Elitism for sale: promoting the elite school online in the competitive educational marketplace.
Drew, Christopher
Abstract
Australia's neoliberal education agenda drives a competitive
market climate where schools compete for potential clientele. In this
climate, school impression management and self-promotion has become an
important factor in maintaining a financially viable school. Schools
produce image management texts including school prospectuses, newspapers
advertisements, and school websites. Examining fifteen elite school
websites from New South Wales Australia, this paper argues that the
websites construct elite ideological discourses in order to position
themselves as desirable within the neoliberal education context. The
placement of promotional images and hyperlinks in salient places on the
websites reveals the importance of self-promotion and the production of
images of elitism in the marketised education climate. The school
websites examined are found to have multiple animated and interactive
functions that are used in the promotion of the schools as elite.
Keywords
Educational marketing, websites, school choice, semiotics,
competition, private schools
Introduction
Australia's schooling sector has been subjected to
marketisation and privatisation under neoliberal rationalities advocated
by successive Australian governments over the past three decades
(Barcan, 2010; Youdell, 2004). Under the neoliberal agenda, the private
education sector has claimed a significantly greater market share
(Barcan, 2010), while the public sector has been forced to compete
against the private sector for potential clients. This climate has
precipitated the need for schools to promote themselves to achieve a
slice of the market share and remain viable. In order to attract
clientele, schools are increasingly producing costly promotional texts
such as prospectuses, newspaper advertisements and television
advertisements (Gottschall, Wardman, Edgeworth, Hutchesson, &
Saltmarsh, 2010; Meadmore & Meadmore, 2004; Mills, 2004; Symes,
1998; Wardman, Hutchesson, Gottschall, Drew, & Saltmarsh, 2010).
This paper examines elite boarding school websites as promotional texts,
and argues that the semiotic design functions of the websites are
influenced by the marketised neoliberal context in which they are
produced. The marketisation agenda, it is argued, encourages image
management and is implicated in the promotion of elitism and
exclusivity.
Academic interest in school promotions has to date focussed on
glossy print prospectuses developed by elite private schools (Gottschall
et al., 2010; Meadmore & Meadmore, 2004; Saltmarsh, 2007; Symes,
1998; Wardman et al., 2010). This academic interest was instigated by
Symes, whose keystone 1998 article Education for Sale in the Australian
Journal of Education argues that school prospectuses are artefacts
necessary in the post-privatisation educational climate if schools wish
to compete in the education market. Since Symes' (1998) article, a
small but growing number of academics have produced literature analysing
the ideological rhetoric in print prospectuses, which is used to attain
market share. In a number of the extant studies, fleeting observations
have been made about the digitalisation of school advertising (Symes,
1998; Wardman et al., 2010). Symes, for example, explains websites as
"buttoned-up prospectuses" (1998, p. 141), implying that
websites mirror the promotional capabilities of their print
counterparts. While the description of school websites as buttoned-up
prospectuses may have been true at the time, in the years since
Symes' influential study, broadband and the increased capacity of
online bandwidth has vastly expanded the potential of the internet
(Cranny-Francis, 2005), so that school websites are not merely
online--or "buttoned-up"--prospectuses but have come to be
both promotional and administrative hubs for school communities.
Websites today have interactive and multimedia capabilities that surpass
the visual and written semiotic capacities of their print prospectus
counterparts. The internet domain has opened up new semiotic
means--motive and sonic--for school advertisers to attract potential
clientele. School websites are interactional domains through which
communication can take place between schools and their communities.
Websites can variously promote the school to potential clientele,
provide newsletters for parents of current students and encourage former
students ("old boys" and "old girls") to donate
money.
The paper begins by outlining the trends in the literature on
school promotional products. School promotions are explained here as
products of the neoliberal era of school marketisation and
privatisation. It then explains the study from which the data emerges,
and includes a discussion of the selection of a corpus of fifteen elite
school websites and a discussion of the social semiotic methods used for
analysis. The functions of the elite school websites are then examined.
I outline the ways schools can use animation, sound and movies on their
websites in order to promote their elite credentials--a significant
affordance available on the digital medium that was not available on
print prospectuses.
