Grace Feuerverger. Teaching, Learning, and Other Miracles.
Mahmoud, Kamal
Grace Feuerverger. Teaching, Learning, and Other Miracles.
Rotterdam, The Netherlands: Sense Publishers, 2007. 156 pp. $30.00 sc.
"Learning is a treasure which accompanies its owner
everywhere." --Chinese proverb
"Better than a thousand days of diligent study is one day with
a great teacher." --Japanese proverb
"Education is light, lack of it darkness." --Russian
proverb
Source: Website of the National Education Association in Washington
DC: http://www.nea.org
Teaching, Learning, and other Miracles by Grace Feuerverger is a
genuine translation of the essence of the aforesaid proverbs. For
example, in conformity with the Chinese proverb above, Feuerverger
reflects on her school days and says, "I was given unimaginable
treasure" (1). In this narrative book, the author shares with
readers her autobiographical story with emphasis on the educational
aspect.
Although the simple and straightforward title of this book does not
reveal its rich content, a critical reader is able to benefit from its
hidden treasures and use them as guidelines for life success. As well,
choosing the word 'miracles' in the title is successful as it
reflects the reality of most schools nowadays. The author's message
here is that miracles are already seen in some schools, while others
still need miracles for change to happen. The introduction of the book
gives an impression of the religious background of the author who
considers "[A]n explanation of teaching and learning in schools as
a sacred life journey" (1), and thinks that "[T]eaching became
a pilgrim's journey" (2) and that "[A] teacher can be a
messenger ... to his or her students" (3). In this ambitious work,
Feuerverger reflects on her academic life, first as a student and later
as a teacher. The book consists of a series of chronological episodes,
each carrying a specific message to learners, teachers, and educators.
The author successfully delivers those messages through discussing the
main goals of this literary work.
"As a child of Holocaust survivors", Feuerverger stated
that one of the main goals behind writing this book was to give hope to
the school children who suffered from war, violence, poverty, and abuse
as well as for those who teach them (1). Another goal was to shed light
on the significant role that a good public education can play in
building the character of students of all backgrounds, cultures, races
and religions (ibid.). Moreover, the book was an attempt "to
explore the ways in which teaching as an act of courage and beauty forms
the basis for creating a spirit of community within the classroom and
beyond (2)." She also wrote this book to highlight the significance
of school as a salvation during her childhood (ibid.). Feuerverger
cleverly discussed those goals through the distinguished outline of her
book, which is divided into two main parts: first her school life as a
child and as a teacher, second her professional experience as a
university professor. Each part is broken down into chapters that were
ordered in pursuant to the author's professional life cycle.
The first part of the book mirrors Feuerverger's experiences
as a school child who survived the Holocaust and found a refuge in the
school. Emotionally and sometimes sadly she described her memories in
school as being full of diverse students who came from different
ethnicities and cultures. The author narrated how she lived
"bilingualism in a multicultural context (19)." Next, she
depicted a portrait of her passion for school and the French language
and how they became her only homeland and offered her hope in the world.
She said that "French language saved my life and the classroom
became my true and only home" (25). Then, Feuerverger discussed her
first experience as a school teacher and how she adopted storytelling as
a pedagogical approach. She believes that "a great teacher is a
great storyteller" (47). This belief conforms with Doyle (1990) who
argues that teachers store their knowledge in narratives.
In part two, Feuerverger reflects on her teaching experience as a
university professor, where she managed to build a warm rapport with her
students via "journaling and storytelling." That was followed
by an elaboration on her philosophy of teaching. She also discussed an
ESL project that was implemented by the Ministry of Education to assist
immigrant children in Canada to develop their literacy knowledge as well
as to enhance parents' involvement in their childrens'
education. In this part, there was a reference to Yiddish, the mother
tongue of the author, as well as the language of communication at home.
Feuerverger successfully described her strong bonds with her heritage
language, which was followed by a discussion of her relations with
refugee children who came from war-torn countries. As a teacher,
Feuerverger sympathized with those children because she thought that
they had lived similar circumstances to hers.
