Situated negotiations of gendered sexualities: evidence from young people in Kabba, Nigeria.
Babatunde, Ekundayo B. ; Durowaiye, Babatunde E.
Introduction
This paper examines young people's sexualities within the
social and cultural contexts of Nigeria and thus outlines how their
sexual negotiations are shaped by the norms of gender-based
expectations. This paper does not simply conceptualize young people as
passive to the normative expectations or circumstances in their
socio-cultural environment, but rather, it emphasizes the constraints
that they faced in their choices as rational actors in response to
social norms which vary according to a number of factors such as age
(which is refered to as generational difference), economic conditions
and values operating within their families and communities. This study
also explores how as sexual-gendered actors, young women and men can be
seen as generationally, economically, and relationally situated actors,
and therefore, we use the terms 'age' and
'generation' interchangeably in an attempt to reveal how young
people, by reason of their being young or of a certain age, are
confronted with different levels of constraints and normative
expectations within their environment. From the findings discussed here,
contradictory and conflicting values influenced young people's
understanding of their sexualities and the way they negotiated sexual
relations, and in this mix, discourses that enabled and inhibited sexual
negotiations in relation to social positioning was discovered.
Socio-Cultural Context and Young People's Sexuality
Over the last two decades, several studies have identified how
different norms and cultural values have affected young people's
sexual practices, particularly as regards safer sex. At a theoretical
level, Giddens (1992) argues that the emergence of late modern values
has eroded the traditional gendered norms and practices that were lived
and experienced in the pre-modern era. From this perspective, Western
societies have undergone core developmental changes in their social,
cultural and economic structures within the past few decades (Beck,
1992, Giddens, 1992). Such changes have in turn, altered ideas and
expectations of human sexuality as well as other aspects of personal
relationships in areas such as marriage, parenthood and family life, and
in patterns of interactions between sexual partners and friends. As a
result, Giddens considers intimate and emoti relationships in late
modern societies to be increasingly based on negotiations, which are
often characterised by greater democracy and gender equality (Giddens,
1992; see also Heaphy, 2007). This analysis suggests that negotiation
has become an essential part of personal life in contemporary societies
as people make informed choices or decisions about their everyday lives
and relationships.
Although Giddens's analysis has been criticized for
overemphasizing the impact of individual agency and ignoring key
structural factors such as class and gender and the influence of power
and intergenerational relationships (Jamieson, 1999, Heaphy, 2007), it
could be argued that Giddens's suggestions still appear to be more
applicable in an individualised Western culture where people are
relatively free from the bonds of traditional values and normative
influences.
In the African context, it has been argued that despite the trend
towards a more global youth culture, often accompanied by a shift to
Western ideas and values, such as on contraceptive use and the
insignificance of virginity at marriage, young people's sexualities
and sexual behaviours have continued to be influenced by dominant
traditional norms and values as well as by their economic circumstances
(Caldwell, 2000). In this study, both young women and young men were
found to be actively involved in negotiating possible choices and
decisions im regard to their sexual relationships. However, their
negotiations were constrained in various ways that were far from
matching Giddens's (Giddens, 1992) picture of negotiated
relationships. Apart from their sexualities being highly gendered and
influenced by various traditional norms, the young people were also
found to be constrained in exercising their agency by their
generational, economic, and social situations via family and community
ethos. Thus, as this study unfolds, young people's narratives
confirms the social constructionist view of sexuality as discursively
constructed, organized and shaped in situated ways within specific
contexts.
