The Jesus Movement and Its Expansion: Meaning and Mission.
van Thanh, Nguyen
The Jesus Movement and Its Expansion: Meaning and Mission. By Sean
Freyne. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2014. Pp. xii + 383. $35.
Context is crucial in biblical interpretation. Context not only
influences interpretation; it also determines its meaning. To really
understand the Jesus movement and appreciate its rapid expansion, one
needs to know the Galilean context where it all began. Freyne's
book provides just that. More than simply examining the Galilean context
or background for interpretation, however, F. attempts to highlight the
underlying "matrix," suggesting "a living, dynamic
environment that is constantly interacting with the various levels of
human life and activity that are taking place" (3). F. is eminently
up to this task.
F. devoted his life to the study of the early Jesus movement in its
Galilean context and was recognized as a leading scholar in the field.
This book, an expansion of his earlier work Jesus, a Jewish Galilean: A
New Reading of the Jesus Story (2004), is the culmination of a lifelong
passion and was completed shortly before his death in 2013. Besides the
introduction and epilogue, the book contains eight chapters. The first
three examine the matrix in which the Jesus movement emerged and
developed. Chapter 1 deals with the influence and impact of
Hellenization in Judea in general and Galilee in particular. Chapter 2
deals with the history of Roman presence in Judea from the middle of the
first century BCE up to the second revolt against Rome in 132 to 135 CE.
With archeological evidence, chapter 3 offers a reliable profile of the
social and economic conditions of Palestine.
Chapter 4 focuses on the ministry of the historical Jesus. Since
this is the central chapter of the book, it is worth examining it more
closely. F. demonstrates that Jesus was greatly influenced by his own
Jewish heritage as well as by the social and economic situation of
Palestine in general and Galilee in particular. These contexts
profoundly shaped his actions and responses to the situations he
encountered. Many of Jesus' sayings challenged the prevailing
assumptions of both the Roman worldview and the Judean priestly
establishment. Furthermore, like other prophets who came from the
countryside, Jesus came from an insignificant village in Galilee to
challenge the authority and prosperity of Jerusalem. He was critical of
the Temple, its personnel, and its rituals. Like Jeremiah, Jesus engaged
in a combination of prophetic words and actions to challenge the temple
hierarchy. The incident in the Temple (Mk 11:15-18) was the decisive act
that led to his arrest, condemnation, and crucifixion. In the eyes of
the religious authority, he not only undermined their authority but also
contested the centrality of the Temple's role in the life of the
people. In a nutshell, F. portrays Jesus as a Galilean eschatological
prophet challenging Israel to immediate repentance or face imminent
judgment. Although it is well done, F.'s portrait of the historical
Jesus does not contribute anything significantly new to the quest, as
many historical critics of Jesus have already provided this
reconstruction--for example, E. R Sanders, John Meier, and N. T. Wright,
to name just a few.
The final four chapters (5-8) deal with the mission and expansion
of the Jesus movement in Palestine and beyond during the first hundred
years of its development. Chapter 5 discusses the Jerusalem community,
especially the distinction between the Hebrews and the Hellenists, with
particular emphasis on their understanding of the mission to the
Gentiles. F. also briefly treats the Samaritan mission. Chapter 6
examines the traces of Palestinian Jesus-followers in Galilee and its
environs, corroborated in various sayings sources like the Q source, the
Gospel of Thomas, and the Didache. Chapter 7 provides a close reading of
the narrative accounts of Mark and Matthew against the backdrop of the
Jewish revolt and the destruction of the Temple, as the movement left
behind its originating matrix in Galilee and Jerusalem. Finally, chapter
8 traces the transition from the New Testament period to later
generations as the Christian movement began to acquire a much higher
profile.
The book is skillfully arranged into three distinct parts: matrix
(chaps. 1-3), ministry (chap. 4), and mission (chaps. 5-8). While
written with a "broader readership" in mind (2), the
volume's language, style, and methodologies presume that, to fully
appreciate the book's sophistication and presuppositions, the
reader has more than a basic knowledge of the New Testament world.
Graduate students willing to plow through this 355-page volume, in a
small font, will surely acquire a comprehensive knowledge of Galilee and
the early Jesus movement and mission.
DOI: 10.1177/0040563915593486
van Thanh Nguyen, S.V.D.
Catholic Theological Union, Chicago