalt concept of an integrated health-oriented lifestyle
espoused here suggests an interdependence between persons'
behavioral involvement in exercise and nutrition as noted in the Figure.
Various scholars have used previous empirical findings as justification
for including both types of behaviors in their conceptualizations of the
influences on a healthful orientation toward life (e.g., Blair, 1988;
Gottlieb & Baker, 1986; Harris & Koehler, 1992; Pender, 1982,
1987; Weitzel, 1989). The notion of a fully integrated lifestyle
suggests that, once participants choose an exercise program as the means
of achieving certain health-related benefits, consistent nutritional
food choices will more likely follow, and vice versa (Brown, 1992). As a
concrete illustration, many fitness centers have successfully installed
health-food bars, thus promoting their clients' parallel
involvement in both nutrition- and exercise-related behaviors. In
complementary fashion, persons who enjoy eating have been known to view
exercise as the means of burning extra calories they have ingested.
Thus, the two behavioral constructs may be conceived to exert
reciprocal, positive influences on each other.
H7: There is a positive two-way flow of influence between nutrition
behavior and exercise behavior.
Clearly, justification for the linkages proposed in this model are
numerous, but because they have found empirical support in other context
does not an assurance that they will find empirical support in the
context of the present study. In sum, the present study is attempting to
investigate a process model of persons' who participate in specific
nutrition and physical fitness activities as a conscious lifestyle
choice.
METHOD
Data Collection
Survey data were collected from a sample of the residents of a
medium-sized community in the southeastern U.S. A total of 370 adults,
aged 18 and older and split evenly between males and females, were
contacted according to a random area cluster sample of dwellings. The
sampling frame included all sixteen sections of town that were
delineated by the municipal government. Respondents completed a
self-administered questionnaire in the presence of trained interviewers,
which served to motivate the cooperation of the respondents, to answer
any questions that might arise, and to monitor the progress of the
respondents.
Measurement
Five-point Likert scales were used to measure exercise attitudes
(e.g., "People who exercise regularly tend to have more energy than
those who don't"), nutrition concerns (e.g., "I am
concerned about my cholesterol level"), and nutrition knowledge
items (e.g., "Red meat is lower in fat than poultry"). The
Nutrition knowledge items were combined to form a composite index by
adding correct scores and subtracting incorrect scores, thus creating a
scale where a higher positive score connotes greater correctness of and
confidence in the respondent's answer. Correctness of response to
these items was judged by the working knowledge of one of the authors
and two experts in the area of nutrition. Each person judged the
correctness of the responses and the judges were 94% in agreement on
what represented a correct response to the nutrition knowledge items.
Exercise benefits (e.g., "Ability to handle stress"), was
operationalized by rating the importance of each benefit on a five-point
scale. Information on nutrition behavior came from reports of frequency
of consumption of food types (e.g., fresh vegetables, potato chips,
complex carbohydrates) on a seven-point scale. Exercise behavior, was
operationalized in three measures: (1) duration of participants'
average workout on a scale using five ranges stated in minutes per day
(e.g., 1-19 minutes/day), (2) frequency of workouts on a scale using
four ranges stated in days per week (e.g., 1-2 days/week), and (3) total
number of popular fitness activities pursued at least once a week.
Demographics were obtained using standard items for marital status,
gender, age, and education; occupational prestige was measured by coding
reported occupation using Duncan's Index (University of Illinois Bureau of Economic Research, 1990).
Data Analysis
The model was tested using structural equation analysis. Because
most constructs were operationalized using multiple measures, the
complete model being tested was relatively complex. Thus, it was
necessary to establish the measurement model separately at the first
stage of the structural equation analysis procedure (Anderson &
Gerbing, 1988; Herting & Costner, 1985). Exploratory factor analysis
and reliability analysis were used to identify those items that
performed best as indicators of the constructs. Then, confirmatory
factor analysis was conducted to form a measurement model consisting of
four exercise attitudes, three exercise benefits, three nutrition
concerns, and four nutrition behaviors.
Table 2 presents the items retained as indicators for the
subsequent structural analysis, which was conducted using LISREL 7
(Joreskog & Sorbom, 1989). The seven constructs portrayed in the
basic conceptual model were treated as ten constructs for empirical
investigation in which four separate demographics constructs were
recognized as sub-constructs. Because of their conceptual closeness, the
demographics measures for occupational prestige and education were taken
as formative measures of a single construct (Fornell & Bookstein,
1982) termed success, while marital status, gender, and age were treated
individually. The structural analysis employed the matrix of
correlations among the 23 indicators shown in Table 1 to obtain easily
interpretable standardized values for the parameter estimates.
EMPIRICAL RESULTS
Support for the Measurement Model
Table 2 presents the standardized pattern coefficients and the test
statistics that indicate the quality of the measurement model. The first
pattern coefficient for each construct was set at 1.0 to establish the
scale for the construct; therefore, this coefficient could not be tested
for significance. However, the coefficient selected to be fixed was the
one found highest by preliminary examination; the remaining, smaller,
free coefficients are all highly significant. Here, z-tests were used to
assess significance of the coefficients (Long, 1983a; Bollen, 1989),
producing z-values or critical ratios ranging from 7.69 to 13.04. In
general, all pattern coefficients are relatively high. Thus, examination
of the measurement model shows the set of operational measures is
appropriate for subsequent investigation of the proposed structural
linkages among the constructs.
Support for the Structural Equation Model as a Whole
Analysis of the full structural model, which includes the
measurement model and the proposed structural linkages, produced a
chi-square value of 406.48 (d.f. 201, p=.000). This test indicates a
discrepancy between the matrix of correlations based on the data and the
matrix imputed by the model; however, such discrepancies are common,
especially for samples of this size (Tanaka, 1993). The goodness of fit index is .916, and the index adjusted for degrees of freedom is .884,
both of which statistics indicate a moderately good fit between model
and data. The root mean square residual is .067. Taken together, these
statistics for the structural equation model as a whole provide solid
empirical support for both the conceptualization and its
operationalization.
Support for the Structural Linkages
On this basis, it is appropriate to examine the results of the test
of the proposed structural linkages. The total coefficient of
determination for the entire set of six structural equations that
explain the endogenous constructs in the model is .440. The squared
multiple correlations for each of these equations are: Exercise
attitudes, .016; Nutrition knowledge, .062; Exercise benefits, .562;
Nutrition concerns, .340; Exercise behavior, .319; and Nutrition
behavior, .533. These R2 values provide solid support for the equations
that explain the four constructs that appear later in the flow of
influence. In particular, the constructs proposed to explain
health-oriented lifestyle behavior perform their explanatory role well.
Expectedly, the two earlier endogenous constructs receive lesser
explanation from their smaller number of antecedents.
