Gender politics of hip-hop and hip-life music in New York and Ghana.
Jabbaar-Gyambrah, Tara
Introduction
Over the last thirty years, hip-hop has become a national
phenomenon that was cultivated out of the youth resistance movement that
emerged in the South Bronx of New York during the 1970s. It ultimately
transformed its segment of popular culture into a worldwide entity.
Known as the headquarters of hip-hop, the South Bronx continues to serve
as its birthplace. It is a community where Black and Latino Youth used
their creative voices of expression to speak out against poverty and
inequity in American society through emceeing, djing, breakdancing and
graffiti. Several factors set the stage for hip-hop's emergence in
the seventies, including, but not limited to: job loss, cutting of music
programs, migration of Black middle class from the Bronx, white flight,
the building of the Cross Bronx Bridge Expressway, increased drug
trafficking, and the rapid building of housing projects that did not
provide families with a good quality of life. Although hip-hop started
as an underground movement that spread from the South Bronx community to
other areas of New York, one song on the radio spurred its international
growth.
In 1979 the Sugar Hill gang's song "Rappers Delight"
put hip-hop on the map as a new innovation of popular culture. While
there were other hip-hop artists who were notable contributors to its
success--the God Fathers of hip-hop: Gil Scot Heron, DJ Kool Here,
Afrika Bambaata and Grandmaster Flash--their music was not selected to
be played on the radio. The late Gil Scot Heron was famous for his song
"The Revolution Will Not Be Televised" which critiqued the
mass media for its representation of the Black community. DJ Kool Here
was known for his signature song "Apache" and the invention of
the breakbeat. Afrika Bambaata formed Zulu Nation, a group named after
the fdm Shaka Zulu (1964) to represent the uniting of gangs in the South
Bronx community. Grand Master Flash was known for the quick mix theory
and the song "The Message." Hip-Hop had a powerful impact on
youth across New York, New Jersey, California, and several other states.
Each community had their own cause to fight and resist. By the late
eighties and early nineties, police brutality became the center of
discussion. NWA's "F*** the Police" (1988) addressed
excessive force in the Compton community of California with its own
unique style. It was not long before hip-hop became a global phenomenon
in the 1980s spreading to France, Japan, Ghana, South Africa, and
Nigeria.
Although many people are aware of the transformative nature of
hip-hop in New York, most are unaware of the transnational influence of
the New York-born musical subculture in the continent of Africa. One
such genre emerged in the early 1990s in Ghana--hip-life. It is the
combination of African American style hip-hop (e.g., rapping) and
highlife music created by Ghanaian youth. It is not just a blend of
other forms of music, but it is a combination of local rhythms like the
Adowa, (1) instruments such as Kpanlogo drums (2), xylophones, flutes,
thumb pianos, and samples of old highlife favorites like Alhaji
Frimpong, Abrechieba Kofi Sammy, CK Mann, Gyedu Blay Ambolley, Amakye
Dede, Nana Tufour, and A.B. Crenstil. Reggie Ossei Rockstone, (3) a
famous Ghanaian musician, introduced hip-life music to Ghanaian youth by
infusing styles and lyrics with traditional African music when he
returned from London in 1994. Rockstone not only transferred
hip-hop's style to Ghana, but he integrated it into Ghanaian
cultural music for the youth. In hip-life, hip-hop's cultural
values remained intact, such as the social consciousness to engage in
political struggle, the wearing of various fashion trends, and the style
of rapping. Hip-life music gained its popularity through television,
radio, nightclubs, music videos, local drinking spots in Ghana, and
through the circulation of newspapers, CDs, and cassettes.
JJC, a Nigerian hip-hop artist created a four-part documentary
entitled Afropop: The Rise of African Hip-Hop, focusing on how hip-life
has given youth a new type of African identity. Through a series of
interviews with producers, DJs, artists, music talk show host Bola Ray
and Reggie Rockstone, he explores the cross-cultural connections of
hip-hop and its African roots. At the core of hip-hop is the West
African tradition of storytelling, which is often passed down through
the griot in an oral history form. It is this African culture that was
brought to America, grew during the slavery plantation era and was
re-created in the form of hip-hop in the [South] Bronx in the 1970s.
Ironically, this same tradition traveled back home to Africa in the
1980s but with an African American and New York influence.
