Impact of Work Life Balance on Job Satisfaction: A Study of Married Working Women in Private Banks of NCR.
Saxena, Nidhi ; Narula, Anupam
Impact of Work Life Balance on Job Satisfaction: A Study of Married Working Women in Private Banks of NCR.
Introduction
In today's competitive and fast paced environment where the
number of dual career couples is progressively increasing and the
support of the joint family is going away, Balance is the key to lead a
successful and beautiful personal life. Today Men and Women both
employees are struggling hard to manage their professional and personal
lives. Women professionals find it difficult to fulfill demands of the
family and society and at the same time do justice to the demands of
their profession at workplace. Research suggests that professionals are
experiencing a time squeeze, and demographics suggest that this is not
going to go away. In this challenging environment, balancing both career
and family is a difficult task for working women thus women employees
face a dual burden-work and family- which creates a lot of stress and
role conflict. Now each and every individual has to balance conflicting
responsibilities and commitments; work-life balance has emerged as a
major issue in the workplace. Work-life imbalance usually arises out of
a lack of adequate time, support to manage work commitments as well as
personal and family responsibilities. Meeting competing demands of work
and family is not only tiring but can be stressful and can lead to
sickness and absenteeism. It adversely affects productivity. It has
become a critical factor for bringing individual and organizational
success. Work-life balance is best accomplished when an
individual's right to a fulfilled life, both inside and outside
paid work, is accepted and respected as the norm, to the mutual benefit
of the individual, business, and society.
Literature Review
In recent year the number of studies has address Work-life balance
with different perspective, because it is one of the most challenging
issues being faced by the employees in the 21st century. According to
Nair, 2010 maintaining work life balance for women were found to be more
challenging because they have to undertake the majority of the house
hold duties along with their professional tasks. The personal and
professional lives of women employees' are just like the two sides
of the same coin. Compromising one for the other or spending more time
pursuing one as opposed to the other can have serious negative
repercussions. Work Life balance is not something that just happens. It
is an evolutionary change which involves efforts of each and every
employee, organization for whom they works and Society where they live.
(N. Gayathri and Dr. P. Karthikeyan, 2013).
The Peters, Montgomery, Bakker & Schaufeli (2005), analyzed
that pressures from the job and family domains are often mismatched, It
gives rise to imbalance. Earlier, the female workforce in India was
mainly employed in non-managerial or low-profile positions. But now,
they occupy almost all categories of positions in the workplace due to
which extra and more duties and responsibilities towards have added.
Job satisfaction is important technique used to motivate the
employees to work with commitment and project a positive image of the
organization. The term job satisfaction refers to the attitude and
feelings people have about their work. The author Armstrong, 2006 state
that Positive and favorable attitudes towards the job indicate job
satisfaction and Negative and unfavorable attitudes towards the job
indicate job dissatisfaction. Managers have important role in
encouraging employees to manage their work therefore a strong
relationship is exists between work life balance and employee
satisfaction, so companies should make policies and programs for
employees on work life balance. Today Managers can apply different roles
of leadership to manage work life balance and provide success to the
company (Rani et al, 2011). When employees are not clear about their
roles to be performed then employees are unable to meet organizational
goals and it affect the personal life and employees become dissatisfied
towards their job and organization faces lack of effectiveness.
A comparative study was conducted by Rajesh K. Yadav and
NishantDabhade(2014) to analyse the Work Life Balance and Job
Satisfaction among the Working Women of Banking and Education Sector.
The research shows that women employees working in banks for financial
support generally faces life challenges than the education sector.
Working hours are satisfactory but sometimes late working and working in
evening branches in banks interrupts work life balance and the
work-loads are not equal between colleagues. Banks should introduce job
sharing option in which full-time post is split across two workers who
agree on working hours decided in between them and career breaks
(paid/unpaid). Somewhere in banking sector employees are dissatisfied or
resist the change. So some workshops on motivating staff on the reason
for change should be done and the economic benefits associated with
change as well as how staff would benefit from these changes should be
communicated properly in order to increase the job satisfaction.
