Elizabeth Barrett Browning.
Stone, Marjorie
In contrast to last year's work on EBB, in which religion
formed a dominant theme, 2006 has brought a return to a strong emphasis
on politics--both the politics of nation and gender politics. Works on
which attention seems to have converged include the explicitly political
Casa Guidi Windows and Poems before Congress, along with Aurora Leigh
and "Mother and Poet," one of the most discussed works in Last
Poems (1862). Among major new primary resources on EBB, Volume 15 of The
Brownings' Correspondence has appeared from Wedgestone Press, as
carefully edited and beautifully produced as its precursors in this
indispensable comprehensive collection of the Brownings' letters,
edited by Philip Kelley with Ronald Hudson (Volumes 1-8), and with Scott
Lewis (Volumes 9-14). Other topics discussed this year include
EBB's treatment of the city, her representation of melancholy, her
collaborative engagement with Robert Browning's works (and his with
hers in works such as "The Runaway Slave at Pilgrim's
Point"), echoes of Shakespeare, and her treatment of social
problems. As the bicentenary of EBB's birth, 2006 has also brought
conferences such as the Armstrong Browning Library's "This is
Living Art" (held March 3-6), and exhibits in libraries and
archives, such as the one mounted by the British Library in February and
March.
Volume 15 of The Brownings' Correspondence is a reminder,
should any be needed, of how rich a resource this annotated collection
of letters, reviews, and other materials related to the Brownings can
be. Although numerous letters in this particular volume (covering the
period from January 1848, to August 1849) have appeared in whole or in
part in earlier collections, there are also many previously unpublished
letters--including letters to correspondents as close to EBB as the
Brownings' friend, the writer and art critic Anna Jameson, and
RB's sister, Sarianna Browning, as well as letters by both the
Brownings to the American writer William Ware, and occasional letters
from readers of EBB's poetry.
Important subjects that recur in Volume 15 include the movements of
"revolution and counter-revolution" in Italy and elsewhere in
Europe (p. 271), EBB's second miscarriage in March 1848, her
pregnancy, and the birth of the Brownings' son on March 9, 1849.
The most intimate and detailed of the letters, not surprisingly, are
those to her two sisters, Arabella and Henrietta. The full texts of the
Arabella letters have earlier appeared in Scott Lewis' annotated
two-volume The Letters of Elizabeth Barrett Browning to Her Sister
Arabella (containing letters from the time of EBB's marriage and
move to Italy in 1846 up to her death in 1861--see the "Year's
Work," 2002). The 1848-49 letters to Henrietta, however, have
previously appeared only in part (and without the ample annotation that
The Brownings' Correspondence provides) in Leonard Huxley's
edition, Elizabeth Barrett Browning: Letters to Her Sister, 1846-1859
(1929). In some cases as well, previously published letters appear in
Volume 15 with dates corrected by Kelley and Lewis.
Like some of the letters in this new volume of the Correspondence
that have previously appeared in Frederic G. Kenyon's The Letters
of Elizabeth Barrett Browning (1897), the full texts of the letters to
Henrietta show how much was suppressed by earlier editorial
deletions-particularly in relation to medical details such as EBB's
use of morphine and matters of the body. (On this point, an extended
analysis of Kenyon's typescript of his edition of the letters, now
in the British Library, with cancelled passages clearly marked, would be
of some interest.) In Volume 15's letters to Henrietta, EBB details
the bodily sensations associated with the "quickening" during
her pregnancy with Pen, for example (p. 149); she subsequently frankly
and fully expresses her views on the mistake of treating pregnancy as a
disease and not one of "the things of pure nature" (p. 221).
These letters also make clear the important role that Robert played in
reducing her reliance on opium during her pregnancy with Pen, which she
willingly did despite her views, consonant with much of the medical
opinion of the time, concerning its appropriate therapeutic uses. She
wrote to her sister-in-law Sarianna encouraging her to consider
proposing morphine to help Robert's mother deal with the pain of
illness, observing, "I was never tempted beyond the medical
prescription, in taking it, nor have I suffered from the practise in any
specific way.. not from headache, not from indigestion.. nor am I
prevented from leaving it off, you see, (Robert must have told you) when
it becomes desirable to leave it off, notwithstanding the long habit
& the excessive use.. few persons having taken such large doses as
I" (p. 201).
