Semi-empirical model of the simulation of traffic pollution dispersion near roadways/Keliu tarsos pernasos aplinkoje pusiau empirinis modelis/Semiempiriskais imitacijas modelis satiksmes radita piesarnojuma izkliedes novertesanai pie autoceliem/Poolempiiriline simulatsioonimudel liiklussaastele teeaarel.
Martinenas, Bronislovas ; Spakauskas, Valdas ; Jasaitis, Dainius 等
1. Introduction
Traffic pollution depending from various reasons has a large impact
on ecological processes and various components of ecosystems and causes
serious health effects. It forms about 70% of the whole air pollution in
the biggest cities of Europe and Lithuania (Vaiskunaite et al. 2009).
While there is a lack of some essential parameters specifying the
level of noxiousness of some materials, the effect of air pollution on
human health is often evaluated statistically by epidemiological
studies. It is determined that traffic pollution effect on human health
depends directly on total aerosol particles concentration, without
distinguishing concrete particles, moreover, the effect increases due to
ultrafine particles (diameter < 0.1 [micro]m), which are produced in
the engines of vehicles. The concentration of ultrafine particles near
the road with the downwind is approximately 25-30 times higher than with
the upwind, these particles often cause respiratory diseases (Zhu, Hinds
2005). Whole view of the dispersion of pollutants is presented in the
exceptional work (Zhu et al. 2002), where the data of CO, black carbon
(BC), total particle number and mass concentration at 30, 60, 90, 150
and 300 m downwind and 300 m upwind in freeway 405 near Los Angeles is
presented. The place chosen for measurements is characterized intense
traffic flow--average traffic flow during the sampling periods 230
vehicles per min, of them 93% vehicles gasoline--powered cars or light
trucks. Besides, the breeze that blows from the ocean keeps the stable
speed perpendicular to the road for a long time. This makes average
concentration of the measured sizes not inconsiderable, for example 30 m
distance from the road it was 1.7-2.2 ppm, 3.4-10 [micro]g/[m.sup.3],
(1.3-2.0) x [10.sup.5] 1/[cm.sup.3] and 30.2-64.6 [micro]g/[m.sup.3],
respectively. Moreover, it is well known that the roadside soil contains
a lot of accumulated metals, most of which are transferred by aerosol
particles size range of 0.32-1.0 [micro]m. It is determined that Pb, Zn,
Mb, As are distributed mainly in fine aerosols, and the noxiousness of
heavy metals for human health is well known.
Traffic pollution extends even up to 300 m wide zone from both
sides of the road, so a lot of inhabitants can feel its effect. The
great many of experiments referred to aerosol particles dispersion show
that the problem is topical. The search of theoretical models of the
road pollution are carried out permanently and for the last years the
attention of scientists is focused on applying Gaussian model, which is
used to determine the dispersion of exhausted aerosol particles from
chimneys that is from the point sources (Seinfield, Pandis 1998). As the
type of traffic pollution source is not the point one, it is attempted
to solve this problem by finding the pollution source, e.g. by replacing
the road with a line of points imitating emission (Chock 1978) or with a
system of planes, formed of such points (Karim, Matsui 1998; Rao et al.
2002). In all cases the results obtained were only satisfactory,
although complex computer programme packages were used. One of the main
reasons of the misfortune is mathematical difficulties occurring while
simulating the dispersion of aerosol particles concentration above the
road. These difficulties arise due to high air convection.
Short-term meteorology has big impact on the dispersion of the
pollution without the wind (Chock 1978; Laurinavicius et al. 2007).
Therefore the analysis of the pollution becomes a problem that is
difficult to solve. Semi-empirical model of the dispersion of pollution
which is made by us on the base of the physical processes will be used
to express the tendencies of the long-term pollution dispersion.
The aim of the work is the research of the influence of the dust
cloud expansion on the aerosol concentration distribution near roadways;
the main attention is paid to the dispersion of aerosol particles in the
size range of 0.05-0.22 [micro]m (Zhu et al. 2002), which the Gaussian
plume model cannot explain.
