Industry insider: John Fisher.
Kadlecek, Jim
Title: Vice President of Ticket Sales and Service, Arizona
Diamondbacks
Education: BSBA in sport management, Robert Morris University
Career: Director, Group Sales, Cleveland Cavaliers and Quicken
Loans Arena
Vice President of Ticket Sales and Service, Lake Erie Monsters
(AHL)
Account Executive, Pittsburgh Pirates
Group Sales Account Executive, Tampa Bay Lightning
This interview was conducted by Jim Kadlecek, associate professor
and chair of the Department of Human Performance and Sport Business at
Mount Union College and Vice President for Industry Relations of the
Sport Marketing Association.
Q: Please provide an overview of your responsibilities with the
Arizona Diamondbacks.
Fisher: I am responsible for all ticket sales for the organization,
which includes season ticket sales and service, group sales, suite
sales, and service and ticket operations. We have about 60 total staff
members that are each dedicated to a specific area of our ticket sales
business.
Q: You came to Arizona from the Cleveland Cavs. How has selling the
Diamondbacks differed from selling the Cavs?
Fisher: The basics of selling tickets remains the same regardless
of the team, market or league. It's about establishing strong
relationships and finding the best fit for the customer based on their
needs and that's done through a proactive sales effort by a
well-trained, dedicated group of sales reps that are equipped with all
the necessary resources. Beyond those basics, however, there are
definitely differences. In Cleveland, we had a team with a
well-established history and a fan base that went back 40 years. In
addition, we had a competitive team for my last few seasons there, which
was highlighted by LeBron James, obviously one of the best and most
popular players in the league. The ability to leverage the NBA's
stars is one of the most powerful sales tools for that league's
teams. In Arizona, although the Diamondbacks have had quite a bit of
success on the field, we're a young franchise that has only existed
since 1998 and we are in a transient market so many of the baseball fans
here in Phoenix grew up watching teams like the Cubs, Cardinals, or
Dodgers. It's also a long season with 81 home games and we have
49,000 seats to fill. That's twice the games and twice the capacity
than what I was selling in Cleveland.
Q: You were with the Pirates before joining the Cavs. What changes
do you see with the business side of Major League Baseball since your
time with the Pirates?
Fisher: The business side of baseball has changed quite a bit and
continues to change. Over the past few years, teams have started
increasing the size of their sales and service staffs and have put more
resources toward proactively selling tickets. Not too long ago a sales
and service staff might consist of 12 to 15 staff members, now some
teams have upward of 45 or more. We increased to about 60 staff members
in sales, service, and operations prior to the 2008 season. There is
also far more communication between teams and more idea sharing so we
can all help each other sell tickets.
Q: What have you learned, from a sales standpoint, selling when the
team is struggling (Pirates, Lightning) or the team is successful
(Cavs)?
Fisher: Focusing on the overall game experience is important in
ticket sales because team performance can change rapidly, from year to
year or even week to week or game to game. It's also important to
develop strong relationships with customers and prospects and provide
them with the highest level of service possible. By focusing on what can
be controlled and delivering a high level of value, the impact of team
performance can be slowed during times when team performance is down and
maximized when team performance is up.
Q: Phoenix has been hit extremely hard by the economy. What changes
have you made at the Diamondbacks to address the challenging times?
Fisher: Like most teams, we saw a dramatic decrease in the
corporate spend leading up to the start of the 2009 season and all
indications led us to believe there wasn't going to be much
improvement as we began our 2010 campaign. In response, we turned our
sales staff almost entirely away from all businesses and focused our
attention on selling to individuals. The reps still made contact with
their corporate leads from time to time to maintain those relationships,
but their efforts were put on calling individuals. Buyers are looking
for even more personal attention and personal contact than ever before,
so our phone calls were set up in a way simply to get to know the
customer and then invite them to the ballpark for a special tour of the
facility. During that tour, the sales rep was able to develop a strong
enough relationship where a sale could eventually be made. We also
rallied around this strategy as an organization and got other
departments involved with aggressive data collection initiatives in
order to increase leads for the staff. It's been very successful
for us. More recently, we are seeing companies making purchases over the
past six weeks so it's hopefully a trend that continues.
