Women in Prison and Their Information Needs: South--South Prison Libraries Perspective.
Sambo, Atanda S. ; Lauretta, Nnebuogor
Women in Prison and Their Information Needs: South--South Prison Libraries Perspective.
Introduction
Prisoners are people who are incarcerated in prisons and denied
freedom of movement due to crimes they have committed. In most countries
around the world, the majority of individuals who make up the prison and
jail population have limited education and life skills and do not come
from a background where reading is carried out (IFLA, 2005). In the
Nigerian context, prison inmates are made up of convicted persons who
are sentenced to serve various terms for crimes committed, and often a
larger number of Awaiting Trial Persons (ATP), who may spend many years
in this condition (Amnesty International 2008). The fact that the
prisoners are incarcerated restricts them from free movement and a full
social life. Most importantly, they are restricted in getting
information from the outside world.
Every individual requires one form of information or the other to
satisfy an information need. Women inmates are individuals who have been
cut off from their local environment and kept in custody as a result of
crimes committed and separated from the larger society. Whether or not
inmates are on short or long term jail, rehabilitation and reformation
is a necessity in the Nigerian prison sector. Prison libraries provide
an important means of self-improvement for inmates. They act as a
supplement to educational programs and lead to better work opportunity
which in turn creates more stable and productive citizens. Oreh (2006)
rightly observed that education in prison is necessary because its
provision will make the prisons become places of continuous and informal
learning rather than schools of crimes.
Bastick and Townhead (2008) argue that women prisoners are
discriminated against as compared to male prisoners in almost every
aspect of prison life including decisions as to pre-trial detention,
opportunities for education and employment and healthcare Information
needs of prisoners are information that are wanted or desired, despite
the fact that the information needs of inmates vary. Prisoners have the
same information needs as persons in the regular society. The relevance
of information need for the prison population has been documented in
several literatures Burt (1977), Campbell (2005), and Medina (2000) as
quoted by Emasealu (2010) described the information needs of inmates to
be information on health related issues, information on how to find
solution to situational problems, information on educational
opportunities, information on how to cope in prison and psychological
information needs. Incarcerated persons have the same reading interest
and information needs like other citizens in the society.
Presently, there is no study on prisoner's women and their
information needs in South- South Prison Libraries, Nigeria, thus the
need to carry out this study to gather a broad insight on the needs of
the women in prison with a view to contributing to the wealth of
knowledge, literature and to improving their condition, identify the
challenges they face while meeting their needs and proffer possible
solutions to them. Finally, findings on prisoner women in prison can be
used to guide the formulation of comprehensive prison reform in
generally and intervention programs for women and men in South-South
Prison.
Objectives of the Study
This study sought to establish ways of enhancing the information
needs of the women in prison. To attain this goal, the study stipulated
the following objectives:
1. To determine the information needs of the women in prison
2. To examine the condition of the South-South prison libraries.
3. To know the extent to which the South-South prison libraries are
meeting the information needs of the prisoners women
4. To establish the challenges confronting women in prison
Research Questions
For the purpose of this research, the following questions have been
formulated:
1. What are the information needs of the women in prison?
2. What are the condition of the South-South Prison Libraries?
3. To what extent the South-South prison libraries are meeting the
information needs of the prisoner's women?
4. What are the challenges confronting women in prison?
Literature Review
An information need is recognition that one's knowledge is
inadequate to satisfy a goal (LISWiki, 2015). Information needs leads to
search and demand for information to meet the required gap. A lot of
studies have been conducted on the prisoners and their information needs
in the Western world. This was recognized in IFLA (2005) which said that
an incarcerated person has not relinquished the right to learn and to
access information. Though restrictions are imposed on the access to
certain information usually when such access is known to present a
danger to prison security, the fact remains that prisoners have their
own information needs. The World Health Organisation (1999) stressed the
need for prisoners to have access to health care, including prevention
measures equivalent to that available in the community. This denotes the
prisoners' health information needs. The condition of most prisons;
for instance overcrowding make the prisoners prone to a lot of health
hazards. This obviously makes information about health and hygiene,
prevention and cure of common diseases like air-borne and water-borne
diseases vital to the prisoners and essential for their survival in the
prison. Campbell (2006) further maintained that any legal information,
that an inmate can apply to his/her situation can mean relief from poor
conditions if not from incarceration itself.
