A Southern Woman of Letters: the Correspondence of Augusta Jane Evans Wilson.
McKee, Kathryn B.
A Southern Woman of Letters: The Correspondence of Augusta Jane
Evans Wilson, edited by Rebecca Grant Sexton. Columbia: University of
South Carolina Press, 2002. xxxv, 205 pp. $29.95 cloth.
TO MODERN READERS OF SOUTHERN LITERATURE, Eudora Welty's Edna
Earl Ponder is a more familiar name than that of Augusta Evans
Wilson's Edna Earl, the heroine of her 1866 novel, St. Elmo. Yet
only Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin sold more
copies in the nineteenth century than St. Elmo, and Wilson, the
best-selling author of nine novels, was for much of her professional
life "a household word across the United States" (p. xxi).
Scholars have periodically renewed their interest in Wilson's
fiction. In 1992, for example, academic presses reprinted three volumes
of her work: Beulah (LSU Press), Macaria (LSU Press), and St. Elmo
(University of Alabama Press). Rebecca Grant Sexton's carefully
edited compilation of Wilson's correspondence, A Southern Woman of
Letters, will usefully supplement the critical investigations of her
fiction now possible.
Still, it can be hard to get excited about Wilson's novels.
Even contemporary reviewers sometimes found her stories pedantic and
overwritten, and anyone who has tried to read Beulah knows that the
narrative is so dense with allusions--classical, historical, and
sometimes indecipherable--that fully decoding them would require
appending a separate volume. Her letters, although marred by an
unfortunate tendency to use the archaic word "yclept," are
less taxing to read. Now readers will struggle with different hurdles:
Wilson's bitterly expressed Southern nationalism (she signed a
letter in 1902 "Your sincere, unreconstructed rebel friend"
[p. 184]), her opposition to universal suffrage, and her commitment to a
domesticated womanhood that left little time for political
opinion-making.
The letters are worth reading, though, both for the moments when
they uphold our expectations and the times when they surprise us. Sexton
pulls together in this volume correspondence scattered through more than
twenty archives and spanning nearly fifty years, supplemented by
extensive footnotes that embed Wilson in an anxious and weary South. The
highest concentration of letters falls during the Civil War and
Reconstruction, so that readers encounter Wilson at the same time that
she was producing her most popular fiction. We witness situations rarely
chronicled first-hand, including the difficulties involved in publishing
a novel on a Southern press in the middle of the Civil War and the
struggle Wilson faced between fulfilling the cultural role of woman as
she defined it in her fiction and negotiating the boundaries of
womanhood as she lived it in a world realigned by patriotic duty. She
numbered among her primary correspondents well-known leaders, including
General P.G.T. Beauregard, to whom she wrote in 1862: "It is not my
privilege to enter the ranks, wielding a sword, in my country's
cause, but all that my feeble, womanly pen could contribute to the
consummation of our freedom, I have humbly, but at least faithfully and
untiringly endeavored to achieve" (p. 42).
Sabotaging her own language here with classic female
selfdeprecation, Wilson elsewhere sharpened her womanly pen to prize
open questions ranging from Jefferson Davis's fitness to lead the
Confederacy to the ill effects slavery exerted on white Southern
womanhood, although never faltering in her allegiance to the South as a
rightfully independent nation. Characterizing most Southern women as
"enervated, lethargic, incapable of enduring fatigue, and as a
class, afflicted with chronic lassitude" (p. 65), Wilson saw
herself differently. So will we, given the energy and passion that makes
her correspondence such appealing reading nearly one hundred years after
her death.
KATHRYN B. MCKEE
University of Mississippi