Research Methods
The population for this study was drawn from young people that are
attending school and nonschoolers (young people that are currently out
of school) in Kabba, a town in Kogi State in midwest Nigeria near Abuja,
the capital city of Nigeria located in the center of Nigeria. The
participants, both schoolers and non-schoolers, comprised equal numbers
of females and males age 16-19 and 20-25 who were selected for both
focus groups and individual interviews. The decision for this
composition was taken in order to examine whether there were differences
or similarities in young people's sexual practices, meanings and
negotiations based on their age, sex, education, or their social status
in terms of skills. Geographical location was used to select
participants who were born or had spent many years in the community. It
was expected that such respondents would be sufficiently familiar with
the culture. Although this is not a comparative gender study of young
people, it was important to establish an approximate gender balance in
the sample, in order to observe the influence of socio-cultural factors
on both sexes. Participants were restricted to the 16-25 age range in an
attempt to ensure that they would be relatively independent and thus
able to decide on their own to participate in the study. It was also
expected that people in this age range would possess relatively
'rich' knowledge of the research topic, having had some
experience of relationships, negotiations and the meanings or
interpretations of sexual issues in relation to the various factors that
the study sought to examine. Overall, The sample consisted of 66
participants for the 10 FGDs (five members for each session) and 16
one-to-one interviewees, including some who also participated in the
focus groups. Following official approval from differnt sources and
levels as well as gaining the consent of potential participants, the
IDIs and focus groups were conducted at venues convienient and safe for
the researchers and participants.
Major Findings: Generational and Economic Dynamics
Young people's narratives reveal them talking about themselves
in different ways that were closely related; however, for analytical
purposes, we discuss young people as generational and economic actors to
situate the dynamics that influenced how they negotiated their
sexualities.
One of the prominent themes that emerged from the narratives of the
young people is that their sexualities and sexual practices were
influenced by their age. The analysis of their accounts reveals the
complex and subtle contexts in which young people of all ages (both
female and male) negotiated their sexual practices. Starting with the
younger women's accounts, the following extracts reveal different
ways in which those aged 16 to 19 years generally negotiated their
sexualities and sexual practice within a constraining and controlling
cultural environment.
Grace: ... we're only good friends for now ... sex is a no-go
area for now ... [May I ask why?] Because we're not ripe for it
yet. Besides, I'm a Christian ... then, my parents mustn't
know that I have a boyfriend at this early stage ... [How will they
feel?] ... my dad can even decide to stop my school fees ... by the time
I'm in school we can freely tell our families. [Younger schooler,
aged 17]
Christiana: ... people don't really know about us. I only see
him when I go to sell things ... I'm not even allowed to visit a
male friend ... My parents said making friends with boys will make me
pregnant while in school ... we see each other after prep class in
school, we just go to enclosed areas, where people can't easily see
us. [Younger schooler, aged 18].
Titi: ... we have agreed that we were going to wait until
we're mature enough before thinking of sex ... but it happened so
fast that I got confused. He told me to meet him at his friend's
place and as I got there, it was just the two of us.... and he insisted.
It was hard to shout because people around might hear me.... then he
pleaded with me. later I discovered that I was pregnant. [Younger
nonschooler, aged 18]
Biola: He's much older than me ... so I was somehow confused
when he told me that if I remained a virgin for too long it might result
in infertility after marriage ... so I got confused. then, somehow, he
lured me into [sex] ... in fact, I've never told anyone about
this.... [Why?] Because I don't want to become subject of gossip
and ridicule ... [Younger non-schooler, aged 19]
In analysing the younger women's narratives, it is useful to
observe two forms of negotiation, which here is refered to as direct and
indirect. At the direct level, many of the younger interviewees engaged
in negotiations with their male partners to postpone sexual activity for
cultural reasons. At an indirect level, it was observed that most of the
young women (both older and younger ones) were engaged in constant
negotiations with their parents regarding expected sexual behaviour,
i.e. whether they should engage in sexual relationships, and if so, to
what level of involvement.
These direct and indirect forms of negotiation were notable for the
complex ways in which most of the younger women balanced the
internalized norms and values in discouraging premarital sexual
relationships against personal influences on them to engage in sexual
activity. An interesting part of this finding is that while they did not
passively accept the dominant norms that prescribed sexual abstinence
for their age group, they did not explicitly reject them. Thus, most of
the younger women interviewed were conducting intimate relationships
outside the surveillance of their parents and members of their
community. While they tended to make these adults believe that they had
not yet begun sexual relationships; most of them were conducting such
relationships in secret.