Turning to the individual linkages, Table 2 presents evidence
concerning the hypotheses that propose relationships between pairs of
constructs. Again, z-tests were used to assess significance of the
parameter estimates for the direct structural linkages (Long, 1983b;
Bollen, 1989), with one-tailed tests used for all hypothesized
relationships. The tests of direct links between constructs show support
(p<.05) for fifteen of the 27 hypothesized relationships. The
standard errors provided by LISREL were also used to perform z-tests on
the total effects, and nineteen of the 27 hypothesized relationships
were supported in this manner. (Further, considering the total effects
for the five additional paths not explicitly proposed by the model, 23
of the 32 possible uni-directional total effect linkages between pairs
of constructs emerged as significant. However, the total effect for the
bi-directional, reciprocal loop between exercise behavior and nutrition
behavior was not significant.) In sum, taken as a set, the individual
hypotheses proposed by the conceptualization were well-supported.
Impact of the Direct Effects
The tests of the direct effects provide simple, easily
interpretable evidence for judging whether the data support the proposed
links between pairs of constructs. This section presents the findings
for these tests of the direct links ending in each of the endogenous
constructs in turn. First, exercise attitudes is positively influenced
by success, such that greater success, as indicated by higher education
and occupational prestige, influences persons to view the idea of
exercising more favorably. Second, nutrition knowledge also increases
with higher Success and with female gender, but not with marital status.
Third, recognition of exercise benefits follows from more favorable
exercise attitudes, but not from success and age. Fourth, nutrition
concerns involving the nature of one's dietary intake is heightened
by the marital status of being married and by greater recognition of
exercise benefits. The empirical evidence indicates that success,
gender, age, and nutrition knowledge do not affect nutrition concerns.
Fifth, greater participation in exercise behavior stems from the
marital status of being single, of male ender, younger Age, more
favorable exercise attitudes, and, in reciprocal fashion, nutrition
behavior involving the consumption of healthy food alternatives.
Contrary to the hypotheses, exercise behavior does not reflect success
and perceived exercise benefits. Sixth, beneficial nutrition behavior
follows from greater success, female gender, older age, and greater
nutrition concerns. Persons' food habits do not reflect marital
status, nutrition knowledge, or exercise behavior. Thus, the empirical
support for the model is pervasive, as can be seen in the finding that
each of the six endogenous constructs is the endpoint for at least one,
and as many as five, significant direct linkages. Further, seven of the
eight constructs preceding the two "output" behavior
constructs (excepting only nutrition knowledge) affect a following
construct.
Impact of the Total Effects
Structural equation analysis also allows the analyst to investigate
a proposed relationship by going beyond the simple, direct link between
a pair of constructs. A direct link is often supplemented by one or more
indirect links that work through other, intervening constructs. The sum
of the direct and indirect effects produces a total effect that gives a
fuller portrayal of how one construct affects another. In fact, Bollen
(1989) claims the total effect is the linkage most relevant for
interpretation. Here, indirect paths augment the hypothesized direct
paths to the extent that they make four additional total paths
statistically significant. Further, because they follow solely indirect
paths, another four total paths emerge as significant where the model
does not posit direct linkages between pairs of constructs.
In the first case, supplemental indirect effects indicate that
exercise benefits increases with greater success, nutrition concerns
increases with both greater success and advancing age, and exercise
behavior increases with greater success. These findings show that the
exogenous demographic constructs, especially success, enter into more
complex relationships with the endogenous psychological and behavioral
constructs than is indicated by the more obvious, direct paths of
influence. In fact, success has a notable indirect impact on the overall
flow of influence on health-oriented lifestyle. In the second case,
positive influences emerge for exercise attitudes on nutrition concerns,
nutrition concerns on exercise behavior, exercise attitudes on nutrition
behavior, and exercise benefits on nutrition behavior.
DISCUSSION
The Process of Influence on Consumers' Health-Oriented
Lifestyle
Based on Bollen's (1989) recommendation, this discussion uses
the total effects that gained empirical support as the basis for
exploring the nature of the process of influence leading to a
health-oriented lifestyle. To reiterate, this study was an attempt to
investigate a process model of influence that focused on persons'
participation in nutritional food choices and physical fitness
activities. All analyses were done on individuals and any reference to
segments is done via marketing implications. Marketers will choose to
segment persons based on the type of food choices they make as well as
either the time of day they exercise or actual exercise of their choice
or the confluence of these two constructs. The purpose of this project
was to study lifestyle choices that consumers make regarding a
health-orientation.
Influences on Exercise Behavior
In general, the results show the importance of demographics for
explaining exercise behavior; all four demographic constructs affect
this element of lifestyle. Those persons who engage in exercise most
heavily are younger, single males who have found greater success in life
(as indicated by their higher education and occupational prestige).
Exercise attitudes also affect exercise behavior; heavier exercisers
have positive feelings about the practice of exercising and how it helps
persons feel good, feel fit, and feel more energetic.
Both nutrition concerns and nutrition behavior affect exercise
behavior. Heavier exercisers express stronger concerns about their
personal nutrition practices, including their intake of fatty foods and
cholesterol level. They also consume a diet of more nutritional foods,
such as fresh vegetables and fruits and wheat bread, while avoiding
snack foods such as potato chips. Thus, persons who exercise more
heavily are more cognitively and behaviorally involved in good health in
general; their involvement features both the exercise and nutrition
components of a health-oriented lifestyle.
In sum, demographics provide an explanation for this component of a
health-oriented lifestyle that is couched in simple terms. A fuller
understanding is gained by recognizing the strong influence from
supportive attitudes toward exercise and the additional contribution
from nutrition-related cognitive and behavioral influences. The person
most heavily engaged in exercise is more likely to be (in some
combination) younger, male, single, successful, positively disposed
toward exercise, concerned about nutrition, and currently following
nutritional food habits.
Influences on Nutrition Behavior
Demographics also contribute importantly to the explanation of
nutrition behavior, as all demographics except marital status affect
persons' consumption of nutritional foods. Those who consume a more
nutritional diet are older, female, and more successful in life.
Nutrition concerns also influences nutritional behavior; persons who
consume a more nutritional diet view nutrition as important, while being
concerned about such ingredients as fat and cholesterol.
The interlocking relationship between persons' orientation
toward both nutrition and exercise continues with this component of
lifestyle, as both psychological exercise constructs affect nutrition
behavior. Persons who have more nutritional food habits are more
positively disposed toward exercising. They are also more likely to
believe that exercising provides benefits that extend beyond the
physiological domain to improve participants' thinking, working,
and handling stress. Counter to expectations, participation in exercise
does not impact nutritional food choices (although the obverse influence
is supported). In sum, persons who consume more healthy food
alternatives can be characterized as female, successful, older,
concerned about nutrition, holding positive attitudes toward exercise,
and recognizing the benefits of exercise.
Influences on Exercise Benefits
Because exercise benefits impacts a criterion construct (nutrition
behavior), it is instructive to examine the influences on this
construct. Demographics do not provide substantial explanation here,
showing merely that more successful persons recognize the greater
mental, psychological, and work-related benefits of exercising. However,
persons' exercise attitudes are consistent with the benefits they
recognize; the data associate a positive assessment of exercising with
recognizing the advantages of participation in these fitness activities.
