In Memoriam: remembering Andre Gunder Frank (February 24, 1929, to April 23, 2005).
Shank, Gregory
THIS SPRING, SOCIAL JUSTICE LOST A FRIEND VALUED CONTRIBUTOR WITH
THE passing of Andre Gunder Frank. Gunder s sons, Paul and Miguel, said
that despite the pain and exhaustion associated with the cancer that was
killing him, Gunder continued to write and conduct research until two
weeks before the April lights finally went out for him in Luxembourg.
The following pages offer a somewhat personal look at Gunder and
his impact on friends and colleagues, since the mountain of commentaries
that filled the press and the Internet upon his death took adequate
measure of his massive intellectual contributions (see, especially, the
essays by Samir Amin, Miguel A. Bernal, Theotonio Dos Santos, Barry K.
Gill, Robinson Rojas, and Arno Tausch at www.
rrojasdatabank.org/agfobit3.htm). Jeff Sommers' piece in this issue
intermingles Gunder's personal biography with his intellectual
history in an attempt to capture the contrarian nature of the man who
mentored and befriended him. Gunder could be ornery and sweet,
fatalistic yet hopeful that sensible arguments might eventually make a
difference, penetratingly visionary and riveted to the mundane
intricacies of international law, admired and despised. Rod Bush's
essay explores Gunder's influence on key thinkers in the Black
Liberation and Pan Africanist movements. In 1960, Gunder visited Ghana
and Guinea in Africa. Rod recalls Gunder's humility, attentiveness
as a listener, and unromantic pessimism regarding the near-term
prospects of social movements seeking to change current global economic
and political arrangements.
Many members of the Social Justice board had close ties with the
man we called Gunder, but whose Latin American friends knew him as
Andres. He humored me as a biographer, due to review essays I had
written on his books in the 1980s, and as part of the stable of editors
in his gargantuan e-mail address book. That group will appreciate the
challenge of reigning in Gunder's penchant for word play and
convoluted sentence structures. When I first met Gunder, he said he was
weary of his itinerant existence and would love to settle among friends.
Did the journal perhaps need a typesetter? Now, anyone who has seen his
typing knows what a disaster that would have been--and how much poorer
the world would have been without his prodigious books, articles, and
interventions.
During the 25 years that I knew Gunder, our paths crossed in the
course of his intense conference circuit and at points of personal
difficulty for him. His young sons and wife, Marta Fuentes Frank,
visited us in San Francisco. Later, Marta, Gunder, and I found ourselves
in post-glasnost-era Moscow, where he eviscerated the arguments of
apparachnik intellectuals--deservedly so--for abstractly promoting the
civilizational role of the free market, while the streets were rife with
rumors of an impending old-guard coup and signs were evident that the
Soviet Union itself might be unraveling. Gunder had me tag along to
discuss these issues as we walked the back streets of the city with a
Moscow specialist in the global economy who Gunder thought deserved a
wider hearing in the West. The common language was Italian, a language
with which Gunder had great facility due to a Swiss education that also
exposed him to French and German. He had taken refuge there at the age
of four when he escaped Berlin, his birthplace and the capital of
Hitler's Germany, along with his father, a pacifist novelist, and
Jewish mother, whom Gunder loved intensely throughout his life. He would
only return to Germany 40 years later. But he was well known there. When
I lectured at East Berlin's Humboldt University, students eagerly
discussed his prophetic tract calling for denuclearization and an
East-West rapprochement in Europe, The European Challenge: From Atlantic
Alliance to Pan-European Entente for Peace and Jobs (1984), as well as
his provocative critique of Soviet policy, "Long Live
Transideological Enterprise!"
Gunder stayed with me briefly after Marta's death, but the
last time he appeared at my door with suitcase in hand seemed to be the
best and the worst of times for him. His latest book, ReOrient (1998),
had received critical acclaim (winning the PEWS Book Award of the
American Sociological Association, Political Economy of the World
Systems section, and later the World History Association 1999 Book
Prize), and yet he had just separated from his wife and was again
homeless and jobless. He was understandably morose when we went to grab
a meal at the Punjab restaurant, a Mission District greasy spoon. But
the waitress, who spoke very little English, would have nothing of it:
"Why you so grumpy, man?" He grinned, and thereafter became a
regular fixture there, evoking smiles and hellos from the staff each
time he lumbered in. I was impressed with how easily this world-famous
man, whose father's circle included Thomas Mann and Greta Garbo,
whom Salvador Allende met at the airport and Che Guevara had asked for
help in transforming Cuba's dependent economy, fit into this modest
setting.
After Gunder landed on his feet in Florida, I grew accustomed to
receiving his regular missives and articles. He was especially
productive in times of crisis: the U.S. interventions in Kosovo and the
Middle East, the Republican electoral coup in 2000, whose dire
consequences for democracy Gunder decried, and finally his writings on
the reemergence of China in the world-economy and the folly of U.S.
economic policy under the George W. Bush administration (published by
the Asia Times in January 2005 under the title "The Naked
Hegemon"). I will miss him, and the world has lost a voice that
consistently challenged injustice and promoted the interests of the
wretched of the earth.
GRECORY SHANK is a member of the Social Justice Editorial Board;
e-mail: socialjust@aol.com.