School marketisation: neoliberalism and the promotion of the elite
school ethos
Contemporary educational discourse in Australia is primarily
dictated by a neoliberal economic agenda predicated on competition,
consumerism and individualism within an open marketplace. Neoliberalism
has emerged at different points in time in different societies and has
taken on its own characteristics within specific assemblages of power
(Davies & Bansel, 2007; Ong, 2006). In advanced liberal societies
such as Australia, which are characterised by rhetoric of individual
freedom and the prominence of the free market (Rose, 1999),
neoliberalism functions in the subjectification of the individual as a
consumer citizen whose social role is to serve the market as an
economically justifiable subject (Apple, 2006). The neoliberal doctrine
assumes that the free market "will distribute resources efficiently
and fairly according to effort" (Apple, 2005, p. 276). In this
context, privatisation of capital and dilution of governmental market
intervention is embraced, allowing market forces to dictate terms of
trade (Stromquist, 2002). In Australia, neoliberalism emerged in the
1970s and 80s through governmental subsidisation of private provision of
services (Davies & Bansel, 2007). Perhaps representative of the
aggressiveness of neoliberal policies specifically in Australia, the
1990s saw ongoing governmental financial sponsorship of the growing
private school sector to encourage parents, as choice-makers, to make
the move to private schooling (Barcan, 2010; Davies & Bansel, 2007).
The public provision of free education has consequently been steadily
dismantled and public education has been "reconstituted under
neo-liberalism as part of the market" (Davies & Bansel, 2007,
p. 254). This has precipitated the growth of the Australian private
schooling sector while leaving public education exposed to competition
from private schools (Barcan, 2010).
The marketisation agenda provides the conditions for discourses of
wealth and elitism to flourish (Gottschall et al., 2010; Saltmarsh,
2007). Social democratic philosophies of education as a free and
accessible service used for the good of the collective public,
regardless of wealth or social standing, are undermined in such a
free-market climate (Barcan, 2010; Campbell, 2007). Wealthy citizens are
rewarded for their wealth by being able to purchase exclusive
"elite" education that carries with it social and cultural
capital (Bourdieu, 1997). Those citizens who cannot afford elite
schooling are restricted in the ability to exercise choice within the
education market, and are denied access to schools at the elite end of
the private spectrum that carry with them the symbols of exclusivity and
privilege.
Elite private schools constitute "a small subset of nonpublic
schools" (Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2009) that are distinctive from
both government schools and middle-class private schools. The
characteristics of elite private schools that demarcate them as
"elite" are perhaps most effectively outlined by
Gaztambide-Fernandez (2009) who provides a set of five markers of
elitism that, while not all necessarily present in all elite schools,
are generally used to distinguish elite schools as elite. The
identification of elite schools as private, he argues, is one
constituent determinant of elitism inasmuch as it affords the schools
the capacity to exclude undesirable clientele. Sophistication of
curriculum, similarly, can position schools as elite. This can typically
take the form of extracurricular activities culturally aligned with
elite education such as rowing and rugby (Light & Kirk, 2001).
Third, the schools' historical standings serve as particularly
important markers of elitism, whereby their longevity functions as a
signifier of generational cultural capital that mainstream public and
private schools can often not match. This demarcation is particularly
pertinent given the rapid growth of the Australian private schooling
sector since the 1970s, which came as a result of neoliberal
rationalities in education policy making (Barcan, 2010). The most elite
of private schools can use longevity beyond this date as a selling point
of institutional lineage available to only a small club of private
schools. Fourth, geographical elitism--promoting architecture and vast
grounds--further provides a signifier of wealth exceeding the average
private or public school (Gottschall et al., 2010; Symes, 1998). Lastly,
the ability to boast influential alumni and famous clientele can
position schools as above the fray of the average school and thus elite
(Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2009).