Using direct negotiation with their partners, the younger women
often expressed their intention to delay sexual activity. As observed in
most of their accounts, these younger women were usually conscious of
the negative impact of premarital sex. References were made to their
parents and other 'authorities' in their community as having
informed them that sexual activity was hazardous to their wellbeing, due
to the possibility of pregnancy and of having to drop out of school or
an apprenticeship. Thus, a number of these younger women negotiated with
their partners to postpone or delay sexual activity until they felt
mature enough.
However, as revealed in many of their narratives, the younger women
could not consistently negotiate their intention to abstain or postpone
sex, due to the clandestine nature of their relationships. An
interesting example of this is that Titi (her comments are forthcomming)
felt unable to forcefully resist unwanted sex with her partner because
she feared that to do so would lead to her already illicit relationship
being exposed to the community. Other younger women, including Tayo (her
comments are forthcomming), could not negotiate total abstinence with
their partners due the contradictions between the moral norm
discouraging of premarital sex and the norm of constructing total
abstinence so not to compromise her later reproductive capacity. Hence,
one of the implications of such secret relationships was that many
younger women may have endured rape or coercive sex in silence.
Meanwhile, analysis of the accounts of the older females (aged
20-25) reveals that sexuality was centred on a concern with marriage,
which was prioritised in their local culture. It appears from these
accounts that the interviewees tended to be conscious of growing older
and of the need to secure a potential life partner to achieve their
ideal, as prescribed in their local context.
Thus, compared with the accounts of the younger females, total
abstinence from premarital sex was less strongly prioritised, with many
viewing sexual intercourse as a means of entering into and sustaining
their relationships or of demonstrating their commitment to a potential
life partner. Thus, negotiations for sexual abstinence among this group
were not as prevalent as with the younger women. The following are
extracts from interviews with some of these older females.
Lizzy: ... we've been much closer ... well, I didn't
object to sleeping with him ... we're both old enough to be
married. [Does your mum allow you to visit him?] ... [Older
non-schooler, aged 24].
Emma: Although I know we were not meant to be having sex until we
get married, I just felt it's still okay since we're in love.
After all, I'm no longer a kid. Then I've got contraceptive
pills, so I'm not afraid of getting pregnant before we're
married ... [Older schooler, aged 22].
Grace: ... I'm of age now and I know better than before ...
[Older non-schooler, aged 23].
Ladun: ... I was ready to get along with him ... then, I wish
something good [marriage] would come of our relationship ... [Older
non-schooler, aged 25].
Participants in a focus group session for older female
non-schoolers (aged 20-25) gave similar responses, referring to the
constraints on safer sexual practice:
Labaks: ... you can't really insist on a condom at all times
... like in some families they never approve of their son marrying until
the potential wife is pregnant.
Oyin: ... My dad did not allow my brother to fix their wedding date
until the fiancee was pregnant ... My dad said some girls are not
fertile and a man must be smart to avoid having them as a wife ...
Such comments constitute a common explanation for the majority of
females in their early twenties engaging in sexual relationships.
Contrary to Giddens's (1991) argumennt of a shift of emphasis in
relationships (including sexual ones) from a collectivistic to an
individual orientation in the western context, the young African women
in this study negotiated their sexual practices in a cultural setting
marked by strong social ties and feelings of belonging to the family, to
the community and to its traditions. Thus, the sexual narratives of the
older females revolved around concerns about what their parents or
community members felt or said about them. However, they appeared to be
relatively independent of parental control, as some were already out of
school, in skilled or unskilled work and in a position to take decisions
about their own lives. They were found to have embraced some aspects of
post-traditional values, such as by ignoring the norms related to the
importance of virginity at marriage, seeing sex beyond reproductive
purposes (reflected in Ladun's and Grace's comments) and using
contraception (such as revealed by Emma) to avoid unwanted pregnancies.