While much in this volume concerns the Brownings' private
lives in a period that saw not only Pen's birth, but
also--immediately following this joyful event--the death of
Robert's mother, another recurrent subject is Italian politics and
the events that inspired Casa Guidi Windows. In a previously unpublished
letter to Fanny Dowglass dated April 6, 1848, EBB writes, "I say to
my husband, when he goes to look at the newspaper, 'Bring me news
of a revolution or two.' And he brings me news of three. And then
the peculiar features of these movements--the manner in which the breath
of the people bows down fields of drawn swords, like the breath of God
Himself!" (p. 46). Her comment conveys the reaction of many in a
year that saw revolutions throughout the Italian states, in France, and
in several other European countries. By 1849, of course, there had been
"counter-revolutions" in Tuscany and in Rome, while in France
the new republic brought the election of Louis Napoleon--which EBB
skeptically viewed as an instance of "true king-worship" (p.
203), in her initial mistrust of the nephew of Napoleon Bonaparte. These
developments made her less optimistic about the power of the people to
effect political change, although she remained a republican.
As in previous volumes of The Brownings' Correspondence,
Volume 15 includes "Biographical Sketches," "Supporting
Documents," and contemporary reviews of the Brownings' works
(in this instance, very different from earlier volumes, the reviews are
all on Browning's poetry). The supporting documents include a
rather sniping comment to a correspondent by Mary Russell Mitford from
an autograph letter at Yale: "By the way Mrs. Browning is to be
confined in February. She always speaks of her husband rapturously--but
I cannot forgive him for not working (I mean by that word writing paying
literature) to supply to her some of the comforts she forfeited for him,
but living upon his wife in contented idleness just as he did before
upon his father" (p. 363).
The detailed yet succinct biographical sketch (pp. 345-354) of the
Brownings' son, Robert Wiedeman Barrett Browning or
"Pen," in Volume 15 is of particular interest as a portrait in
miniature of one of literature's most celebrated children, who grew
up into a young man with the burden of great expectations heaped upon
him. Within a week of his mother's death, Pen's long hair was
shorn--"the golden curls & fantastic dress gone ... just as Ba
is gone"--and he became "a common boy all at once," RB
wrote to his sister Sarianna. Within the next month, he was removed by
his father from Italy to England. Looking back on his mother's
death, it is not surprising that Pen observed, "I have always
remembered that date ... and the pain and anguish of it all are only too
vivid and enduring" (p. 347). Pen's less than stellar
performance as a student at Oxford is treated in some detail, and the
biographical sketch casts some light on the bitter differences with his
father provoked by his continental love affair with the daughter of a
Belgian innkeeper in Dinant--a young woman whom he resolved to marry
until finally persuaded to break the relationship off. In this instance,
Kelley and Lewis draw on the large trove of unpublished letters by
Browning's close friend, Joseph Milsand, recently acquired by the
Armstrong Browning Library--letters which will no doubt greatly enrich
volumes of the correspondence yet to appear, as well as new biographies
of the Brownings and accounts of their relationship.