Concisely, the findings indicate that those who recognize the benefits
of regular and consistent exercise are more successful persons who hold
attitudes toward exercise that are consistent with their perceptions of
its benefits.
Influences on Nutrition Concerns
All of the demographics but gender influence nutrition concerns.
Persons who have greater concerns about nutrition tend to be married,
older, and more successful in life. In addition, both psychological
exercise-related constructs affect these cognitions. Persons who are
more likely to recognize benefits from exercising and to hold positive
attitudes toward exercising are more concerned about nutrition. In that
nutrition concerns subsequently affects exercise behavior, it emerges as
a central construct in a network of interlocking influences that gives
credence to the notion of a holistic health-oriented lifestyle.
Concisely, consumers who are concerned about nutrition are more likely
to be married, successful, and older, and to approve of exercise and
believe in its benefits for participants.
Influences on Nutrition Knowledge and Exercise Attitudes
While the model proposes only four linkages from demographics to
nutrition knowledge and exercise attitudes, the data support three of
them. Females and successful persons are more knowledgeable about
nutrition, and successful persons are also more favorably disposed
toward exercise. To summarize, the three nutrition-related constructs
are explained by eight significant (of course, hypothesized) direct
effects, two additional hypothesized total effects, and three
non-hypothesized total effects. The three exercise-related constructs
are explained by seven (hypothesized) direct links, two additional
hypothesized total effects, and one non-hypothesized total effect.
Exercise behavior receives five significant (hypothesized) direct
effects, one additional hypothesized total effect, and one
non-hypothesized total effect. Nutrition behavior receives four
significant (hypothesized) direct effects and two non-hypothesized total
effects. In all, the data provide a very even explanation for the
multiple constructs of the nutrition and exercise components of a
health-oriented lifestyle.
IMPLICATIONS FOR MARKETING PRACTITIONERS
This section examines some of the many implications for marketers
that issue from the empirical findings. It considers these implications
in reference to the market as a whole, the characteristics of individual
customers, entry points for marketing strategy, and suggested elements
of strategy for a health-oriented lifestyle (Kraft & Goodell, 1993).
The Nature of the Market
The findings indicate that the market can be cautiously considered
in holistic terms, given that there is considerable overlap involving
the psychological and the behavioral elements of both the nutrition- and
exercise-related components of lifestyle. Nonetheless, two somewhat
distinct segments can be discerned, those persons who are primarily
nutrition-oriented and those who are primarily exercise-oriented.
Further, the findings show this overlap between the two segments is
somewhat asymmetrical at the level of behavior. Persons who have an
interest in nutrition are more behaviorally involved in exercise than
persons who have an interest in exercise are involved in nutrition. To
speculate, it may be that a core of consumers, perhaps importantly
consisting of younger males, exercises regularly, yet is not
particularly concerned about what it eats and drinks.
Four general alternatives for designing an effective strategy are
possible. First, marketers can target a general health-oriented segment
by marketing aids to health improvement and maintenance in broad terms.
The findings suggest that, while this strategy would likely reach some
customers in both segments, it might also fail to connect with many
other consumers because it is not sufficiently specific to the entry
points offered by the psychological constructs and the demographic
characteristics. Second, targeting either nutrition-oriented or
exercise-oriented consumers could effectively and efficiently reach
persons in that particular segment, regardless of these consumers'
current membership in a market segment. However, this approach would
likely be ineffective with those in the other segment. Third, targeting
both segments in specific terms would likely be more effective, but
prohibitively inefficient. Fourth, marketers could target both segments
simultaneously, using relatively few, but fairly specific elements of
strategy. This dual-pronged strategy would emphasize selective aspects
of both nutrition and exercise, while indicating that the two components
are mutually interrelated elements of a health-oriented lifestyle. The
fourth alternative is both effective and efficient to the extent that
(current and potential) customers for nutrition- and exercise-related
offerings constitute overlapping segments.
The findings from this research indicate these two basic segments
do overlap. Thus, practitioners who seek to market nutrition, whether
through "diet" programs, food lines at a worksite, behavioral
therapy, or other means, should recognize they can further aid their
customers by encouraging and facilitating customers' participation
in regular exercise. They can communicate the message that a full
health-oriented lifestyle includes not only nutritional food
alternatives but also a regular exercise program. Note, however, that
those who supply clothing, equipment, instruction, and facilities for
exercisers may find it more difficult to expand into food offerings. The
findings indicate marketers who seek to expand their market in this way
will find lesser success in promoting the fitness-related benefits of
eating nutritional food to exercisers. Perhaps they can emphasize the
dysfunctional narrowness of a lifestyle that focuses only on exercise.
Characteristics of Individual Customers
The present findings indicate some difficulties in designing a
dual-pronged strategy based on consumers' demographics. The
findings portray those who are most active in exercise-related
activities as successful, younger, male, and single. Yet the persons
most active in nutrition-related activities are successful, older,
female, and married. The only common positive influence on their
health-oriented lifestyle is their greater success in life.
Of course, marketers would do well to consider to what extent the
(current and potential) customers identified here want external
commercial support for their lifestyle. Some persons are too
independent-minded to need, for example, a wellness center or nutrition
therapy (John & Miaoulis, 1992) to support their lifestyle choices.
It seems the desire for outside- vs. self-help lies on a continuum that
ranges from complete independence, through selective support, to
complete dependence on commercial providers for promoting health and
curing illness. In this sense, the more profitable targets would
apparently be those customers who will not or cannot act independently.
Thus, the question for marketers then becomes: which persons will be
most receptive and responsive to their marketing efforts?
Marketers should note this study focuses on influences that are
characterized as health-related. Yet, for some persons, the motivation
for a "health-oriented" lifestyle may be minimally concerned
with improving or maintaining their health. For example, persons with
strong social needs may want to join with others for primarily social
reasons with the benefits of exercise are less salient. Or,
hypochondriacs may simply want maximum attention from, perhaps rather
than relief from the healthcare system (John & Miaoulis, 1992).
Entry Points for Marketing Strategy
Marketers must identify those characteristics of consumers that
influence their lifestyle, yet are accessible to marketing strategy.
Such constructs in the model provide foci for efforts to influence
customers' behavior, given that they have received empirical
support in this study. For example, the findings indicate marketers can
enter the flow of influence to motivate positive nutrition-related
behavior by seeking to arouse customers' concern about nutrition,
encourage their favorable attitudes toward exercise, and heighten their
recognition of the benefits of exercise. Conversely, the finding that
nutrition knowledge does not influence behavior suggests educating
consumers would not be a productive strategy to use. Demographics, of
course, cannot be influenced, but marketers should recognize them as
important in devising a marketing strategy.
The finding that the flows of nutrition- and exercise-related
influences on behavior overlap indicates that the constructs in both
flows can be used as entry points for the suggested dual-pronged
marketing strategy. For example, success exerts a positive influence on
nutritional food habits and physical fitness activities. As Bloch (1984)
states, the marketing implication is that better-educated persons who
pursue wellness actively seek relevant information. They can better
handle the details of health-related treatments and procedures, and can
better understand their risks, as well. By extension, these consumers
should also be more accessible to complex offerings in the marketplace.
