Introduction.
Moore, Deborah Dash ; Rosengarten Dale
On June 5, 2006, more than a hundred scholars arrived in
Charleston, South Carolina, for the seventh Biennial Scholars'
Conference on American Jewish History, sponsored by the American Jewish
Historical Society, the American Jewish Archives, and the College of
Charleston. Focused on the theme of regionalism in American Jewish life,
the gathering drew individuals from various disciplines--architectural
historians and literary critics, graduate students completing their
doctorates and senior scholars in American history, newcomers to the
study of American Jews and veterans of the field. The current issue of
American Jewish History gives readers a chance to experience this
diversity, as well as the range and scope of the conference.
In editing the first issue of the journal drawn from the
proceedings of a biennial scholars' conference, we have been
mindful of both the need to provide continuity and our desire to
innovate. Thus we have encouraged contributors to expand on the papers
they presented and to include photographs and drawings to illustrate and
extend the reach of their articles. We also have transcribed the opening
remarks in a roundtable discussion on the significance of place in
American and American Jewish history, albeit recognizing that the
written word cannot fully capture the liveliness of the face-to-face
encounter.
The conference presentations by Adam Mendelsohn and Daniel
Ackermann constituted a single session entitled "Languages and
Landscapes." In their essays, both scholars emphasize how connected
Jews were across the Atlantic and throughout the English-speaking world.
Mendelsohn demonstrates the impact of "twin revolutions" in
transportation and communication that permitted, indeed propelled, a
transnational flow of goods, ideas, and preachers. He argues for the
power of English-language publications to annihilate time and space and
for renewed attention to their significance. Ackermann shows how, in the
architecture of their 1794 synagogue, Jews in Charleston, South
Carolina, negotiated a shrinking divide between Sephardim and
Ashkenazim, while at the same time accommodating and in some ways
mimicking their non-Jewish neighbors. The spire that marked Kahal Kadosh
Beth Elohim's position on the skyline was visible but not
overreaching, symbolizing the congregation's "aspirations to
full integration into the city's civic and religious life."
Architecture also serves as metaphor in Joseph Butwin's
"Tevye on King Street." The essay breaks new ground in several
ways. It focuses not merely on place in terms of cities and their social
spaces, but also on street level interactions. It grounds its
observations in a blend of memoir, biography, and literary criticism, a
new form of interpretive filiopietistic writing. In a nuanced reading of
influences, Butwin suggests how Charlestonians' preoccupation with
creating a usable past shaped a comparable Jewish undertaking. Sholem
Aleichem's fictional shtetl may have its roots as much in South
Carolina as in Eastern Europe. The new world imagines the old one not
only in translation but also in its own image.
"Whistling 'Dixie' while Humming
'HaTikvah'" by Hollace Weiner moves us from the
southeastern seaboard to Fort Worth, Texas. The article is "a tale
of two congregations," dissecting the differences between a Reform
temple and an Orthodox shul. The rediscovery and painstaking translation
of a minute book, dating from 1898 to 1905 and containing nearly two
hundred pages of notes in Yiddish, has made possible the restoration of
Ahavath Sholom to its rightful place in the historical pantheon. Weiner
explores multiple dimensions of accommodation among congregants even as
they remain steadfast in their attachment to Judaism.
The concluding tribute to Gerald Sorin on the occasion of his
receiving the Lee Max Friedman medal celebrates his pioneering and
influential career. Since Sorin's "cross-over" in the
1970s from the field of American history to Jewish studies, he has
illuminated the struggles of Jewish workers and radicals, youth and
immigrants, and has explored the dynamic relationship between Jewish
religious culture and secular politics in lucid and accessible prose
that narrows the gap between specialist and generalist.
We hope our effort to translate three days of conference into a
single volume captures a taste of what participants enjoyed. We cannot
bring you the sunshine and southern hospitality, the Creole cooking, the
distinctive streets, or the moss-draped live oaks, nor can we convey the
fellowship and friendship. While we have had to exclude much from the
fine conference, we can provide a sampling of the intellectual exchange,
that which is so fleeting yet worthy of preservation.
Deborah Dash Moore and Dale Rosengarten, guest editors