C.F.W. Higham & A. Kijngam (ed.). The origins of the civilization of Angkor, volume 3. The excavations of Ban Non Wat: introduction.
Moore, Elizabeth
C.F.W. HIGHAM & A. KIJNGAM (ed.). The origins of the
civilization of Angkor, volume 3. The excavations of Ban Non Wat:
introduction, xvi+264 pages, 322 colour & b&w illustrations, 25
tables. 2009. Bangkok: Thai Fine Arts Department; 978-974-417-997-5
hardback 50 [pounds sterling] (available through Oxbow).
[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]
This volume is the third report on the on-going research project
'The Origins of the Civilization of Angkor'. The first volume
on the Bronze Age mound of Ban Lum Khao in 2005 was followed in 2007
with one on Noen U-Loke and Non Muang Kao, two Bronze Age to Iron Age
moated settlements nearby. The present volume on Ban Non Wat, located a
few kilometres east of Noen U-Loke, illustrates the setting and
relationships between settlement mounds in the region, its analysis
enabled by the project's extensive excavations. The Ban Non Wat
report continues the clear presentation of data seen in the first two
books of the series. It is organised into eleven chapters on
stratigraphy, chronology, the excavation layers and square X (4x4m) on
the southern periphery of the mound and square Y (8x4m) near the centre,
the burials, the material culture and a summary. The cultural sequence
is divided into 12 phases, each with distinct mortuary and occupational
artefacts and more than 60 radiocarbon dates. The data is summarised in
a compilation for Ban Non Wat, Ban Lum Khao and Noen U-Loke, with flexed
burials (1750-1050 cal BC), Neolithic 1-2 (1650-1050 cal BC), Bronze 1-5
(1050-420 cal BC), Iron 1-4 (420 cal BC-500 cal AD) and Early Historic
(AD 500 onwards) cultural periods (p. 25). Each chapter contains tables,
plans and photographs of pits and finds followed by a concise
bibliography and useful index.
The Ban Non Wat results have accumulated over seven seasons of
excavations from 2002 to 2007 uncovering a total of 906[m.sup.2] on
three different parts of the site. From approximately 3000[m.sup.2] of
excavated material, 635 human burials and over 20 000 artefacts, the
authors provide summary charts and selected objects in a stratigraphic
sequence. This is followed by descriptions of the mortuary custom and
the stone, bronze, iron, bi-metallic, ceramic and other clay objects
such as pellets, counters and rollers, marble, shell and tektites. In a
short entry on the tektites W.E. Boyd suggests that these glassy rocks,
found in the Quaternary sands of the Lower Khorat Plateau and which
occurred throughout the Ban Non Wat sequence in stratigraphic clusters,
may have been used in times of social and/or environmental stress
associated with changing environmental conditions (p. 249). This detail
exemplifies the careful formulation of hypotheses in this volume, in
this instance noting that they will appear in a later volume of the Ban
Non Wat monograph series. It also illustrates attention given to
environmental aspects throughout the 'Origins of Angkor'
programme.
Since its inception in 1992, the programme has provided an
extraordinary dataset for understanding the prehistory of the upper Mun
Valley in the northwestern part of the Khorat Plateau of Northeast
Thailand some 250km north-west of Angkor. The many Khmer temples of the
seventh to thirteenth century have long prompted hypotheses on the role
of inland 'Chenla' (the putative name of the Khorat Plateau in
the later part of the first millennium AD) in the consolidation of
Angkor. While curvilinear earthworks encircle prehistoric mounds around
Angkor, the absence of Mun Valley data for cultural changes of the
Neolithic, Bronze and Iron Ages in the two thousand years before the
transition to the state of Angkor has stymied efforts to extend the
shared cultural heritage of Angkor and the Khorat Plateau back to
prehistoric times. This gap is now being filled with the continuing
excavation and analysis of sites under 'The Origins of the
Civilization of Angkor' project. This does not imply a bias
affecting the data presented but brings a focus to the selective
presentation of material from the vast body of objects and analyses
carried out. Where conclusions cannot yet be formulated, such as the
reasons for fewer grave goods with few bronze objects in Bronze Age 4
burials, the observation is backed empirically by the radiocarbon dates
rather than speculation on reasons for changes from earlier burial
layers (p. 173). However, when the data is summarised in the last
chapter, the rich natural resources are neatly paired with the enormous
extent of the excavations--a sample of unprecedented scale--to highlight
the significance of the site and the primacy of the conclusions drawn
from the project's work. To take one example, excavation was
continued below a sterile substrate to reveal further material such as a
deposit of bivalve shells on the edge of square E8 that yielded a
radiocarbon date of 15 000 cal BC which, it is plausibly claimed, is
possibly the earliest evidence of Pleistocene hunter-gatherers on the
Khorat Plateau (p. 251). Concerning the differential wealth found in the
early Bronze Age burials, a strong case is made for hierarchy rather
than the heterarchy proposed by others working elsewhere on the plateau.
Finally, when considering the rich Iron Age burials, the abundance of
iron weapons and tools used by a rising population well able to exploit
local resources such as salt, and the engineering of water resources
seen in the moats and banks encircling the site, all come together to
support the project's underlying premise: that the Khorat Plateau
may have been pre-eminent in the transition to state at Angkor.
ELIZABETH MOORE
School of Oriental and African Studies, London, UK
(Email: em4@soas.ac.uk)