Marketing communications should follow accordingly.
As another entry point, concern for nutrition was shown to
influence both nutrition- and exercise-related activities. It seems that
marketers can profitably appeal to this concern with the dual-pronged
strategy, perhaps drawing from what has been learned about the marketing
of insurance services. This entry point seemingly provides access to
various specific domains of health-related concerns; e.g., concerns
involving disease prevention, proper physical functioning, sound
emotional outlook, and attractiveness. As another entry point, exercise
benefits (here, involving mental stability and workplace productivity)
were found to influence nutrition behavior. Thus, marketers can
profitably emphasize health-related benefits to their potential market,
perhaps by further segmenting the market in terms of more
narrowly-defined subsets of benefits.
Suggested Elements of Marketing Strategy
This sub-section suggests illustrative elements of marketing
strategy. It offers somewhat speculative suggestions intended to
stimulate the creative thoughts of practitioners who seek to serve this
market. Given the variety of offerings that apply to this market, it is
of course necessary to speak in generalities.
Product/Service Strategies. One basic strategy decision involves
what range of products/services/programs is appropriate for the target
market. Put otherwise, the firm must select the distinctive competencies
it will develop (Stone, Warren & Stevens, 1990). If a dual-pronged
strategy is used, the range of offerings and corresponding competencies
must acknowledge whether the firm's customers follow a conceptually
concentrated, holistic, health-oriented lifestyle (Harrell & Fors,
1985). If they do, the range of offerings may be fairly wide, although
marketers can likely narrow this range to the extent they will commit to
serving a clearly-defined, limited set of lifestyle activities.
The strategy may require the firm to exhibit a variety of
competencies. To illustrate, the notion of experience-based management
of a recreation setting suggests the value of facilitating the
appropriate mix of physical, social, and managerial settings for
lifestyle activities (Driver & Rosenthal, 1982). Consider marketing
strategy for a health spa. Translated into this context, the concept
suggests a dual-pronged strategy should address multiple dimensions of
an environment created to help customers engage in their common
lifestyle activities. Marketers might seek to motivate participation in
exercise by a segment of more-successful females who make nutritional
food choices, but who lag less-successful males in exercising. The
strategy could locate an attractive health-food bar within the facility
so that the women can interact socially with other successful women.
This setting would provide a supportive venue for a nutritional snack
and, simultaneously, the site for a vigorous workout.
Promotion Strategies. When selecting an appropriate communication
strategy, marketers should certainly consider demographics, both those
empirically supported here, as well as others that were not
investigated. To speculate, while more-successful consumers might easily
envision their success in a new workout program, management might have
to convince targeted less-successful consumers they can succeed.
Further, while consumers who generally rate the benefits of exercise
participation highly would likely be receptive to communications
involving such benefits, other persons might have to be initially
informed or even constantly reminded of the importance of these
benefits. Regarding the thrust of promotional messages, despite the
emphasis given cognitive constructs by this study, previous studies
indicate that not all health-related decisions are rational (Burns,
1992).
Promotions can reach the target market through a variety of media
such as pamphlets, films, videotapes, slides, audiotapes, workbooks, and
health assessment instruments. They might use such devices as
sponsorship of local sporting events and sports clubs, ads in
health-related publications, displays at health fairs, computer
messages, interaction with live instructors, brochures, newsletters,
open houses, posters, and word of mouth (Bloch, 1984; Leafgren &
Elsenrath, 1986; McPartland, 1989). Their messages should use the entry
points discussed above to emphasize such outcomes as body strength and
stamina, mental wellness, independence, youthful functioning, and a slim
and beautiful appearance (Hertzler & Grun, 1990).
Marketers should recognize that some persons will become opinion
leaders for others, which suggests the value of promoting a two-step
flow of information. For example, the strategy could attempt to persuade
health-care professionals by using such entry points as nutrition
concerns and exercise benefits, with the hope these opinion leaders will
subsequently recommend the firm's offerings to their own clients in
similar terms. Or, where the findings indicate being married exerts a
positive influence on another construct such as nutrition concerns, the
strategy could target married persons to enhance the effectiveness of a
communication designed to impact these nutrition concerns.
IMPLICATIONS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH
Overall, the model finds fairly strong support. Demographics play
an important part in the flow of influence. The contribution of success
is particularly noteworthy, and its role in the process of influence
leading to a health-oriented lifestyle should be investigated further.
As usual, the findings also reveal areas for improvement. Considering
just the demographics that were used here, the model should be revised.
The modification indices provided with LISREL indicate a significant
link would connect gender to exercise attitudes if it were allowed.
Going further, a different set of demographics, or even other personal
characteristics, might furnish stronger explanation of the six
endogenous constructs in the model than do the three demographics other
than success. Future research should investigate this possibility.
Beyond demographics, one notable gap in the model that deserves
further investigation is the failure of nutrition knowledge to influence
any following constructs. If such knowledge does not link with behavior,
devising a cognitive approach to motivating behavior, especially one
involving food habits, becomes difficult. However, as usual, the issue
of appropriate measurement of the construct should be considered.
Perhaps pencil-and-paper measures of this knowledge lack validity, even
though this means of measuring knowledge is broadly acceptable to
educators. Quite likely, better educated persons score higher on any
test of this kind, even when they are no more able to apply this
knowledge to decision-making. The best operationalization of knowledge
would measure that form of cognitive understanding that is actually put
into practice when making behavioral choices. If it is appropriate to
measure this form of knowledge, future research should search for the
best way to measure this construct.
Finally, while exercise benefits affects two nutrition constructs,
it does not impact exercise behavior. Future research can investigate
why such a cognitive justification for exercise behavior is insufficient
to motivate that behavior. Perhaps participants' involvement is
less cognitive and more affective; that is, many exercisers may being
seeking pleasure in the form of an emotional, or even a physiological,
"high" (Clough, Shepherd & Maughan, 1989). In any case,
the reason why the proposed link from exercise benefits to exercise
behavior was not supported deserves further investigation; again, the
possibility of a different operationalization should be considered.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
This study proposes a model of the process of influence on
consumers' pattern of activities referred to here as their
health-oriented lifestyle. The empirical test of the model provides
general, but qualified, support for the model. The findings indicate
that persons who consume more nutritional food are more concerned about
nutrition, more strongly emphasize the benefits of exercise, hold more
favorable attitudes toward exercise, and are more likely successful,
female, and older. Those who exercise more heavily eat more nutritional
food, evince greater concern for nutrition, possess more favorable
attitudes toward exercise, and are more likely successful, single, male,
and younger.
Consumers who are more concerned about nutrition emphasize more
strongly the benefits of exercise, hold more favorable attitudes toward
exercise, and are more likely successful, married, and older. Those who
stress more strongly the benefits of exercise hold supporting attitudes
toward exercise and are more successful. Persons who know more about
nutrition possess more favorable attitudes toward exercise and are more
likely successful and female.
