Innovation and survival: education in rural and regional communities: May 2016.
Kline, Jodie ; Drummond, Aaron
Welcome to the first issue of the Australian and International
Journal of Rural Education for 2016. This release coincides with news
that yet another university is considering closing a regional campus.
The debate about the consequences of demand-driven funding for regional
providers has been raging since 2012. It is now clear that this is
playing a role in rendering regional campuses 'unsustainable'.
The ramifications are significant for rural and regional students who
are traditionally those most likely to be studying on regional campuses;
many of whom are not in a position to study at city-based universities.
While distance education has and will continue to become a viable
alternative for many, retention rates for rural students studying in
this mode suggest that for some it is not an adequate substitute for
face-to-face learning. With this at the fore, it is with pleasure this
issue of AIJRE showcases how teacher education programs in Nauru and New
Zealand are working towards coupling distance learning with localised
knowledge to enhance their programs, and how in the Labrador Straits
researchers are working with communities to improve distance education
experiences for school students. In this issue our authors also: share
findings from a mid-scale quantitative study investigating impacts on
schools students' financial literacy; examine how the subjects
studies in secondary schools are associated with post-secondary study
choices for rural students; examine the impact of fires in four
Australian schools; and share an example of collaborative inquiry and
collaborative reporting between a teacher researcher and university
research about rural languages education.
Bill Ussher's article "Student teachers' placement
experiences in a familiar school setting: Local community partnerships
with a distance ITE program" adds to our understandings of
pre-service teachers' becomings as teachers and the benefits gained
through placement in local communities. Opportunities created through
familiarity for distance education students and the ways in which
schools can become for pre-service teachers a 'village' of
learning are examined.
Penelope Serow, Neil Taylor, Terence Sullivan, Jodana Tarrant, Greg
Burnett, Dianne Smardon, and Emily Angell report on the Nauru Teacher
Education Project, administered by the University of New England to
develop Pacific focused teacher education programs accessible to those
studying teaching in the Republic of Nauru. It describes the use of
Innovative models of teacher education that couple distance and
intensive deliveries. It also provides a robust critique of the
over-valuing of technological methods of learning and investigates how
to best address local issues relating to teacher education, via the use
of a combination of technology, and local knowledge. By discussing the
ways in which some distance education models are incompatible with
localized social and economic infrastructures the reader is granted
insight both into teaching in Nauru and the ways in which an
international partnership can contribute to positive education outcomes
for Nauruan students. As with Ussher, Serow et al. consider the role of
the on-site mentor as a way of facilitating learning via distance.
This theme is also reflected in Dennis Mulcahy, Michael K. Barbour
and Minakshi Lahiri's article "The straight truth about online
learning in the Straits: An investigation into the nature of education
in a rural and remote region of Newfoundland and Labrador". Their
research identifies some of the key issues associated with heavy
reliance on distance education offerings, in this case for school aged
children of the coastal rural communities of Labrador Straits.
Challenges associated with limited opportunities for teacher-student
interactions in online delivery models are discussed as also is the
trend for smaller schools in the region to be those most likely to
utilise distance education programs in place of face-to-face learning
opportunities; those who could not master the demands of distance
learning were found to be left behind. The authors note that this
reveals a shift from the original intent of providing supplementary
programming to the only way for students to attain the academic credits
required for graduation. Community informed recommendations for how to
modify existing teaching and learning models are presented with their
call for equal access to quality education in part addressed through
increased on-site supports and supervision for students taking distance
courses.
In a similar vein, Frances Quinn and Terry Lyons raise questions
about the real subject choice opportunities for rural and regional
secondary school students as a consequence of reduced access to
appropriately qualified and experienced teachers in maths and physical
sciences. They note that the STEM disciplines of engineering that are
significantly more frequently selected by metropolitan students are more
lucrative than Agriculture and Environmental Studies, appear to have
more job openings and are easier to find employment. When read alongside
the article by Mulcahy and colleagues, and the contribution from Ali and
colleagues, these articles begin to paint a picture of how residential
location can impact life choices in complex ways.
Prepared by Paul Ali, Malcolm Anderson, Cosima McRae and Ian
Ramsay, the research underpinning "The financial literacy of young
people: Socioeconomic status, language background, and the rural-urban
chasm" found that, in general, the financial literacy of rural and
regional students was lower than urban students. While this was not the
only factor impacting financial literacy, nor was it the most potent,
rurality was presented as 'adverse' in the analysis raising
for the reader a number of critical questions about why this might be
the case.
Jenny Evans and Anne-Marie Morgan's article offers a fresh
contribution to the teaching languages in rural settings by coupling
teacher researcher and university researcher voice using a sonata form
conversation. It heartening to read of the mutual benefit of the
undertaking and to gain insight into the positives of rural languages
education, insights which will do doubt be of great value to teacher
educators, pre-service teachers and in-services teachers alike.
In the final article for the current issue, Adele Nye shifts our
attention to community rebuilding in the face of school fires, looking
to accounts of school fires in four NSW schools--two rural and two
urban. This paper relies heavily upon textual sources, illustrating how
the Media mediate crises.
We hope that you enjoy this issue of the Australian and
International Journal of Rural Education, and the rural education
research that it chronicles.
Jodie Kline, Aaron Drummond and the Editorial Team