Q: You came in to help establish a strong sales culture at the
Diamondbacks. What steps were taken to create the culture?
Fisher: The size of the staff was increased by about 35 people and
that brought our total number of staff members to around 60. With this
increase, we needed space for all of our reps so we had an entirely new
office area built out, allowing us to have our entire staff on the same
sales floor. That has helped increase the buzz and energy level when the
reps are all on the phones. We also created dedicated sales and service
teams--season ticket sales, group sales, suite sales, ticket services,
and inside sales--that focus on selling particular areas of our
business. All of our reps can sell full menu, but by having reps focused
and dedicated we are making sure we have year-round coverage in those
areas. We increased our training. Externally we use Charlie Chislaghi
and Dale Carnegie, Inc. Internally we run role-plays multiple times per
week and they are led by our senior level sales staff, which also
provides them with an opportunity for leadership and growth. In
addition, we've added sales bells, sales boards, run contests
constantly and have the reps email their sales and success stories to
the rest of the staff. Having the right culture in order to be a
successful sales staff is a critical element.
Q: In a smaller marketplace that contains three other major league
sports (Suns--NBA, Cardinals--NFL, and Coyotes--NHL), what are you doing
to grow your ticket base?
Fisher: We're working hard to add as much value as possible to
our ticket packages. Whether the package is a one-game family pack or
it's an 81-game season ticket package, buyers are looking for more
value now than ever. We've increased the list of benefits that
season ticket holders receive, providing them with more
behind-the-scenes access and we're including new opportunities for
both season ticket holders and groups by using loaded tickets this
season for the first time. It also goes back to having more personal
interaction with all of our customers and prospects while providing a
high level of service for all of our fans. Our fans have direct access
to contact our President/CEO Derrick Hall, our dedicated service team
for our season ticket holders has been received very well, and the
one-on-one time our sales reps have taken with ticket prospects has
generated some very good results this year. We're holding town hall
meetings at a minimum of once per month and we are using that feedback
to help us make better decisions and put together strategies that better
line-up with what the fans want to see. That will allow us to ultimately
provide a better overall fan experience at the ballpark whether the team
wins or loses.
Q: What changes do you see on the horizon that will impact ticket
sales?
Fisher: I think the increased integration of technology and the
increased presence of the secondary ticket market will be growing
factors for teams moving forward. We've already seen it recently
with the creation of paperless tickets and loaded ticket value. Teams at
the forefront of finding ways to inject the latest technology trends
into ticket benefits and game experiences will quickly separate
themselves from the rest of the pack. Although the secondary ticket
market has always been in existence, it's changing quickly and
growing, especially with its online presence making accessibility for
fans much easier. It becomes a challenge when fans can simply cherry
pick good locations for the best games and it can discourage casual fans
from purchasing season ticket packages. The secondary marketing is not
going anyway so teams need to find a way to embrace it and use it to
create opportunities to grow fans and revenues.
Q: As you reflect on what you have done in Arizona and look to the
future, what thoughts come to mind?
Fisher: Extending our sales and service timeline was an important
decision for us over the past couple of years. We've adopted the
NBA model and it has worked well. Traditionally teams wait until the end
of the season to send renewal invoices and only after the renewal
process has started will teams begin selling new locations, which is
oftentimes not until January. Prior to the 2009 season, we began sending
out renewal invoices and selling specific new sales seat locations in
August. It's allowed us to now have an eight or nine month sales
and renewal opportunity, compared to a window of only three or four
months. It also allows us to fully capitalize on any postseason
appearances or late season runs that get fans excited about the
following season.
I think there is also a strong temptation during tough economic
times like we are currently facing to decrease prices, offer significant
discounts or create special buy-one, get-one season ticket packages. We
have worked hard to avoid moves like this and in fact, had a price
increase in our lowest priced sections this year despite coming off of a
92-loss season. Our research and analysis showed that an increase made
sense and sales in those sections have not been negatively impacted. So
sales have been consistent and revenue has increased. Price slashing is
a slippery slope and can be difficult to recover from.
Q: What recommendations do you have for sport management faculty to
prepare students for professional teams' sales needs?