Interestingly, however, they accepted the norms associated with marriage
as a recognised status in their culture. Thus, these older women, like
their younger counterparts, engaged in indirect negotiations, informing
their parents about their potential life partners at some point but
concealing from them their involvement in sexual activity. Thus, even
when some of these older females, like Emma, might have parental consent
to begin a potentially lifelong relationship, they were not yet expected
to engage in sexual activity. However, based on the need to show
commitment or sustain their relationships for a lifetime, or for
economic reasons, most of these older females consented to sex in their
relationships, while keeping this secret from family and community. A
major implication of this finding is that, like their younger
counterparts, many of these older females acknowledged that they were
not often in a position to freely negotiate their pleasure or
protection.
Young Men
Analysis of the accounts of young male interviewees provides clear
evidence that age and generation were also for them important factors in
how sexuality and its associated meanings and practices were shaped.
While male abstinence from sex before marriage was clearly not regarded
as having the importance of female abstinence in this setting, the
younger males (aged 16-19) narrated different circumstances that
constrained their sexual activity.
Toks: We stopped meeting at home since my dad saw her and started
advicing me about unwanted pregnancy ... Now I see her after school ...
we just go to hidden areas to have some fun ... [Do you use a condom
with her? Ah, that's a big question, it's really hard to buy
it here, people around will look at you as if you're a criminal. I
buy them outside this town. [Younger schooler, aged 18].
Austin: ... but we're in the modern age, so I still have fun
... [Younger schooler].
Alaba: ... parents don't understand, because you're
depending on them for financial support, so they get embarrassed to see
you with a girl ... so most times we meet in school ... [Younger
schooler, aged 19].
Deji: My dad is generally very strict with my sisters ... but for
us [his sons], he allows us to receive visitors including our female
friends.... but he doesn't allow us to take a female friend to our
private room ... [Younger non-schooler, aged 19].
Micheal: ... the day my mum saw us together I just said she's
a casual friend. [Why?] For them, it's too early to have a
girlfriend. They want you to at least be a good age, like late 20s or
early 30s ... Most times we meet at my friend's place ... [Younger
non-schooler, aged 19].
Richard:... I cannot buy condom because people will see me as
spoilt. I get them from one of my friends who is much older and bolder
... [Younger non-schooler, aged 19].
These accounts illustrate different ways in which younger men aged
16 to 19 negotiated their sexual relations and the contexts in which
their sexual encounters took place. Their accounts suggest that they
were not strictly constrained like the young women in terms of freedom
to visit and receive visitors (including female friends) under parental
guidance. However, they were often expected not to express or explore
their sexuality until they were older or financially independent. Thus,
similar to their female counterparts, they acknowledged the norms and
gave the impression of adhering to them, whilst indirectly negotiating
their sexual encounters in secret. For instance, Toks' narratives
of having fun with his partner in quiet or enclosed corners of his
school typically explained how some of the young men made alternative
arrangements for themselves even when they appeared to be complying with
the moral obligations expected of them by their parents and within their
cultural setting.
Such narratives indicate the difficulties encountered by many of
these younger males who might be open to safer sexual practice. Their
sexual situations also pointed to the lack of an enabling environment
where both partners could discuss and negotiate their sexual safety and
pleasure. By contrast, the sexuality of the older males (aged 20-25)
appeared less constrained and controlled in these respects. From their
narratives, the older males appeared relatively free to express their
sexuality and negotiate the context of their sexual activity. They were
mostly found to be using direct forms of negotiation with both partners
and parents, unlike the younger generation. Hence:
Joel: I've read a lot of things abouts ex and HIV/AIDS on the
internet and even on radio ... so I'm more careful ... I don't
live with my parents, I have my own apartment ... [Older schooler, aged
22].