Panji Anoff, the first producer of hip-life of Ghana, furthers this
argument as he believes that hip-hop is derived from a traditional
African tradition that has been reinvented in America. According to
Anoff, "The source of hip-hop is an African tradition, an ancient
African tradition of freestyling, which is spontaneous poetry to a
rhythmic pattern." (4) One of the core connections between hip-hop
and hip-life music is rapping, which is the art of sharing one's
story. In this way, hip-hop globally adapted to cultural expressions of
each region it encountered and served as a platform for a variety of
voices in collaboration and in competition with its original message.
Although they have often been overshadowed by their male
counterparts, women played a key role in the founding moments of
hip-hop. In New York, women artists and emcees such as MC Lyte,
Salt-N-Pepa, Lauryn Hill, Nikki Minaj, LiT Kim, Foxy Brown, and the Real
Roxanne illustrate how hip-hop culture is infused with various meanings
and cultural strategies. These strategies are not gender neutral but
take on the message of the emcees. For women emcees, this can be read as
both lessons of liberation and tales of caution.
This article examines the ways in which women in hip-hop and
hip-life navigate a male-dominated music genre by embracing cultural
strategies of global liberation. By focusing on the similarities and
differences of experiences women in these different geographic contexts,
I address the following questions: (1) What is the relevance of the
birth of hip-hop in New York to its various global transformations and
hip-life in particular? (2) How do the roles of women in hip hop and
hip-life music industries differ based on their locations in Ghana as
compared to New York-based artists? What are women's roles in
hip-hop and hip-life music?
New York Origins and Global Transformations
The music of the Black Atlantic world was the primary expressions
of cultural distinctiveness in which populations in New York and other
areas across the African Diaspora seized upon and adapted to its new
circumstances. Black and Latino youth used these separated, but
converged musical traditions of the Black Atlantic world to create
itself anew as a conglomeration of communities as a means to gauge the
social progress of spontaneous self-creation. All of this was cemented
together by the endless pressures of economic exploitation, political
racism, displacement, and exile.
In his book The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness
(1995), Paul Gilroy indicates that as music travels across the Diaspora
it adapts to new ascribed conditions to which it is subjected, thus
creating a space whereby traditions are upheld and creatively sculpted
to fit the location, time, socio-cultural factors, and the individual
and communal life experiences of the people. It is through these
factors, the transatlantic flow of Black music via the Diaspora, that
creative expressive culture is reborn. I posit that hip-hop and hip-life
(5) music are two forms of music that have traveled across the Black
Atlantic and embody Gilroy's definition and are representative of
"Sankofian Diasporic" connections. (6) Furthering this idea,
in Dangerous Grounds: Popular Music, Postmodernism and the Poetics of
Place (1997), Lipsitz states: "hip hop and other forms of Diasporic
African music participate in constructing these local identities, but
they bring to them a global consciousness." (7) In other words,
when music travels across the diaspora, it is sort of like a
butterfly--it goes through a metamorphism that creates a hybrid form,
sculpted to its particular locations, culture, politics, and economic
status.
Hip-hop and hip-life music industries are two Diasporic communities
where there are complex and contradictory hierarchies centered upon
socio-cultural histories (i.e., colonialism, cultural reproduction of
youth identity, etc.) that are continually reproduced through lyrics and
music videos that create a patriarchal illusionary image of women.
Gender inequity in both of these male dominated music industries stems
from societal views and cultural influences from different groups of
people that have been reproduced to fit today's world.
In his book, Hip-Hop Generation (2003), Bakari Kitwana says that
the gender problem between Black men and women are related to the
generational divide between the Civil Rights generation and what he
calls, the hip-hop generation, those born between the years of
1965-1984, which essentially boils down to the older vs. younger
generation ideology. Disparities in housing, education, health care,
mortgage loan programs, public policy, and the negative portrayal of
Blacks in the media have led to increased tensions within the community
that have turned into misdirected anger towards Black women. (8)
Misrepresentations of the Black community, especially women in hip-hop
music videos sparked some of the conflict between the older and younger
generation. And, Byron Hurt unpacks this in his film, Hip-Hop Beyond
Beats and Rhymes (2006) that explores issues of masculinity, violence,
and sexism in hip-hop music, ultimately finds that hip-hop is a
reflection of American society's view on gender roles.