The study conducted by Maren et al. (2013) to analyze work-life
balance and job satisfaction among teachers exposed a negative
relationship between work-life conflicts and job satisfaction. The study
suggested that if organizations offer facilities to reduce work-life
conflicts, it will lead to improvement in employees' job
satisfaction. Chahal et al. (2013) suggested to increase the efficiency
of the employee's bank should timely appraise their employees and
encourage them to work hard because satisfied employees are reason for
the success of the organization. When employees were satisfied with
their jobs they become loyal and committed to the organization. Saleem
et al (2013) suggested that organization should make strategies and
policies that will help employees to have clear understanding regarding
their job tasks and objectives and if employees were not satisfied with
their job they would not pay attention to their work and would not make
customers happy.
K. Thriveni Kumari and Dr. V. Rama Devi (2013) in their research
paper namely "Work- Life Balance of Women Employees--A Challenge
for The Employee and The Employer in 21st Century" suggested that
Work life balance is one of the most challenging issues being faced by
the women employees in the 21st century because of the type of roles
they played at home and the spillover of personal life over work life.
The study concluded that Work-life balance initiatives designed to help
employees balance their work and personal lives were not only an option,
but also a necessity for many employers. There is a need for
organizations to adopt human resource strategies and policies that
accommodate the work-life needs of a diverse workforce in the current
business environment.
Gururaja, UmeshMaiya, Elsa Sanatombi Devi and Anice George (2013)
have analyzed the 'Perceptions and Attitude towards Quality of
Work-life Balance among nursing teachers' by conducting a
descriptive survey among 67 nursing faculty towards their perceptions
and attitude towards quality of Work-Life. This study has concluded that
the work-life balance and job satisfaction were directly linked.
Satisfaction in one's own area of work can lead to a satisfying
career.
In many organizations human resource managers evaluate personnel
practices to increase employee loyalty toward the organization. In
addition many organizations have begun to take a role in developing
quality of work-life programs. (Sakthivel Rania, 2011) found that
recognition was linked with work/life balance, which leads to employee
satisfaction and the effects of recognition for the employee
contribution are reflected in their satisfaction. Work task and work
life are positive related. Pay is related to mediating factor of
work/life balance which ends up in employee satisfaction. Benefits are
highly correlated to work life balance. Better benefits programs leads
to employee satisfaction. Today human resource has concluded that there
is strong relationship between employee satisfaction and business. In
result organization focus on developing policies and programs on work
life issues. Employees feel more satisfaction with their work and family
when they enjoy the benefits of work life balance programs provided by
their employers. (Yutaka Ueda, 2012) Conclude that work life balance
programs have different effects for male and female employees. Male
employees are satisfied with all the three measures such as job, work
life balance program and employer. But female employees have a
significant relationship only with employer satisfaction. Work life
balance programs have greater effects for employees of higher income as
compared to lower income.
The study conducted by R.K Yadav, 2014 concluded that work can
dominate your life. Recognizing what is important and necessary and
striving for what is valued will make a work-life balance feasible.
Utilizing management skills will enable you to have a job satisfaction
and balance between work and home life. For the employers, work-life
balance and job satisfaction of employees will be an important input in
designing appropriate policies.
Purpose of the Study
The working roles of women in India is changing at incredible pace
due to progressive reduction in trade barriers, modern innovation in
technologies, globally interconnected market place, cut throat
competition and business rivalry and changing family and population
patterns. These factors bring out tense anxiety into the life of the
women and then it is magnified many times if both the husband-wife work
and they have children of growing age and old age parents. This constant
worry can cause disorder on the psychological comfort of the women.
Apart from it there is variety of factors that make women employee feel
positive or negative about their job. A positive and healthy employee
oriented culture translates into increased job satisfaction and
productivity while work life imbalance causes relationship degradation
and job dissatisfaction. The purpose of this study was to examine the
impact of work life balance on job satisfaction among married women of
private banks of NCR and also test the relationship between the various
organizational factors of work life balance.
Objectives of the Study
In particular, the study has been conducted based on the following
research objectives:
* To find the Impact of work life balance on overall job
satisfaction among married working women in Private banks of NCR.
* To find the association between various organizational factors of
WLB including (Work Load, Work Autonomy, Social Support at workplace,
Work family conflict, WLB Policies) of work life balance and job
satisfaction among married women working in banking sector.
* To find the challenges associated with married women in managing
balance between professional and personal life.