These empirical findings demonstrate the interlocking nature of
consumers' psychological and behavioral involvement in the
nutrition- and exercise-related aspects of health. The findings thus
support the basic concept of this study: (1) a health-oriented lifestyle
integrates both nutrition and exercise components, and (2) those who
follow this lifestyle can be usefully characterized in terms of their
psychological involvement in both nutrition and exercise, and by their
demographics. Therefore this study has made a significant step at trying
to characterize a lifestyle that has gained considerable attention in
the popular press. It is the first attempt to empirical test a process
model that considers many constructs involved in a health-oriented
lifestyle. It provides information useful to marketers in developing
strategies aimed at specific segments of nutrition and physical fitness
enthusiasts.
REFERENCES
Abella, R. & R. Heslin. (1984). Health, locus of control,
values, and the behaviors of family and friends: An integrated approach
to understanding preventive health behavior. Basic and Applied Social
Psychology, 5 (December), 283-294.
Amstutz, M. K. & D. L. Dixon. (1986). Dietary changes resulting
from the expanded food and nutrition education program. Journal of
Nutrition Education, 18, (April), 55-60.
Anderson, A. S. & R. Shepherd. (1989). Beliefs and attitudes
toward healthier eating among women attending maternity hospital.
Journal of Nutrition Education, 21,(October), 208-213.
Armstrong, J. E., E. Lange & D. E. Stem, Jr. (1990). Reported
dietary practices and concerns of adult male and female recreational
exercisers. Journal of Nutrition Education, 22 ,(October), 220-225.
Assam, E. H. & Bucklin, L. P. (1973). Nutrition labeling for
canned goods: A study of consumer response, Journal of Marketing, 37,
32-7.
Bagozzi, R. P. & P. R. Warshaw. (1990). Trying to consume,
Journal of Consumer Research, 17 (September), 127-40.
Barr, S. I. (1986). Nutrition knowledge and selected nutritional
practices of female recreational athletes, Journal of Nutrition
Education, 18, (August), 167-174.
Becker, M. H. & L. A. Maiman.(1975). Sociobehavioral
determinants of compliance with health and medical care recommendations.
Medical Care, 13, (January), 10-24.
Berger, M. C. & P. Leigh. (1989). Schooling, self-satisfaction,
and health. Journal of Human Resources, 24 (Summer): 433-455.
Blair, S. N. (1988). Exercise within a healthy lifestyle, in
Exercise Adherence: Its Impact on Public Health, Rod K. Dishman, ed.
Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics Books.
Bloch, Pe. (1984). The wellness movement: Imperatives for health
care marketers, Journal of Health Care Marketing, 4, (Winter), 9-16.
Block, G., W. F. Rosenberger & B.H. Patterson. (1988).
Calories, fat, and cholesterol: Intake patterns in the US population by
race, sex and age, American Journal of Public Health, 78 (September),
1150-1155.
Booth, M. L., P. Macaskill, N. Owen & B. Oldenburg, et al.
(1993). Population prevalence and correlates of stages of change in
physical activity, Health Education Quarterly, (Fall), 431-440.
Brooks, T. L., M.E. Hughes & I. Waldron. (1996). Marriage
protection and marriage selection-prospective evidence for reciprocal
effects of marital status and health, Social Science Medicine, 43 (1),
113-122.
Brown, J. D. & J. M. Siegel. (1988). Exercise as a buffer of
life stress: A prospective study of adolescent health, Health
Psychology, 7 (4), 341-353.
Brown, J. D. (1992). Benefit segmentation of the fitness market,
Health Marketing Quarterly, 9 (3/4), 19-28.
Burns, A. C. (1992). The expanded health belief model as a basis
for enlightened preventive health care practice and research, Journal of
Health Care Marketing,, 12 (September), 32-45.
Cahill, D. (1996). Hit target market with your best shot, Marketing
News, 30(7), (November 18), 24.
Campaigne, B. N., K. W. Landt, M. J. Mellies, F. W. James, C. J.
Glueck & M. A. Sperling. (1985). The effects of physical training on
block lipid profiles in adolescents with insulin-dependent diabetes
mellitus, Physician and Sports Medicine, 13 (December), 83-89.
Casper, R. C. & D. Offer. (1990). Weight and dieting concerns
in adolescents: Fashion or symptoms? Pediatrics, 86 (September),
384-390.
Clough, P., J. Shepherd & R. Maughan. (1989). Motives for
participation in recreational running,, Journal of Leisure Research, 21
(Fourth Quarter), 297-309.
Contento, I. R. & B. M. Murphy. (1990). Psycho-social factors
differentiating people who reported making desirable changes in their
diet from those who did not, Journal of Nutrition Education, 22
(February), 6-12.
Davies, E. & A. Furnham. (1986). The dieting and body shape
concerns of adolescent females, Journal of Child Psychology and
Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines, 27(May), 417-328.
Deeter, T. E. (1988). Does attitudinal commitment predict physical
activity participation?, Journal of Sport Behavior, 11 (December),
177-192.
Dimance, F. & D. Samdahl. (1994). Leisure as symbolic
consumption: A conceptualization and prospectus for future research,
Leisure Sciences, 16(2), (April/June), 119-129.
Dishman, R. K. (1982). Compliance/adherence in health-related
exercise, Health Psychology, 1 (Summer), 237-267.
Dishman, R. K. & L. R. Gettman. (1980). Psychobiologic
influences on exercise adherence, Journal of Sport Psychology, 2 (4),
295-310.
Dishman, R. K., W. Ickes & W. P. Morgan. (1980).
Self-motivation and adherence to habitual physical activity, Journal of
Applied Social Psychology, 10 (March/April), 115-132.
Dishman, R. K., J. F. Sallis & D.R. Orenstein. (1985). The
determinants of physical activity and exercise, Public Health Reports,
100 (March-April), 158-171.
Doyle, T. B. (1989). Survival of the fittest, American
Demographics, 11 (May), 38-41.
Duda, J. L. & M. K. Tappe. (1988). Predictors of personal
investment in physical activity among middle-aged and older adults,
Perceptual and Motor Skills, 66 (April), 543-549.
Duda, J. L. & M. K. Tappe. (1989). Personal investment in
exercise among middle-aged and older adults, in Aging and Motor
Behavior, Andrew C. Ostrow, ed. Indianapolis, IN: Benchmark Press,
219-238.
Duffy, M. (1989). Mental well-being and primary prevention
practices in women heads of one-parent families, Journal of Divorce, 13
(1), 45-64.
Eklund, R. C. & S. Crawford. (1994). Active women, social
physique, anxiety, and exercise, Journal of Sport and Exercise
Psychology, 16 (December), 431-448.
Ferguson, K. J., C.E. Yesalis, P. R. Pomrehn & M. B.
Kirkpatrick. (1989). Attitudes, knowledge, and beliefs as predictors of
exercise intent and behavior in schoolchildren, Journal of School
Health, 59 (March), 112-115.
Field, L. K. & Steinhardt, M. A.(1992). The relationship of
internally directed behavior to self-reinforcement, self-esteem, and
expectancy values for exercise, American Journal of Health Promotion, 7
(September/October), 21-27.
