Dieter Schafer (ed.). Das Mesolithikum-Projekt Ullafelsen (Teil 1). Mensch und Umwelt im Holozan Tirols (Band 1).
Burdukiewicz, Jan Michal
DIETER SCHAFER (ed.). Das Mesolithikum-Projekt Ullafelsen (Teil 1).
Mensch und Umwelt im Holozan Tirols (Band 1). 560 pages, 500 colour and
b&w illustrations, CD. 2011. Innsbruck: Philipp von Zabern;
978-3-8053-4375-6 hardback 85.90 [euro].
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
Mensch und Umwelt im Holozan Tirols (translated into English on the
book cover as 'Man and environment in the Holocene of Tyrol'),
is the first volume of a series edited by Dieter Schafer. It
reports--predominantly in German with English summaries--the results of
Das Mesolithikum-Projekt Ullafelsen ('The Mesolithic Project
Ullafelsen').
An important motivation for the research project was the discovery
of 'Otzi'--the exceptional Copper Age mummy with
well-preserved body, clothing and equipment, who lived and died c. 3300
BC in the Tyrolean Alps. Under the direction of Dieter Schafer of the
University of Innsbruck, Austria, the Mesolithikum-Projekt centred on
the archaeological site of Ullafelsen, located at 1869m asl in the
Fotscher Valley (Stubai Alps, Austria). The site was the focus of an
extensive and interdisciplinary study, including climatology, geology,
geomorphology, glaciology, soil science, petrography, mineralogy and
palaeobotany, conducted by a research team of scientists from Innsbruck
University, as well as specialists from Germany, Italy, Switzerland and
the Philippines.
The results extend our knowledge of the early Holocene in Tyrol and
living conditions in the vicinity of the Alpine treeline. They show how
favourable local conditions enabled regional and transalpine
routes--followed much later by Otzi--to be already in use during the
early Holocene.
The book is divided into 16 chapters of various sizes--from two
pages to over a hundred. A short introduction by Schafer describes the
aims of the project and introduces the research team. Chapter 1, by
Schlosser, presents the climatic and meteorological context: the
Fotscher Valley clearly presented a difficult challenge for Early
Mesolithic people.
In Chapter 2, Gruben & Holdermann analyse the geology,
palaeogeography and morphology of the eastern Alps, considering possible
transalpine trails and access to raw materials. The latter were gathered
from the area between the Rhine Valley in the west and Salzkamergast in
the east. Again, the difficulties of the Alpine environment for the
Mesolithic inhabitants of Ullafelsen are apparent. The following
chapter, also by Holdermann & Gruber, considers the geology and
morphology of the Otztal and Stubai Alps and the potential mobility of
the Mesolithic hunter-gatherers in the Fotscher Valley. They establish
that Mesolithic routes depended on altitude, the orientation of local
mountain ridges, and the presence of glaciers which were different from
the present day.
Following Nittel's chapter on the hydrology and geomorphology
of the Fotscher Valley, Kerschner considers glacier extent during the
Late Glacial in the valley and its surroundings. He suggests the
presence of Mesolithic hunters at Ullafelsen coincides with the eastern
Alpine ice retreat during the early Holocene. Geitner et al. then
present an extensive chapter on soils and stratigraphic finds in the
area of Ullafelsen and their interpretation of the evidence in terms of
wider landscape history. In particular, the field research and
laboratory analyses enabled the recognition of a light-grey layer in an
eluvial soil horizon as an Aeolian sediment which underlay
archaeological finds; radiocarbon dates of charcoal recovered from this
horizon pre-date 9600 BP, originating during the Younger Dryas. In this
way, fixed points have been established for four phases of soil
formation and the chronology of the ice retreat from Ullafelsen dated to
before the Older Dryas.
Kemmer's chapter on the recent vegetation of the Inner
Fotscher Valley, lying between 900m and 3000m asl, notes the vertical
vegetation gradient and the position of the treeline at around
2000-2200m. Oeggl & Schoch identify tree species from charcoal in
the soil samples from the Early Mesolithic site at Ullafelsen. Charcoal
samples from three hearths belong to tree species growing in the region
during the Preboreal period, as well as today.
Long-distance routes across the Alps during the Mesolithic period
are considered by Kompatscher & Kompatscher. The chapter provides an
important analysis of the supply of lithic raw materials and expands on
the 'migration model' of seasonal nomadism with annual
movement cycles in high mountain landscapes. The chapters maps display a
complex network of paths and it is surprising to see the number of
southern--as well as the expected northern--Alpine sources used by
Mesolithic hunter-gatherers.
One of the longest chapters, at over 100 pages, is authored by
Schafer: 'Das Mesolithikum-Projekt Ullafelsen--Landschaftlicher
Rahmen und archaologische Befunde', or 'Landscape framework
and archaeological features'. It reports the archaeological
excavation of an area of 25[m.sup.2] comprising 4 extant hearths and
evidence for a further 10, plus almost 8000 lithic artefacts of alpine
radiolarites, Jurassic hornstone and rock crystal--all mapped
three-dimensionally. The analyses explore the chronological and spatial
relationships in detail, explaining patterning from a behavioural
perspective. Pawlik's substantial chapter--also over 100
pages--details microscopic use-wear analysis of a sample of 252
artefacts. This study establishes that these lithic artefacts were
mostly tools for hunting which were repaired and maintained on the site.
The following four chapters describe various lithic raw materials from
the southern, northern and possibly western Alps, and Bavaria. The final
chapter, by Schafer, summarises the advances in knowledge achieved by
the Mesolithikum-Projekt.
This volume--carefully edited and beautifully illustrated--presents
a wealth of new data about Early Mesolithic hunter-gatherers living in
high mountain environments. Careful research in this difficult landscape
has documented a valuable stratigraphic record of meaningfully patterned
early Holocene artefacts. Abundant raw lithic materials at Ullafelsen
confirm that transalpine paths were already in use several thousand
years before 'Otzi'. In this way, we can perhaps expect that
melting Alpine glaciers will expose more--and earlier--human bodies,
clothing and otherwise perishable materials in this 'natural
freezer'.
JAN MICHAL BURDUKIEWICZ
Institute of Archaeology, University of Wroclaw, Poland
(Email: jan.burdukiewicz@archeo.uni.wroc.pl)