The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Anglo-Saxon England.
Reese, Alan W.
The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Anglo-Saxon England, edited by
Michael Lapidge, John Blair, Simon Keynes, and Donald Scragg. Oxford,
England, Blackwell Publishers, 1999. xviii, 537 pp. $99.95 U.S. (cloth).
Blackwell Publishers have filled an important gap in the reference
section with this first major reference work solely devoted to the
interdisciplinary study of Anglo-Saxon England from circa 450 to 1066.
The editors, all senior scholars at major British universities, have
consolidated the voluminous findings of the past generation of
Anglo-Saxon scholars represented by the 150 contributors to this volume.
Of special interest is the careful inclusion of recent findings in
archaeology, architectural history, palaeography, codicology, and
numismatics which are increasingly vital complements to the more
traditional literary and historical approaches to this period. The book
is richly illustrated by twenty-four black and white plates, twelve
maps, and thirty-one figures (line-drawings). Other useful features
include a table "Rulers of the English circa 450-1066," an
"Index of Contributors,"(listed with the titles of their
respective articles) followed by a "Classified Index of
Head-Words" (with cross-references).
The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Anglo-Saxon England should be
compared to another excellent recent publication: Medieval England: An
Encyclopedia, edited by Paul E. Szarbachm, M. Teresa Tavormina, and Joel
T. Rosenthal (New York and London, Garland Publishing, 1998). Unlike The
Blackwell Encyclopedia of Anglo-Saxon England, this volume covers the
entire medieval period and is edited by American scholars. Both volumes
provide fairly detailed articles with up-to-date bibliographies for each
article. On comparing the two reference books one finds that the
different interests and approaches of the contributors are as evident in
the article bibliographies as in the articles themselves. In at least
one instance, though, the two volumes provide not merely complementary
reformation but contradictory information. In the article on "Bede
in the Blackwell Encyclopedia" one reads: "At the canonical
ages Bede was ordained deacon and then priest"(p. 57). Turning to
the Garland volume, see under, "Bede the Venerable (circa
673-735)" one reads: "Ordained a deacon at the age of nineteen
(six years before the usual canonical age), Bede then proceeded to the
priesthood at age thirty (703)" (p. 115). The Garland article is in
this instance much more detailed and, on examination of the ancient
canons, quite correct in noting that Bede was not ordained deacon at the
canonical age. As one would expect, the Blackwell Encyclopedia of
Anglo-Saxon England provides enough articles on the more recondite
aspects of Anglo-Saxon England not found in the Garland publication (for
example, the article on "bone working" and the article
"Aelfwine, Prayerbook of") to warrant its purchase by
libraries as a specialized reference for the Anglo-Saxon period.
This book should be recommended, together with Medieval England: An
Encyclopedia, to students and scholars at all levels.
Alan W. Reese
University of Saskatchewan