Among the articles dealing directly or indirectly with gender
issues and politics in EBB's poetry this year, Katherine
Montwieler's "Domestic Politics: Gender, Protest, and
Elizabeth Barrett Browning's Poems before Congress" (TSWL 24
[2005]: 291-318) is particularly ground-breaking. Montwieler rightly
points out that "several book-length studies of Barrett
Browning's poetry" omit any "sustained" analysis of
Poems before Congress as a whole (p. 292). The only poem to receive
detailed treatment to date has been the final one, "A Curse for a
Nation." In discussing this particular poem, Montwieler largely
covers ground traversed in earlier articles and books (the controversy
in the reviews, the poem as a powerful "speech act," its
gender politics, and its pun on "right" and
"Write"). What makes her essay innovative is the illuminating
discussion of the works in Poems before Congress that precede "A
Curse for a Nation." This is the first critical study to treat
Poems before Congress comprehensively as a whole, considering its
rhetorical intentions, the artistry of its structure, and the complex
dialogical relations that operate within the sequence of poems it
includes. Montwieler approaches the much misunderstood collection
"not as an aesthetic failure or as a political blunder but as a
carefully wrought poetic articulation of international and gender
politics by a sophisticated and knowing mid-nineteenth-century
poet" (p. 294). She analyses the relations between the personal and
the political in the collection, showing how poems such as "The
Dance" and "A Court Lady" contribute to its treatment of
the intersections between "the events that structure women's
married lives--courtship, motherhood, and widowhood" and political
events. Refreshingly, she also reads the complex opening ode to Napoleon
III--traditionally approached as an expression of EBB's naive
hero-worship of the French emperor--in counterpoint with the
"hardly respectful" dramatic monologue in his own voice,
"An August Voice," appearing midway through the sequence (p.
306). She furthermore treats the ode as a work as much about "the
right of the woman poet to speak of any subject she chooses" (p.
299) as Napoleon III. "On one level," the poem represents
"the baptism of a new leader," she argues, while on another,
it is "an assertion of the extraordinary powers and role of the
woman poet" (p. 300).
In "A 'Bad Patriot'?: Elizabeth Barrett Browning and
Cosmopolitanism" (VIJ 33 [2005]: 69-95), Christopher M. Keirstead
takes a less heroicizing approach than Montwieler to EBB's
engagement with politics. Where Montwieler finds a "triumphant
woman poet" intervening in the political sphere in Poems before
Congress, Keirstead finds less triumph and more conflict in tracing the
"poetics of cosmopolitanism" that emerges in "complex
dialogue" with "nationalist devotion" in EBB's later
poetry (p. 69). In Casa Guidi Windows EBB "commits poetry to the
political objective of Italian nationalism and privileges the
poet's access to an idealized language of the nation" in order
to articulate an internationalist vision in which the individual is
subsumed by the nation, he argues (p. 73). Such "[e]vangelical
nationalism" gave her "a way of expressing a connection to
Italy that could be at once political but also safely feminine," he
argues (p. 75). In later works such as Aurora Leigh and "Mother and
Poet," she continues to "give voice to this inter(nationalist)
ideal," while also doing more to "close the gap between the
personal and the political and between the private and the public"
(p. 73). Whereas in Casa Guidi Windows, she casts "Italians as
souls rather than bodies," largely "erasing individual
Italians" (p. 77), in Aurora Leigh she embodies and
"narrativizes" cosmopolitanism in the hybrid nationality of
the poet protagonist. Noting, but passing over Poems before Congress as
EBB's "most explicitly cosmopolitan work" (p. 84),
Keirstead focuses instead on the "conceptual leap" he finds in
"Mother and Poet." "If Poems before Congress expresses
the dream of internationalism via nationalism, 'Mother and
Poet' explores the difficulty and personal cost of truly realizing
that vision" through "its inability to conjoin individual and
collective identity under the banner of nationhood" (pp. 84-85).
While Kierstead thus investigates as Montwieler does the intersections
of the personal and political, the private and the public, in EBB's
later political poetry, he focuses on differing manifestations of this,
and finds a less triumphant poetics. "At the end of her
career," he concludes, "Barrett Browning was trying to find a
way out of the extremes of international politics--a way of replacing
sacrifice with survival" (p. 87).
