Product design suitable for assembly.
Peterka, Jozef ; Senderska, Katarina ; Vaclav, Stefan 等
1. INTRODUCTION
The effective assembly assumes a product that responds to the
requirements of manipulation and joining of separate parts into higher
units (subassemblies and final products). In order to take in the
consideration all aspects the designers need to understand to the
assembly processes and procedures. The development of the complex
products is teamwork. The basic problem, which we must to concern, is
how the parts behave during the transport, manipulation, joining and
testing. In this context are in the foreground different properties of
the parts and components as by evaluation of their function.
2. PRODUCT DESIGN BACKGROUND
To ensure the required product function it is possible to design
the product by various concepts often by using of entire different
concepts and design principles (Vaclav 2005). By comparison of two
products, that ensure the same function in the same range and in a
comparable quality (so that they have a comparable utility value) can be
observed great differences. It can be used not only other design
principles but also other materials, forms and dimensions of the parts
and components. The products have often other relative position of the
parts and components, other tolerance limits and etc (Lotter &
Wiendahl 2006). According to the design quality it is then possible to
produce and to assemble the product relatively simply without serious
technical problems and by relatively low costs or in the limit case is
the production and also the assembly complicated or unacceptable from
the point of view costs. A lot depends also on the production batch
size. The design of a product with a great batch size should be differ
from the design of the same product to the piece or robotized assembly
(Boothroyd & Dewhurst 2006). The significance of the product design
and their influence to production and assembly can be confirmed also by
following data. Independently from the product kind are in the design
process specified more than 70% manufacturing cots including costs of
the assembly. 70-80% of the possible savings are depended on the product
design, 10-20% are depended on the changes of technology, production
means, fixtures and tools. 5-10% are connected with changes of the
organization.
3. METHOD AND TOLL TO PRODUCT ANALYSIS FROM THE POINT OF VIEW
ASSEMBLY
For the product design analysis from the point of view assembly was
proposed a method issued from the decision analysis. The basis of this
approach is a set of rules and recommendations for the assembly and the
collection of questions. The analysis and evaluation is divided into
four steps: product, parts, joints and assemblies. The method assumes to
answer at five main questions in all four steps. The "answer"
is a point evaluation and an own creative proposal that can be inspired
so by existing stored proposal for similar products, parts, joints or
assemblies as by the set of rules and recommendations (IPA 2007).
The developed access tool is dedicated to analysis of medium
complex mechanical products and was tested at several products
(Senderska 2006).
Main functions:
* Refill and modify the contained rules and recommendations.
* The evaluating questions/criteria selection and definition.
* Definition of the point values for decision analysis.
* Product/products analysis.
* Analysis of the parts, joint and subassemblies.
The conception enables also to modify the material, part symmetry,
kind of the joint and other parameters assortment. The whole system is
opened for further modification for instance as comparison of two or
more variants of the products, evaluation from the point of view
disassembly etc. For better information the system can include also
drawings, 3D models or photographs of the products, parts, joints and
subassemblies.
On the figure 1 is shown the main screen for the product data
input.
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
The figure 2 shows the screen with processed data and
recommendations to product change.
In this system was created some default reports. On the figure 3 is
shown an output report of the product analysis. From the data and
analysis results contained in this system can be created various reports
according to the requirements.
[FIGURE 2 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 3 OMITTED]
The basic of this approach is a list of rules and recommendation
for product design from the point of view assembly. The system is
created so that in time of the system using can be the rules,
recommendation and examples continuously refilled. On the figure 4 is
shown the screen with the list of rules and appropriate examples.
The questions can also be modified or changed. On the figure 5 is
shown the screen to creation of a relation between questions and defined
rules. By changes in this filed must be clearly that the obtained
results can be depended on the putted questions. This must be considered
in the case of comparison of such results that was obtained by using
different questions.
[FIGURE 4 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 5 OMITTED]
4. TOPICS TO FURTHER RESEARCH
In this phase of the development is performed an augmented
verification in several directions. First augmented verification is
oriented to the tool using for the analysis of various assembled
products. The target is to verify the scope of the tool using from the
point of view product variety. The second researched aspect is the
possibility of the integration into the general procedure of the
assembly process and system design and planning. The further considered
characteristic is the product design change supporting. The main goal is
to become the impulses and experiences from the industry. Important can
be also the integration into the education. On the basis of the obtained
answers to the above putted questions can be considered also the toll
modification, selection of the other program tool or Internet
publishing.
5. CONCLUSION
Experiences with creation and application of the developed tool to
product design analysis from the point of view assembly show, that it is
one of the possible directions in the design for assembly supporting.
The tool can be easy used, modified and refilled. Important in also,
that by this tool can be stored and managed any previous proposed
solution of part, joint assemblies or product changes.
Acknowledgements
This paper was elaborated in the frame of the projects: Objective
method of assembled product design and assembly system VEGA No.:
1/3163/06 and Innovative education materials for bachelor study line
Automobile manufacturing KEGA No.: 3/6342/08 Supported by Ministry of
Education of the Slovak Republic. We are indebted for support.
6. REFERENCES
Boothroyd, G. & Dewhurst, Inc. (2006). Design For Assembly,
Available from: http://www.dfma.com Accessed: 03-04
Fraunhofer institute (IPA) (2007). Design For Assembly and
Manufacturing, Stuttgart, Available from: www.ipa.fhg.de Accessed:
2007-08-05
Lotter, B. & Wiendahl, H.P. (2006). Assembly in Production
Industrial, ISBN 13978-3-540-21413-7 s.531, Springer, Berlin Heidelberg,
New York
Senderska, K.; (2006). Approaches and Tools to Evaluation Support
of Product Construction for Assembly, In: Inovations Transfer, SjF TU,
pp. 214-215, ISBN 80-8073701-0, Kosice
Vaclav, S. (2005). What is the Assembly? Proceedings of 13th
International Scientific Conference CO-MAT-TECH 2005, pp. 1289-1294 ISBN
80-227-2286, Trnava