2. Theoretical base of the model
The process of traffic pollution dispersion is very complex due to
complicated, trickily explained physical and chemical phenomena in the
process. Due to the fact that in atmosphere aerosols have hard, liquid
and air stages with high temperature and a rapid cooling, the processes
of steaming, condensation and coagulation occur (Jacobson, Seinfeld
2004), though the experimental and theoretical evaluations show that the
greatest impact on decrease of particles dispersion has atmospheric
dispersion--dilution process near the source (Zhu, Hinds 2005). Thus, a
conclusion can be drawn that the sum of particles in the cloud, formed
above the road, settled particles and particles remaining in the air do
not change a lot. This enables from the view of the long term pollution,
to interpretate the cloud, formed above the road when the traffic is
intensive, as a generator of pollution particles with constant power,
e.g. as the source of environmental pollution.
As the crosswind, directed perpendicularly to the road blows, the
formed cloud shifts downwards spreads in the direction of the wind and
expands causing the decrease of particle concentration in it. To
evaluate the velocity of cloud's expansion usually the line source
emission model is used (Chock 1978; Zhu, Hinds 2005), which is applied
in the work as well. In line source emission modelling the road is
replaced by emission generating line and the best results are obtained
when the line is at 4.5 m height (Chock 1978), but in the work (Zhu,
Hinds 2005) the road is elevated ~4.5 m above the surrounding terrain.
To evaluate the expansion of the cloud a simplified atmospheric
diffusion Eq is applied:
U [partial derivative]C/[partial derivative]x = [partial
derivative]/[partial derivative]z ([K.sub.zz] [partial
derivative]C/[partial derivative]z), (1)
where U--the mean ambient wind speed at source height, m/s; C--mean
concentration of a pollutant, g/[m.sup.3]; [K.sub.zz]--the vertical addy
diffusivity, [m.sup.2]/s.
And the solution for the line source per unit length, considering
it to be a dotted line without the gravitation effect (Zhu, Hinds 2005),
is given by
[K.sub.zz] = [gamma][U.sub.x], (2)
where [gamma]--turbulence parameter. The solution for Eq (1) is
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] (3)
where q--line source strength (particle/ms); h--the height of line
source, m.
From solution (3) it follows that the parameter of vertical
dispersion coefficient [[sigma].sub.z] usually used in Gaussian method
alters according to the line law
[[sigma].sub.z] = [square root of [gamma]]x, (4)
which determines the expansion of the [gamma] emission cloud.
3. Construction of the model
Having constructed the model it is assumed that, when there is no
wind, the cloud, formed above the road, is the pollution source with
permanent power in a shape of a cutoff cylinder, which afterwards is
transferred to the roadside by the wind directed perpendicularly to the
road. The aerosol particle dispersion in the cloud, formed by
vehicle-and gravitation-intended turbulent air streams, when the wind
blows, conditions the law of the changes of aerosol particles
concentration near roadside above the ground surface. Such model
describes well the dispersion of carbon oxide, black carbon (soot) and
general concentration of particles (Grigaliunaite-Vonseviciene et al.
2008). Having incounted the particle buoyancy and thermal pollutant
plume rise effects, it is obtained the dispersion of concentration
typical for particles size range of 0.050-0.300 [micro]m, which has some
peculiarities typical only for this fraction (Martinenas, Spakauskas
2010). The concentration of aerosol particles of such size range
receding from the road is decreasing slower than the concentration of
smaller particles, what is more, at the certain distance the decrease
vanishes otherwise the increase is observed, its place depending on the
wind speed (Zhu et al. 2002). The concentration of heavy metals in the
air, soil and plants near the roadside alters according to analogical
consistent patterns (Carsignol, Calovi 2005), because aerosol particles
of this size range are related to the transfer of heavy metals
(Martuzevicius et al. 2004). This fact is also confirmed by the
investigations of heavy metals concentration carried out in Lithuania
(Juknevicius et al. 2007).
The work continues the modification of the model, when the cutoff
cylinder shaped emission cloud recedes from the road in the horizontal
direction of the wind and the expansion of the cloud is taken into
consideration.