Seye: Well, some people still talk about how they love to marry
virgins, but for me, I see it as an old tradition ... [Younger
non-schooler, aged 18].
Akin: ... my mum usually insists on some things, like I
shouldn't be staying out late or not to have anything to do with
some type of girls but I didn't stop. since I gained admission to
university, she seems to have relaxed from scrutinizing my movements ...
[Older schooler, aged 24].
Kenny: ... my parents didn't like the first girl I introduced
to them. so I decided to give it a long time. In fact, they had to start
persuading me before I told them about this present one ... and it
really worked, because they accepted without many queries ... [Older
non-schooler, aged 25].
The above excerpts are representative of the narratives of most of
the older male interviewees and reveal the freer social context in which
they negotiated their sexual relationships. It may be inferred from this
that as these young men entered their twenties they tended to circumvent
some of the traditional beliefs and moral norms, such as those requiring
young men to be sexually abstinent and their brides to be virgins.
Moreover, many of these older males were already earning an income,
which appeared to empower some, like Joel to buy, possess and use
condoms. Others, like Akin, found that parental control appeared to
lessen once they had completed secondary school and were preparing to
enter higher education. Thus, while most of the younger males reported
engaging in clandestine sexual activity, the older ones disclosed their
relationships to parents and family members as well as engaging in
sexual activity within the comfort of their homes. Further, while some
of the older males could make use of condoms and could buy them openly,
a majority of the younger men lamented being unable to do so,
complaining of the stress involved in buying condoms when their
anonymity could not be ensured.
Interestingly, however, the older men's accounts suggest that
they were still somewhat constrained and might have to use indirect
negotiation to achieve their aims or protect their interest in the area
of choosing a life partner. Some, like Akin, engaged in indirect
negotiation with their parents on issues such as how long to stay out at
night and the calibre of young women to associate with.
A wider implication of the different contexts in which the two age
groups of male respondents reported engaging in sexual activity is that
the younger ones were more likely to see sexual intercourse as an
opportunistic activity with little regard for the feelings or safety of
their female partners. This could be observed in the way most of younger
women described being 'persuaded', 'lured' or forced
into sex by their partners. Another implication is that generational
constraints hindered young people's access particularly the younger
ones to adequate knowledge on sexual issues and both young men and women
negotiated often contradictory norms and peer influences.
Young People as Economic Actors
One of the themes emerging from this study of the sexuality of
young Kabbarians is the significant influence of economic factors on
their sexual negotiations. Most were engaged in economic or
income-generating activities, or at least helped their parents to
conduct family businesses such as farming and trading. Importantly, the
following accounts reveal how some of these young women used various
methods of negotiation with men in sexual situations.
Titi: I met him while selling goods for my mum ... He's a very
nice and generous Man ... then he seems to be interested in me. Somehow
I was afraid of losing him as a good customer, so I decided to go to his
place with my younger brother ... Even then, he was still quite friendly
and would buy things from me. Then on this particular day, I didn't
go with my brother, he just came close and held me so close to himself
and I was just like ah! this man is about to rape me--but I quickly
threatened to scream and alert his neighbours. That was how he left me,
but told me never to come to his house again ... [Younger non-schooler,
aged 18].
Mary: He used to be one of my customers. then we became close
friends and started Dating ... In fact, most times he gives me money
even when I didn't I ask him ... Then, he asked me for sex, but I
told him about my fear of getting pregnant. So I kept giving him
different excuses to avoid seeing him until recently ... My problem with
him now is that he doesn't like to use a condom ... I've
decided to stop having sex with him. I just told myself that I must stop
seeing him. [Older schooler, aged 24]
Justina: He comes to our restaurant to eat ... then he asked me a
few questions. When I told him why I'm doing the job, he promised
to pay for my training for the apprenticeship and to establish my own
outlet afterwards ... so even when he asked me out I didn't
hesitate to agree because he's been so kind to me ... the only
thing I don't just like is that he's always demanding sex,
even when I'm not feeling like it ... [Older non-schooler, aged
24].
