RESEARCH OUTPUTS OF STATE GOVERNMENT UNIVERSITIES OF ODISHA: A BIBLIOMETRIC STUDY.
Satpathy, Sunil Kumar ; Sa, Manoj Kumar
RESEARCH OUTPUTS OF STATE GOVERNMENT UNIVERSITIES OF ODISHA: A BIBLIOMETRIC STUDY.
Introduction
Bibliomertic study is one of the most promising areas of research
activities in the field of Library and Information Science and has
become very popular with the development of various citation databases.
Universities being the premier institutions in the field of higher
education apart from normal teaching must contribute their research
outputs for the benefits of society since large amount of public money
are utilized to carry out various research works. Bibliomertic study
facilitates the analysis of research outputs of researchers from various
aspects. There are many government and private universities, autonomous
institutions including technical institutions in Odisha. Among these,
the present study covers only six state government universities such as
Utkal University, Bhubaneswar; Sambalpur University, Burla; Berhampur
University, Berhampur; North Orissa University, Baripada; Revenshaw
University, Cuttack and Fakir Mohan University, Balasore.
Literature Review
Koganuramah, M. M, Angadi, M. & Kademani,B. S (2002) had
carried out a research on Bibliometric dimension of innovation
communication productivity of Tata Institute of Social Sciences, which
reveals the domination of single author contributing 613 publications
out of 663 publications. Maharana, R. K & Das, P. (2013) Analyzed
447 number of publications contributed by the researcher of Utkal
University during 2008-2012. It revealed that Annual average growth of
Utkal University during the study was 8.77% as well as they noticed that
three authored publications (29.75%) dominated during the period of
study followed by two authored publications with 20.36%. Maharana, R. K
& Sethi, B. B. (2013) in their study on A bibliometric analysis of
the research output of Sambalpur University's publication in ISI
Web of Science during 2007-11 found that annual average growth rate of
publications of Sambalpur University during the study was 30.53%. Out of
170 publications 47 (27.65%) numbers of publications published under
Chemistry as a subject of research area. Swain, D. K, Rautaray, B. &
Swain, C (2013) In the study Scientimetric dimension of research
productivity KIIT University, Bhubaneswar and found that most of the
publications were contributed by three authors followed by two authors
and four authors respectively where as quite less number of publications
contributed by single authors .Also the degree of collaboration was
0.93.
Chaurasia, N. K. & Chavan, S. B (2014) in their study on
Research output of Indian Institute of Delhi(IIT Delhi) during
2001-2010: a bibliometric analysis found that out of total 6109 number
of publications journal articles were observed as the most favored
document type having 5731 publications followed by proceeding paper with
461 publications and Review with 192 publications . Maharana,R.K &
Pati, S (2014) in their study on Bibliomertic analysis of Fakir Mohan
Universities research output indexed in Scopus during 2008 to 2012 found
that maximum number of four authored paper published during the period
with 29.79% of total publications as well as degree of collaboration is
0.96 during the period of study. Kumar, H. A., Dora, M. & Desai,
A.(2015) analyzed 760 number of publication contributed by the
researcher of Gujarat University during 2004-2013.The study completely
revealed that Journals are the most favored form of publication by the
researcher of Gujarat University. Sa, M. K (2015) made a study on
Research output of institute of minerals and materials technology India
indexed in scopus during 2004-2013: a bibliometric analysis. He found
that average growth rate of publications is 7.43%. In the field of
subject area he found chemistry is the most productive subject area
contributing 144 publications out of 419 publications which is 34.37% of
total publications. Similarly keyword "Article" used maximum
number of time in 82(19.57%) publications where as degree of
collaboration is 0.98 and Journal is the source type of publications.
Siwach, A.K. & Kumar, S (2015) in their study on Bibliometric
analysis of research publications of Maharshi Dayanand University
(Rohtak) during 2000-2013 analyzed 1247 number of publications of which
highest 455 number of publications contributed by the researcher of
Maharshi Dayanand University under Chemistry as the major subject area
of publications.
Objectives of the study
The various objectives of the present study are summarized below.
a) To analyze yearly contribution of publications
b) To recognize most productive authors
c) To find out most preferred subject area of research
d) To highlight contribution of publications by type of document
e) To identify the most productive journals
f) To investigate the most frequently used keywords by the
researchers
g) To know the most productive institutions
h) To study source wise distribution of publications
i) To study authorship pattern
j) To recognize most cited papers
k) To study the Degree of collaboration
Methodology followed for the study
In order to get require data for the study "Scopus" used
as the main source of data provider from where data were retrieved on
dated 5/4/2015 by making advanced search choosing affiliated city option
putting Orissa as affiliated city then limited to the following six
state university namely Utkal University,Sambalpur University, Berhampur
University, North Orissa University, Ravenshaw University and Fakir
Mohan University from the year 2010-2014.The retrieved data i.e. 490
number of publications were exported into MS Excel and then data were
arranged in a organize way based on the objectives of the study to make
analysis of the data .
