Millennials & the Workplace: Chellenges For Architecting Organizations of Tomorrow.
Kumar, Pankaj ; Ghosh, Soumya Kanti
MILLENNIALS & THE WORKPLACE: CHELLENGES FOR ARCHITECTING
ORGANIZATIONS OF TOMORROW by Pritam Singh, Asha Bhandarker & Sumita
Rai, New Delhi: Sage Response, 2012, Rs. 425, Paperback, ISBN:
978-81-321-089-6, 233 pp.
"Change is the only constant"--Heraclitus. A constant
state of flux is probably the sole invariable of the human condition
down the ages. Incremental changes have been a part of human existence
for millennia, where our journey from the Stone Age to the Information
Age has not merely been technological, but also societal, cultural,
philosophical and political. But society, as we know it now, is not
merely changing, but doing so at an accelerated pace. People today, are
becoming increasingly empowered; privileges are being treated as rights;
institutions, which were previously beyond reproach, are facing scathing
criticism, and in some cases violent protests. Large-scale public
protests and uprisings have targeted financial institutions in the
Euro-American world, military dictatorships in the Arab world and the
government in India, the world's largest functional democracy,
amongst others. The people at the forefront of these protests are part
of a generation termed as Millennials, also variously known as
"Generation Y" or "Gen Net". Organizations, an
integral part of modern societies, therefore cannot remain impervious to
these changes when these protestants are part of, or soon will be, their
workforce. But, the enormity of most modern organizations, coupled with
the need for constant boundary spanning activities, makes tailoring an
organization to the needs of the workforce an arduous task, yet it is
essential if the organization is to survive and thrive. Therefore, books
like "Millennials and the Workplace", serve a very important
purpose where organization leaders are given a blueprint for taking
their organizations forward by able academicians.
The book's approach is an empirical one, where based on a
large scale survey of 2,158 respondents across India on certain
demographic, social and psychological variables, the authors try to
understand the meaning of and the expectations from the workplace for
the Millennials. All the respondents were born within 1977-1984, the
standard age criteria for Millennials. On the basis of that
understanding the authors put forth a detailed plan for organizations to
attract and retain talent.
The book is organized into five chapters. The introductory chapter
provides an extensive literature review on the meaning of work for
humans and how it has changed down the ages throughout the world, before
going on to what work and workplace have come to mean for the
Millennials. The chapter then provides a brief introduction of the
research variables, instrument design and finally the research
instrument itself. The second chapter provides an extensive profiling of
the respondents on the basis of demographic (age, gender, education,
work experience and place of upbringing), psychosocial (family type,
parental occupation, parents' employment status, father's
style, family decision-making and risk-taking style), personality and
value variables. The personality variables used are achievement
orientation and workplace locus-of-control, while the values studied are
personal growth, self-fulfillment, progressive orientation and community
development. While the variables included for the study are undoubtedly
important, the authors do not expound on the reasons for specifically
choosing these variables for their study.
The third chapter deals with the Millennials' expectations
from the workplace and identifying the antecedents influencing these
expectations. The dominant themes which emerged in terms of expectations
were: entrepreneurial innovation; performance-based recognition;
transparency and fairness; opportunities for learning and development;
and work-life balance. Among these, entrepreneurial innovation was the
most important factor. The chapter concludes by examining the effects of
the demographic, psychosocial, personality and value variables on these
expectations.
The fourth chapter brings out the large gaps in between
employees' expectations from the workplace and actual
organizational realities. These gaps, along with the gaps in
expectations from and experiences of supervisory behaviors, are chief
influencers in an employee's intent to leave an organization. The
chapter concludes with a view from another perspective, as the authors
present their finding from their interviews with HR professionals.
The concluding chapter provides the blueprint for tomorrow's
organizations by pointing out what are the essential shifts in
organizational mindscapes which are required if organizations are to
excel. The authors state that an organization which encourages
entrepreneurial innovation provides a just, fair and equitable work
environment, along with opportunities for employees'
self-development and enough room for the exercise of free-will is the
organization which will succeed with its Millennial workforce. The
authors conclude the book by providing two important checklists for
organizations and leaders, which would help them to reduce the
differences between employee expectations, supervisory behaviors and
organizational realities.
The reviewers find this book a very valuable piece of work
especially considering that there has been no previous work on
Millennials as a workforce in India. The scale of the data, along with
the various sources from which data is drawn (employees, students, HR
professionals, etc.) makes it a particularly commendable work. As it is
the Millennials who will be leading Indian organizations in the near
future, the book is important for current practitioners who will hand
over the baton, to know what to expect from and what to provide to
tomorrow's leaders. From the researchers' point of view, the
book provides a starting point on which a body of work on Millennials of
India can be built. Since the authors have concentrated only on a
limited number of psychological variables, it gives ample scope for an
expansion of this research agenda. Similar research on the same cohort
can also be conducted at a later date (or on a longitudinal sample), to
see what differences have emerged in the interim period and how have
they come about. Since the data is cross-sectional, it is only through
such studies (or by comparison to previous studies) it can be
conclusively said whether this generation is actually very different
from the others preceding it, or is it just a case of "plus ca
change, plus c'est la meme chose".
Pankaj Kumar Chairman & Professor & Soumya Kanti Ghosh, FPM
Student, Human Resource Management Group, Indian Institute of
Management, Lucknow