Even though hip-life's historical location are firmly placed
in Ghana, it was born out of the cultural history of Ghanaians and
African Americans through migration. In this sense, factors such as the
generational divide in West African communities and the African
Americanisms in hip-hop culture have shaped hip-life. Studying these
elements will help us understand the ways in which hip-life artists
represent themselves in the music industry. As a result, some hip-life
artists emulate some forms of African American hip-hop culture in the
music genre while others uphold a strong Ghanaian cultural heritage
through their music. In other words within the hip-life music industry
there are two primary forms of expression:
1. Hip-life artists imitate African American culture (e.g.,
hip-hop). Musicians do this by using similar messages in their lyrics,
adopting dress code values of hip-hop, hairstyles, and using African
American slang in their music.
2. Hip-life artists maintain strong Ghanaian cultural traditions
through their music. Hip-life artists symbolize and preserve their
culture through the types of clothing that they wear, hairstyles, the
production of metaphorical "creative" messages in their songs
that addresses socio-cultural and political issues of the Ghanaian
community and the use of native languages and/or dialects. (9)
The above examples show that there are West Africanisms in hip-hop
and African Americanisms in hip-life. There is a reciprocal relationship
between hip-hop in the United States and hip-life music in Ghana.
However, these connections do not mean that one hip-life artist cannot
possess cultural representations of both African Americans and
Ghanaians. For example, Sidney, a popular hip-life artist in the
Ghanaian song "Abuskeleke,"U) degrades women by using
misogynistic lyrics and making fun of the newest sexualized Western
fashion style of wearing half shirts." By imitating the language
used in African American hip-hop, Sidney is expressing his disapproval
of the Ghanaian female fashion that was adopted from Western culture in
the 1990s. In another song called "Scenti No," (12) he plays
the role of revolutionary who speaks about corrupt behavior in the
government system that goes against Ghanaian ethical values. Both songs
send two different messages which fall into two
categories--"negative" and political. Within the hip-life
industry, themes ranging from social, cultural, political, and
African/Black feminist perspectives have emerged. The categories
discussed above do not exempt the continual emergence or integration of
other musical forms or cultural ideologies into hip-life.
The British Post-Colonial Effects on Hip-Life Music
Although hip-life is a genre of protest music that emerged from
Ghanaian youth expressing themselves, some British colonial influences
have appeared in the genre which creates a contradiction of cultures.
Many historians such as Adu Boahen, Jean Allman, Victoria B. Tashijian,
Amina Mama and others have studied and researched economic, political,
social structure and religion on West African countries, but do not
explore the impact of colonialism on hip-life music. Kofi Agawu believes
that scholars have "ignored" colonialism's impact on
music because it is such a complex area to study. According to Kofi
Agawu, "... unlike political history, with its kingdom wars,
migrations and inventions, music-an art of sound and a performing art in
an oral culture-leaves different, more complex and elusive traces on the
historical record, which may explain why historians of Africa have
ignored its music." (13)
In other words, according to Agawu, music is a creative form that
is bound by complicated oral histories where only traces are left behind
to be examined on record. Music includes a wide variety of styles and
practices that continuously re-invents itself through migrations.
Colonialism has produced a complex musical society in Africa. Similar to
the way Black music in the United States has been shaped by structural
forces of slavery and Jim Crow, in contemporary Africa a bewildering
diversity of inter-and intracontinental musical influences have shaped
hip-life. Agawu urges us to consider that these 'foreign'
modes of expression sometimes retain their original forms in the new
environment, at other moments they transform indigenous forms. As we
think about the place of hip-life music and the legacy of hip-hop in
Africa, postcolonial Africa is thus best characterized as a
constellation of musical practices. (14)
One example of these "constellations" at work in
postcolonial Africa is a specific music form called highlife, "a
blend of traditional Akan rhythms and melodies with European musical
elements, such as the European instruments and harmony. It encompasses a
variety of artistic expressions: music, dancing, storytelling, and
theater." (15) Highlife music origins reside in English speaking
West African countries of Liberia, Sierra Leone, Ghana, and Nigeria.