Since the exposure of the education sector to market forces and
subsequent competition between schools for potential clients (Apple,
2006; Barcan, 2010), schools from public, private and elite education
sectors have increasingly used aesthetic symbolism to promote their
ideological narratives to attract potential clientele (Gottschall et
al., 2010; Meadmore & Meadmore, 2004; Mills, 2004; Saltmarsh, 2007;
Symes, 1998; Wardman et al., 2010). Studies have emerged which primarily
examine elite school print prospectuses for the ways they construct
ideological discourses of social class, gender and exclusivity in order
to position themselves as desirable within the marketised climate.
Notably, Symes (1998) argues that the production of print prospectuses
by schools has been increasingly necessary as a result of the neoliberal
restructuring of education discourses. Educational artefacts, Symes
argues, can construct an elite aesthetic for schools attempting to
position themselves as desirable for potential clientele.
Symes' study was a keystone text that led the way for
subsequent studies to examine how schools attempt to position themselves
as elite in print prospectuses, and, how schools' representation
practices are implicated in the (re)construction of discourses about the
ideal elite school subject (Gottschall et al., 2010; Meadmore &
Meadmore, 2004; Saltmarsh, 2007; Wardman et al., 2010). School
prospectuses can develop schools' credentials as elite
institutions, positioning attendance at the schools as a symbol of
cultural capital (Saltmarsh, 2007). These texts can similarly position
the schools as desirable for the development of moral and conservative
standing within societies (Gottschall et ah, 2010; Meadmore &
McWilliam, 2001; Saltmarsh, 2007; Wardman et al., 2010). Particularly,
scholars have identified how print prospectuses can position schools as
institutions that regulate students' gender identities in order to
raise children with desirably heteronormative masculine (Gottschall et
al., 2010) and feminine (Wardman et al., 2010) subjectivities. These
image management strategies, while used to position the schools as
desirable institutions, simultaneously reproduce images of elite private
schooling as a superior model of education, privileging exclusivity and
gender norms as images of educational success (Gottschall et al., 2010;
Saltmarsh, 2007; Wardman et al., 2010). Therein, the image management
practices of elite schools actively work to shape discourses of
educational "excellence" within the neoliberal context.
The study
Examining fifteen elite boarding school websites, which were
analysed over a 3-month period in 2012, this paper considers how the
websites produce elitism in order to attract potential clientele. The
websites were selected through criterion sampling, whereby a criterion
for the selection of data is designated at the beginning of the study
(Gall, Gall, & Borg, 2007). With a focus on the makeup of schools in
the specifically Australian neoliberal context, the criterion for data
selection was: schools from New South Wales, Australia, which are
private boarding schools, which run websites. Private boarding schools
were selected because they are considered to be at the forefront of the
marketisation agenda (Campbell, 2007; Gottschall et al., 2010). Boarding
schools that are elite historically "represent clear examples of
the 'ideal type' of [elite] school"
(Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2009, p. 1096) as they represent a more
concentrated elite lifestyle context. Private boarding schools in
Australia are run by non-government bodies that manage the schools with
financial sustainability in mind (Campbell, 2007). They work to attract
clientele through the selling of their educational value to potential
clients, and are thus representative of schools at the forefront of
neoliberal rationalities. The schools selected collectively compete for
clientele from across the state of New South Wales, the nation and,
increasingly, the world (Campbell, 2007). These clientele include rural
families (Welch, 2007), wealthy Australian families and wealthy
international families. A list of private schools was taken from the New
South Wales Board of Studies website (NSW Board of Studies, 2012), from
which a shortlist of boarding schools was taken. Online search engines
were used to find the schools' websites. Fifteen school websites
were located for the analysis. An alphabetic system to describe school
names--School A through School O has been developed in no particular
order to de-identify the schools discussed in the study.
Social semiotic analysis was used to glean information from the
websites about their functions and designs. A semiotic analysis involves
the analysis of the signifying practices of a text in order to develop
an understanding of the meaning being conveyed (Kress & van Leeuwen,
2006). The semiotic approach employed in this paper draws on the
"social" semiotic method of analysis of multimodal texts
informed by Kress and van Leeuwen (2006) and Cranny-Francis (2005).