Similarly, Womboh (1991) revealed that most of the prisoners (about
76%) were not educated beyond school certificate. Only about 24% of them
acquired education higher than that. The inmates' educational level
is a major factor to be considered in providing library and information
services to them. The prisoners in the different groups from all the
prisons alike, admitted having dire need for information that can give
them spiritual and emotional stability so as to be in good terms with
God and man and become better citizens of the society. Ajogwu (2005) in
Nigeria noted, that the prisoners' information needs include
religious and spiritual needs amongst others. Just as Dike (2002) and
IFLA (2005) noted, the prisoners need spiritual information materials to
attain emotional stability and better life style.
A study conducted by Sambo, Usman & Rabiu (2017) showed that
the information needs of prisoners covered health conditions/financial
(99%), spiritual and moral (88%), life after prison/ information on
legal issues (86%), family/friends (68%), literacy education (65%),
skill acquisition (63%), right in prison (42%), prison rules (34%), and
others information needs (26%). More so, in the same study, majority
(85%) of the respondents found libraries condition inadequate. Likewise,
IFLA (2005) stated that the prison library collection should include
materials in print and other formats to meet the informational,
educational, cultural, recreational, and rehabilitative needs of the
prison population.
Women in prison require specialised resources and attention with
respect to diet, exercise, clothing, medication and medical care (Women
in Prison Project Group, 2007). However it is argued that the prison
environment is incompatible with the needs and care of women body. It is
more difficult to catch up on missed sleep and missed meals due to the
inflexibility of the prison regime while alerting staff to a medical
problem may be difficult, particularly at night (Women in Prison Project
Group, 2007). Additionally, although the responsibility for prison
health care was transferred from the Prison Service to the NHS in April
2006, which in theory means that prisoners should have access to the
same range and quality of services as are available to the general
population, this has not necessarily been effective and efficiency
utilized by prisoners women in Nigeria.
Women are more likely to lose their housing while in custody in
comparison to men (Loucks, 2004). Corston (2007) states that at least
30% of women in prison lose their homes during incarceration, although
some would say this is a conservative figure which is more likely to be
almost 40% (Davies, 2011). This may be explained by the fact that women
are more often single parents and have tenancy agreements in their own
names while men are more likely to have a partner at home to maintain
the tenancy (Loucks, 2004). A lack of accommodation has significant
implications for the lives of women on release. Often during the process
of possession of a property, the contents, or more specifically, the
occupiers' possessions, are disposed of. This can make the early
stages of release particularly difficult and unsettling. Also, many
women are unable to regain their children from care without suitable
accommodation yet this is made difficult but that fact that they often
cannot get access to housing in the first place without being the main
carer of their children (Social Exclusion Unit, 2002). According to
(Penal Reform International, 2007) that women in prison frequently come
from deprived backgrounds, and many have experienced physical and sexual
abuse, alcohol and drug dependence and inadequate health care before
imprisonment. In addition, Human Rights Watch Women's Rights
Project documented custodial misconduct in many forms including verbal
degradation, rape, sexual assault, unwarranted visual supervision,
denying goods and privileges, and use or threat of force. "Male
correctional officers and staff contribute to a custodial environment in
state prisons for women which is often highly sexualized and excessively
hostile" (Human Rights Watch Women's Rights Project, 1996).
Although women are a minority in national prison populations all
over the world, the female prison population is increasing. This
increase in women's imprisonment is part of a global trend towards
the increasing popularity and use of imprisonment and a corresponding
under use of constructive alternative, non-custodial sanctions. Further,
the rate of increase in the number of women in prison is much greater
than that for men (Bastick, 2005). For instance, in England and Wales,
the number of women in prison has increased by more than 200% in the
past 10 years versus a 50% increase in the number of men in prison
during the same period (Prison Reform Trust, 2006).