Firebaugh, G. (1989). Gender differences in exercise and sports,
Sociology and Social Research, 73 (January), 59-66.
Fries, J. & J. P. Leigh. (1993). Associations among healthy
habits, age, gender, and education in a sample of retirees,
International Journal of Aging and Human Development, 36(2), 139-155.
French, W. A. & Barksdale, H.C. (1974). Food labeling
regulations: Efforts toward full disclosure, Journal of Marketing, 38,
14-9.
Fornell, C. & F. L. Bookstein. (1982). Two structural equation
models: LISREL and PLS applied to consumer exit-voice theory, Journal of
Marketing Research, 19 (November), 440-52.
French, S. A., R. W. Jeffery & R. R. Wing.(1994). Sex
difference among participants in a weight-control program, Addictive Behaviors, 19(2), 147-58.
Ganley, R.M. (1989). Emotion and eating in obesity: A review of the
literature, International Journal of Eating Disorders, 8 (May), 343-361.
Gephardt, D. L. & C. E. Crump. (1990). Employee fitness and
wellness programs in workplace, American Psychologist, 45(February),
262-272.
Godin, G. & R. Shephard. (1986). Psychosocial factors
influencing intention to exercise of young students from grades 7 to 9,
Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 57 (March), 41-52.
Gottlieb, N. H. & J. A. Baker. (1986). The relative influence
of health beliefs, parental and peer behaviors and exercise program
participation on smoking, alcohol use and physical activity, Social
Science and Medicine, 22 (9), 915-927.
Granzin, K. L. & K. D. Bahn. (1988). The role of attitudes
toward nutrition in restaurant patronage, Journal of Nutrition
Education, (April), 56-62.
Haralson, M. K., Sargent, R. G. & Schluchter, M. (1992). The
relationship between knowledge of cardiovascular dietary risk and food
shopping behaviors, American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 6(6),
318-322.
Harrell, G. D. & M. F. Fors. (1985). Marketing ambulatory care to women: A segmentation approach, Journal of Health Care Marketing, 5
(Spring), 19-28.
Harris, M. B. & K.M. Koehler. (1990). Eating and exercise
behaviors and attitudes of southwestern anglos and hispanics, Psychology
and Health, 7(6), 165-174.
Hayes, D. & C. E. Ross. (1987). Concern with appearance, health
beliefs, and eating habits, Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 28
(June), 120-130.
Hendrix, W.H., N. K. Ovalle & R. G. Troxler. (1985). Behavioral
and physiological consequences of stress and its antecedent factors,
Journal of Applied Psychology, 70 (February), 188-201.
Hollis, J. F., T. P. Carmody, S. L. Connor, S. G. Fey & J. D.
Hatarazzo. (1986). The nutrition attitude survey: Associations with
dietary habits, psychological and physical well-being, and coronary risk
factors, Health Psychology, 5 (4), 359-374.
Homer, P. M. & L. R. Kahle. (1988). A structural equation test
of the value-attitude-behavior hierarchy, Journal of Personality and
Social Psychology, 54 (April), 638-646.
Hope, A. (1988). Psychosocial Factors that Discriminate Among
Exercisers, Occasional Exercisers, and Nonexercisers, D.P.E. Thesis,
Springfield College. Microfiche BF337.E9 H66 1988
Ippolito, P. M. & A. D. Mathios. (1990). Information,
advertising and health choices: A study of the cereal market," RAND
Journal of Economics, 21(3), (Autumn), 459-80.
Jacoby, J., R. W. Chestnut & W. Silberman. (1977). Consumer use
and comprehension of nutrition information, Journal of Consumer
Research, 4 (September), 119-128.
John, J. & G. Miaoulis. (1992). A model for understanding
benefit segmentation in preventive health care, Health Care Management
Review, 17(2), (Spring), 21-32.
Kirk, M. C. & A. H. Gillespie. (1990). Factors affecting food
choices of working women with young families, Journal of Nutrition
Education, 22 (August), 161-168.
Koslow, R. W.(1988). Age-related reasons for expressed interest in
exercise and weight control, Journal of Applied Social Psychology,
18(March, Part 2), 349-354.
Kraft, F. B. & P. W. Goodell. (1993). Identifying the health
conscious consumer, Journal of Health Care Marketing, 13(3), (Fall),
18-25.
Kulik, J. A. & H. I.M. Mahler. (1987). Health status,
perceptions of risk, and prevention interest for health and non-health
problems, Health Psychology, 6 (1), 15-27.
Lau, B. (1985-1986). The best diet for busy people, Management
Quarterly, 26 (Winter), 22-25.
Lau, R. R., K. A. Hartman & J. E. Ware, Jr. (1986). Health as a
value: Methodological and theoretical considerations, Health Psychology,
5 (1), 25-43.
Leafgren, F. & D. E. Elsenrath. (1986). Resources for campus
recreation and wellness programs, New Directions for Student Services,
No. 34 (June), 67-81.
Lee, C. (1993). Attitudes, knowledge, and stages of change: A
survey of exercise patterns in older australian women, Health
Psychology, (November) 476-480.
Leutzinger, J. A.& D. M. Hunnicutt. (1996). Applying marketing
concepts and social change strategies to worksite health promotion,
Compensation and Benefits Management, 12(3), (Summer), 15-20.
Lifestyles, lifestages: Understanding their impact on purchasing
patterns, Drug Store News, 18(15), (September 23), A7-A8.
Loro, L. (1992). Lifestyle information gives the soul of person,
Advertising Age, 63(29), (July 20), S34.
Maehr, M.L. & L. A. Braskamp. (1986). The Motivation Factor: A
Theory of Personal Investment, Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Marcus, B.H., C. A. Eaton, J. S. Rossi & L. L. Harlow.(1994).
Self-efficacy, decision-making, and stages of change: An integrative
model of physical exercise, Journal of Applied Social Psychology,
(March) 489-508.
Mathios, A. D. (1996). Socioeconomic factors, nutrition, and food
choices: An analysis of the salad dressing market, Journal of Public
Policy and Marketing, 15(1), (Spring), 45-54.
McAuley, E., Courneya, K. S. & R.udolph, D. L. et al.(1994).
Enhancing exercise adherence in middle-aged males and females,
Preventive Medicine, 23, 498-506.
McIntosh, W.A., K.S. Kubena, J. Walker, D. Smith & W. A.
Landmann. (1990). The relationship between beliefs about nutrition and
dietary practices of the elderly, Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 90 (May), 671-676.
McPartland, P. A. (1989). Health care marketing minicase, Journal
of Health Care Marketing, 9 (March) 59-63.
Moorman, C. & E. Matulich. (1993). A model of consumers'
preventive health behaviors: The role of health motivation and health
ability, Journal of Consumer Research, 20(September), 208-28.
Nayga, R.M., Jr. (1997). Impact of socio-demographic factors on
perceived importance of nutrition in food shopping, Journal of Consumer
Affairs, 31(1), (Summer), 1-9.