Mathematical model of the traffic pollution expansion is
constructed to determine the unitary length cloud expansion, formed
above the road. Let us assume that vehicle-intended mechanical and
thermal turbulence in the volume of cut-off cylinder's radius
[r.sub.0] and unitary length [V.sub.0] create permanent aerosol
particles concentration [[rho].sub.0] in the cloud, which is
[[rho].sub.0] = n/[V.sub.0], where n--the number of aerosol particles in
the volume [V.sub.0] (Fig. 1), and with its expansion to the roadside at
a permanent velocity [v.sub.x] due to the gravitation, buoyancy and
thermal effects plume rises and aerosol particles concentration [rho]
alters and with a distance from the road x and a height above the ground
surface [DELTA]h is expressed by function, i.e. [rho] = p(x,[DELTA]h).
The expansion of the cloud in the vertical direction is evaluated
according to vertical dispersion coefficient [[sigma].sub.z] and the
alteration laws in Gaussian point source model, when under neutral
atmospheric conditions at the beginning of coordinates [[sigma].sub.z0]
= a, where a is an empirical parameter. Then vertical dispersion
coefficient [[sigma].sub.z] at distance x from the source is (Chock
1978)
[[sigma].sub.zx] =(a + bx). (5)
Having used Eq (5) in the model (Fig. 1) and having equated a with
[r.sub.0], the alteration law of cylinder radius r is obtained when it
is transferred further from the road by the wind:
[r.sub.x] = [r.sub.0] + [[beta].sup.*], (6)
where [r.sub.0] = 15 m and is a radius of cylinder, which is
selected for the flat width of the road, m; [beta]--expansivity of
radius of cloud. Cylindrical plume, which moves in the direction of wind
at the velocity [v.sub.x], settles slowly falling at a constant velocity
[v.sub.z]. Having assumed that the cloud carried by the wind at the
distance [DELTA]x shifts downwards at [DELTA]h, and the whole aerosol
particle cloud settles at the distance [x.sub.max] from the road, we
get:
[DELTA]h = [h.sub.0]/[x.sub.max] [DELTA]x(m). (7)
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
The horizontal velocity of plume movement, that is along the z
axis, consists of falling velocity [??](z) and plume rise velocity
[??](z). To evaluate the plume rise we use the tendency of velocity
change typical for plume centerline rise above the source (Linden 2010):
[omega](z) = [C.sub.1] [B.sup.1/3] [z.sup.-1/3], (8)
where [C.sub.1]--the dimensionless constant; B--the buoyancy flux
constant. Therefore, for plume rise velocity is
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII]. (9)
Moreover, due to the heated air flow rising from the roadside and
the buoyancy effect, the concentration of aerosol particles is
increasing when shifting upwards (Imhol et al. 2005; Zhu, Hinds 2005).
The volume V([alpha]) of the cloud is equal to the area, which is
the cut-off circle (further we will use this consideration) multiplied
by the length l of the aerosol particle cloud located along the roadway:
V([alpha]) = [lr.sup.2.sub.x]/2 ([alpha] - sin [alpha]. (10)
The initial angle [[alpha].sub.0] corresponds to the initial volume
[V.sub.0] = V([[alpha].sub.0]) in m/s.
The probability density function f([alpha]) obtained according to
definition is given by
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] (11)
where [[alpha].sub.0] [greater than or equal to] [alpha] [greater
than or equal to] 0, [[alpha].sub.0]--an angle of the cylinder segment
at the initial time moment, and the angle [alpha] when the cylinder
settles by [DELTA]h (Fig. 1).
As Fig. 1 shows:
[h.sub.x] = [h.sub.0x] - [DELTA]h = [h.sub.0x] -
[v.sub.z]/[v.sub.x] [DELTA]x, (12)
[h.sub.x] = [r.sub.x] (1 - cos [alpha]/2). (13)
We include the mentioned gravitation, buoyancy and thermal effects
as the probability density function factor g([DELTA]h),
g([DELTA]h) = 1/N ([e.sup.-a[DELTA]h] + [ce.sup.b[DELTA]h]) (14)
where a and b express the gravitation and buoyancy coefficients,
c--the relative weight of buoyancy contribution, [[DELTA]h.sub.max] is
the initial height of a dust cloud, N is the normalizing coefficient:
[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] (15)
Therefore, we multiply the probability density function f([alpha])
by the coefficient g([DELTA]h) and obtain the probability density
function [gamma]([alpha], [DELTA]h):
[gamma]([alpha],[DELTA]h) = f([alpha])g([DELTA]h). (16)
Passing from the probability density function to the quantitative
concentration evaluation, the probability density function
[gamma]([alpha], [DELTA]h) should be multiplied by the emission rate per
unit length Q (kg/ms).