Social semiotics (Hodge & Kress, 1988) differs from the semiotics of
early structuralist semioticians by examining the ways semiotic signs
are situated within specific contexts that inform the text. As Symes
argues, "mainstream semiotics, particularly in its Saussurean
incarnations, had tended to be context-devoid" (1998, p. 135). In
what Symes calls "the socialisation of semiotics" (1998, p.
135), semioticians in the late 1980s and 1990s began to consider context
as an important factor in the creation of meaning. Accordingly, a social
semiotic methodology acknowledges that textual signs must be considered
within a specific context. The signifiers must be considered in relation
to the cultural (Hodge & Kress, 1988) and intertextual
(Cranny-Francis, 2005) inferences that can inform the reading of the
text.
In this study, the political climate of marketisation, image
management and consumerism--broadly under the banner of neoliberal
economics (Apple, 2006)--forms a significant part of the context with
which the websites are viewed. The images, text and hyperlinks placed on
the websites, and their location on the pages, can reveal the ways the
schools are situated within a political rationality that sets the
schools' priorities and constructs a hierarchy of political values.
Schools observe these rationalities in order to remain viable
institutions in this climate of school marketisation. The semiotic
functions of the websites are thus not considered as context devoid;
rather, the website designs are significantly influenced by, and reveal,
the priorities set by prevailing political rationalities.
Selling points: the designs of elite boarding school websites
Online promotion on school websites represents a progression in
mediums for image management from print to digital as schools continue
to seek out new ways to market themselves to prospective clients. School
websites deliver an initial symbolic impact for schools: the use of a
website situates the school as a digitally savvy, contemporary and
professional institution. As Symes notes, school promoters will do
"anything to press home ... that the school is keeping abreast of
the latest technology" (1998, p. 144). A schools's competence
with information technology can instantly send a message to prospective
clients that the institution can provide its students with a competitive
edge in an information age.
When potential clients--local, national and international use
search engines to access information about elite schools, they are
directed to the homepages of the school websites. The information placed
on homepages holds symbolic importance as the "first
impression" that the viewer of a school website will have of the
school. For prospective clients searching for schools for their
children, this can be the first time that they have ever had any contact
with the school, so the homepage functions as a high-stakes text. The
school website's contents and the representation of them are
therefore highly relevant to the school's image management
practices. Over and beyond the traditional school promotional medium of
school prospectuses, school websites have semiotic functions unavailable
to the print medium--namely, animation and sound. Elite schools can now
promote their elite identity online, using not only the traditional
textual and visual modes but also sonic functions and digital
animations.
Most school websites in this study had prominent hyperlinks to
embedded pages promoting the schools' boarding experience to both
Australian and overseas students. The international promotional function
on the websites is indicative of the ways these elite schools have
positioned themselves to benefit from the lucrative education market
precipitated by neoliberal restructuring of the education sector. Here,
education is seen through the neoliberal frame of economic profiteering
as opposed to as a free and accessible social good. The schools sell
their boarding and educational experience as a prime opportunity for
Asian children to prepare for a globalised workforce by familiarising
themselves with the English language and western cultures. An embedded
video on the School C website, for example, highlights the benefits to
specifically Asian students who want to board at the school in order to
learn English to make the most of globalisation when they enter the
workforce. A student on the video explains, "My parents want me to
improve my English and get a better job in the future."
Furthermore, the video attempts to differentiate School C from its
inner-city counterparts and gain a slice of the international market
share by promoting the advantages of schooling in the countryside. An
Asian student explains that "I did have many choices for my
schooling in Australia but I chose [School C] because it's in the
countryside and that takes away more [sic] distractions." These
promotions to prospective international clientele on the elite boarding
school websites thus function to both position the schools as education
exporters in a globalised and neoliberal education climate of education
as a profit-making industry and differentiate schools from their
competitors in order to attract potential international clientele.
Of interest here is how the schools' promotions target not
only traditional ruling-class Australian families but also wealthy and
savvy international potential clientele. The interaction between the
traditional Australian elite school clientele and non-traditional
international elite school clientele is delicately framed by the elite
boarding schools. School J, for example, sells the international flavour
of the school as beneficial to the traditional elite school client base
by exclaiming that the international student group "[provides] a
rich diversity and broadens our perspectives along with assisting all
students to embrace our growing global world." The school thereby
attempts to simultaneously attract new international clientele and use
them as a selling point to retain the traditional, Australian, elite
school client base.
