Landmarks.
Talley-Jones, Kathy
"Don't step there!" My friend Harrison has a
seven-year-old's keen interest in gross things, and I look on the
sidewalk for chewing gum, dead worms, or worst of all, dog poop.
There's nothing there.
"I don't see anything."
"Cooties," he says. "Taylor threw up there."
"When did he throw up there?" I ask, thinking it might
have been that morning. But there aren't any stains on the
sidewalk.
"She threw up there the day after Halloween," Harrison
gives me the details. It's New Year's, and Taylor's
overindulgence was A Long Time Ago by seven-year-old standards, but to
Harrison it's still vivid. He points out other landmarks: just
where he stood when he saw the bicycle his father brought home for
Christmas. A spot where a storm blew down a squirrel's nest. Behind
his house where men blew up a big boulder in what had once been a field
so they could squeeze in four more houses.
Harrison's personal cognitive map of his neighborhood
doesn't include local historical landmarks; he's just reaching
the developmental stage where he's grasping the idea of History.
When he gets to third grade, however, he will start to study what he has
already experienced: the continuity and change of the cultural and
physical landscape of California. He'll learn more about his own
community of Rocklin, Placer County, and the greater Sacramento area.
The California state history and social science standards determine
that:
"Students in grade three learn more about our connections to
the past and the ways in which particularly local, but also regional and
national, government and traditions have developed and left their marks
on current society, providing common memories. Emphasis is on the
physical and cultural landscape of California, including the study of
American Indians, the subsequent arrival of immigrants, and the impact
they have had in forming the character of our contemporary
society."
Many California counties have excellent online resources developed
in conjunction with the California Department of Education. For example,
Butte County offers course models for California history and social
science. A contribution by teachers in Los Angeles leads third graders
through an exploration of their local surroundings that includes the way
soil, water, and landforms have affected their city's history.
Suggestions for readings, including a resource list of atlases suitable
for third-graders, are included as well as class activities that involve
creating a map that shows local landforms and landmarks.
Historic Spots in California, reviewed in this issue of California
History, provides a guide to and description of statewide sites useful
for such a student project and gives the lie to classic student
complaints that "nothing ever happened here."
WHY LANDMARKS?
What is a landmark and why do we consider certain places to be more
important than others? Why spend time and money to protect them? These
are questions that members of the cultural community asked ten years ago
in the wake of the Los Angeles riots of 1992 when vast blocks of the
city went up in flames. Asked Dr. Mahasti Afshar of the Getty
Conservation Institute, "What is the rationale for conservation in
a world driven by change, by an astronomical energy to produce, consume,
and develop, then destroy the old to make room for the new? What is the
value of place and permanence to an increasingly mobile citizenry with
mixed ethnic and cultural identities and cross-historical memories? And
how should it manage change--preserving the past while helping to create
the future?"
The Getty Conservation Institute developed "Teaching
Landmarks," a curriculum unit for middle school that led students
to identify their own landmarks and those of others in their community,
to learn why landmarks are significant, identify how landmarks define
the identity of groups, communities, cities, and nations, and document
landmarks through photography, memoirs, painting, and other media.
The curriculum's underlying premise is that if students come
face-to-face with their landmarks and if they see the built environment
as an extension of their cultural history and its outstanding features
as an embodiment of their personal and social identities, they will
develop a sense of caring for it. These feelings, in turn, will help
prevent landmarks from being neglected or abused.
As he explores local history, my young friend Harrison will find
that his community is especially rich in Gold Rush landmarks, which has
left its legacy in the county's name: Placer County. Harrison, who
is very interested in trains, may also find himself intrigued by the
town of Rocklin's role as a major terminal for the Central Pacific
Railroad in 1864.
Inspired by Ansel Adams's photograph of Fort Ross (see Adam
Arenson, "Ansel Adams's Eucalyptus, Fort Ross," pages
10-25), Harrison and I take a camera and see if we can find the
terminal. But nothing remains, and the site is as intangible as the spot
where Taylor lost her Halloween candy. We'll have to go to nearby
Roseville if we want landmarks celebrating the construction of the
transcontinental railroad. Meanwhile we take a few pictures of a
historical marker and look for ice cream.
"Teaching California" is a column intended to provide
resources to teachers, parents, and students for integrating the study
of California and its peoples for students in elementary, middle, and
high school. California History welcomes feedback about this column and
encourages teachers, students, and cultural organizations to share their
strategies for teaching California history by contacting Kathy
Talley-Jones at ktalley@lmu.edu.
RESOURCES
California Department of Education. California: Statehood and
Beyond, Recommended Resources for Kindergarten through Twelfth Grade.
http://www. cde.ca.gov/ci/cr/lb/documents/statehoodandbeyond.pdf An
addendum created in 2002 http://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/cr/lb/
documents/sthdbynd.pdf
Center for History-Social Science Education. California State
University, Dominguez Hills, "Exploring the Local Landscape,"
http://www.history.ctaponline.org/center/hsscm /index. cfm?Page_Key=1149
Fort Ross State Historic Park: Classroom and Home Curriculum.
http://www.mcn. org/1/rrparks/fortross/
Getty Conservation Institute. Picture LA: Landmarks of a New
Generation. Los Angeles: Getty Conservation Institute, 1994. (Also.
Picture Cape Town, Picture Mumbai, Picture Mexico City.)
Getty Conservation Institute, "Teaching Landmarks."
http://www.getty.edu/artsednet/resources/Landmarks/index.html
Kyle, Douglas E. Historic Spots in California (Stanford: Stanford
University Press. 2002).
Local History Resources Online, Suitable for Third Graders
http://score.rims.k12. ca.us/cgibin/DB_Search/db_search.cgi?s
etup_file=resource3_db.setup.cgi[??]include
=true[??]grade3=3_3c[??]submit_search=Sub mit+ These+Search+Parameters
Placer County History and Social Science standards
http://www.placercoe.k12. ca.us/ archived/pcoe/departments/curriculum/st
andards/hss_3nd. PDF
San Bernardino County Schools, Connecting California's
Classrooms to the World http://score.rims.k12ca.us/ index.html