(16) These influences evolved from contact with soldiers stationed on
the Guinea Coast, African American seamen, centuries of church music,
and adaptations of Western ballroom music. In its modern form, highlife
music includes traces of African American blues, Caribbean reggae, pop
and rock music all blended in a unique African style. Similar to
hip-hop, highlife music is a multi-ethnic and cultural blend of music
that represents a constellation of traditions across the Diaspora.
As Gilroy argues extensively in The Black Atlantic, there are no
pure forms of Black music. There are distinctive attributes of Black
cultural forms that are "modern" because they are hybrid and
have origins in the West and Creole. Gilroy states:
They [Black cultural forms] are modern because
they have struggled to escape their status as
commodities and the position within the cultural
industries it specifies, and because they are
produced by artists whose understanding of their
own position relative to the racial group and of
the role of art in mediating individual creativity
with social dynamics is shaped by a sense of
artistic practice as an autonomous domain either
reluctantly or happily divorced from the
everyday life world. (17)
In the end, Gilroy argues that the Black cultural forms derive
their power from Western and modern ideals and that a doubleness of
locality comes along with them, where in fact the music is being
produced with unique attributes produced by their experiences.
Extending Gilroy's argument related to the presence of hip-hop
in Ghana, I believe that hip-life follows a similar trajectory, whereas
there is a distinct Ghanaian cultural dynamic embedded within the music,
related to an artist's experiences and creativity. There are
significant cultural markers and societal themes such as gender roles,
economic, political, social, and cultural issues that have been
influenced Ghanaian society are evidence in new cultural forms of the
music.
Facing similar commercial scenarios that hip-hop and Black cultures
have historically encountered in the United States, aspects of Ghanaian
popular culture have also struggled to escape commoditization. This is
an important and integral theme in hip-life music that makes it worthy
of comparison to hip-hop. There has been a steady shifting of power
between artists and record companies that, as they have in the United
States, have the ability to influence the production of the music and
its meaning as they filter life experiences and socio-cultural histories
through various media.
Elements of African traditional music often resurface in the face
of the rebirthing process of highlife and hip-life bringing together
events, location, time, language, traumatic events (e.g. slave trade
experience and colonialism) and space. Hip-life music was birthed out of
this very process of remixing Diasporic voices of African American
hip-hop, highlife music, and Ghanaian youth, to confront the effects of
British colonialism.
Roles of Women in Hip-Hop and Hip-Life Music
Ghanaian and African American women often face challenges when
addressing sexuality in their songs. This is frequently met with
backlash from the media and community. The globalization of hip-hop has
brought a variety of images that continues to transform the perceptions
of Black women in Africa and the African Diaspora. In her work, Black
Feminist Thought, Hill-Collins, discusses the irreparable damage of the
jezebel, mammy, matriarch, and hot momma plays in the United States
against Black women. These images did not grow over night, but has
historically been developed for hundreds of years through the
pre-colonial, colonial, and Jim Crow eras.
The perpetuation of Black women's beauty, sexuality, and
personas have manifested through various media forms, including but not
limited to commercial ads, films, and music videos. It is not the fact
of these being developed and shown to the global world that makes them
so powerful, but how others perceive Black women through media
experiences without knowing their true character and how the development
of the self-fulfilling prophecy drives the identity of so many young
Black women in society today. Self fulfilling prophecy is the idea that
when one is presented with the same image over and over again, they
begin to take on those characteristics. Now, while I love hip-hop
culture and the socio-cultural movement that grew out of resistance, I
cannot deny the fact that over the last 10 years, I have grown to
question the ways in which women's bodies are canvassed and
utilized in music videos to shape their identity. But it has become an
intricate web that points to the complexity of economics, privilege, and
how colonial history has shaped our perceptions of Black women's
body, beauty, and sexuality.
Hip-hop is no stranger to the discussion of derogatory lyrics and
music videos that subject the Black female body into submission through
the power of patriarchal ideals. Nelly's received backlash from
Spelman College students in 2004, when he released his explicit music
video "Tip Drill" which displayed Black women in various
comprising positions. In one scene, a credit card was swiped down the
buttocks of a young African American woman, signifying that her body can
be bought. More than this, the ideology itself connects to aggressively
sexual behavior that was displayed during slavery, thus emerging through
the stereotypical image--jezebel. As time has passes by, I have tried to
unpack the multidimensional representations of Black women in media,
namely hip-hop videos, and the benefit that we receive as Black women,
and the greater international community.