Scope and limitations of the study
The scope of the present study covers the research productivity of
six state Universities of Odisha namely Utkal University, Sambalpur
Unibersity, Berhampur University, North Orissa University,Ravenshaw
University and Fakir Mohan University which has been indexed in SCOPUS
during 2010 to 2014.The other publications of these universities of
Odisha state which are not included in the SCOPUS has been excluded from
the study
Data Analysis
Yearly Distribution of Publications
Table 1 divulges the yearly distribution of publications by six
state university of Odisha during 2010 to 2014. it is observed that out
of total 490 publications published during the period of study, maximum
170 (34.69%) numbers of publications published in 2011 followed by 128
(26.12%), 117 (23.88%), 50 (10.20%) numbers of publications in the year
2010, 2012 and 2013 respectively where as only 25 (5.10%) publications
published in 2014 which is lowest during the period of study. Further
the average growth rate of the publications is -103 (-105.63%) because
except the year 2011, the trend of publications is in decreasing order.
Most Productive Authors
To find out top productive authors, total count method was used and
equal weightage was given to each author. The analysis of Table 2
reveals that out of 490 numbers of publications R.K.Mishra is the most
productive author with highest numbers of publications i.e.15 (3.06%)
securing 1st rank. It is followed by three authors such as S.K.Sahoo,
S.K. Dutta and B.K.Mishra with 14 (2.86%) publications each securing 2nd
rank. Similarly S.Sahoo, N.N.Das, P.K.Behera, C.K.Chakraborty, S.P.Pati,
and R.C. Mohanty contributed 13 (2.65%) publications each securing 3rd
rank in the hierarchy.S.Panigrahi is the author with 7th rank who
contributed 9 publications (1.84%).
Most Preferred Subject Area
The purpose of subject wise scientific research outputs is to
observe the research trends in specialized subject areas in terms of
research outputs. Table 3 depicts subject wise publications by the
researchers of six universities of Odisha.. "Physics and
Astronomy" is the top subject with 98 (20%) numbers of
publications; followed by "Pharmacology, Toxicology and
Pharmaceutics" with 96 (19.59%); Chemistry with 82 (16.73%);
Engineering with 80 (16.33%); Materials Science with 68 (13.88%) numbers
of publications respectively. Whereas Neuroscience; Nursing and
Psychology are the lowest subject areas with only 1 (0.20%) number of
publication each.
Preferred Types of publications
Table 4 shows the preferred type of publications by research
communities of six state university of Odisha during the study. It is
found that out of total 490 number of publications, article is the most
preferred type with 428(87.35%) number of publications, followed by
Conference Paper with 30 (6.12%); Review with 16 (3.27%) and Book
Chapter with 13 (2.65%) publications respectively. The last preferred
type of publication in this study is Editorial, Letter and Note with
1(0.20) publication each.
Most Productive Journals
Table 5 lists the most productive journals with their rank where
the researchers of six state universities published their research
outputs. The analysis of data reveals that both "Optics
Communication" and "Indian Journal of Physics" are in 1st
rank with 8(1.63%) numbers of publications each; followed by Journal of
the Indian Chemical Society, Tropical Journal of Pharmaceutical Research
and AIP Conference Proceedings are in 2nd rank with 7(1.43%) numbers of
publications each. Similarly Theoretical Physics and Nonlinear Optics
Theories and Models, Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical and Clinical
Research, Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, Indian Drugs,
International Journal of Pharmtech Research, Journal of the Korean
Chemical Society are in 3rd rank with 5 (1.02%) numbers of publications
each. The other journals where researchers have published their research
output are listed in Table-5.
Most Frequently Used Keywords
Table 6 depicts the most frequently used keywords by the
researchers of state universities of Odisha under the study. It is found
that "Article" is the most frequently used keywords having 144
(29.39%) publications followed by "Controlled Study" having 76
(15.51%), Nonhuman having 63 (2.86%), and publications respectively.