Fisher: The first step is recognition by faculty of the importance
of ticket sales throughout the sport industry and the number of
opportunities that ticket sales provides students. Many teams now have
more than 20 people in their tickets sales and service departments
compared to considerably smaller numbers of staff members in other areas
of the organization.
The next step is making students aware of the opportunities that
are available through tickets sales, as well as making them aware of how
important ticket sales is for each team. Many students are simply not
aware that ticket sales is a great career path that can be both
lucrative and help put them on a faster track for advancement. Many
students have intentions of getting into marketing or team operations
upon completion of their studies. Opportunities can be much more limited
in those areas.
Finally, it is important to provide the students with proper tools
so they are prepared for a career in ticket sales. While more specific
training will always be provided by teams once hired, an understanding
of the sales process and actual experience selling while still in school
will only increase a student's opportunities in the future.
I recommend that academic programs establish working relationships
with their closest located professional teams. This relationship should
include guest speakers in class, tours of the team's facility and
sales office, and open dialogue between students and the sales
managers/reps. The relationship should also include giving the students
opportunities to actually sell tickets for the team. This also helps the
students create their own relationships and networks within the team and
can be helpful when looking for a full-time job. Through my own
experience, I have seen students who participated in these programs
eventually get fulltime positions with those teams. The school should
also look to incorporate selling tickets to their own sporting events as
additional ways to gain actual selling experience.
Q: What type of projects/involvement have you done/are currently
doing/would be interested in doing with a college sport management
program?
Fisher: I have been involved in two projects that gave students
hands-on experience working with a professional team. While in Cleveland
we had students sell group tickets for the Cavaliers of the NBA.
Students were in direct contact with one group sales rep from the
Cavaliers' staff that was available to answer questions, provide
sales advice, and to process the actual sales that were made by the
students. The students also went through a morning of sales training by
representatives of the team.
While also in Cleveland, we had students do a research project on
the youth hockey market of Northeast Ohio for the organization's
new minor league hockey team, the Lake Erie Monsters of the American
Hockey League. The students were responsible for finding local league
histories, hierarchies of leadership, and decision maker contact
information. Next, they took the information they gathered and provided
their recommendations on the best way for the team to generate tickets
sales revenue from this very critical and important market segment.
Q: If a faculty member wants to do a project with a team, how
should the instructor go about it?
Fisher: The instructor should be in contact with the sales managers
of the teams in the school's market. The instructor's
relationship with the team is critical. It will be important for the
instructor to set up face-to-face meetings of their own with these
individuals to help better understand the overall team's
initiatives, the team's sales and service situation, and for the
team to better understand the instructor's initiatives for the
program.
Q: What opportunities exist with your team for fulltime sport
management students?
Fisher: There are many opportunities within the Diamondbacks
organization, especially through internships and seasonal work. More
specifically, within sales, each year we hire a number of new graduates
to a nine- to 12-month entry-level sales program we call Inside Sales.
Through Inside Sales, graduates learn sports sales from the ground up
and receive coaching on a daily basis. They have similar
responsibilities as the senior level full-time sales staff but with
lower expectations. Many professional teams now have an Inside Sales
department.
This program provides graduates with a fast track to a full-time
position within the organization and provides the organization with a
"farm system" of young, new talent to fill holes when
full-time opportunities become available and to continually push the
full-time staff. If positions are not available, it is very common for
the team's sales managers to help find the top performers full-time
jobs with other teams.
Q: What benefits and frustrations have you experienced in working
with college sport management programs?
Fisher: There are many benefits from the team's point of view.
You get to meet young professionals that will be the next wave of talent
coming into the industry. You get to build relationships with students
that may become good candidates for internships, seasonal jobs, or
Inside Sales. Through a ticket-selling project, the team is able to
generate additional group ticket sales revenue. Also, it is good for
professionals in the industry to be able to give back by sharing their
thoughts and advice with the students.
But there are frustrations as well. Free time in the sport industry
comes at a premium so finding time to speak in classes and providing
advice for students can be challenging. When involved in a class project
the students will often times have many questions and that can take away
from a manager or rep's time to complete their own work tasks. And
no matter how much emphasis is placed on experience and hard work, many
students will not apply themselves and will underachieve.