Aurora Leigh and "Mother and Poet" are also the principal
works treated in Olivia Gatti Taylor's "Written in Blood: The
Art of Mothering Epic in the Poetry of Elizabeth Barrett Browning"
(VP 44 [2006]: 153-164), which reflects, as Keirstead's work does,
an emphasis on the poetics of the body. Drawing on Julia Kristeva's
theory of the maternal in the essay "Stabat Mater," as well as
her distinction between the semiotic and the symbolic in Revolution in
Poetic Language, Taylor explores the "link between the maternal and
the poetic" by analyzing the literal and metaphoric relations
between bearing children and creating poems in Aurora Leigh and
"Mother and Poet" (pp. 153-154). While some mention of
EBB's own adaptation of a Medieval version of the hymn "Stabat
Mater" might have added to Taylor's analysis, she presents
some thought-provoking connections between the two works she focuses on,
avoiding the perils of essentialism that her central analogy might seem
to provoke, much as the poet herself does. She approaches EBB's
complex adaptation of the myth of Jove and Danae to express poetic
inspiration and creativity in Aurora Leigh by embedding it within the
numerous "gestational" images of this novel-epic written in
nine books. "According to Barrett Browning, the mother/poet must
clothe 'unspeakable poetry' in flesh, thereby becoming a
Marian figure," Taylor argues, contesting earlier critics such as
Linda Lewis who have found a troubled passivity in Aurora becoming a
"'receptacle of wisdom and word in the poetic sense as Mary
was the receptacle of Christ the Word and Wisdom'" (Lewis,
cited by Taylor, p. 161). Taylor's article gives the most attention
to religious dimensions of EBB's poetics in the articles published
this year, approaching the "child/text" in Aurora Leigh and
"Mother and Poet" as "a type of Christ, a messianic force
which both subordinates and elevates the maternal poet as an agent of
loving apocalypse" (p. 154). Like Kierstead, however, she
emphasizes the cost and pain of such maternal and poetic creativity,
especially in "Mother and Poet," where human progress
"comes at the price of blood" (p. 160). She makes especially
suggestive use of Kristeva's observation that "A mother is a
continuous separation, a division of the very flesh. And consequently a
division of language" (p. 157) in treating Aurora Leigh and
"Mother and Poet," bringing home her argument concerning the
pain of maternal and poetic creativity by a sensitive analysis of the
sob and drum-like rhythms of "Mother and Poet."
Whereas Taylor explores the paradoxical agency of maternal
metaphors for creativity in Aurora Leigh and "Mother and
Poet," Leslee Thorne-Murphy's "Prostitute Rescue, Rape,
and Poetic Inspiration in Elizabeth Barrett Browning's Aurora
Leigh" (Women's Writing 12 [2005]:241-257) explores the
"Greek myths of rape that Aurora uses as metaphors for her own
poetic inspiration" (p. 241). Thorne-Murphy's subtle
investigation of the "interrelation of rape, prostitution, and
inspiration" in Aurora Leigh connects Marian Earle's rape with
Aurora's poetic theories in order to explain "why the
elimination of sexual violence is essential to Barrett Browning's
vision of a reformed world" (p. 242). Like Linda Lewis, whom she
cites (pp. 243-244), Thorne-Murphy considers Aurora's
"shocking" use of "three different rape episodes from
Greek mythology"--involving Ganymede, Io, and Danae--to depict
divine inspiration, giving particular attention to the last. She
differs, however, from Lewis to some degree, and even more so from Joyce
Zonana (in Zonana's much cited article on "The Embodied
Muse") in her reading of the myth of Danae. While Zonana draws
parallels beween "Aurora's idealizing images of divine
rape" in her invocations of Danae and the actual rape of Marian in
the poem (Zonana, cited by Thorne-Murphy, p. 245), Thorne-Murphy argues
that "at no time does Aurora refer to Danae's tale as a
rape" (p. 245). Instead, EBB uses this metaphor of "sexual
union" to symbolize the "willing union of moral and
divine," in contrast to Marian's rape, which "threatens
that union and the poetic inspiration that it represents" by
separating "the spiritual from the material" or physical world
(p. 246). In a second section of her essay, Thorne-Murphy considers
EBB's adaptation of contemporary paradigms of prostitute rescue in
Aurora's relationship with Marian, approaching this in the context
of feminist dimensions of French socialist thought (Fourier's works
in particular) and mid-Victorian discourse on prostitution, especially
as represented by Henry Mayhew. While earlier critics have emphasized
that Marian's innocence (by virtue of her rape) contributes to the
conventionality of EBB's portrayal of prostitution in Aurora Leigh,
Thorne-Murphy argues that Aurora's belief in Marian's
"wild story of betrayal, rape, and injured innocence" without
the evidence from corroborating sources emphasized by Mayhew and others
"would have sent a shudder down the spine of any self-respecting
Victorian philanthrophist." Indeed, "this is the reaction
which philanthropic women were most warned against" (pp. 251-252).