Similarly India as a name of a country used in 49(10%) publications
where as "Orissa" which is a state of India used in 28 (71%)
publications. In addition to that "PH" and "Water"
are two different keywords used in only 17 (3.46%) publications which
have been used rarely by the researchers.
Most Productive Institutions
Table 7 shows the collaborative research productivity of the six
state universities of the Odisha under the study. The total numbers of
publications of these universities in this table exceeds 490 because
many publications which are published jointly by authors of two or more
universities, the same publications have been listed more than once in
all universities by SCOPUS. It is found that Utkal University is in top
position contributing highest 185 (37.76%) numbers of publications out
of total 490 publications. It is followed by Sambalpur University with
120 (24.49%), Berhampur University with 92 (18.78%), North Orissa
University with 58 (11.84%) and Ravenshaw University with 41 (8.37%)
numbers of publications. Fakir Mohan University contributed lowest
numbers of publications i.e. 22 which is only 4.49 % of the total
publications.
Source Wise Distribution of Publications
Table 8 depicts the distribution of research publications by
different type of sources. It reveals that out of total 490 number of
publications ,as high as 441 numbers of publications(90%) contributed in
Journals followed by Conference Proceedings with 24 , Books with 13 and
Trade publications with 7 numbers of publications contributing
4.90%,2.65% and 1.43% of total publications respectively. Further only 5
(1.02%) publications contributed in book series which is lowest of its
type.
Authorship Pattern
Table 9 analyzes collaborative publications by six different
authorship patterns. The analysis of data indicates the domination of 3
authored publications contributing highest publications i.e. 137
(27.96%), followed by 4 authored with 112 publications (22.86%), 2
authored and [greater than or equal to]5 authored with 107 (21.84%)
publication each. Further only 16 (3.27%) publications contributed by
single authored and lowest 11 (2.24%) publications contributed by
[greater than or equal to]10 authored.
Most Cited Publications
Citation is tool to measure the impact of research. Table 10 listed
top 10 cited papers. The paper titled "The impact of conservation
on the status of the world's vertebrates" published in Science
is the highest cited paper which has been cited 283 times followed by
"2-Iodoxybenzoic acid (IBX): An efficient hypervalent iodine
reagent" by Satam, V. published in Tetrahedron cited 98 times and
"Geochemical speciation and risk assessment of heavy metals in the
river estuarine sediments-A case study: Mahanadi basin, India" by
Sundaray S.K. published in Journal of Hazardous Materials cited 78
times.
Degree of Collaboration
Degree of collaboration examines the trend in authorship pattern of
publication. Table 11 used K. Subramanian's formula for Degree of
collaboration. It is observed from the table that degree of author
collaboration is 0.97.
DC=[[M.sub.n]/[s.sub.n]+[M.sub.n]] where
DC= Degree of Collaboration
[S.sub.n]=Single Author
[M.sub.n]=Multiple Authors
DC= [474/16+474]
Findings of the study
The findings of the present study are summarized below.
a) It is quite surprising that in spite of continuous growth of
faculty members , full time and part time research scholars of these
universities ,the growth rate of research publications during the study
is -105.63%,which shows a negative trend.
b) Utkal University found the most productive university among the
six state universities of the study with 37.76% numbers of publications.
c) R.K.Mishra is the most productive author contributing 3.06 % of
the total 490 numbers of publications.
d) Physics and Astronomy is the most preferred subject area with
20% of total publications followed by Pharmacology, Taxicology and
Pharmaceutics and Chemistry in 2nd and 3rd rank respectively. Further
Social science subjects remains in the 14th rank .It indicates that
social science researches in these universities is lagging far behind
basic and pure science subjects.
e) Article is the most preferred document type with 87.35% of total
publications which seems to be quite natural.
f) The journals "Optics communication" and "Indian
Journal of physics" are jointly recognized as most productive
journals with 1.63% of publications which also seems to be justified
since Physics and Astronomy is the most preferred subjects by the
researchers of these universities.
g) The keyword "Article" is found to be the most
frequently used keywords by the researchers with 29.39% of total
publications.
h) Journal found most productive source for publication of research
outputs with 90% of total publications which is quite natural. Also the
reason behind this is that research outputs published in journals have
more Academic Performance Indicator (API) Score than other sources.
i) The paper titled "The impact of conservation on the status
of the world's vertebrates" by Hoffmann M.,et al published in
Science. is the highest cited paper which has been cited 283 times.
j) Domination of multiple authors on single author is quite high
with 96.73% of total numbers of publications. It indicates towards
present trends of collaborative research and inters disciplinary
research by the researchers of these universities.