In 2009, the National Association of Women Judges disclosed that
women, including pregnant women, in federal prisons were receiving
unacceptable health care (Saar, 2010). The Federal Bureau of Prisons
(BOP) has developed policies that exclude routine use of restraints
during labour and delivery ("Facts," 2014). However,
information is lacking regarding the implementation of this policy
(Saar, 2010). Further, only 21 states have passed similar laws
("Facts," 2014).
A special report by the Bureau of Justice Statistics (2006) based
on a survey of prisoners found that female inmates had much higher rates
of mental health problems than male inmates. An estimated 73% of females
in State prisons, compared to 55% of male's inmates had a mental
problem. In Federal prisons, the rate was 61% of females compared to 44%
of males; and in local jails, 75% of females compared to 63% of male
inmates. Further, 62% of white females, 20% of black females and 22 % of
Hispanic females in State prison were identified as mentally ill. Nearly
four in ten white female inmates aged twenty-four or younger were
mentally ill.
The prisoners also complained bitterly about the strictness of the
prison security policies on reading materials. They said that many
information resources are not allowed into the prison because of
security and this affects their reading rights. This agreed with what
Singer (2000); Shirley (2003) and (2007) lamented, that many prison
functionaries whimsically try to stop entry of materials in the library
on the basis that it may be harmful to the security of the institution
and mental health of the inmates.
In the case of Nigeria, findings further showed that the
uncomfortable nature of prisons coupled with prison policies and laws
militate against meeting of the prisoners 'women information needs
through library and information resources and services. This is in line
with what Lehmann (2000) and Singer (2000) stressed, that the library
programme does not function independently but operates within the larger
prison environment, whose mission and security policies often conflict
with the library professional code of ethics and its belief in free
access to information.
Methodology
The study adopted a descriptive survey using questionnaire and
interview to collect data. Also, three research assistants who were
prison staff in each of the prisons. This is due to the restrictive
nature and security constraints tied to the Nigerian Prison Service. A
total of three hundred and fifty six respondents comprise of South-
South Prisons in Nigeria were selected for the study. The prisons are:
Akwa-Ibom State prison, Bayelsa State prison, Edo State prison, Cross
river State prison, River State prison and Delta State prison. As shown
in table 1 was the population and sample of the study.
The purposive sampling technique was used for this study. This
technique also known as judgmental, selective or subjective sampling is
that sampling technique where the units that are investigated as based
on the judgement of the researcher (Egbule and Okobia, 2001). Therefore
the sample size is 356. The data collected for the study were analysed
using descriptive and inferential statistics. Simple percentage was used
to analyse the respondents' characteristics and the research
questions. A total of 356 copies of the questionnaire were distributed
and 306 (86%) copies of the questionnaire were retrieved. The response
rate of (86%) is considered adequate for the study because the standard
and acceptable rate for most studies is 60%.
Research Findings and Discussion
Table. 2, shows that Akwa-Ibom State Prison topped the highest
(21%) of the women in South-South Prison, followed by Cross River State
Prison (19%), Delta State Prison (18%), Edo State Prison/Rivers State
Prison (17%) and Bayelsa State Prison (8%). This represents the
prisoners women involved in the survey.
Results in Table 3, shows that majority 37% of the respondents had
secondary school, 33% primary school certificate, 11% polytechnic, 8%
technical college, 6% college of education, 5% university degree. This
is supported by Womboh (1991) revealed that most of the prisoners (about
76%) were not educated beyond school certificate. Only about 24% of them
acquired education higher than that. The inmates' educational level
is a major factor to be considered in providing library and information
services to them.
As indicated in Table 4, 98% of respondent's medical
information, 97% education information/security, 86% life after
prison/spiritual and moral, 84% financial information, 82%
family/friends, 72% information on legal issues, 61% right in prison,
36% skill acquisition and 22% others information needs. This is agreed
with World Health Organisation (1999) stressed the need for prisoners to
have access to health care, including prevention measures equivalent to
that available in the community.