The innocence that modern readers assume in Marian, in other words,
would by no means have been obvious or uncontested in Victorian
contexts. Emphasizing Aurora's "middle-class values" and
unreliability as a narrator before her encounter with the bitter truth
of "rape in all its murderous violence" (pp. 251,254),
Thorne-Murphy points out that Aurora's conception of and approach
to facts differs from Mayhew's, in relying on poetic intuition and
"divine truth" (p. 253). Moreover, in forming a personal and
passionate relationship with Marian and moving with her to Italy, Aurora
"goes well beyond the practical efforts of most prostitute-rescue
workers" (p. 252); in turn, her confrontation with Marian's
violation contributes to her poetic maturation (p. 254).
While prostitution became a particularly pronounced and
controversial subject associated with the growth of cities in the
mid-Victorian period, it does not figure prominently in Daniel
Karlin's analysis in "Victorian Poetry of the City: Elizabeth
Barrett Browning's Aurora Leigh," included in the interesting
collection, Babylon or New Jerusalem? Perceptions of the City in
Literature, ed. Valeria Tinker-Villani (2005) (pp. 113-123). Karlin
focuses mainly on the ways in which Aurora Leigh draws on the Romantic
"rhetoric of the sublime" as this was adapted by Victorian
poets to "the modern city" (p. 113). As Karlin presents it,
however, Aurora's life, like EBB's own, is less of the city,
than simply in it. Although Aurora seems to be a "busy professional
woman, immersed in literary life" in London "in a way quite
foreign to Barrett Browning's own experience"; in fact she
leads a kind of "double existence" there, "one which
takes advantage of urban culture and economic conditions, but which is
not in fact committed to urban identity" (p. 116). He supports this
argument in part through a perceptive analysis of the rhetoric of the
sublime and metaphors of dissolution in a "densely figurative"
passage that he rightly terms "remarkable" in Book III of
Aurora Leigh (ll. 169-203), but which has hitherto not been treated in
criticism on the poem (pp. 117-118). In this passage, Aurora evokes the
city as a "source of visionary creative power," as she
observes the sun "[on] lurid morns or monstrous afternoons,"
or contemplates the "great tawny weltering fog" sucking up the
London streets like a sponge--watching "the city perish in the mist
/ Like Pharaoh's armaments in the deep Red Sea" (ll. 196-197).
Contemplating these spectacles, Aurora affirms her right like
"Miriam" to "sing the song" she chooses. Karlin
points out how these "apocalyptic images of loss and dissolution
reverse those of clarity, stillness, and harmony" in
Wordsworth's Westminster Bridge sonnet (p. 118). In treating
passages "which are not about writing poetry in the city, but about
the city itself," Karlin turns to the much-cited passages in which
Aurora describes the slums of St. Margaret's Court, arguing as some
earlier critics have done, that it is "filled with standard images,
familiar to middle-class readers who were shocked and thrilled by
accounts of darkest London" (pp. 120-121). He doubts "if
Barrett Browning knew how priggish, condescending, and self-serving
Aurora sounds when she blesses the prostitute" she encounters in
St. Margaret's Court, concluding that Aurora gets to the New
Jerusalem of the poem's conclusion by "not much caring who she
tramples on to get there" (p. 123). This phase of Karlin's
argument might have been more con vincing if he had engaged with earlier
critics such as Margaret Reynolds (in the "Critical
Introduction" to the edition of Aurora Leigh that Karlin uses) who
argue that EBB dramatically portrays Aurora as an unreliable narrator in
her response to the slums in Book IV of the poem. One wonders, as well,
if Aurora's encounter with Marian in Paris and her subsequent move
with her to Florence reflect a differing engagement with urban realities
than we see in the London scenes? Certainly, this is the view that
Thorne-Murphy seems to take in considering the trajectory of
Aurora's relationship with Marian in the context of narratives of
prostitute rescue.