4. Results and discussions
For the validation of the model developed in our study the
experimental data obtained in (Zhu et al. 2002) were used. Substantial
changes in the investigations of the traffic pollution dispersion near
roadways were obtained during the experiment in the vicinity of roadways
in the Los Angeles area using the CPC 3022A aerosol particle counter for
measuring the aerosol particle number concentration and the SMPS 3936
aerosol particle seizer for the aerosol particle size distribution with
expected error [+ or -] 10%. The aerosol particle number concentration
and the size distribution in the size range from 0.006 to 0.22 [micro]m
were measured. Measurements were carried out at a distance of 30, 60,
90, 150 and 300 m downwind from the central line of the highway, which
is 30 m wide, when the average crosswind velocity was 1 m/s and 2.5 m/s.
A general concentration decrease of all aerosol particles receding from
the highway and the dependence of their fraction dispersion on the
particle size were obtained.
It has been determined that the number concentration for all size
aerosol particles dropped to approx half its original value at the
distance somewhere between 90 and 150 m. The decrease of the normalized
total particle number and volume concentration in the size range of
0.006-0.22 [micro]m is close by the exponential law, but in the size
range of 0.050.1 [micro]m and 0.1-0.22 [micro]m a decrease has some
peculiarities. For these size ranges, when the wind speed is 1 m/s at
the 60 m distance from the roadway in the concentration diagram a small
hole is observed, while at the 90 m distance from the roadway the
concentration increase is observed. When the wind speed is 2.5 m/s, the
min of the particle size range of 0.05-0.1 [micro]m shifts towards 90 m,
and the max--towards 150 m. For the size range of 0.1-0.22 [micro]m, the
concentration extremums of these aerosol particles disappear completely.
The probable [[omega].sub.0] value over the road at the 1 m height
was evaluated in (Chock 1978) by improving the common Gaussian line
source model, where Eqs evaluating the plume rise speed were obtained.
From these equations it follows that under neutral atmospheric
conditions, when the wind speed is 1 m/s and 2.5 m/s, the plume rising
velocity is 0.062 m/s and 0.042 m/s, respectively.
In the model the optimal probability density function for aerosol
particles in the size range of 0.05-0.1 [micro]m was obtained when
[[alpha].sub.0] = 4.8 rad (it corresponds to the max plume height equal
4.8 m over the road), with the road half width r = 15 m. When the wind
speed [v.sub.x] = 1 m/s and 2.5 m/s, then [v.sub.z] = 0.1 m/s, and
[[omega].sub.0] = 0.045 and 0.04 m/s, respectively. In the probability
density function the gravitation and buoyancy effect conditioned
statistical weights at the initial time moment 1/N = 0.39 and c/N = 0.18
when the wind speed [v.sub.x] = 1 m/s, and 1/N = 0.45 and c/N = 0.03
when the and buoyancy coefficients a and b, expansivity of cloud [beta]
when the wind speed [v.sub.x] = 1 m/s, are a = 0.9; [beta] = 0.7; p =
0.15, and when [v.sub.x] = 2.5 m/s - a = 1.4; b = 0.7; [beta] = 0.04.
The normalized (equated to one in point of concentration values at
the distance of 90 m) model and experimental (Zhu et al. 2002) curves,
when the wind speeds are [v.sub.x] = 1 m/s and [v.sub.x] = 2.5 m/s, are
shown in Figs 2 and 3. The pollutants concentration of CO, BC, NC only
at a distance of 300 m downwind and upwind from the roadside becomes
equal, the pollutant concentration at a 300 m distance from the roadside
can be considered as background. Thus the values of the probability
density and experimental concentrations are with the background
concentration illegibly, and the concentration value at the [x.sub.max]
= 300 m distance should be equal to 0. True, these particles form small
part of the total mass of the particles of pollutants. The bigger
particles do not reach this distance (Figs 1, 2).