In the U.S., artists like Salt-N-Pepa, Lil' Kim and Foxy Brown
set the stage for Black women expressing their sexuality in music videos
through their dress and lyrics. Salt-N-Pepa's "Push It"
(1986) was one of the first songs to express Black women's
sexuality from their perspective. Nearly ten years later, under the
mentorship of Biggie Smalls, Lil' Kim released her album Hardcore
(1996) which took the idea of Black womanhood to another level of
expression. While on one hand, Lil' Kim challenged the notion that
African American women did not have control over their bodies. On the
other hand, her crass but explicit lyrics, fed into patriarchal
illusions and fantasies of men about Black women's bodies and
sexuality. Sut Jhally's Dreamworlds 2 (1995) considers how these
narratives are shaped through a narrow set of myths of gender and
sexuality in music videos, sometimes blurring the division between
reality and fantasy. Consequently, the emotional ride given by the male
viewer can often times lead him to believe that all women want to be
engaged in their sexualized fantasies, thus erupting in more sexual
assaults and rapes in American society.
Black women who encounter these personas and attempted to engage
broader themes in the African Diaspora face significant challenges. In
Ghana, hip-life artists like Mzbel have used their music to address
gender issues such as sexual violence and harassment under the shadow of
colonialism. Mzbel's career began in 2002 with Hush Studios but
skyrocketed after the release of her two most controversial albums Awoso
Me (Give It To Me) (2004) and 16 Years (2006). In between the releasing
of these albums, Mzbel (2005) was brutally attacked (18) and sexually
assaulted. (19)
The first incident occurred in October of 2005 Mzbel was invited to
perform on campus of Kumasi Nkrumah University of Science and Technology
(KNUST) in Kumasi in celebration of Art Society week at the college.
Mzbel was dressed in a "white unzipped long-sleeved mini-jacket; a
glittering pink bra, a pair of white 'track' trousers and a
pair of white sneakers" (20) Mzbel was accompanied by her female
dancers who wore "red-checkered mini-skirts." She performed
three songs solo, one being a hit, with hip-life artist Castro,
"Awoso Me" (Give It to Me); a song about two lovers who create
a dialogue about their intimacy with one another. Core themes of the
video are freedom of female expression, reclaiming sexuality, and the
ability to assert sexual desires. In one of the verses, Mzbel provides
directions to her lover Buk Tye and warns him against infidelity:
That's how it is, let's do it as it is
It's so sweet, very sweet
Can you? No, don't rush. Take it easy
Don't be busy like a player
I'm about to give you flavor
Something sweet which you can never stop eating
Give it to me (21)
During the performance the two hip-life artists play the role of
lovers who create a dialogue about their sexual experiences and
pleasures. Mzbel gave a compelling performance with many of the students
demanded an encore but she was unable to comply because other artists
were waiting to perform. Nothing could prepare her for what happened
next. A riot erupted, with audience members lurching forward stripping
Mzbel naked citing her refusal to comply with the demands of the crowd.
Although some students tried to carry her off to safety, there were
others who blatantly assaulted her by ripping fondling her breasts and
buttocks. Ultimately, three students at Kumasi Nkrumah University of
Science and Technology (KNUST) were implicated in the molestation charge
of Mzbel, Alex Dapaah, Aaron Adusah-Poku and Theodore Djokoto. Each of
the students was suspended from the university for one year.
The second incident occurred in September of 2006 Mzbel and her
dancers were attacked, raped, and robbed at her home in Accra, Ghana.
According to news reports from ghanamusic.com, Joy FM and myzongo.com,
thieves stole items such as DVD players, laptop computers, jewelry and
clothes. While there is still a debate as to whether Mzbel and her
dancers were raped, Mzbel reported verbally in an interview with Joy FM
that she was in fact raped. Although the experience was horrifying Mzbel
continued to write and sing her music. Is it because of the way that she
dresses? Or, is it because she has chosen to voice her opinion as a
Ghanaian woman?