k) Degree of collaborations by the authors of this study is 0.97
Conclusion
Universities being the premier institutions of higher education
should give proper emphasis on research and more and more researches
need to be carried out by the faculty members and research scholars .But
the present study highlights a gloomy picture of the research outputs of
the six old government universities of Odisha with quite less numbers of
research publications which are indexed in SCOPUS. Further the growth of
research publications shows negative trends which are a matter of
concern for all. Hence the state government and universities authorities
need to take necessary steps for creating conducive research environment
in these universities, so that more and more people will take interest
in research and there by numbers of research publications will increase
.Also strict guideline need to be framed for faculty members and
research scholars for quality research publications, not merely to full
fill the promotion criteria but also to serve the society and nation.
References
(1.) Chavan, S. B., & Chaurasia, N. K. (2014). Research output
of Indian Institute of Technology Delhi (IIT Delhi) during 2001-2010: A
bibliometric analysis. International Journal of Information
Dissemination and Technology, 4(2), 141-147.
(2.) Hanumappa, A., Desai, A., & Dora, M. (2015). A
Bibliometrics Profile of Gujarat University, Ahmedabad during 2004-2013.
DESIDOC Journal of Library & Information Technology, 35(1), 9-16.
(3.) Koganuramah, M. M., Angadi, M., & Kademani, B. S. (2002).
Bibliometric dimension of innovation communication productivity of tata
institute of social sciences. Malaysian Journal of Library and
Information Science, 7(1), 69-76.
(4.) Maharana, R. K., & Sethi, B. B. (2013). A bibliometric
analysis of the research output of Sambalpur University's
publication in ISI Web of Science during 2007-11. Library Philosophy and
Practice (e-Journal), Paper 926.
(5.) Maharana, R. K., & Das, P. (2013). Research publication
trend of Utkal University's researchers indexed in Scopus during
2008 to 2012: a bibliometric analysis. Library Philosophy and Practice
(e-Journal), Paper 999.
(6.) Maharana, R. K., & Pati, S. (2014) Bibliometric analaysis
of fakir mohan university's research output indexed in scopus
during 2008 to 2012. e-Library Science Research Journal, 2(3), 1-9.
(7.) Sa, M. K. (2015). Research output of institute of minerals and
materials technology india indexed in scopus during 2004-2013: a
bibliometric analysis. 10th International CALIBER, 198-212.
(8.) Siwach, A. K., & Kumar, S. (2015). Bibliometric Analysis
of Research Publications of Maharshi Dayanand University (Rohtak) During
2000-2013.DESIDOC Journal of Library & Information Technology,
35(1), 17-24.
(9.) Swain, D. K., Rautaray, D., & Swain, D. (2013).
Scientometric Dimension of Research Productivity of a Leading Private
University in India. Library Philosophy and Practice (e-Journal), Paper
926.
Dr. Sunil Kumar Satpathy
Deputy Librarian
National Institute of Technology
G.E. Road, Raipur (C.G)-492010, India
drsksatpathy@gmail.com
Manoj Kumar Sa
Assistant Librarian
KIIT University,Bhubaneswar(Odisha)-751024,India
Email: manoisa100@gmail.com
Dr Sunil Kumar Satpathy
Dy.Librarian,Central Library,National Institute of
Technology,Raipur,India
Manoj Kumar Sa
Assistant Librarian KIIT University,Bhubaneswar(Odisha),
manojsa100@gmail.com
Caption: Fig. 2-: Source wise distribution of publications
Table-1: Yearly Distribution of Publications
Year Publication(N=490) Percentage (%) Growth Rate Growth
%
2010 128 26.12 0 0.00
2011 170 34.69 42 32.81
2012 117 23.88 -53 -31.18
2013 50 10.20 -67 -57.26
2014 25 5.10 -25 -50.00
Total 490 100.00 -103 -105.63
Table-2: Most Productive Authors
No. of
Rank Author Name Publications(N=490) Percentage (%)
1 Mishra, R.K. 15 3.06
2 Sahoo, S.K. 14 2.86
2 Dutta, S.K. 14 2.86
2 Mishra, B.K. 14 2.86
3 Sahoo, S. 13 2.65
3 Das, N.N. 13 2.65
3 Behera, P.K. 13 2.65
3 Chakraborti, C.K. 13 2.65
3 Pati, S.P. 13 2.65
3 Mohanty, R.C. 13 2.65
4 Khandpekar, M.M. 12 2.45
5 Mohanty, P. 11 2.24