This book is an extraordinary piece of literature; it is a vivid
and rich book with endless lessons to learn. In fact, Teaching,
Learning, and Other Miracles has something to offer to all those
involved in the education process, namely students, teachers, educators,
and parents. The book beautifully presents a portrait on the art of
teaching, a perception of teacher-student relations, and most
importantly, gives inspiration and practical guidance to educators. A
critical analyst should be able to track many issues Feuerverger handled
in her book, such as justice, oppression, respect of the other, freedom,
and democracy in a multicultural society. Having read this narrative
more than once, it seems that the author is influenced by educational
theorists, such as Paulo Friere and John Dewey. Freire called for the
liberation of his students (Freire 1968) and Dewey called for a
democratic education (Dewey 1944). They both stressed the import nee of
mutual respect and dialogue between students and teachers. This book
also provides a panoramic view of the significance of inclusion of
minority students in the public education system in Canada. It awakens
the decision makers who set the educational policies so they will not
ignore the diverse nature of schools in Canada. Curriculum planners
should also take into account the importance of teaching heritage
language and homeland culture in order to encourage students from
culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds to develop their
literacy skills both in English as their second language and their first
language as well.
The author competently used a poetic language to convey various
messages to her readers. She used metaphors, such as "Yiddish was a
drowning man taking others down with him" (105), and sometimes,
similes: "I ran into the arms of French language like an orphan
child" (22). Undoubtedly, Feuerverger's autobiographical story
gives hope to many students who lived and still live similar life
conditions. Needless to say, the book provides teachers with the courage
required to create a more democratic environment in the classroom, as
she stated: "All issues can be raised because everything is
negotiable" (72). Here, Feuerverger adopts Dewey's theory of
education in which he argues that the most effective form of education
was a democratic education, wherein students were prepared for their
role as participants in a democratic society (Engel 2008). Furthermore,
one of the strengths of this narrative work is its universality. It
carries a universal message that is valid at all times and in all
settings; it is the message of love, peace and coexistence. Added to
that, Feuerverger repeatedly referred to the power of language in
building character or what is called "character education." To
her, language represented a "safe place", "refuge",
and "home". She believed in the significant role that language
plays in our lives, and for that reason she adopted storytelling as an
approach to teaching diverse students in order to develop their language
skills and to gain life experiences. By choosing this approach,
Feuerverger agrees with Collins and Cooper (1997), who believe that
storytelling develops appreciation for the beauty and rhythm of the
language.
Another strength in this work is that Feuerverger speaks in
different voices: as an educator: "teaching and learning are a
shared enterprise" (6); as a humanist: "a sense of belonging
to the family of mankind" (39); as a Holocaust survivor: "I
had a sense of woundedness" (37); and as a peace maker: "all
students must learn to live together peacefully" (140). As a
researcher and observer, Feuerverger also tackled, intentionally or
unintentionally, crucial issues, such as inequality, discrimination, and
social justice when she mentioned that "the image of stranger is
central to many immigrants" (78). The one message she wanted to
deliver through those voices is that a teacher is someone who does more
than teach.
Although the book is ordered in an academic format and the chapters
are neatly organized, some areas seem misplaced and do not conform to
the twelve-chapter outline. For example, Chapter 8 (My Yiddish Voice)
seems oddly placed in the midst of part two of the book. However, this
weakness is outweighed by the many strengths of the work. Overall, the
book is written in a readable and understandable language. It is a blend
of social, cultural, linguistic, and educational studies. And it
represents a rich source for teachers, educators and researchers,
especially those who work with diverse students.
References:
Collins, R., and P. J. Cooper. 1997. The Power of Stow: Teaching
through storytelling. Needham Heights, MA: A Viacom Company.
Dewey, J. 1944. Democracy and Education (First Free Press Paperback
Edition 1966 ed.). New York: Macmillan Publishing Co.
Doyle, W. 1990. Case methods in the education of teachers. Teacher
Education Quarterly 17.1: 7-15. Engel, L. H. 2008. Experiments in
Democratic Education: Dewey's Lab School and Korczak's
Children's Republic. Social Studies 99.3: 117-121.
Freire, P. 1968. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Trans. M. B. Ramos. New
York: Herder and Herder.
Kamal Mahmoud
Department of Curriculum, Teaching, and Learning, OISE, University
of Toronto