In her article, "African Women, Fashion, and
Scapegoating," Audrey Wipper talks about controversy surrounding
"appropriate" dress of African women in East and Central parts
of Africa. In the excerpt below Wipper explains how the wearing of
mini-skirts sparked a massive riot in Ethiopia:
Mini-skirts were blamed for widespread rioting in Ethiopia in which
50 persons were injured, 100 vehicles destroyed, and schools closed for
two weeks. There has been vigilante mob action. 'Offending'
women have been jeered at, physically assaulted and stripped of their
clothes in public by youth wingers and college students. (22)
Many of these types of attacks have occurred in Kenya, Uganda,
Malawi and Zambia. These attacks are as a result of the deep-rooted
social changes that urban Africa has been experiencing over the last
several years and African women are being used as targets of aggression
to symbolize the strains of these changes. (23)
Mini-skirts in particular provoked the government to put a ban on
wearing short skirts and dresses that were deemed
"inappropriate." As Wipper states, "in Zambia, President
Kenneth Kaundra ruled that all skirts must be at least three inches
below the knee. And one of the most authoritarian of all heads of state,
Dr. Banda, forbade women to use lipstick, straighten their hair, paint
their fingernails, and wear trousers or shorts." (24) African women
who wore Western fashions, make-up, wigs, and lightened their skin were
ridiculed because they were moving away from being "African."
Some African countries, in an attempt to preserve
"traditional" African culture banned such items from being
used. (25)
Mzbel has used the site of the concert as a form of resistance in
which she challenges African traditional roles subscribed to women in
the community by using dress. According to Allman:
Dress and fashion have been centrally
implicated in the forgoing of a distinct African
modernity, through slavery and freedom,
colonialism and conversion, ethnicity and
nation, gender, and generation, hybridity and
cosmopolitanism, state-building and state
authority, subjecthood, and citizenship.
Moreover, as part of their agenda of liberating
modernity from Eurocentric paradigms, they
dismantle the tradition vs. modernity binary by
demonstrating that tradition does not exist either
prior to or in opposition to the modern. (26)
In other words, is it possible to be "modern" and
"traditional" at the same time? Mzbel has been cited for being
dressed inappropriately, and not serving as an "appropriate"
role model for young girls in the community. In the end, there is a
merging of African and Western culture ideologies through Mzbel's
song "Awoso Me." Through the influence of colonialism,
Ghanaian women were encouraged to wear clothing that did not reveal
their breasts or butts [bottoms?], as they were thought of as
"sexual beasts."
In 1957 under Kwame Nkrumah's presidency, Hannah Kudjoe, a
woman's rights activist, began to campaign for women to wear
European style clothing. Her purpose appeared to be different from that
of Ghana's former colonial master, Britain, because she wanted to
"uplift" women and create an atmosphere of self-reliance. It
is however ironic that her leadership role to empower women mirrored
that of colonial guidelines given Britain's influence on Ghana.
There has been a complex merging of African patriarchy and Western
ideologies that continues to resurface in Ghanaian society. Mzbel
resists both African and British patriarchy by straying away from the
"norm" by wearing mini-skirts, dresses, halter tops, and
shorts.
Dress is important because it has been influenced throughout
Ghana's colonial history with Britain. Dress can be used as a form
of power and it is deeply embedded in economic, political, the gendered
perspectives of the British and culture. The ways in which women dress
in the community gets played out in these areas because it is a complex
realm of socio-cultural realities. Over time it has become a hybrid form
that either resists African patriarchy or plays into Western ideologies
about African women. For example, the British attached the way in which
women dressed in African communities to their sexuality. Through the use
of educational services, missionary groups such as the Basel and
Wesleyan Mission encouraged and promoted the idea of wearing European
clothing, suits for the men and flowery long dresses for the women.
The current debate surrounding young girls and women's choices
to be more "sexy" in the way that they dress is said to be
moving away from the more "traditional" forms of dress in
Ghana towards Western fashions. However, is it possible that women are
reverting back to Ghanaian traditional forms of dress prior to
colonialism? Or, is the way in which young girls or women choose to
dress a reflection of the shift in gendered perspectives of Ghanaians as
a result of colonialism? The patriarchal relations in Ghanaian society
disregard the significance of women's experience which suggests
that violence against women in Ghanaian societies is deeply rooted in
"gender power relations, identities, and social institutions."
(27) Inevitably, young women are violated to maintain systems of
oppression that subordinate their roles in society.
