An inspirational and instructive memoir: Andrea Mitchell, a real-life Brenda Starr, looks back at an action-packed career in broadcast journalism.
Stepp, Carl Sessions
Talking Back ... to Presidents, Dictators, and Assorted Scoundrels
By Andrea Mitchell
Viking
432 pages; $25.95
Cooped up in a North Korean hotel, not allowed out without an
escort, NBC's Andrea Mitchell did something to make every reporter
cheer: She sneaked out with a handheld camera and filmed ordinary life
in the "forbidden kingdom," until someone turned her in and
soldiers hauled her off.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Still defiant, Mitchell first refused to turn over her tape, then
secretly switched it for a blank one, saving the real tape for
broadcast.
In this unusually interesting memoir, veteran reporter Mitchell,
58, shows again and again that old-fashioned, elbows-out doggedness.
Combined with another old-fashioned trait--her unabashed love of
journalism--it makes for both inspirational and instructive reading.
Mitchell's jammed career began with local broadcasting in
Philadelphia and Washington, followed by three decades with NBC,
covering the White House, Congress and stories from Cuba to China.
Initiative has marked every stage. An early break came after she
"talked my way into a job as a copyboy" at a Philadelphia
station. When Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated, "the news
director needed someone to cover what was happening in the streets, and
I volunteered immediately." She was investigating (and tracking
down video of) Osama bin Laden long before 9/11.
Her book's title, "Talking Back," refers to her
willingness to confront the powerful. She was once carried away by
Syrian security forces for interrupting a photo op with President
Clinton to ask Hafez al Assad why he supported terrorism. But Mitchell
also balances gumption with the kind of human feeling reporters
don't ordinarily brag about.
"As tough as I can be in reporting a story," she writes,
"I don't enjoy going in for the kill." In Philadelphia,
Mitchell contended fiercely with the nail-tough Mayor Frank Rizzo. But
when Rizzo died, she wept.
Perhaps her biggest White House nemesis was Ronald Reagan's
Chief of Staff Donald Regan, whom she describes as an
"abusive" bully who "wielded power roughly, and
ruthlessly" and who "had been slandering me in public settings
... the low point of my White House career."
But as Regan himself plunged from power, Mitchell says, "I
couldn't help feeling kindly toward him."
She delivers the book's most hair-raising tale, however, with
punishing brutality. Mitchell describes interviewing the
ultraconservative U.S. Sen. Jesse Helms (R-N.C.). She learned that
Commerce Secretary Ron Brown, a Democrat, had been killed in a plane
crash, and she solemnly informed Helms.
"Jesse Helms looked at me, smiled, and said, 'That's
good.'
"I was stricken. I didn't know--and don't know to
this day--whether he really heard me. But I think he did. And I think
that was his honest response, unfiltered by the conventions of
Washington."
Mitchell, an increasingly rare broadcaster better known for tough
reporting than glib commentary, readily shares unflattering
embarrassments and mishaps. She was briefly banished from TV to radio
after freezing during a report on John Hinckley, passed out on the press
plane accompanying President Reagan to China, and once was summoned to
do an early-morning "Today" show report that, after a night of
"more than my share of wine," found her not "completely
sober."
Mitchell also seems candid about the special pressures facing women
in television and the damage that reporting can do to family life.
Indeed, her marriage provides the most extraordinary material here. As
wife of Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan, Mitchell balances
outsider reporting status with insider access to government and
society's highest rungs.
When Colin Powell was named secretary of state, she
"considered him a friend." The book is filled with sentences
such as "we had spent a weekend at the [Gerald and Betty]
Fords', along with the Cheneys."
The couple's solution to potential conflict involves
"erecting a firewall between his work and mine." But Mitchell
recognizes early on, after meeting more Washington insiders through her
husband, that "I might be gaining unusual access, but losing some
independence."
She attended, but didn't report on, a private dinner where an
argument erupted between United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan and
Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld over the treatment of prisoners at
Guantanamo, and eventually Rumsfeld "got up and left in the middle
of dessert."
So here is a collection of good stories, inside dope and real-life
quandaries, all from someone still eager enough to compare herself to
Nancy Drew and Brenda Starr. "After all these years, I still love
the chase for news," Mitchell says. "I often wonder how I got
to be so lucky."
Stepp, an AJR senior editor, teaches at the Philip Merrill College
of Journalism at the University of Maryland.