A better congruity with the experiment was obtained when the wind
speed was 1.0 m/s because selected parameters of the model not always
correspond precisely to the aerosol particles in the size ranges of
0.05-0.1 [micro]m, as at the same distance there are also particles in
the size ranges of 0.1-0.22 [micro]m, dispersion of which is similar.
When the wind speed is 2.5 m/s, the dispersion consistent pattern of
aerosol particles in the size ranges of 0.05-0.1 [micro]m is the same as
of aerosol particles in the size ranges of 0.1-0.22 [micro]m, although
the latter concentration in both velocities is a lot less.
[FIGURE 2 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 3 OMITTED]
It is noticed that aerosol particles dispersion peculiarities
depend on their settle velocity [[??].sub.z], which depends on buoyancy
effect, determined by the size of the particles.
5. Conclusions
A semi-empirical model intended for simulation of dispersion of
particles with the diameter larger than 0.05 [micro]m near roadways has
been proposed in the work. Mathematically described dispersion of
aerosol particles (>0.05 [micro]m) in a pollution source allows
simulation of the pollutant concentration change near roadways which
well coincides with the experimental measurements. Experimental data
shows that the dispersion of aerosol particles in the size ranges of
0.05-0.1 [micro]m and 0.1-0.22 [micro]m depends on the wind speed. When
the wind speed is 1 m/s, the concentration of aerosol particles of both
size ranges at the beginning decreases at the distance of up to 60 m
from the road, and increases at the distance of 90 m, but further it
decreases again. When the wind speed is 2.5 m/s, the concentration decay
of aerosol particles of the first size range (0.05-0.1 [micro]m) is
observed at the distance of up to 90 m, and an increase--at up to 150 m,
but further it again decreases. The concentration of aerosol particles
of the second size range (0.1-0.22 [micro]m), when the wind speed is 2.5
m/s, decreases uniformly receding from the road.
By simulating the pollution source as a cut-off cylinder, which is
formed on the roadway at the initial time moment due to traffic
pollution and is uniformly filled with aerosol particles, and with the
wind transfer further from the road aerosol particles settle influenced
by the gravitation, particle buoyancy and thermal pollutant plume rise
effects.
According to the model it was obtained that the semi-empirical
parameters of the model, including the dispersion of the dust cloud
transferred by the wind further from the road, depend on the size of the
aerosol particles. It was determined that the second important factor
after the wind speed that causes the dispersion of the particles is the
particle settle velocity [[??].sub.z], which changes depend on buoyancy
effect, that in its turn depends on the size of the particles. This fact
was not taken into account while counting the dispersion of the
particles in Gaussian model and only one parameter [gamma] was applied
for all particles which allowed to obtain only approximate particle
dispersion.
The obtained aerosol particle concentration change near roadways
better coincides with the experimental data and explains why the heavy
metals pollution near the roadside practically doesn't vary in a
wide range from 50 to 150 m away from the road.
doi: 10.3846/bjrbe.2011.03
Received 23 December 2010; accepted 21 January 2011
References
Carsignol, J.; Calovi, L. 2005. Roadside Soil and Plant Pollution.
Metal Trace Elements. Setra Information Note [cited 12 December 2010]
Available from Internet:
<http://www.setra.equipement.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/US_NI_EEC_073_
GB.pdf.>.
Chock, D. P. 1978. A Simple Line-Source Model for Dispersion near
Roadways, Atmospheric Environment 12(4): 823-829.
doi:10.1016/0004-6981(78)90019-7
Grigaliunaite-Vonseviciene, G.; Martinenas, B.; Szydlo, A. 2008.