5 Ray, R.C. 11 2.24
5 Chand, P.K. 11 2.24
5 Poddar, D.R. 11 2.24
6 Behera, S. 10 2.04
6 Jena, S.N. 10 2.04
6 Pal, A. 10 2.04
6 Nath, R.K. 10 2.04
7 Panigrahi, S. 9 1.84
Table-3: Most Preferred Subject Area
Rank Subject Area Number of Percentage
Publications(N=490) (%)
1 Physics and Astronomy 98 20.00
2 Pharmacology, Toxicology and 96 19.59
Pharmaceutics 96 19.59
3 Chemistry 82 16.73
4 Engineering 80 16.33
5 Materials Science 68 13.88
6 Environmental Science 67 13.67
7 Biochemistry, Genetics and 65 13.27
Molecular Biology
8 Agricultural and Biological 60 12.24
Sciences
9 Medicine 45 9.18
10 Mathematics 40 8.16
11 Chemical Engineering 39 7.96
12 Computer Science 38 7.76
13 Earth and Planetary Sciences 25 5.10
14 Social Sciences 22 4.49
15 Energy 16 3.27
15 Immunology and Microbiology 16 3.27
16 Business, Management and 7 1.43
Accounting
17 Arts and Humanities 6 1.22
17 Economics, Econometrics and 6 1.22
Finance
18 Multidisciplinary 5 1.02
19 Health Professions 4 0.82
20 Veterinary 3 0.61
21 Decision Sciences 2 0.41
22 Neuroscience 1 0.20
22 Nursing 1 0.20
22 Psychology 1 0.20
Table-4: Preferred Document
Number of
Rank Type of Document Publications(N=490) Percentage (%)
1 Article 428 87.35
2 Conference Paper 30 6.12
3 Review 16 3.27
4 Book Chapter 13 2.65
5 Editorial 1 0.20
5 Letter 1 0.20
5 Note 1 0.20
Total 490 100.00
Table-5: Most Productive Journals
Rank Name of The Journals No. of Percentage
Publications (%)
(N=490)
1 Optics Communications 8 1.63
1 Indian Journal of Physics 8 1.63
2 Journal of the Indian Chemical 7 1.43
Society
2 Tropical Journal of Pharmaceutical 7 1.43
Research
2 AIP Conference Proceedings 7 1.43
3 Theoretical Physics and Nonlinear 5 1.02
Optics Theories and Models
3 Asian Journal of Pharmaceutical and 5 1.02
Clinical Research
3 Environmental Monitoring and 5 1.02
Assessment
3 Indian Drugs 5 1.02
3 International Journal of Pharmtech 5 1.02
Research
3 Journal of the Korean Chemical 5 1.02
Society
4 Journal of Hazardous Materials 4 0.82
4 Colourage 4 0.82
4 Research Journal of Pharmaceutical 4 0.82
Biological and Chemical Sciences
4 International Journal of 4 0.82
Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and
Research
4 International Journal of Earth 4 0.82
Sciences and Engineering
5 13 publications has three each 3 0.61
6 61 Publications have 2 each 2 0.41
7 70 Publications have 1 each 1 0.20
Table-6: Most Frequently Used Keywords
Rank Keywords Number of Percentage
Publications(N=490) (%)
1 Article 144 29.39
2 Controlled study 76 15.51
3 Nonhuman 63 12.86
4 India 49 10.00
5 Unclassified drug 41 8.37
6 Infrared spectroscopy 29 5.92
6 Scanning electron microscopy 29 5.92
7 Orissa 28 5.71
8 Priority journal 27 5.51
9 Male 23 4.69
10 In vitro study 22 4.49
11 Animal experiment 21 4.29
12 Rat 20 4.08
13 Animal model 19 3.88
13 Animals 19 3.88
13 FTIR 19 3.88
14 Plant extract 18 3.67
14 Drug formulation 18 3.67
15 PH 17 3.47
15 Water 17 3.47
Table-7: Ranking of Universities
Rank Most Productive Number of Percentage
Institutions Publications(N=490) (%)
1 Utkal University 185 37.76
2 Sambalpur University 120 24.49
3 Berhampur University India 92 18.78
4 North Orissa University 58 11.84
5 Ravenshaw University 41 8.37
6 Fakir Mohan University 22 4.49
Table-8: Source wise Distribution of Publications
Number of
Rank Source Type Publications(N=490) Percentage%
1 Journals 441 90.00
2 Conference Proceedings 24 4.90
3 Books 13 2.65
4 Trade Publications 7 1.43
5 Book Series 5 1.02
Total 490 100.00
Table-9: Authorship Pattern
Year Authorship
1 2 3 4
2010 3 30 37 30
2011 3 38 44 43
2012 8 24 30 25
2013 1 9 21 7
2014 1 6 5 7
Total 16 107 137 112
% 3.27 21.84 27.96 22.86
Year Authorship Total
[greater than [greater than
or equal to]5 or equal to]10
2010 26 2 128
2011 38 4 170
2012 28 2 117
2013 10 2 50
2014 5 1 25
Total 107 11 490
% 21.84 2.24 100.00
Table-10: Most Cited Publications
Rank Title Authors Year
1 The impact of conservation Hoffmann M.,et al. 2010
on the status of the world's
vertebrates
2 2-Iodoxybenzoic acid (IBX): Satam V., Harad A., 2010
An efficient hypervalent Rajule R., Pati H.