Table 5, shows that majority 70% of respondents found prison
libraries condition inadequate for meeting their needs, 20% found them
adequate and 10% no response. This is against prisoners rules. The
recognition of the prisoners' right to information is contained in
the United Nations (Rule 40) Standard Minimal Rules for the Treatment of
Prisoners of 1955 (IFLA 2005). This states that every institution shall
have an adequately stocked library for use of all categories of
prisoners and the prisoners shall be encouraged to use it.
Table 6, revealed that counselling 73% topped the highest way of
meeting information needs of women in South- South prison, followed by
67% family/friends and mosque/church, 58% physician/Nurses, 32% prison
staff, 21% books/newspaper/magazine 17% radio/television broad cast, 14%
libraries and 10% others. Libraries which supposed to be the highest
information providers are lack behind. This could be as a result of poor
funding of the libraries and prisons as a whole.
From Table 7, it is clear that the factors affecting the
prisoner's women information needs is congestion/lack of hygiene /
poor funding of the prison 96%, lack of medication / health care 91%,
lack of security 89%, lack of accommodation after released 78%, lack of
time to interact with family/ friends 77%, sexual abuse/excessive
prolonged use and pre-trial detention 75%, lack of training/lack of
special treatment for women 66%, mental health problem 61%, illegal
activities 55%, lack of policies to protect pregnant women 38% and 24%
others problems.
Conclusion
Certain conclusion can be drawn from the study: Women in prison and
their information needs were vary which can be provided for through
library and information services. The prison library is in the best
position to provide the prisoners information needs. Meanwhile, prison
libraries in Nigeria had not meet up with this challenges. This study
brought into lime-light the needs of the Federal, State and
administrator to look into prison libraries in Nigeria and South-South
prison libraries in particular so as to achieving the objectives of
modern day imprisonment thus- rehabilitation, re-socializing and
re-integrating as well as to preparing the prisoners to becoming better
citizen who can readapt into the society after prison.
In view of the foregoing, the following recommendations are made:
1. Government should ensure that prison policies and programmes are
specifically tailored to the needs of women, including those in the
areas of resettlement.
2. Timely access to all services available for women outside prison
should be available for women inside prison. As with all prisoners,
confidentiality of medical records should always be guaranteed.
3. Needs of women in prison should be tackled by taking advantage
of the time they are in prison to provide education about preventing
illness and maintaining good health, especially HIV and other sexually
transmitted infections. Further, vocational and job training programmes
should be offered.
4. Government should ensure that prison policies and programmes are
specifically tailored to the needs of women, including those in the
areas of resettlement.
5. The prisoners should be encouraged to use libraries by making
libraries conducive and adequately stocked with current materials for
all categories of prisoners.
6. Women in prison should always have access to condoms as well as
dental dams, given the possibility of sex within prisons. As a basic
rule, however, sex involving staff and prisoners should be prohibited
under all circumstances.
References
Ajogwu, M. (2005). The role of Non-governmental Organisations,
(NGOs) in providing library and information services to two
disadvantaged groups--the blind and the prisoners in Nigeria.
Unpublished Master's Degree Project of the University of Nigeria,
Department of Library and Information Science.
Amnesty International (2008). Prisoners' rights systematically
flouted. London: Amnesty International.
Bastick, M (2005). A commentary on the standard minimum rules for
the treatment of prisoners. Geneva, Quaker United Nations Office.
Bastick, M. and Townhead, L. (2008) Women in Prison: A Commentary
on the UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners. Geneva:
Quaker United Nations Office
Bruce, H, (2005). Personal, anticipated information need.
Information Research.10 (3).
Burt, C.N (1977). Information Needs of Inmates. Available at
http://www.ideas.illinois.Edu/Bistream/Handle/2142/6945/Librarytrends/
26ild_opt.pdf? Sequence=1. Retrieved 13th May 2011.
Campbell, D.K (2005). The Context of the Information Behavior of
Prison Inmates. Professional Librarian Issue Number 26.