Key iconography of elite school websites
A key icon on all school website homepages is the school name. On
the websites examined in the study, the school name was most commonly
provided in large, bold and capitalised text written in strong font in
the upper-left or upper-middle sections of the page, along with an image
of the school crest. Kress and van Leeuwen (2006) identify the left-hand
segment of a page as the location for representation of something that
is an anchoring position, providing the image that orients the viewer to
the text. The top of the page, meanwhile, is the place for idealistic
images which orient the viewer to the idealised narrative of the
institution (Kress & van Leeuwen, 2006). It is a location where the
school's ideals and ethos can be promoted. Often large, capitalised
and emboldened, the school name is designed to be a highly salient
element of the web page. It is intended to be the first thing that the
eyes see on the screen, demanding attention and orienting the viewer to
the school to which the webpage belongs. The font selected for the
school name is revealing of the school's desired image. For
example, School C, and all-boy's school, has its school name
written in strong font which is bold and upright like a stoic stone
pillar, with angular Roman serifs. The regal font represents the
school's desired image of majesty and grandeur. As van Leeuwen
(2006) explains, angularity can signify stoicism and masculinity, as
opposed to personal and feminine cursive font. Similarly, its boldness
signifies daring and assertiveness as opposed to the delicacy of thin
font (van Leeuwen, 2006). This all-boy's elite school thus uses the
stoic and masculine font on this website to signify that it is a regal
and strong locale. The font used in the school name at the top of the
homepage can thus orient the viewer to the identity of the elite
schools--both in name and character.
Alongside the school name is often a school crest. The school crest
is a symbolic anchoring sign that often contains images such as open
books to signify scholarship, swords to signify strength, holy crosses
to signify Christianity and Latin mottoes to signify tradition and
cultural elitism (Synott & Symes, 1995). These images are
strategically placed on the crest to signify and valorise the elite
ethos of the school. Accordingly, the school crest is placed on the
school homepage to mark the homepage as a location governed by the
school's elite values. For example, one school's crest, which
is placed on the top-left of the homepage beside the school name, is
described elsewhere on the website:
The open book represents the Bible; the stars are those of the
Southern Cross; the shell represents the connection between the School
and [parent school], from whose funds the School was founded; while the
Torch refers to the School's motto. (School A)
Here, the coordinates are set for this school's religious
(Bible), national (Southern Cross) and economic and cultural
associations (funding from parent school). The school thus reinforces
its commitment to particular elite ideological narratives, which
position it within the marketplace: it is a Christian school, proud of
its Australian identity and economic ties to another elite private
school. The school motto, to which the torch refers, is written along
the bottom of the school crest. This motto, vitai lampada tradunt,
written in Latin to signify traditionalism (Synott & Symes, 1995),
translates to "They hand on the Torch of Life"--signifying the
goal of the school to "hand on" its elite traditions to future
generations. The school is referring to its majesty by highlighting the
longevity of the school. By promoting its traditions, the school is
indicating to the observer that it is a "historically elite"
(Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2009, p. 1093) school that can boast longevity
beyond the average, and therefore less exclusive, school--private or
otherwise. All of this information about the eliteness of the school is
visually incorporated into the school crest, which in turn is placed on
the homepage, inculcating this school's homepage with the valorised
elite values produced on the school crest.
On the top-centre or top-right of the school website homepages is
often an animated image which acts as a first photographic impression of
the elite school, its architecture or its grounds. A key understanding
in semiotics is that the right-hand segment of a screen is dedicated to
information that is new to the viewer--something to be learned (Kress
& van Leeuwen, 2006). The top, as stated, represents the ideal
(Kress & van Leeuwen, 2006). Accordingly, the images placed on the
top-right of school websites are often idealistic images of a
particularly significant schooling location or happening which the
school would like to promote. For example, School B has images of its
shining new classrooms on the top right to signify the school's
innovation, which fades after a few seconds into an image of the
school's majestic old dormitory buildings which signify tradition.