Unlike the majority of new criticism this year focused on political
dimensions of EBB's later poems, David G. Riede's
"Elizabeth Barrett and the Emotion of the Trapped," chapter
three in his book Allegories of One's Own Mind: Melancholy and
Victorian Poetry (2005), treats poetry written in the first half of her
career. Not surprisingly, Riede emphasizes the religious dimensions of
much of this work, given his subject matter: "the allegorical
figurations of melancholy" in the poetry of the Brownings and
Tennyson (p. 38). Framing his approach to melancholy within a masculine
tradition of Romantic poetics, and a body of Freudian and post-Freudian
theory that he acknowledges as "gendered" in its bias (p. 91),
Riede argues that, despite "struggles to formulate a social
position for the woman poet's separate will as well as her official
sentiments," EBB "ends up in her early work reinscribing the
accepted role of the female poet with an eloquence and creativity that
highlights the fault lines separating the limits of creativity for women
poets from those of men and distinguishing between a female tradition of
sentimental poetry and a male tradition of melancholy" (pp. 92-93).
Riede points out that "the majority of Barrett's most recent
critics have argued that even her early poetry is subtly subversive of
conventional morality," but his argument, to the contrary, is that
this "poetry is in fact conservative in its sentimentality at least
throughout her early career writing as a trapped 'Mariana'
figure in her father's house" (p. 93). It is conservative, he
maintains, because the "latent Byronic melancholy" in
EBB's earlier poetry "is, in fact, kept in check by the
'cruel policing' of her orthodox Christian conscience"
(p. 94). Riede's argument in relation to "The Poet's
Vow," "The Seraphim," and at greater length, A Drama of
Exile, is often thought-provoking, though less persuasive than it might
have been if he had engaged more robustly with earlier criticism that
takes a different tack than his own. I was also left wondering if a
different historical and theoretical framing of the poetics of
melancholy than he employs (one that included female Romantic writers as
well as male writers, for example) might have yielded very different
readings. That said, Riede offers a subtle analysis of EBB's
earlier works and concludes with a particularly original argument
concerning the "transgendered" melancholy (p. 40) of Sonnets
from the Portuguese and the ways it which it functions as a turning
point in the poet's career, away from "the emotion of the
trapped" (p. 125).
"The Runaway Slave at Pilgrim's Point" is one among
several poems by EBB that figure in "'Singing Song for
Song': The Brownings 'in the Poetic Relation,'" an
essay co-written by Corinne Davies and Marjorie Stone in Literary
Couplings: Writing Couples, Collaborators, and the Construction of
Authorship, edited by Marjorie Stone and Judith Thompson (2006) (pp.
150-174). Part of a collection that treats the diversity of literary
couplings and collaborations from the time of Sir Philip Sidney and the
Countess of Pembroke to Sylvia Plath and Ted Hughes, this essay, written
in the form of letters, debates "the extent to which the Brownings
attained a harmonious partnership as the two poets read, edited, and
revised each other's poems in the courtship period; contemplated a
literary collaboration; cast each other as "siren" muses; and,
as a married couple, quarreled over politics and spiritualism" (p.