iodine reagent
3 Geochemical speciation and Sundaray S.K., 2011
risk assessment of heavy Nayak B.B., Lin S.,
metals in the river estuarine Bhatta D.
sediments-A case study:
Mahanadi basin, India
4 Comparative study of bio- Behera S., Kar S., 2010
ethanol production from Mohanty R.C., Ray
mahula (Madhuca latifolia L.) R.C.
flowers by Saccharomyces
cerevisiae cells immobilized
in agar agar and Ca-alginate
matrices
5 Certain subclasses of analytic Srivastava H.M., 2010
and bi-univalent functions Mishra A.K.,
Gochhayat P.
6 A compact UWB bandpass Ghatak R., Sarkar 2011
filter with embedded SIR as P., Mishra R.K.,
band notch structure Poddar D.R.
7 Studies of dielectric and Pradhan D.K., 2012
electrical properties of a new Behera B., Das P.R.
type of complex tungsten
bronze electroceramics
8 Chemical and microbial Dhal B., Thatoi 2013
remediation of hexavalent H.N., Das N.N.,
chromium from contaminated Pandey B.D.
soil and mining/metallurgical
solid waste: A review
9 Reduction of hexavalent Dhal B., Thatoi H., 2010
chromium by Bacillus sp. Das N., Pandey B.D.
isolated from chromite mine
soils and characterization of
reduced product
10 Organogels: Properties and Sahoo S., Kumar N., 2011
applications in drug delivery Bhattacharya C.,
Sagiri S.S., Jain K.,
Pal K., Ray S.S.,
Nayak B.
Rank Title Source title Cited
Times
1 The impact of conservation Science 283
on the status of the world's
vertebrates
2 2-Iodoxybenzoic acid (IBX): Tetrahedron 98
An efficient hypervalent
iodine reagent
3 Geochemical speciation and Journal of Hazardous 78
risk assessment of heavy Materials
metals in the river estuarine
sediments-A case study:
Mahanadi basin, India
4 Comparative study of bio- Applied Energy 42
ethanol production from
mahula (Madhuca latifolia L.)
flowers by Saccharomyces
cerevisiae cells immobilized
in agar agar and Ca-alginate
matrices
5 Certain subclasses of analytic Applied Mathematics 37
and bi-univalent functions Letters
6 A compact UWB bandpass IEEE Microwave and 36
filter with embedded SIR as Wireless
band notch structure Components Letters
7 Studies of dielectric and Journal of Materials 34
electrical properties of a new Science: Materials in
type of complex tungsten Electronics
bronze electroceramics
8 Chemical and microbial Journal of Hazardous 33
remediation of hexavalent Materials
chromium from contaminated
soil and mining/metallurgical
solid waste: A review
9 Reduction of hexavalent Journal of Chemical 33
chromium by Bacillus sp. Technology and
isolated from chromite mine Biotechnology
soils and characterization of
reduced product
10 Organogels: Properties and Designed Monomers 31
applications in drug delivery and Polymers
Table-11: Degree of Collaboration
Year Single([N.sub.s]) Multiple([N.sub.m])
2010 3 125
2011 3 167
2012 8 109
2013 1 49
2014 1 24
Total 16 474
Degree of
Year [N.sub.s]+[N.sub.m] Collaboration(c)
2010 128 0.98
2011 170 0.98
2012 117 0.93
2013 50 0.98
2014 25 0.96
Total 490 0.97
Fig-1: No. of Publications
No of Publications
No of Publications
2010 128
2011 170
2012 117
2013 50
2014 25
Note: Table made from line graph.
COPYRIGHT 2015 University of Idaho Library
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2015 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.