Riot outbursts are not just limited to economic and political
concerns. There are other factors such as gender inequities and
women's public invisibility, which partially emerged as a result of
British colonialism. The attack on Mzbel at the KNUST concert in 2005
emerged as a result of complex social and cultural contradictions. What
transpired at this concert and at other similar events over the last
several years in Ghana are traceable to the influence of British
colonialism. For example, the way in which Ghanaian women dressed became
associated with her sexuality during colonialism. Wearing little or no
clothing for the British symbolized a "loose woman." The
ideology that women are to wear clothing that covers their entire body
emerged during colonial rule and has been internalized in Ghanaian
culture. The young women who were at the concert stepped out of roles
that have been inscribed by British colonialism and that are continually
carried out as a "norm" of Ghanaian society. By wearing
clothing that revealed "sacred" parts of the body they
resisted British and Ghanaians subscribed roles. While dress may seem to
be a big part of the issue, it is only part of the equation. Dress was
used to create subscribed gender roles for Ghanaian women in the
community.
Similar to its American counterpart, hip-hop, hip-life is often
characterized by male aggression with women largely absent in the
industry. When women are present, their ability to articulate authentic
critiques of serious societal issues is muted by hyper masculine sexual
objectification of their bodies and music. This aggression has serious
consequences in a transnational context that have been more carefully
scrutinized in the United States than abroad.
The riot at Mzbel's concert emerged as a result of a
complicated web stemming from Ghanaian society's transitions
between the economic, social, cultural, and political sectors. Mzbel who
was attack at the concert at KNUST in 2005, then, serve as
"scapegoats" for the real issues that plague Ghanaian society
such as high unemployment rates, the meshing of Ghanaian and British
patriarchal views of women, and subscribed gender roles.
Conclusion
Comparing the impact of hip-hop culture on hip-life artists in
Ghana, several important issues become apparent. Music is not simply a
passing culture form relegated to the aesthetic realm but rather it
becomes a conduit for political, cultural, emotional, and sexual trauma.
From the experiences of Mzbel and others we can see how the remix of
hip-hop in a West African context both challenged and confirmed
traditional roles assigned to women in West African societies. As a
platform hip-life has great potential to challenge Western patriarchal
stereotypes about a "woman's place," however it also can
exhibit and amplify the same misogynistic and anti-feminist qualities
that characterized aspects of the subculture in the United States
Despite these contradictions, understanding hip-life as a strategy
of liberation for women is important for a variety of reasons. First, it
broadens our understanding of the power of Black music by engaging the
international dimensions of its appeal. We see a New York form that was
developed to address a certain socio-political context taking on new
forms to challenge colonial and patriarchal systems of power. While much
has been discussed about how African American youth have interpreted
hip-hop music as a venue for their political affirmation, we also see
that Ghanaian women can engage the music and the culture as a platform
with the same fervor.
We should carefully consider the connection of regional and
cultural influences in New York to a broader conversation about gender,
power, class, and culture. Instead of thinking of New York as a separate
microcosm, we can use stories of trauma and musical performance to
interrogate patriarchy and violence directed against women on a global
scale.
(1) The adowa is a local rhythm that has several different meanings
that can be used in the musical and theatrical concept. It is connected
to the cultural heritage of the Ga people of southeastern Ghana. It is a
body of songs and/or dance that is utilized as a rite of passage for all
Ga people which are performed by women. For example, a particular dance
form may be named after a drum, and an adowa would be an example of
this.
(2) The kpanlogo drum is a musical instrument that is used to
signify the culture of the Ga people in Ghana's Accra region. It is
used for marking the rhythm for traditional kpanlogo dance performances.
It is a hand crafted dram made of tweneboa wood, with a calfskin dram
head attached to wooden pegs with round ropes. Although it is derived
from the Ga people of Ghana it is popular throughout West Africa because
of its defined characteristics (e.g. deep and loud sound).
(3) Although Reggie Rockstone invented hip-life music in the early
1990s, he did not release his first commercial album until 1997. His
album Maaka Maka (If I said so I said it) was produced by Ghanaian
Michael Coalhouse Horthman, who was familiar with Britain. Rockstone was
finally recognized internationally in March of 2001 for his creation of
hip-life in The Source Magazine in the United States. Other Ghanaian
artists such as Freddie Funkstone, Lord Kenya, Michael Cook, Talking
Drum and Panji Anoff of Pidgen music soon followed suit by releasing
their own albums.
