Introduction: identity formation and migration focusing on Latin America and the Caribbean.
Jones, Terry-Ann ; Mielants, Eric
This issue of Human Architecture: Journal of the Sociology of
Self-Knowledge has a focus on the complexity of identity formations
experienced by migrants in the world-system, with a regional focus on
Latin America and the Caribbean which have been at the heart of many
recent scholarly debates in migration studies and the subsequent
emergence of transnationalism. The current issue can be therefore
understood as an attempt to establish an intellectual dialogue between
different academic disciplines, as well as theoretical perspectives.
The focus on large scale migratory developments by substantial
numbers of people in the last couple of decades, which some refer to as
the age of globalization, has not only re-energized earlier pre-1945
discussions about immigration, assimilation, generational change and
socioeconomic implications for migrants as well as states of origin and
destination, but raised new questions about migrants'
self-awareness and (re)production of their own identities, be they
ethnic, racialized, national, regional or gendered. How migrants
constitute a self, maintain and reproduce an identity as being part of a
diaspora, has especially been relevant in the Caribbean and Latin
America. While it is widely understood that the experiences of migrants
from this region can greatly vary depending on a variety of factors,
many of these factors are particular to the migrants themselves
(nationality, socioeconomic class, race, and gender, for example).
However, the role of the receiving context also greatly affects the
migrants and their communities.
Among the various themes of this issue is the importance of
context, as illustrated through the use of comparisons, and the
application to the domestic migration context of theoretical approaches
commonly used to explain international migration. The receiving context
is not merely a factor in the migration process; it determines to a
large extent what in the literature on migration and transnational
identity is sometimes referred to as the 'mode of
incorporation' of immigrants. The incorporation of migrants into
their host communities--whether they are a desired or involuntary
destination--is a feature of the sometimes-circular process of
migration. The incorporation process cannot be separated from the
migrants' potential socioeconomic mobility over many years, if not
entire generations, as immigrants transform themselves and are being
transformed into minorities.
Another theme that emerges among these papers is that of
integration, or in the case of deportees--a very specific group of
immigrants--reintegration. A crucial aspect of incorporation is identity
formation, often central to migration research and highlighted in a
variety of ways in the papers. Plaza explores the use of technology in
identity formation among second generation West Indians, while Audebert
takes a geographic perspective, emphasizing the relevance of residential
concentration among immigrant communities. Harrington et al., on the
other hand, examine the intersection of identity with violence. The
papers use different approaches to underscore concerns that are relevant
to a wide range of migrant populations. While there is some emphasis on
migration among Jamaicans, Haitians, and Brazilians, the approaches of
the articles that follow hold broader theoretical implications for other
international migrants.
In her article, Jones uses international migration frameworks to
discuss the experiences of temporary, migrant, Brazilian sugar cane
workers who move from the northeast to the center-south of Brazil. Among
the many parallels between the domestic and international experiences
are the often-traumatic family dynamics that accompany seasonal
migration, poor living and working conditions, and discrimination. While
international migrants have the unique experiences of being uprooted (or
uprooting themselves) and transplanted (or transplanting themselves)
into a foreign society, their understanding of the process does not
differ much from that of Brazilian domestic migrants, or those in other
large countries where cultural and socioeconomic differences abound.
Prest et al. examine the potential role of Jamaicans and Haitians
in the Diaspora in conflict resolution and peace building in their home
countries. The nature and scope of the political and economic landscape
that contribute to each country's volatility are discussed, as well
as the appropriateness of defining them as countries of conflict and
what this might imply for the construction of minorities'
self-identity. They find that, given some degree of political access in
the home countries, the Jamaican and Haitian diasporas are able to wield
considerable power in the reduction of conflict and violence. Although
there are a number of complex ways in which members of the Jamaican and
Haitian diasporas are able to contribute to their home countries, among
the basic channels are economic support and political pressure. Economic
support is transferred in the form of remittances, while political
pressure can be exerted from abroad without the fear of repercussions.
Plaza provides an analysis of the ways in which the Internet, via
the construction of different web sites, sustains a fluid Caribbean
transnational identity among second generation Caribbeans in Canada, the
US as well as the UK. His research explores the ways in which second
generation Caribbean students construct identities that are uniquely
theirs. These identities are rooted in cultural norms that are derived
from the homeland, yet represent a hybrid that is characteristic of
diasporic culture. Although they are familiar with the norms, values,
and culture of their or their parents' country of birth, they
experience the world through the context in which they live, that is the
destination country. Through his analysis of Caribbean student
organizations' websites, Plaza illustrates how second generation
students manage to negotiate the home and destination countries.
In his contribution, Audebert analyzes the issue of ethnicized
constituencies and explores the connection between the residential
concentrations of immigrant groups, in this case West Indians, and the
making of a political power base distinct from other immigrant groups
and from native Blacks. Audebert applies a double comparison, focusing
on Jamaicans and Haitians in the metropolitan areas of South Florida and
New York. Within the context of immigrant communities, Audebert explores
the relationship between ethnicity, residential settlement and political
empowerment. He finds that at the national level, West Indian political
interests become subsumed within those of African Americans. It is at
the local or metropolitan levels that political representation becomes
more distinctively linked to national identity.
Drotbohm looks at the issue of crime, the constructions of
"otherness" and the project of migration as it relates to
Haitians at home and in the Diaspora at large. She explores the
different perspectives of Haitian parents and their children with regard
to the parents' migratory project and the eventual destruction of
that project when delinquent children are deported, and the separate
meanings that deportation holds for different generations.
Terry-Ann Jones and Eric Mielants
Fairfield University
tjones@mail.fairfield.edu * emielants@fairfield.edu
Terry-Ann Jones is Assistant Professor of Sociology at Fairfield
University, with primary teaching responsibilities in the International
Studies Program. Professor Jones is actively involved in the Latin
American and Caribbean Studies and Black Studies programs and serves on
the advisory boards of both. Her areas of research and teaching interest
are in international migration, particularly between Latin America and
the Caribbean and North America. Her previous research compared Jamaican
immigrants in the metropolitan areas of Miami and Toronto, and was
published in her book, Jamaican Immigrants in the United States and
Canada: Race, Transnationalism, and Social Capital, in 2008. Professor
Jones is currently doing research on temporary labor migration in
Brazil, particularly among sugar cane workers who travel from
Brazil's northeast to the central and southeastern regions. The
role of migration as a livelihood strategy among both domestic and
international migrants is central to this research. She received her
Ph.D. from the University of Miami, School of International Studies in
2005. Eric Mielants is Associate Professor in Sociology in the College
of Arts and Sciences at Fairfield University and Research Associate of
the Maison des Sciences de l'Homme in Paris. He is the author of
The Origins of Capitalism and the Rise of the West (Temple University
Press, 2007). Most recently he co-edited Caribbean Migration to Western
Europe and the United States (Temple University Press, 2009) and Mass
Migration in the World System (Paradigm Press, forthcoming).