The two images symbolically construct an impression of the elite
boarding school as both traditional and innovative; both conservative
and pioneering (Meadmore & Meadmore, 2004). The blend of tradition
and innovation are used as selling points for the school, simultaneously
promoting its longevity as an elite education provider and promoting its
continued deliverance of elite education into the present day. Another
school (School A) has in this upper-right section an image of the Sydney
Harbour Bridge. In the case of this school, the image of the bridge
highlights the significance of the elite school's geographical
location. It shows the viewer that the school is in the heart of a world
famous city. This, perhaps, is to create the school's image as
being a part of, and equally as savvy as, a bustling world city
(Gottschall et al., 2010; Symes, 1998). By placing the image of
the harbour bridge on the website, the school is positioning itself
within the marketplace as having a unique connection to Sydney, its
landmarks, and their associated prestige. As Gaztambide-Fernandez (2009)
points out, the geographical positioning of the school is a central
indicator of a school's exclusivity, and thus elite credentials.
Prestigious spaces "mark the atmosphere of elite boarding
schools" (Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2009, p. 1108) inasmuch as they
indicate that the schools have acquired some of the most desirable lands
possible. Furthermore, the symbolism of the lands as private and gated
as opposed to public parklands or sporting grounds highlights the
exclusivity of the schools. Not only do the schools have access to the
grounds but that have exclusive access to them. The message to potential
clients is that their children, too, can gain access to such exclusive
locales by purchasing the school's education experience.
Geographical exclusion of people who do not attend the schools thus
functions as a central tenant to the symbolism of elite school
education. It serves a particularly pertinent function in the image of
School A as an all-boys school inasmuch as space and gender intersect to
highlight how this space is both exclusive to the wealthy and to males.
The masculinity of the school is therefore highlighted by the private
space of the school, as if to say that behind the gates of this elite
school is one of the few spaces that can be shared by wealthy men, to
the exclusion of all others. The great symbolism of the images of
exclusive lands on the elite school websites is thus not only the
amassment of lands but the amassment of lands in ways that marginalise
in terms of social class and gender.
Image management: prominence of promotion over administration
Often, directly beneath the top-of-page elements on school
webpages--the school name, crest and a photograph of school grounds--is
a menu (row) or sidebar (column) of hyperlinks. What typifies these
hyperlinks, for the most part, is that they are located towards the top,
left or top-left segments of the website to make them highly accessible
(Kress & van Leeuwen, 2006). These hyperlinks link to other pages on
the elite school website, which provide further information about the
school. Interestingly, the hyperlinks placed closest to the top-left
link to value-laden internal webpages that continue to promote the
school's exclusivity and elite ethos to prospective clients. This
reveals the importance the schools place on the promotional aspects of
the website--practical and banal administrative functions such as links
to absentee forms and excursion details are buried deeper in the
websites. In the neoliberal marketised educational climate where
attracting clientele is central to the school's economic success,
the websites must maximise their promotional functions by placing them
in the most accessible location. These accessible links have titles such
as "Values and Attitudes," "School History" and
"Principal's Message." By placing the most important
hyperlinks in the idealistic top-left segment of the screen (Kress &
van Leeuwen, 2006), the schools subtly recommend the order in which
content should be read, with the most important value-laden webpages
first. In so doing, schools attempt to resist the capability of digital
texts to be read in a non-chronological order (Cranny-Francis, 2005) and
attempt to control the viewer's experience. On the School A
homepage, for example, beneath the school crest, school name and image
of the Harbour Bridge, is a row of drop-down hyperlinks. Towards the
left of the row of drop-down hyperlinks is a drop-down heading titled
"About." It reveals numerous hyperlinks, among which are the
titles: "Headmaster's welcome," "[School A]'s
Beginnings" and "A Christian School." Significantly, the
placement of a principal's message hyperlink as one of the most
prominent hyperlinks reflects the authoritative importance of the
principal (Symes, 1998). Likewise, the placement of a values and
attitudes hyperlink (i.e. "A Christian School") as one of the
most prominent hyperlinks indicates the high importance of promotion of
school values and attitudes on the school websites. Whilst not all
religious schools are elite, Christian ethos can function as a
typological (Gaztambide-Fernandez, 2009) symbol of elitism that
demarcates the elite school as more exclusive and discerning than
non-elite public schools that are characteristically secular and
accessible to a broader working and lower middle-class market segment.
