Training days: students and professors move research into the world at 4-H Camp Bristol Hills.
Hall, Olivia M.
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
On a sunny July day, a dozen girls in shorts and t-shirts gather by
the small store at 4-H Camp Bristol Hills in Canandaigua, N.Y. Slurping
slushies that stain their lips bright orange, blue, and red, they
chatter over the sounds of a strumming guitar. Unlike most of their
fellow campers, these girls are headed to Big Chief cabin for a unique
afternoon activity. Guided by two human development undergraduates,
they'll reflect on puberty as part of the "Writing about Life
Changes" study led by Jane Mendle, assistant professor of human
development. Following a successful pilot study last summer, Mendle is
again partnering with camp director Tim Davis to further investigate the
health benefits of writing about teen transitions.
"The 4-H program has always had a wonderful connection with
the university," says Davis, interim executive director and 4-H
program leader of Cornell Cooperative Extension in Ontario County and,
thanks to a coffee habit, "Java" to his 70 staff members and
1,000 co-ed campers. "There is a real emphasis on how the camp
experience will develop the whole child, and if there is a good fit
between faculty and our priority areas--healthy living, STEM (science,
technology, engineering, and math), or workforce development--we're
very open to discussing partnerships." Indeed, 4-H Camp Bristol
Hills is becoming a prime spot for Cornell professors and students to
pursue research and outreach projects. Along with Mendle's study,
this summer the nearly-90-year-old camp hosted the "Health and the
Brain Neuroscience Outreach" project by Valerie Reyna, professor of
human development, and a geospatial science study in the College of
Agriculture and Life Sciences, all run by CCE interns.
On this afternoon, Mendle's research assistants Alexandra
Holmes '16 and Kathleen McCormick '16 walk 14 girls from the
camp store to Big Chief, where they spread out on a collection of
mismatched chairs around several tables. They open booklets titled
"Dear Diary--Day 3" and listen to Holmes deliver instructions
to write for 20 minutes about changes they have noticed in their
relationships with their parents and family members since entering
puberty. Hunched over their booklets, the girls scribble away, the
silence broken by kitchen clatter heard through the screen doors and
sheep bleats from the critter care class outside.
"Some of the things they write are really funny, some are
sad," Holmes says after the girls hand in their booklets
anonymously and leave for their cabins. "No matter the focus of the
writing, it is amazing how genuine and thought-provoking the responses
are."
"Often they're glad they've gotten their thoughts
out on paper," McCormick adds. Such expressive writing
exercises--brief, focused interventions to write about periods of
change--have been shown to benefit participants, Mendle explains.
For pubescent girls, writing about their relationships with peers
and parents could help to head off potential negative consequences of a
difficult life stage, including depression, anxiety, poor self-esteem,
and body dissatisfaction. "Everybody knows that puberty is rough on
kids," she says.
Mendle will measure their mental health changes against control
groups completing a neutral writing exercise and by following up with
the campers after three months. She anticipates that by the
summer's end her research assistants here and at Hidden Valley,
another 4-H camp near Watkins Glen, will have recruited more than 100
girls--lured by the promise of free slushies--adding to 50 from her
pilot study last year.
Molding Minds
Down the hill from Big Chief cabin, on the bright second floor of
Woodard Lodge, human development research assistant Lindsay Dower
'17 opens a session on health and the brain with two
middle-school-aged girls and one boy gathered at a long craft table.
"Let's make our own brains out of clay!" Dower tells
the campers. They roll two white balls for the left and right
hemispheres, bridge them together with a thin red corpus callosum, add a
blue cerebellum, and cover everything with colorful parietal, temporal,
and occipital lobes. Along the way, Dower explains each part's
function.
"The medulla oblongata controls breathing, so it's very
important," she says. "I got my camp name,
'Medulla,' when I told other counselors that it's my
favorite part of the brain stem."
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
For the next two hours, campers bounce around the room, absorbed in
such hands-on activities as pretending to be fat cells that try to
process "calories" made from yarn.
"The goal of our project is to look at how effective this
curriculum is in helping kids learn about neuroscience, genetics, and
nutrition," Dower says.
During three weeks at Bristol Hills, Dower is observing
participants--some of whom were part of a special 4-H STEM program--as
they complete randomly assigned nutrition or genetics modules.
Both are updates from last year's pilot study based on
Reyna's fuzzy-trace theory, which proposes that people retain
information in two ways--verbatim and gist. But when making decisions,
adults tend to rely on the fuzzier gist of the situation whereas teens
analyze the verbatim facts, an approach that often leads them to
underestimate the dangers of risky choices.
"In the context of Lindsay's research, verbatim knowledge
could be memorizing calorie counts of foods and making nutrition into a
math problem," Reyna's graduate student lab leader Evan
Wilhelms says.
"But many people, despite knowing what good nutrition is,
don't make healthy choices. We theorize that they lack insight into
why, for example, it is important to count calories. You're more
likely to retain and use information when you have an understanding of
it."
While adolescents are great at memorization, they are still
learning to rely on gist knowledge, leaving them prone to make risky
choices. "That's why we're specifically targeting
them," Wilhelms adds.
By creating model brains, Dower hopes campers will understand the
essence of how the brain works, even if they don't remember the
specifics about each part.
Role Models
In the same way that archery, swimming, woodworking, and singing
around the fire draw campers to Bristol Hills, Davis hopes the camp will
become known for introducing kids to the value of STEM.
"The studies are wonderful experiences," he says,
pointing to numerous benefits for participants, including exposure to
higher-level subject matter and personal growth.
Faculty members, on the other hand, develop new youth curricula,
provide outreach opportunities to their undergraduate and graduate
students, and find subjects for their studies. "The big advantage
of the camp is that it allows us to test research on a pretty broad
sample of people in a relatively short timeframe," Mendle says.
"I'm very grateful to Tim for that opportunity, which embodies
what extension is supposed to be."
Students learn to move research from controlled lab settings into
the real world, where distractions can require "going with the
flow," says Dower. "It's also taught me leadership and
interpersonal skills. My favorite part is working with the campers.
Some of them ask me questions about studying science in college,
and I love talking about my experiences. There is definitely a mentoring
component."
For Davis, it is one of the greatest benefits of bringing CCE
interns to the camp. "STEM might not be something that our campers
have enjoyed previously, but then they see the enthusiasm that young
adults like Lindsay have for it," he says. "They're
seeing young women who are succeeding at college and doing some
incredible things."
The research assistants' full integration into camp--from
eating meals in the lodge to teaching afternoon recreation classes--
reinforces these interpersonal connections.
"By the end of the week, the girls enjoy not just the
experiment but also hanging out with us," says Holmes.
"The best thing is when someone gives us a hug goodbye and
says, 'I'm going to miss you,'" McCormick agrees.
"That's pretty impressive."
Olivia M. Hall, PhD '12, is an anthropologist and freelance
writer.