Campbell, D. (2006). The context of the information behaviour of
prison Inmates.
Progressive Librarian. 26 (1) 1-12. Retrieved on December 12, 2008
from connection.ebscohost.com/.../context-information-behaviour-.--Cached.
Corston, J. (2007). The Corston Report: A review of women with
particular vulnerabilities in the Criminal Justice System. London: Home
Office www.internetjournalofcriminology.com 26
Davies, P. (2011) Gender, Crime and Victimisation. London: Sage
Publishing
Dike, V.W. (2002). Prison library services in Nigeria. Journal of
Librarianship and Information Sc. 2 (1) 26- 37.
Egbule, J.F. and Okobia, D.O. (2001). Research method in education
for colleges and universities, Agbor Kmensuo Educational Publishers.
Emasealu, H.U (2010) Information Needs, Accessibility and
Utilization of Library Resources as Determinants of Psychological
Wellbeing of Prison Inmates in Nigeria (Unpublished PhD Prefield
Seminar) Available at
http://Xa.yimg.com/kq/groups/22150699/564789630/name/PREFIELD. Retrieved
12thJune 2012
Facts. (2014). Birthing Behind Bars. Retrieved 2015, April 20, from
http://nationinside.org/campaign/birthing-behindbars/facts/
Human Rights Watch Women's Rights Project. (1996). All too
familiar: Sexual abuse of women in U.S. state prisons. New York: Human
Rights Watch.
International Federation of Library Association and Institutions
(IFLA) (2005) Guidelines for library services to prisoners (3rd Ed.).
IFLA Professional Reports No. 92.
Kurten-Vartio S (2007). Women in prison: social, economic and
cultural rights of female prisoners Brussels, European Parliament
(http://www.europal.europa.eu/hearings/20070626/femn/kurten Vartio en
pdf, accessed 26 January 2009). 52
Lehmann, V. (2000). The prison library: A vital link to education
rehabilitation, and recreation. Education Libraries, 24 (1) 5-10.
LISWiki (2008). Information behaviour theories. Retrieved on 23rd
January, 2009 from http://liswiki.org/wiki/information-behaviour-theories.
Loucks, N. (2004) 'Women in Prison' in McIvor, G. Women
Who Offend. London: Jessica Kingsley: 142-158
Medina, D. (2000). The importance of prison libraries. Education
Libraries, 24 (1), 17-19.
Nigerian Prison Service (2009). Annual report.
Oreh, C.I (2006) Non- Formal Education Needs of Adult Inmates of
Nsukka Divisional Prison and the Millennium Development Goals. Adult
Education in Nigeria: The Journal of Nigerian National Council for Adult
Education (2)
Penal Reform International (2007). Women in prison: incarcerated in
a man's world. London, Penal Reform International (Penal Reform
Briefing No. 3).
Prison Reform Trust (2006). Bromley briefings prison fact file.
London, Prison Reform Trust.
Sambo, A S.; Usman, S A.; & Rabiu, Nafisa (2017).
"Prisoners and Their Information Needs: Prison Libraries
Overview". Library Philosophy and Practice (e-journal). 1467.
http://di gitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/1467
Saar, M. (2010). Mothers Behind Bars: A state-by-state report card
and analysis of federal policies on conditions of confinement for
pregnant and parenting women and the effect on their children.
Washington, DC: The National Women's Law Center.
Shirley, G. (2003). Correctional libraries, library standards and
diversity. Journal of Correctional Education 54, 70-74.
Shirley, G. (2004). Prison libraries and the internet: Behind the
walls--library services in prison. Retrieved on December, 16th, 2008
from http://www.ala.org/ala/olos/outreachresource/prisoncolumn2.htm.
Shirley, G. (2007). Correctional education libraries acquire
bookmobiles. Interface, 29, (3). Retrieved on January, 25th, 2009 from
www.dllr.state.md.us/ce/lib/celibmatarticles.shtml.