Many of the elite school websites also offer drop-down menus for
newsletters and current affairs for present school clients to keep in
touch with the school. Archives of school newsletters and links to
calendars of upcoming events allow schools to continue to manage their
elite image to current clients throughout their affiliation with the
school. "Events" pages list upcoming school events such as
musical concerts, school holiday camps and parent-teacher meetings.
"Publications" pages provide school newsletters downloadable
in PDF form. These publications are updated on a regular basis, while
archived publications are made available on many of the websites for
download. Remaining consistent with the conservative-traditional theme
of the School A website, the downloadable forms are sorted by terms of
the school year (1 to 4) written in the historical roman numerals
format, i.e. "Term IV." Furthermore, again for current
clients, crested uniform and goods can be purchased from the many school
websites through hyperlinks. Crested goods identified included crested
towels, umbrellas, golf balls, stress balls, teaspoons, playing cards,
dog leads and wall plaques among other assorted goods. These goods not
only bring money into the school upon purchase but also continue to
promote the elite school in the marketplace when the buyers wear the
crested goods in public. This reiterates the elite schools'
engagement in the neoliberal consumerist agenda. With this array of
communicative and promotional resources, the elite school websites
examined here do not merely reflect their print counterparts--that is,
function as "buttoned-up" prospectuses but are rather dynamic
promotional and administrative hubs for communication of elite ethos
between potential, present and future clientele. While the
administrative functions are buried further into the websites than
promotional functions, administrative functions are representative of
the new capacities that an online presence makes available to schools.
Conclusion
Neoliberal rationalities that have governed educational policy in
Australia have posited schools as products in an education market. This
competitive market climate has encouraged the production of school
advertising texts. While these texts traditionally took the form of
print prospectuses (Symes, 1998), schools are increasingly using school
websites to appeal to potential clientele. With a focus on elite school
websites, this paper has examined how elite schools use interactive,
animated and sonic functions in the self-promotion of the schools'
elite ethos in the education marketplace. These functions provide
schools with more dynamic and interactive marketing capabilities than
are available on the print format. Furthermore, whereas print
prospectuses are exclusively targeted at potential future clientele,
websites can be used by schools to communicate with and manage their
elite image not only to potential clients but also current and past
school patrons.
This paper has explored the capabilities of elite school
websites--both promotional and administrative--and argued that the
current political context of neoliberalism has facilitated the promotion
of elitist and exclusionary school imaginaries. The placement of the
images and hyperlinks promoting the schools' elitism in the most
salient and accessible locations shows the necessary importance schools
place on image management on websites in a climate where they must
compete for prospective clientele. The websites frequently construct
narratives of geographical, historical, religious and gendered
exclusivity in order to position the schools as locations where elite
cultural capital can be attained. Alongside promotional capabilities,
school websites have the capacity to conduct administrative functions
such as provide newsletters and purchasing of crested school goods. This
represents a significant advancement in the communication capacities of
schools. These administrative functions, however, were found to be
secondary to the promotional and image management functions of the elite
school websites.
Declaration of conflicting interests
None declared.
Funding
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in
the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
DOI: 10.1177/0004944113485838
References
Apple, M. (2005). Doing things the 'right' way:
Legitimating educational inequalities in conservative times. Educational
Review, 57(3), 271-293.
Apple, M. (2006). Educating the "right" way 2nd ed. New
York, NY: Routledge.
Barcan, A. (2010). Public schools in Australia from the late 1970s
to the late 1980s: The seeds of change. Education Research and
Perspectives, 37(2), 1-37.
Bourdieu, P. (1997). The forms of capital. In A. H. Halsey, H.
Lauder, P. Brown, & A. Stuart Wells (Eds.), Education."