(4) "Accra Reclaims Hip-Hop", BBC News, accessed February
13, 2015, http://news.bbc.co.Uk/2/hi/africa/3241007.stm
(5) It is a combination of African American style hip-hop (i.e.,
rapping) and highlife music.
(6) The literal meaning of sankofa is "se wo were fi na wosan
kofa a yenki " (it's not a taboo to go back and fetch what you
have forgotten). The Sankofian Diasporic connection is the way in which
hip-hop and hip-life music participates in constructing cultures and
identities by traveling from locality to another.
(7) George Lipsitz, Dangerous Grounds: Popular Music, Postmodernism
and the Poetics of Place (New York and London: Verso, 1997), 33.
(8) Bakari Kitwana, The Hip Hop Generation (New York: BasicCivitas
Books, 2003), 87.
(9) Tara Jabbaar-Gyambrah, "Hip-Hop, Hip-Life: Global
Sistahs" (PhD diss., University of Buffalo, 2007)
(10) The translation could mean mini skirt, or short dress that
women wear that show body parts that are not to be seen in public
according to Ghanaian cultural values.
(11) John Collins, "A Social History of Ghanaian Popular
Entertainment Since Independence" (unpublished paper presented at
the Ghana Historical Society, August 2005). To be published in
Transactions: Journal of the Ghana Historical Society in 2006-2007.
(12) The translation literally means smell and signifies something
is rotten or not good in reference to Ghanaian government politics.
(13) Kofi Agawu, "Colonialism's Impact," in
Representing African Music: Postcolonial Notes, Queries, Positions, ed.
Kofi Agawu, 1-22 (New York: Routledge, 2003), 2.
(14) Ibid., 22.
(15) Sjaak Van Deer Geest and Nimrod K. Asante-Darko, "The
Political Meaning of Highlife Songs in Ghana," African Studies
Review 25 no. 1 (March 1982): 27-35.
(16) John Collins, "The Early History of West African Highlife
Music" Popular Music, 8 no. 3 (October 1989): 222.
(17) Paul Gilroy, The Black Atlantic: Modernity and
Double-Consciousness (New York and London: Verso, 1993), 73.
(18) "Mzbel Sues KNUST 600m," Ghanaweb, accessed February
13, 2015, http://www.ghanaweb.eom/GhanaHomePage/entertainment/artikel.p
ho?ID-98252
(19) "Mzbel: Standing Strong," Modern Ghana, accessed
February 13, 2015, http://www.modernghana.com/music/3393/3/mzbel-standing strong.html; "Mzbel's Attackers escape from police
custody," GhanaWeb, accessed February 13, 2015,
http://www.ghanaweb.eom/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/artikel.p
hp?ID=114962; "Mzbel rape story turns dramatic Laptop Found in
Hairdressing Salon," GhanaWeb, accessed February 13, 2015,
http://www.ghanaweb.eom/GhanallomePage/entertainment/artikel.p
hp?ID=192612; "Goodies Hits back at Mzbel," GhanaWeb, accessed
February 13, 2015,
http://www.glianaweb.eom/GhanaHomePage/entertainment/artikel.p
hp?ID= 192790; "Mzbel was not raped," GhanaWeb, accessed
February 13, 2015,
http://www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArc hive/artikel.p
hp?ID=110552; and "Mzbel Damns Manager," GhanaWeb, accessed
February 13, 2015,
http://www.ghanaweb.eom/GhanaHomePage/entertainment/artikel.p hp?ID
1927S0
(20) "Mzbel Sues KNUST 600m," Ghanaweb, accessed February
13, 2015,
http://www.ghanaweb.eom/GhanaHomePage/entertainment/artikel.p hp?ID
9S252
(21) This part of the song was originally sung in Twi and
translated into English by Hannah Essien of Indiana University.
(22) Audrey Wipper, "African Women, Fashion, and
Scapegoating," Canadian Journal of African Studies 5, no. 2 (1972):
329-330.
(23) Wipper, "African Women, Fashion, and Scapegoating,"
330.
(24) Ibid., 335.
(25) Ibid., 331.
(26) Jean Allman, "Introduction" in Fashioning Africa:
Power and the Politics of Dress (Indiana University Press: 2004), 5.
(27) Ibid., 166.