Active Academics: Standing up for Learning.
Shelton, Steve
Active Academics: Standing up for Learning.
Can improved levels of physical fitness positively impact academic
performance? Are healthy children who feel well more prepared to learn?
Can enough movement accelerate cognition? Are students more engaged with
the teacher and subject matter in activity permissive learning
environments when compared to traditional seated environments? These and
many other questions have been the focus of a growing body of research
in recent years. This literature review briefly examines some of the
more prominent studies and progress reports that have highlighted how
physical activity and improved fitness levels can help students to
maximize their potential to succeed in school.
Examples abound in both the topical literature and research
findings of the link between physical activity and academic progress,
improved behavior, increased attendance and overall engagement with the
teacher and subject matter. After conducting an extensive review of 215
published articles addressing the relationship between physical activity
and academic performance, Castelli et al. (2014) concluded "this
line of inquiry is growing exponentially and that valuable discoveries
about children's health have implications for educational practice,
public policy, and funding priorities" (p. 140). Castelli et al.
(2014) included school attendance, on-task behaviors, standardized
tests, attention, memory, and executive/ cognitive control when defining
the term academic performance. Increased interest in this subject is
timely as children are less active and more physically out of shape than
ever before and as schools are simultaneously facing greater demands
associated with increased academic standards (Shelton, 2009). Two out of
three children are not physically active enough (Let's Move!, 2016)
and "one in three kids in the United States is overweight or
obese" (Castelli, Glowacki, Barcelona, Calvert, & Hwang, 2015,
Introduction section, para. 1). In 2008, Prosser and Jiang reported,
"The evidence demonstrates that overweight and obese children
suffer the same health problems as obese adults and suffer increased
morbidity during adulthood" (as cited in Shelton, 2009, p. 4).
Health problems such as type 2 diabetes and childhood asthma have
resulted from this rapidly developing epidemic (Ehrlich, 2008). Many
schools have indicated a narrowing of the curriculum to devote more time
for instruction in mathematics and reading often at the expense of other
subjects such as physical education (Shelton, 2009). In the Commonwealth
of Virginia, although elementary schools are required to provide daily
recess, time devoted to these periods of physical activity can be
extremely brief and withholding physical activity, including recess, as
a disciplinary tool is not prohibited. Additionally, classroom teachers
are not required to provide physical activity breaks for children (SHAPE
America, 2016).
Because students spend so much time at school each day, schools
have a unique role to play in creating a more active and healthy
lifestyle (Castelli et al., 2015; Let's Move!, 2016). Beyond the
well documented positive benefits of regular physical activity such as
improved circulation and stronger muscles and bones, more school
divisions seem to be embracing this brain-body connection and some have
shown an interest in developing physically active classrooms and
researchers have even documented the reduction in students' time
off-task as well as improved attention and overall behavior particularly
following a physical activity break or recess (Trost, 2009).
Former First Lady, Michelle Obama, launched a national
collaborative in early 2013 to improve the health of our nation's
youth by bringing education, health, government, non-profit, and private
business leaders together to promote physical activity in as many of the
130,000 K-12 schools across the United States as possible, moving away
from a siloed approach to combating staggering physical inactivity and
obesity statistics. Since its inception, Let's Move! Active Schools
has evolved by partnering with 30 prominent organizations to promote the
daily goal of students accumulating 60 minutes of physical activity
before, during, and after school. Currently, more than 14% of U.S.
schools, mostly located in southern cities with higher percentages of
students receiving free and reduced lunch and with a significant number
of African-American students have enrolled in the program. In the recent
2016 publication, Let's Move! Active Schools Progress Report,
several positive outcomes based on related research were highlighted
including better school attendance, improved attention, behavior and
test performance, and less off-task behavior.
Physical activity during the school day is listed as one of five
important components of the Let's Move! Active Schools program and
Korbey (2014) recently reported on the use of standing desks (see image
1 below) as a positive alternative to the "sit down and be
quiet" structure of most classrooms by highlighting the findings of
Mark Benden, Associate Professor at Texas A&M Health Science Center,
who concluded that students (especially obese students) burned more
calories, showed larger improvements in attention and were more engaged
as noted by how often students looked at the teacher, were distracted by
a peer, or made notes on their paperwork. The use of standing desks
combined with wobble chairs, and stability balls has grown in popularity
and appears to have positive anecdotal and intuitive support from
teachers who are using these innovative pieces of equipment (Korbey,
2014).
In summary, after conducting a review of numerous scholarly
articles, progress reports and research briefs, it is clear that the
evolving association connecting physical activity and academic
performance is increasingly being investigated by educational
researchers and neuroscientists alike. While conducting their systematic
review of relevant studies, Castelli et al. (2014) concluded the
following:
Given the body of evidence suggesting that healthy children learn
better, the continued rigorous study of the link between physical
activity and academic performance, along with a targeted dissemination
of results, must transpire for teaching and learning to be maximized (p.
140).
References
Castelli, D., Centeio, E., Hwang, J., Barcelona, J., Glowacki, E.,
Calvert, H., ... Nicksic, H. (2014, December). The history of physical
activity and academic performance research: Informing the future.
Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 79(4),
119-148. Retrieved June 8, 2016, from Education Research Complete
database.
Castelli, D., Glowacki, E., Barcelona, J., Calvert, H., &
Hwang, J. (2015, January). Active education: Growing evidence on
physical activity and academic performance research brief. Active Living
Research, Retrieved June 6, 2016, from http://
activelivingresearch.org/sites/default/files/ALR_Brief_ActiveEducation_Jan2015.pdf
Ehrlich, G. (2008, October). Health = performance. American School
Board Journal, 195(10), 42-44. Retrieved June 12, 2016, from Education
Research Complete database.
Fiore, N. (2014, August 8). The benefits of movement in schools.
Message posted to http://www.creativitypost.com/education/
the_benefits_of_movement_in_schools.
Korbey, H. (2014, October 21). How standing desks can help students
focus in the classroom. Message posted to
http://ww2.kqed.org/mindshift/2014/10/21/how-standingdesks-can-help-students-focus-in-the-classroom/Let's Move!. (2016, March). Let's
move! active schools progress report. Retrieved from
https://static1.squarespace.com/
static/53b1a843e4b0dcbabf4b4b85/t/56f6ec77ab48de2c7c 1
779ab/1459101694419/LMAS+Annual+Progress+Report_Published+March+2016.pdf
SHAPE America. (2016). 2016 Shape of the nation report. Retrieved
from http://www.shapeamerica.org/advocacy/
son/2016/upload/Shape-of-the-Nation-2016_web.pdf
Shelton, S. (2009). Mind games: Let's play with the evolving
association between academic achievement and physical activity. The
Virginia Journal, 30(1), 4-7.
Trost, S. G. (2009, Summer). Active education: Physical education,
physical activity and academic performance research brief. Active Living
Research, Retrieved June 10, 2016, from http://
activelivingresearch.org/liles/ALR_Brief_ActiveEducation_ Summer2009.pdf
Steve Shelton, M.S., Instructor, Physical and Health Education
Teaching, Radford University
Caption: Image 1
COPYRIGHT 2017 Virginia Association for Health, Physical Education and Dance
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2017 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.