Conceptual Framework
A conceptual framework has been developed by providing visual
representations of theoretical constructs (variables) for finding
relationships amongst them. According to this study Job satisfaction is
the dependent variables and Work life balance & its Organizational
factors are the independent variables. Work life Balance is the main
independent variable, which is measured on the basis of different
organizational factors and its impact on Job Satisfaction.
The Authors are interested to find whether there is a relationship
between Work-life Balance and overall Job Satisfaction. This will be
tested by testing the following hypothesis:
[H.sub.01]: There is no relationship between Work load and Job
Satisfaction.
[H.sub.a1]: There is relationship between Work load and Job
Satisfaction.
[H.sub.02]: There is no relationship between Work Autonomy and Job
Satisfaction.
[H.sub.a2]: There is relationship between Work Autonomy and Job
Satisfaction.
[H.sub.03]: There is no relationship between Social support at
workplace and Job Satisfaction.
Ha3: There is relationship between Social support at workplace and
Job Satisfaction.
[H.sub.04]: There is a no relationship between Work family conflict
and Job Satisfaction.
[H.sub.a4]: There is a relationship between Work family conflict
and Job Satisfaction.
[H.sub.05]: There is no relationship between Work-life Balance
Policies and Job Satisfaction.
[H.sub.a5]: There is relationship between Work-life Balance
Policies and Job Satisfaction.
Research Methodology
Research Design
In the Proposed research, relationship between work-life balance
and its variables with Job Satisfaction among married women working in
the banks of NCR is investigated through Multistage and convenience
sampling method. Methodologically, the study. can be characterized as
exploratory as well as Descriptive in nature.
Data Collection Method
For collecting the primary responses a structured questionnaire was
designed to extract information about the objectives. The respondents
were asked to judge the factors/statements describing employees'
job satisfaction towards their job. Each statement had to be rated by
the respondent on a five point Likert type scale of 1 to 5. The
statements were measured on a scale of "strongly agree" to
"strongly disagree" where the former had a score of 1 and the
latter, a score of 5." Apart from this, the data would also be
collected through personal interviews and telephonic conversation with
the branch head, Managers etc. The interviews were taken in an
unstructured form and further analysis/outcome has been suitably
presented. The interviews were quite revealing and presented a deep
insight about the issues related to Work Life Balance and the challenges
associated with married women in managing balance between professional
and personal life. This covered generally the main thrust/or strong
points and weak links of the female employees as well as core
competencies of banking sector to have a greater understanding.
The secondary data was collected through annual reports of banks
available in Indian Bank Association website, RBI website, Books and
Journals. The secondary sources were used to understand the conceptual
framework and previous researches related to work life balance and job
satisfaction. These sources helped to understand the nature of earlier
studies, to know the research gap as well as the scope for future
studies.
Population of Study
The population for the study consisted of only married female
employees working in different functional areas of private banks of NCR.
Sample Design
The sample of 150 married female employees, working in private
banks were chosen from NCR and out of these 125 complete responses were
received. The NCR is consisting of various sub regions and each sub
region is consisting of various districts. In the research the
multistage and convenience sampling were used for selection of sample.
Through multistage sampling various districts were selected from
different sub regions like from Haryana sub region - Gurgaon and
Faridabad districts, from Uttar Pradesh sub region - Noida, Greater
Noida and Ghaziabad and then through convenience sampling the sample is
made up of employees who were accessible.
Analysis and Results
The analyses consisted of three stages using Microsoft excel
software. The first stage was to analysis the demographic profile of
respondents. The second stage of the analyses was the conducting of
reliability estimates to ensure consistency. The correlation analyses
was conducted, which measures how well the variables positively relate
to one another. In this study, correlation was used to test the main and
subhypothesis, as per the objective1and objective 3. The third stage of
the analysis of the conceptual model was through regression analysis and
enabled to examine the hypothesized relationships shown in the
conceptual model.
In Stage 1, the demographic status of married women in Private
Banks of NCR was analyzed. Out of total figure of 125 respondents the
qualification status was that 79 percent were postgraduate and 21
percent were graduate. Furthermore 50 percent were those who had more
than 5 years of experience in banking sector and their family type was
single, 32 percent females were having one child. Employment status
reflects that 87 percent women were permanent whereas only 13 percent
were working on ad-hoc basis.