O'Connell, D. & W. F. Velicer. (1988). A decisional
balance measure and the stages of change model for weight loss,
International Journal of the Addictions, 23 (July), 729-750.
O'Connor, P.J. & G. L. Sullivan. (1995). Market
segmentation: A comparison of benefits/attributes desired and brand
preference, Psychology and Marketing, 12(7), (October), 612-623.
Oman, R. & McAuley, E. (1993). Intrinsic motivation and
exercise behavior, Journal of Health Education, 24(July/August),
232-238.
Pender, N. J. (1987). Health Promotion in Nursing Practice, 2nd ed.
Norwalk, CT: Appleton & Lange, 58-68.
Pender, N. J. & A. R. Pender. (1986). Attitudes, subjective
norms, and intentions to engage in health behaviors, Nursing Research,
35 (January/February), 15-18.
Peterkin, B. (1986). Women's diets: 1977 and 1985, Journal of
Nutrition Education, 18(6), 251-257.
Poag, K. & McAuley, E. (1992). Goal setting, self-efficacy, and
exercise behavior, Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 14,
352-360.
Prohaska, T. R., E. A. Leventhal, H. Leventhal & M. L. Keller.
(1985). Health practices and illness cognition in young, middle-aged,
and elderly adults, Journal of Gerontology, 40 (September), 569-578.
Rabinowitz, S., S. Melamed, E. Weisberg & D. Tal, et al.
(1992). Personal determinants of leisure-time exercise activities,
Perceptual and Motor Skills, (December), 779-784.
Rea, P. S. (1987). Using recreation to promote fitness, Parks and
Recreation, 22 (July), 32-36, 59.
Ross, C. E. & C.Wu. (1995). The links between education and
health, American Sociological Review, 60 (October), 719-745.
Rowland, G. L., R. E. Franken & K. Harrison. (1986). Sensation
seeking and participation in sporting activities, Journal of Sport
Psychology, 8 (September), 212-220.
Rudman, W. J.(1989). Age and involvement in sport and physical
activity, Sociology of Sport Journal, 6(September), 228-245.
Russo, J. E., R. Staelin, C. A. Nolan, G.J. Russell & B. L.
Metcalf. (1986). Nutrition information in the supermarket, Journal of
Consumer Research, 13(June), 48-70.
Sandor, G. (1994). Attitude (not age) defines the mature market,
American Demographics, 16(1), (January), 18-21.
Schafer, R. B. & E. Schafer. (1989). Relationship between
gender and food roles in the family, Journal of Nutrition Education, 21
(June), 119-126.
Schlosberg, J. (1987). The demographics of dieting, American
Demographics, 9 (July), 34-37, 61-62.
Signorielli, N. & Lears, M. (1992). Television and
children's conceptions of nutrition: Unhealthy messages, Health
Communication, 4(4), 245-257.
Slenker, S. E., J.H. Price, S. M. Roberts & S. G. Jurs. (1984).
Joggers versus non-exercisers: An analysis of knowledge, attitudes and
beliefs about jogging, Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 55
(December), 371-378.
Sobal, J., D. Revicki & B. R. DeForge. (1992). Patterns of
interrelationships among health-promotion behaviors, American Journal of
Preventive Medicine, 8 (6), 351-359.
Sonstroem, R. J., L.L. Harlow & L. Josephs. (1994). Exercise
and self-esteem: Validity of model expansion and exercise associations,
Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology. (March), 29-42.
Sonstroem, R. J.(1988). Psychological models, In Exercise
Adherence: Its Impact on Public Health, Rod K. Dishman, ed. Champaign,
IL: Human Kinetics Books, 125-183.
Stephens, T., D.R. Jacobs, Jr.& C. C. White. (1985). A
descriptive epidemiology of leisure-time physical activity, Public
Health Reports, 100 (March-April), 147-158.
Stone, T. R, W.E. Warren & R. E. Stevens. (1990). Segmenting
the mental health care market, Journal of Health Care Marketing, 10
(March), 65-69.
Storz, N. S. (1983). Body weight, body image, and perception of fad
diets in adolescent girls, Journal of Nutrition Education, 15(Spring),
15-18.
Summers, J. J., V. J. Machin & G. I. Sargent. (1983).
Psycho-social factors related to marathon running, Journal of Sport
Psychology, 5 (3), 314-331.
Taylor, H. (1991). Has the fitness movement peaked?, American
Demographics, 13(1), (October), 10-11.
Tappe, M.K., J.L.. Duda & P. M. Ehrnwald. (1989). Perceived
barriers to exercise among adolescents, Journal of School Health, 59
(April), 153-155.
Thompson, A. M. & P. F. Kaminski. (1993). Psychographic and
lifestyle antecedents of service quality expectations: A segmentation
approach, Journal of Services Marketing,, 7 (4), 53-61.
Trent, L. K. (1992). Nutrition knowledge of active-duty navy
personnel, Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 92(June),
724-728.
Tudor, R. K. & S. S. Carley. (1995). Time to choose, Journal of
Health Care Marketing, 15(2), (Summer), 48-53.
Veal, A.J. (1993). The concept of lifestyle: A review, Leisure
Studies, 12 (October), 233-252.
Verhoef, M. J., Love, E. J. & Rose, S.M. (1992). Women's
social roles and their exercise participation, Women & Health,
19(4), 15-29.
Walton, S. (1987). Eating healthfully: For appearance' sake,
Psychology Today, (December), 18. (Microfilm).
Wankel, L. M. & K. W. Mummery. (1993). Using national survey
data incorporating the theory of planned behavior: implications for
social marketing strategies in phsycial activity. Special issue: The
application of social psychological theories to health and exercise,
Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, (September), 158-177.
Weber, J. & E. H. Wertheim. (1989). Relationships of
self-monitoring, special attention, body fat percent, and
self-motivation to attendance at a community gymnasium, Journal of Sport
and Exercise Psychology, 11 (March), 105-114.
Weitzel, M. H. (1989). A test of the health promotion model with
blue collar workers, Nursing Research, 38(March/April), 99-104.
Witte, D. J., Skinner, J. D. & Carruth, B. R.(1991).
Relationship of self-concept to nutrient intake and eating patterns in
young women, Journal of the American Dietetic Association,
91(September), 1068-1073.
Wyner, G. A. (1995). Segmentation analysis, then and now, Marketing
Research: A Magazine of Management and Application, 7(1), (Winter),
40-41.