Culture, economy, society (pp. 46-58). Oxford, UK and New York, NY:
Oxford University Press.
Campbell, C. (2007). Schools and school choice. In R. Connell, C.
Campbell, M. Vickers, A. Welch, D. Foley, & N. Bagnall (Eds.),
Education, change & society (pp. 127-154). Melbourne, Australia:
Oxford University Press.
Cranny-Francis, A. (2005). Multimedia: Texts and contexts. London,
UK: Sage.
Davies, B., & Bansel, P. (2007). Neoliberalism and education.
International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 20(3),
247-259.
Gall, M., Gall, J., & Borg, W. (2007). Educational research: An
introduction (8th ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson Education.
Gaztambide-Fernandez, R. (2009). What is an elite boarding school?
Review of Educational Research, 79(3), 1090-1128.
Gottschall, K., Wardman, N., Edgeworth, K., Hutchesson, R., &
Saltmarsh, S. (2010). Hard lines and soft scenes: Constituting
masculinities in the prospectuses of all-boys elite private schools.
Australian Journal of Education, 54(1), 18-30.
Hodge, R., & Kress, G. (1988). Social semiotics. Cambridge, UK:
Polity.
Kress, G., & van Leeuwen, T. (2006). Reading images: The
grammar of visual design 2nd ed. London, UK: Routledge.
Light, R., & Kirk, D. (2001). Australian cultural
capital--Rugby's social meaning: Physical assets, social advantage
and independent schools. Sport in society, 4(3), 81-98.
Meadmore, D., & McWilliam, E. (2001). The corporate curriculum:
Schools as sites of new knowledge production. Australian Educational
Researcher, 28(1), 31-45.
Meadmore, D., & Meadmore, P. (2004). The boundlessness of
performativity in elite Australian schools. Discourse." Studies in
the Cultural Politics of Education, 25(3), 375-387.
Mills, M. (2004). The media, marketing, and single-sex schooling.
Journal of Education Policy, 19(3), 343-360.
NSW Board of Studies. (2012). List of registered non-government
schools in New South Wales. Retrieved 30 July 2012 from http://www.board
ofstudies.nsw.edu.au/non-gov-schools/
Ong, A. (2006). Neoliberalism as exception. Durham, NC: Duke
University Press.
Rose, N. (1999). Powers of freedom: Reframing political thought.
New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
Saltmarsh, S. (2007). Cultural complicities: Elitism,
heteronormativity and violence in the education marketplace.
International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 20(3),
335-354.
Stromquist, N. (2002). Education in a globalized world. Lanham, MD:
Rowman & Littlefield.
Symes, C. (1998). Education for sale: A semiotic analysis of school
prospectuses and other forms of educational marketing. Australian
Journal of Education, 42(2), 133-152.
Synott, J., & Symes, C. (1995). The genealogy of the school: An
iconography of badges and mottoes. British Journal of Sociology of
Education, 16(2), 139-151.
Van Leeuwen, T. (2006). Towards a semiotics of typology.
Information Design Journal + Document Design, 14(2), 139-155.
Wardman, N., Hutchesson, R., Gottschall, K., Drew, C., &
Saltmarsh, S. (2010). Starry eyes and subservient selves: Portraits of
'well-rounded' girlhood in the prospectuses of all-girl elite
private schools. Australian Journal of Education, 54(3), 249-261.
Welch, A. (2007). The city and the bush. In R. Connell, C.
Campbell, M. Vickers, A. Welch, D. Foley, & N. Bagnall (Eds.),
Education, change & society (pp. 70-93). Melbourne, Australia:
Oxford University Press.
Youdell, D. (2004). Engineering school markets, constituting
schools and subjectivating students: The bureaucratic, institutional and
classroom dimensions of educational triage. Journal of Education Policy,
19(4), 407-431.
Christopher Drew
PhD candidate, School of Education, Australian Catholic University
(Strathfield), Australia
Corresponding author:
Christopher Drew, School of Education, Australian Catholic
University, Locked Bag 4115 DC, Fitzroy VIC 3065, Australia.
Email: christopher.drew@acu.edu.au