29). The focus, however, falls upon the Brownings' literary and
textual exchanges, not upon their personal lives. Davies and Stone
discuss criticism on the Brownings' writerly interactions (noting
that female critics such as Adrienne Munich seem more inclined than male
critics to see "poetic strife" between the Brownings as
opposed to harmony), consider EBB's extensive editorial comments on
poems by RB in the courtship period such as "The Flight of the
Duchess," and examine how they learned from each other's
innovations in the forms of the ballad and dramatic monologue. Their
most pointed debate occurs over RB's penciled revisions in a fair
copy of "The Runaway Slave at Pilgrim's Point," in
particular his enclosure of EBB's characteristic signature initials
at the end of the ms in heavy brackets, prefaced by the underlined word
"my". (A photograph of the manuscript page is included with
the essay.) Is RB's gesture a "charming instance of the fond
new husband's terms of endearment"? Or a mark of enclosure and
possessiveness akin to that which Munich finds in RB's
"enringing" of EBB's name (and fame) with his own at the
close of The Ring and the Book (pp. 166-167)? Ranging through works in
Men and Women and some of EBB's Last Poems, Davies and Stone
approach, from differing angles, the paradox that the Brownings, with
their "legendary happy marriage produced some of the most powerful
poetry about disillusionment in love, erotically charged revenge, and
marital breakdown during the Victorian period" (p. 169) in works
such as EBB's "Bianca Among the Nightingales" and
RB's "James Lee's Wife." They close with a debate on
RB's salute to EBB in Men and Women, "One Word More,"
Stone emphasizing the dissonances of this complex tribute, Davies its
expression of the "redemptive qualities" (p. 173) of love,
akin to the vision of Aurora and Romney's conjugal love at the
close of Aurora Leigh.
Other new or recent treatments of EBB include Ruth Robbins'
"Hidden Lives and Ladies' Maids" (Women: a cultural
review 15 [2004]: 217-229), Jane Wood's "Elizabeth Barrett
Browning and Shakespeare's Sonnet 130" (N&Q 52 [2005]:
77-79, and an article published in Korean, Hongsang Yeo's
"Dialogism and Social Criticism in Elizabeth Barrett
Browning's Poetry," appearing in Segi Yongogwon Munhak
(Nineteenth. Century Literature in English) 8 [2004]: 55-86).
Robbins' essay, as much about Margaret Forster's novel
Lady's Maid (1990) as EBB, explores issues of secrecy, the
challenges of biographical writing, and the divisions of social class in
an essay concerned both with writing women's reliance on
others' labor and, more particularly, EBB's relationship with
her maid Lily Wilson in particular (the protagonist of the Forster
novel). While Robbins presents a thought-provoking consideration of
class differences in particular, her assessment of Forster's
representation of the woman EBB called "Wilson" might have
been enriched by more use of The Brownings' Correspondence, and
what it reveals about both Lily Wilson and EBB's relationship with
her. Wood argues that the description of Marian's appearance in
Aurora Leigh as "[n]o wise beautiful," " not white nor
brown," echoes Shakespeare's famous sonnet, "My
mistress's eyes are nothing like the sun." Unfortunately, I do
not read Korean, but the English quotations and notes in Hongsang
Yeo's substantial article indicate that her Bakhtinian analysis of
EBB's social criticism draws on Marx as well, and includes
consideration of "The Cry of the Children," "The Cry of
the Human"--a much less discussed social protest poem published in
Poems (1844)--and "A Song for the Ragged Schools of London."
Volume 26 of SBHC, a special issue entirely on EBB which I read in
proofs kindly furnished by the Armstrong Browning Library and covered in
last year's essay, actually appeared in print in the spring of
2006. I also overlooked mention last year of a comprehensive essay on
EBB's literary biography of my own appearing in the New Dictionary
of National Biography (2004). Like Beverly Taylor's comprehensive
essay for the Dictionary of National Biography (1999), this seeks to
address and correct some of the many myths and inaccuracies that have
obscured accounts of EBB's life and works in the old Dictionary of
National Biography and analogous sources. The coming year promises to
bring a wave of new criticism on EBB to mark the bicentenary, including
a special issue of Victorian Poetry on the poet, and another special
issue of Victorian Review. One can only hope as well that many of the
many interesting papers given at the Armstrong Browning Library's
March 2006 conference will begin to make their way into print by that
time.