Singer, G. (2000). Prison libraries inside out. Education Libraries
24 (1) 11-16. United Nations Standard Minimal Rules for the Treatment of
Prisoners (1995). New York: United Nations.
Social Exclusion Unit (2002) Reducing re-offending by ex-prisoners,
London: Social Exclusion Unit.
Womboh, B .S.H. (1991). Nigerian prison library services: Status
and needs. Focus on International and Comparative Librarianship 22 (1),
10-15.
Women in Prison Project Group (2007) 'Women in Prison and the
Children of Imprisoned Mothers: a briefing for friends' (Internet)
Available at: http://www.quaker.org.uk/files/Women-in-Prison-A-Briefing-for-Friends.pdf, Accessed 08/03/12
World Health Organization (WHO) (1999). Guidelines on HIV infection
and AIDS in prisons. UNAIDS Publications.
Atanda S. Sambo
atsalsam2006@yahoo.com
Nnebuogor Lauretta OJEI
rettann2003@yahoo.com
Atanda Saliu Sambo,
Federal University of Petroleum Resources, Library
P.M.B. 1221, Nigeria
TEL:080 3856 0334
E-mail: atsalsam2006@yahoo.com
&
OJEI, Lauretta Nnebuogor
Yaba College of Technology P.M.B. 2011Yaba, Lagos
Email:rettann2003@yahoo.com
Table 1: Population and Sample of the Study
Location Number of Number of
Questionnaires Questionnaires
Administered Returned
Prison Akwa-Ibom State 79 64
Prison Bayelsa State 23 23
Prison Edo State 59 52
Prison Cross River State 71 59
Prison Rivers State 68 53
Prison Delta State 57 55
Total 356 306
Source: South-South Prison Service Records and Statistics as
at 2016/2017
Table 2: Distribution of Women in South-South Prisons, Nigeria
Women in South-South Prisons Frequency Percentage
Akwa-Ibom State 64 21%
Bayelsa State 23 8%
Edo State 52 17%
Cross River State 59 19%
Rivers State 53 17%
Delta State 55 18%
Total 306 100%
Table 3: Educational Distribution of Respondents
Qualification of the Respondents Frequency Percentage
Primary School Certificate 101 33%
Secondary School 113 37%
Technical College 24 8%
Polytechnic 33 11%
College of Education (NCE) 19 6%
University Degree (s) 16 5%
Total 306 100%
Table 4: Information Needs of the Prisoners Women
Information Needs Frequency Percentage
Rights in the prison 187 61%
Family/friends 251 82%
Life after prison 263 86%
Medical information 299 98%
Security information 297 97%
Information on legal issues 221 72%
Financial information 257 84%
Education information 297 97%
Skill acquisition 109 36%
Spiritual and moral 263 86%
Others 67 22%
Table 5: South- South Prison Libraries Condition
Prison libraries condition Frequency Percentage
Adequate 61 20%
Inadequate 214 70%
No response 31 10%
Total 306 100%
Table 6: Ways of Meeting Information Needs of Women in Prison
Sources Frequency Percentage
Library 42 14%
Family/Friends 205 67%
Counselling 223 73%
Radio/Television broad cast 51 17%
Church/mosque 205 67%
Books/Newspaper/magazine 63 21%
Physician/Nurses 179 58%
Prison staff 97 32%
Others 31 10%
Table 7: Problems Confronting Women in Prisons
Problems Frequency Percentage
Congestion 293 96%
Sexual abuse 231 75%
Lack of medication and health care 278 91%
Poor funding of the prison 291 95%
Lack of training 203 66%
Illegal activities 167 55%
Lack of hygiene 293 96%
Lack of accommodation after release 238 78%
Lack of time to interaction with 235 77%
family/friends
Mental health problem 187 61%
Lack of security 271 89%
Excessive prolonged use and pre-trial 231 75%
detention
Lack of special treatment for women 203 66%
Lack of policies to protect pregnant women 115 38%
Lack of babies care 105 34%
Others 73 24%
COPYRIGHT 2018 University of Idaho Library
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2018 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.