Kenneth D. Bahn, James Madison University
Kent L. Granzin, University of Utah
Newell D. Wright, James Madison University
Table 1: Pattern Coefficients, z Statistics, Reliabilities for the
Measurement Model
Construct/Indicator Standardized
Coefficient
Success Occupational Prestige .770
Education .615
Marital Status Currently married (0=no; 1=yes) 1
Gender (0=male; 1=female) 1
Age (years) 1
Exercise Attitudes Exercise is important .752
Being fit/in shape is important .733
People who exercise regularly
have more energy .716
Feel good from exercising .702
Exercise Benefits Ability to think more clearly .732
Increased productivity at work .729
Ability to handle stress .727
Nutrition Knowledge: An index based on correctness
of answers to 12 questions 1
Nutrition Concerns Watch my intake of fatty foods .801
Concerned about cholesterol level .678
Nutrition important in my life .659
Exercise Behavior Duration of average workout .783
Frequency of workouts .753
Total number of activities .531
Nutrition Behavior Intake of fresh fruit .741
Intake of fresh vegetables .701
Intake of wheat bread products .526
Intake of potato chips -.459
Construct/Indicator z
Success Occupational Prestige -- (a)
Education 8.12 (b)
Marital Status Currently married (0=no; 1=yes) -- (a)
Gender (0=male; 1=female) -- (a)
Age (years) -- (a)
Exercise Attitudes Exercise is important -- (a)
Being fit/in shape is important 13.04 (b)
People who exercise regularly
have more energy 12.77 (b)
Feel good from exercising 12.51 (b)
Exercise Benefits Ability to think more clearly -- (a)
Increased productivity at work 12.02 (b)
Ability to handle stress 12.00 (b)
Nutrition Knowledge: An index based on correctness
of answers to 12 questions -- (a)
Nutrition Concerns Watch my intake of fatty foods -- (a)
Concerned about cholesterol level 11.69 (b)
Nutrition important in my life 11.41 (b)
Exercise Behavior Duration of average workout -- (a)
Frequency of workouts 10.86 (b)
Total number of activities 8.77 (b)
Nutrition Behavior Intake of fresh fruit -- (a)
Intake of fresh vegetables 11.11 (b)
Intake of wheat bread products 8.73 (b)
Intake of potato chips 7.69 (b)
Construct/Indicator Indicator
Reliability
Success Occupational Prestige .593
Education .378
Marital Status Currently married (0=no; 1=yes) 1.000 (a)
Gender (0=male; 1=female) 1.000 (a)
Age (years) 1.000 (a)
Exercise Attitudes Exercise is important .566
Being fit/in shape is important .537
People who exercise regularly
have more energy .513
Feel good from exercising .492
Exercise Benefits Ability to think more clearly .536
Increased productivity at work .531
Ability to handle stress .529
Nutrition Knowledge: An index based on correctness
of answers to 12 questions 1.000 (a)
Nutrition Concerns Watch my intake of fatty foods .651
Concerned about cholesterol level .464
Nutrition important in my life .438
Exercise Behavior Duration of average workout .614
Frequency of workouts .569
Total number of activities .283
Nutrition Behavior Intake of fresh fruit .55
Intake of fresh vegetables .492
Intake of wheat bread products .277
Intake of potato chips .211
(a) Coefficient of leading indicator for each construct was
set to 1.0 to establish scale for the construct
(b) p<.001
Table 2: Magnitude and Significance of Hypothesized Structural
Relationships
Following/Leading Hypo. Parameter Standard
Constructs Sign Effect
Exercise Attitudes
Success + [Y.sub.11] 0.125
Nutrition Knowledge
Success + [Y.sub.21] 0.258
Marital Status + [Y.sub.22] -0.101
Gender + [Y.sub.23] 0.173
Exercise Benefits
Success + [Y.sub.31] 0.066
Age + [Y.sub.34] 0.021
Exercise Attitudes + [[beta].sub.31] 0.737
Nutrition Concerns
Success + [Y.sub.41] 0.128
Marital Status + [Y.sub.42] 0.154
Gender + [Y.sub.43] 0.076
Age + [Y.sub.44] 0.110
Exercise Attitudes -- -- --
Nutrition Knowledge + [[beta].sub.42] 0.087
Exercise Benefits + [[beta].sub.43] 0.416
Exercise Behavior
Success + [Y.sub.61] 0.092
Marital Status - [Y.sub.62] -0.249
Gender - [Y.sub.63] -0.190
Age - [Y.sub.64] 0.193
Exercise Attitudes + [B.sub.61] 0.508
Nutrition Knowledge --
Exercise Benefits + [B.sub.62] -0.308
Nutrition Concerns [B.sub.63] --
Nutrition Behavior + 0.301
Nutrition Behavior
Success + [Y.sub.81] 0.192
Marital Status + [Y.sub.82] -0.006
Gender + [Y.sub.83] 0.181
Age + [Y.sub.84] 0.185
Exercise Attitudes --
Nutrition Knowledge + [B.sub.82] -0.038
Exercise Benefits 4 [B.sub.8] --
Nutrition Concerns + [B.sub.86] 0.551
Nutrition Behavior + -0.120
Following/Leading Direct (Total) z Values
Constructs Effect
Exercise Attitudes
Success .153 (a) (.153a (a)) 1.84 (1.84)
Nutrition Knowledge
Success .420 (a) (.420 (a)) 2.97 (2.98)
Marital Status -.101 (-.101) 1.39 (1.38)
Gender .173 (a) (.173 (a)) 3.13 (3.15)
Exercise Benefits
Success .079 (.189 (a)) 1.08 (1.08)
Age .015 (.015) .41 (.41)
Exercise Attitudes .717 (a) (.717 (a)) 10.10 (10.10)
Nutrition Concerns
Success .167 (a) (.282 (a)) 1.43 (2.39)
Marital Status .123 (a) (.116 (a)) 1.79 (1.68)
Gender .061 (.073) 1.34 (1.62)
Age .088 (.095 (a)) 1.63 (1.73)
Exercise Attitudes --(.326 (b)) -- 6.04
Nutrition Knowledge .070 (.070) 1.61 (1.59)
Exercise Benefits .455 (a) (.455 (a)) 6.49 (6.50)
Exercise Behavior
Success .117 (.280 (a)) .960 (2.37)
Marital Status -.195 (a) (-.171 (a)) 2.81 (2.48)
Gender -.149 (a) (-.093 (a)) 2.88 (2.07)
Age -.151 (a) (-.091 (a)) 2.49 (1.69)
Exercise Attitudes .528 (a) (.473 (a)) 4.30 (6.86)
Nutrition Knowledge --0.002 -- (.150)
Exercise Benefits -.127 (-.051) .970 (.430)
Nutrition Concerns -- (.156 (a)) -- (2.26)
Nutrition Behavior .318 (a) (.307 (a)) 2.36 (2.58)
Nutrition Behavior
Success .232 (a) (.332 (a)) 2.12 (3.02)
Marital Status -.004 (.077) .070 (1.18)
Gender .134 (a) (.177 (a)) 3.13 (4.12)
Age .137 (a) (.196 (a)) 2.75 (3.84)
Exercise Attitudes -- (.112 (b)) -- (2.49)
Nutrition Knowledge -.028 (.007) .720 (.180)
Exercise Benefits (.237 (b)) -- (4.74)
Nutrition Concerns .509 (a) (.491 (a)) 6.91 (7.33)
Nutrition Behavior -.113 (-.109) 1.22 (1.27)
(a) p<.05 using one-tailed test to reflect a proposed direction
hypothesis for this direct effect
(b) p<.05 using two-tailed test to reflect no proposed
(directional) hypothesis for this total effect; all four significant
additional total effects are positive in sign