The designation of 68 percent women were of Middle level i.e.
Assistant Manager in various functional unit of banks and 26 percent
women belonged to lower level of management i.e. Single window operator,
cashier, front office executive. Out of total 45 percent women employees
have monthly salary range between 20-35k, 37 percent employees have
salary range between 35k-50k and 12 percent employees have salary range
between 50-75k and 6 percent women belongs to top level i.e. Manager,
Branch Head.
In Stage 2 the correlation analysis among different organizational
factors of work life balance are measured. It measures how well the
variables related to one another. The result shows that a strong
relationship exists among all five variables.
The stage 3 of the analysis shown in Table-1 above, the conceptual
model was tested through regression analysis and enabled to examine the
five hypothesized relationships shown above in the conceptual model.
The first factor W.L in the above Table-1 shows that p value is
.0022 which is less than .05 (P < .05) hence the null hypothesis H01
is rejected and Ha1 is accepted. The output shows that work load is
related to Job Satisfaction (r=0.985, P < .05) and the coefficient is
1.8553 which shows that there is significant impact of work load factor
on job satisfaction. R2 is 0.971 this value tells us that how much of
variability in job satisfaction can be explained by work load factor. We
can say that work load accounts for 97 percent of the variability in job
satisfaction. Hence it is concluded that banks should reduce work load
among married women to increase job satisfaction and can allocate job
duties according to women's skills. They can also enrich job of
women employees to motivate them by giving them increased responsibility
and variety in their jobs.
The second factor W.A of work life balance in the above table shows
that p value is .1114 which is greater than .05 (P > .05) hence the
null hypothesis H02 is accepted and Ha2 is rejected. The output shows
that there is relationship between work autonomy and Job satisfaction
but its insignificant (r=0.791, P > .05). R2 is 0.625 this value
tells us that how much of variability in job satisfaction can be
explained by work autonomy factor. We can say that work autonomy
accounts for 62 percent of the variability in job satisfaction. Hence it
is concluded that banks should pay attention to work autonomy among
married women employees to increase job satisfaction. During research it
was also found that more independence in a job leads to higher job
satisfaction, commitment, involvement at workplace.
The third factor SSW of work life balance in the above table shows
that p value is .2944 which is greater than .05 (P > .05) hence the
null hypothesis H03 is accepted and Ha3 is rejected. The output shows
that there is relationship between social support at work place and Job
satisfaction but it's insignificant (r=0.591, P > .05). R2 is
0.349 this value tells us that how much of variability in job
satisfaction can be explained by social support at work place factor. We
can say that social support at work place accounts for 35 percent of the
variability in job satisfaction. Hence it is concluded that social
support at work place is not a major factor affecting job satisfaction
for married women employees in NCR region.
The fourth factor W.F.C of work life balance in the above table
shows that p value is .4076 which is greater than .05 (P > .05) hence
the null hypothesis H04 is accepted and Ha4 is rejected. The output
shows that there is relationship between Work life balance policies and
Job satisfaction but its insignificant (r=0.485, P > .05). R2 is
0.235 this value tells us that how much of variability in job
satisfaction can be explained by work family conflict factor. We can say
that work family conflict accounts for 23.5 percent of the variability
in job satisfaction. Hence it is concluded that work family conflict is
not major significant factor for job satisfaction of married women
employees working in banks of NCR region.
The fifth factor WLBP's of work life balance in the above
table shows that p value is .0194 which is less than .05 (P < .05)
hence the null hypothesis H05 is rejected and Ha5 is accepted. The
output shows that work life balance policies have significant impact on
Job satisfaction (r=0.936, P < .05). R2 is 0.876 this value tells us
that work life balance policies accounts for 87.6 percent of the
variability in job satisfaction. Hence it is concluded that work life
balance polices is major significant factor for job satisfaction of
married women employees working in banks of NCR region. It was also
found in research that women employees from different age groups have
different perceptions regarding WLBP's. They are satisfied with
overall work life balance but not satisfied with the work life balance
policies of banking sector, they need flexible work hours, work from
home, job sharing schemes, creche facilities, and necessary breaks so
that they can fulfill their dual responsibility and able to coordinate
the family and professional life. The Banks should organize special
training programs for women at all levels, It should be related to
safety and security measures during fieldwork, soft skill and technical
training, Managerial leadership skills enhancement training etc for
better productivity, service skill and better interaction with customers
and various stakeholders.