Banwo: ... He made promises of how he would support me financially
... When we started having sex, ... I knew it wasn 't right, but I
didn't resist because I was so convinced by his promises....
[Younger non-schooler, aged 19]
The excerpts above provide examples of a range of sexual situations
and the manner in which young women in the study actively negotiated or
became passive in their sexual encounters. It could be concluded that
while some of the young women thought abstractly that they did not want
to have sex with particular men or at a particular time, or had the
intention to negotiate the use of a condom, their economic limitations
seemed to prevent them from actively negotiating their feelings and
safety during sexual encounters. This finding revealed that a 'pure
relationship' in Giddens' (1992) term, in which sexual and
emotional equality exists, cannot be easily achieved within economically
motivated relationships. Such relationships often widen the gender gap
between women and men, making the above young women suppress their
distaste or unhappiness about the sexual encounter while protecting male
self-esteem and domination. However, it was interesting to find that
some of the young women could actively reject unwanted sex, even in
complex sexual situations
Mary's account illustrates a common constraint that most young
women in this study faced when attempting to negotiate protected sex in
their relationships. She recognized the need for protected sex, but
appeared to lack the capacity to negotiate her demand for the use of a
condom with the man exploiting her sexually. Her statement that she
"decided to stop having sex with him" reveals how some young
women find it extremely difficult to convince their partner to use a
condom and how others had been enduring unprotected sex. It is
interesting to note that Mary found it easier to break up the
relationship instead. This finding is consistent with what has been
observed among other young women in sub-Saharan Africa. In his review of
several studies, Luke (2004) reports that while a number of young women
in many African societies do not often negotiate protected sex, due to
the transactional nature of their relationships, most of them were
significantly involved in negotiating their choices in terms of
disputing requests to start sexual relationship or in terminating them.
As observed in the present study, some of the young women, like Titi,
could decide with whom to have sex or whom to have as a partner, despite
economic constraints.
Additionally, Mary recounts that her decision was first to engage
in protected sex and when this appeared unrealistic, to end the
relationship despite its financial benefits. These young women's
accounts confirm the argument that 'there are no relations of power
without resistance' (Foucault, 1978:142). The issue is to what
extent resistance is effective and what its limitations are. Taking into
account the narratives of many young women like Mary and Titi, one could
observe that their male partners, as financial providers, assumed the
position of power by demanding sex and/or deciding on condom use.
Interestingly, there were considerable levels of resistance by these
young women in the way they decided to avoid further contact with the
men irrespective of their financial dependence on them.
However, this pattern of negotiation was uncommon among young women
in this setting. A further analysis of others' accounts reveals
that most of them chose to continue their relationships for various
reasons. For instance, the third interviewee above, Justina, described
her partner as an 'answer to her prayer' in terms of solving
her financial problems. Thus, even when she felt that her partner was
pestering her for sex, she found it impossible to resist him. A major
implication of this pattern of financial dependence is that the young
women were often subject to sexual exploitation by older men. This is
also exemplified by Banwo's explanation that her customer had a
'stable business' and 'his own apartment' and had
promised to assist her financially. All these aided her decision to
accept his sexual proposal. In her own words, "when we started
having sex, ... I knew it wasn't right, but I didn't resist
because I was so convinced by his promises". This clearly explains
why she could not exercise her agency to negotiate protected sex.
As for the young men, analysis of their accounts reveals that they
tended to engage in the same economic activities as their fathers, such
as farming and repairs. Others were self-employed as transporters or
engaged in skilled or unskilled employment. Such activities appeared to
enable them to meet their economic needs to a reasonable level. Thus,
young men like Lanre and Deolu appeared to be more financially secure
and were well positioned to negotiate their choice of partner. For
instance, when an older schooler was asked if his desires were met in
his relationship, he replied in the following way:
Anthony: Yeah, I'm very pleased and very satisfied because
people used to say that these educated girls would never say yes to
people like us who are not educated ... I decided to work my way to this
girl. You know that with money you can do anything ... I was giving her
what those boys in her school could not. and that was it ... and
we're still together [Male: Older non-schooler, aged 23].