Traffic Exhaust Spreading into the Roadside. Statistical Model, in Proc.
of the 7th International Conference "Environmental
Engineering": selected papers, vol. 3. Ed. by Cygas, D.; Froehner,
K. D. May 22-23, 2008, Vilnius, Lithuania. Vilnius: Technika, 1154-1159.
Imhol, D.; Weingartner, E.; Vogt, U.; Dreiseidler, A.; Rosenbohm,
E.; Scheer, V.; Vogt, R.; Nielsen, O. J.; Kurten-bach, R.; Corsmeier,
U.; Kohler, M.; Baltensperger, U. 2005. Vertical Distribution of Aerosol
Particles and N[O.sub.x] Close to a Motorway, Atmospheric Environment
39(31): 5710-5721. doi:10.1016/j.atmosenv.2004.07.036
Jacobson, M. Z.; Seinfeld, J. H. 2004. Evolution of Nano-particle
Size and Mixing State near the Point of Emission, Atmospheric
Environment 38(13): 1839-1850. doi:10.1016/j.atmosenv.2004.01.014
Juknevicius, S.; Matyziute-Juodkiene, D.; Sabiene, N. 2007.
Contamination of Soil and Grass by Heavy Metals along the Main Roads in
Lithuania, Ekologija [Ecology] 53(3): 70-74.
Karim, M. M.; Matsui, H. 1998. A Mathematical Model of Wind Flow,
Vehicle Wake, and Pollutant Concentration in Urban Road
Microenvironments. Part 1: Model Description, Transportation Research
Part D: Transport and Environment 3(2): 81-92.
doi:10.1016/S1361-9209(97)00028-X
Laurinavicius, A.; Cygas, D.; Ciuprinskas, K.; Jukneviciute, L.
2007. Data Analysis and Evaluation of Road Weather Information System
Integrated in Lithuania, The Baltic Journal of Road and Bridge
Engineering 2(1): 5-11.
Linden, P. 2010. Plume dynamics. Mechanical and Environmental
Engineering Laboratory [cited 22 December 2010]. Available from
Internet: <http://
maecourses.ucsd.edu/labcourse/lecturenotes/Plume_lecture_2010.pdf>.
Martinenas, B.; Spakauskas, V 2010. Simulation of Traffic Pollution
Dispersion near Roadways, Lithuanian Journal of Physics 50(2): 255-260.
doi:10.3952/lithjphys.50212
Martuzevicius, D.; Grinshpun, S. A.; Reponen, T.; Gorny, R. L.;
Shukla, R.; Lockey, J.; Hu, S.; McDonald, R.; Biswas, P.; Kliucininkas,
L.; LeMasters, G. 2004. Spatial and Temporal Variations of PM2.5
Concentration and Composition throughout an Urban Area with High Freeway
Density - The Greater Cincinnati Study, Atmospheric Environment 38(8):
10911105. doi:10.1016/j.atmosenv.2003.11.015
Rao, K. S.; Gunter, R. L.; White, J. R.; Hosker, R. P. 2002.
Turbulence and Dispersion Modeling near Highways, Atmospheric
Environment 36(27): 4337-4346. doi:10.1016/S1352-2310(02)00353-9
Seinfeld, J. H.; Pandis, S. N. 1998. Atmospheric Chemistry and
Physics: from Air Pollution to Climate Change. New York: John Wiley
& Sons.
Vaiskunaite, R.; Laurinavicius, A.; Miskinis, D. 2009. Analysis and
Evaluation of the Effect of Studded Tyres on Road Pavement and
Environment (II), The Baltic Journal of Road and Bridge Engineering
4(4): 203-211. doi:10.3846/1822-427X.2009.4.203211
Zhu, Y.; Hinds, W. C. 2005. Predicting Particle Number
Concentrations Near a Highway Based on Vertical Concentration Profile,
Atmospheric Environment 39(8): 1557-1566.
doi:10.1016/j.atmosenv.2004.11.015
Zhu, Y.; Hinds, W. C.; Kim, S.; Sioutas, C. 2002. Concentration and
Size Distribution of Ultrafine Particles Near a Major Highway, Journal
of the Air & Waste Management Association 52(9): 1032-1042.
Bronislovas Martinenas (1), Valdas Spakauskas (2), Dainius Jasaitis
(3)
Dept of Physics, Vilnius Gediminas Technical University, Sauletekio
al. 11, 10223 Vilnius, Lithuania E-mails: (1) brm@vgtu.lt; (2)
valdas.spakauskas@vgtu.lt; (3) Dainius.Jasaitis@vgtu.lt