Conclusions and Recommendations
The purpose of this study was to examine the impact of work life
balance on job satisfaction of married women in private sector banks of
NCR region and to identify which factor of work life balance have more
influence on employee job satisfaction. The research findings show that
work load and work life balance policies have significant impact on
employee job satisfaction and other three factors of work life balance
such as work autonomy, social support at work and work life conflict
have relation with employee job satisfaction but are insignificant in
designing banking policies.
It is recommended that efficient and effective HR system is
required which will focus on work life balance and introduce innovative
people practices like family friendly policies or work-life benefits and
programmes which allows employees to maintain healthy work-life balance.
These practices were not only help employees to better manage their work
and family roles but also affect employee attitude and behaviors towards
organization which will lead to increase job satisfaction,
organizational commitment and decreases the intention to quit.
Limitations of Study
* The target population of this research was only the married
female employees of Private Banks so; the scope of this research is
limited.
* Due to heavy workload, time constraint and demonetization of
money, employees were not able to discuss more issues of H.R system of
banking sector.
* The sample was collected from specific geographical areas so it
was difficult to generalize the result.
References
Adikaram.D.S.R. (2016). Impact of Work Life Balance on employee job
satisfaction in private sector commercial banks of Sri Lanka.
International Journal of Scientific Research and Innovative Technology,
3, 11.
David. S., & Panchanatham. N. (2013). A Review on work life
balance among working woman, man in India, Serials Publications, 96
(12), 5443-5452.
Greenhaus, J. H., Collins, K. M., & Shaw, J. D. (2003). The
relation between work-family balance and quality of life. Journal of
Vocational Behavior, 63, 510-531.
Kumari, Thriveni. K., & Devi, Rama, V. (2013). Work-life
balance of women employees--A challenge for the employee and the
employer in 21st Century. Pacific Business Review International, 6,
33-40.
Marks, S. R., & MacDermid, S. M. (1996). Multiple roles and the
self: A theory of role balance. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 58
(2), 417-432.
Peeters C.W. Maria. (2005). Balancing work and home: How job and
home demands are related to burnout. International Journal of Stress
Management, 12 (1), 43-61.
Ranga. Priyanka., & Vohra.P.S. (2016). Work-Life Balance of
public banking professional--relationship analysis. International
Journal of Marketing, Financial Services & Management Research, 5,
49-67.
Rania, Sakthivel, Kamalanabhanb., & Selvarania. (2011). Work
life balance reflections on employee satisfaction. Serbian Journal of
Management, 6 (1), 85-96.
Shujat, Sobia., & Cheema -E-Azam (2011). Impact of work life
balance on employee Job Satisfaction in private banking sector of
Karachi. Journal of Management and Social Sciences, 7 (2), 08-15.
Sudha.J., & Karthikeyan.P. (2014). Work Life Balance of women
employee: A literature review. International Journal of Management
Research & Review, 4 (8), 797-804.
Yadav, K. Rajesh., & Dabhade, Nishant. (2014). Work life
Balance and job Satisfaction among the working women of banking and
education sector--A comparative study. International Letters of Social
and Humanistic Sciences, 21, 181-201.
Nidhi Saxena
Research Scholar, Uttarakhand Technical University, Dehradun.
Anupam Narula
Associate Professor, FORE School of Management, New Delhi.
Paper received in January 2018
Revised paper received in April 2018
Paper accepted in April 2018
Caption: Figure 1 Conceptual Framework
Table-1
Pearson Correlation Result for Five Organizational Factors of Work
Life balance
Regression Output r [r.sup.2] p-Value Coefficient
Work Load (WL) 0.985 0.971 .0022 1.8553
Work Autonomy (WA) 0.791 0.625 .1114 1.1391
Social support at 0.591 0.349 .2944 0.6854
workplace(SSW)
Work family 0.485 0.235 .4076 0.6017
conflict (WFC)
Work-life Balance 0.936 0.876 .0194 1.2588
Policies (WLBPs)
The confidence interval is taken at 95 percent level.
Source: Authors Research Analysis
COPYRIGHT 2018 Foundation for Organisational Research & Education
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2018 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.