Another young man gave a similar response:
John: I have two girls and I never hide it from either of them ...
because all women want is money. There's no time they ask me for
money that I will not settle them. In fact, they compete to please me,
because they want me to marry them ... [Male: Older non-schooler, 25].
Two of the younger men (aged 16-19) related complementary
experiences in a focus group.
Toks: Most of our women keep running after big men, and the okada
men, because of their money ...
Samuel: Exactly. A friend of mine just broke up with his
girlfriend, because the girl was having an affair with an officer in the
new bank ... She was even bold enough to tell my friend that she's
got a better person who is up to standard ...
The above accounts indicate that economic factors could be a major
influence in the young men's sexual negotiations. They also reveal
the extent to which some of them appeared to be conscious of their
economic power as a prerequisite to negotiating their choice of partner
or acquiring a dominant role in their heterosexual relationships. In
addition, such notions as expressed by Anthony, John and those in the
focus group indicated strongly that the existing gender practices in
heterosexual relations (Holland et al., 1998) are further reinforced by
economic circumstances thereby increasing the exploitation of women by
men through socioeconomic power (Walby, 1990; 1995). Further, as
observed in the above findings, most relationships formed on economic
relations may lack the type of commitment that is required to develop an
intimate relationship, based on emotional, democratic and equal
negotiation (Giddens, 1992).
The narratives of a number of young women and young men indicate
that access to economic resources reinforced male power and encouraged
men to behave in a dominant way towards women, as well as shaping the
choices of sexual partners and the negotiations of both genders.
Moreover, other studies have reported that men who use their
socioeconomic power to persuade young women to engage in sex often
consider such relationships as transactional and in most cases do not
agree to use condoms (Leclerc-Madlala, 2003, Luke, 2003, Longfield et
al., 2004, Nkosana et al., 2007).
Conclusion
The evidence of this study suggests that young people's sexual
practices were largely influenced by different gender-based expectations
and norms, by virtue of their belonging to younger or older age-groups,
and of their economic status. While the young women and men did not
passively adhere to or accept the norms, and values imposed on them by
these different factors, they were constrained in different ways from
engaging in protected sex. For instance, analysis of their responses
reveals that while most participants appeared to accept the norms
applied to young people in their community, such as that of premarital
chastity, they found it difficult to apply these to their own real
situations and practice, due to conflicting social pressures.
These findings are consistent with other studies across the world
that have revealed the extent to which young people's sexuality has
remained contextualized within the normalization of patriarchy,
perpetuating the influence of traditional norms on sex, sexuality and
the capacity to exercise sexual agency (Holland et al., 1998, Izugbara,
2004a; 2004b, Jackson et al., 2004, Maxwell, 2007, Reddy and Dunnes,
2007). While the findings of this research show similarities with many
studies across the world, they also reveal that we should not assume
young people's sexuality as a universal phenomena.
As observed in this study, other social and institutional contexts
impacted on young people's sexuality and sexual negotiations. For
example, the strong social ties of young people with their families and
their communal way of existence impacted their sexuality and
'sexual conduct' in how how they engaged in clandestine
relationships and avoided the use of condoms in order to maintain a
pretence of conformity before their parents, and older adults within the
wider community. It also seems that the conception of being
'young', for example within family and community are indeed
problematic for young people as it constrains their sexuality in
particular ways, even when they do not necessarily agree with that
conception. In addition, unlike the young people in UK contexts surveyed
in the WRAP (Women, Risk and AIDS Project) and MRAP (Men, Risk and AIDS
Project studies, limited economic resources play an especially crucial
role in reinforcing gender inequality and traditional (dominant) male
identities and sexual practices.
References
Alan, B. (2004). Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Beck, U. (1992). Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. London:
Sage.
Caldwell, J. C. (2000). Rethinking the African AIDS epidemic.
Population Development Review, 26(1):117-135.
Connell, R. W. (2002). Gender. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Foucault, M. (1978). The History of Sexuality (Vol. 1: An
Introduction). New York: Pantheon.
Foucault, M. (1980). The History of Sexuality. (Vol. 3), New York,
Pantheon.
Giddens, A. (1991). Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society
in the Late Modern Age. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Giddens, A. (1992). The Transformation of Intimacy: Sexuality,
Love, and Eroticism in Modern Societies. Stanford, CA: Stanford
University Press.
Heaphy, B. (2007). Late Modernity and Social Change: Reconstructing
Social and Personal life. London and New York: Routledge.
Holland, J., Ramazanoglu, C., Sharpe, S. & Thomson, R. (1998).
The Male in the Head: Young People, Heterosexuality and Power. London:
Tufnell Press.
Izugbara, C. O. (2004a). Notions of sex, sexuality and
relationships among adolescent boys in rural South-East Nigeria. Sex
Education, 4(1):63-79.
Izugbara, C. O. (2004b). Patriarchal Ideology and Discourses of
Sexuality. Africa Regional Sexuality Resource Centre. Retrieved on 14th
December, 2013 from http://www.arsrc.org/downloads/uhsss/izugbara.pdf.
Jackson, S. & Scott, S. (2004). Sexual antinomies in late
modernity. Sexualities, 7(2):233-48.
Jamieson, L. (1999). Intimacy transformed: a critical look at the
pure relationship. Sociology, 33(3):477-494.
Krueger, R. (1994). Focus groups: A practical guide for applied
research. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
LeClerc-Madlala, S. (2003). Transactional sex and the pursuit of
modernity. Social Dynamics, 29(2):213-233.
Longfield, K., Glick, A., Waithaka & Berman, J. (2004).
Relationships between older men and younger women: Implications for
STIs/HIV in Kenya. Studies in Family Planning, 35:125-134.
Luke, N. (2003). Age and economic asymmetries in the sexual
relationships of adolescent girls in sub-Saharan Africa. Studies in
Family Planning, 34(2):67-86.
Maxwell, C. (2006). Understanding young women's sexual
relationship experiences: The nature and role of vulnerability. Journal
of Youth Studies, 9(2):141-58.
Maxwell, C. (2007). 'Alternative' narratives of young
people's heterosexual experiences in the UK. Sexualities,
10(5):539-558.
Nkosana, J. & Rosenthal, D. (2007). The dynamics of
intergenerational sexual relationships: The experience of schoolgirls in
Botswana. Sexual Health, 4(3):181-187.
Plummer, K. (1995). Telling Sexual Stories: Power, change and
social worlds. London: Routledge.
Reddy, S. & Dunne, M. (2007). Risking it: Young heterosexual
femininities in South African context of HIV/AIDS. Sexualities,
10(2):159-172.
Selikow, T. (2004). "We have our own special language."
Language, sexuality and HIV / AIDS: A case study of youth in an urban
township in South Africa. African Health Sciences, 4(2):102-108.
Smith, D. J. (2004). Premarital sex, procreation, and HIV risk in
Nigeria. Family Planning, 35(4):223-35.
Walby, S. (1990). Theorizing Patriarchy. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Walby, S. (1997). Gender Transformations. London: Routledge.
by
Ekundayo B. Babatunde, Ph.D.
dayo.astar@yahoo.co.uk
Lecturer, Department of Sociology, Landmark University, Omu-Aran,
Nigeria
&
Babatunde E. Durowaiye
babtee2@yahoo.com
Lecturer, Department of Sociology
Landmark University, Omu-Aran, Nigeria