Development of Innovation in Field of Precision Agriculture.
Vekic, Aleksandar ; Borocki, Jelena ; Stankovski, Stevan 等
Development of Innovation in Field of Precision Agriculture.
1. Introduction
This paper focuses on innovation in the area of Precision
Agriculture and give reviews of modern solutions which are implemented
for this purpose. Dynamic changes in all areas of human life have
changed the views and ways of doing certain jobs, especially those of
the traditional ones. The effort to reduce the amount of time spent and
investing in a particular area always leads to the rapid development of
innovation. Innovative activity is always inherent in human society, so
many authors try to explain the notion of innovation. Some definitions
of innovation are [1]: Schumpeter (1930) explains innovation "as
process of introducing a new product or modifications brought to an
existing product". Drucker (1954) considers that innovation is
"one of two basic functions of an organization" Simmonds
(1986) theoretical view of innovation is: "Innovations are new
ideas that consist of: new products and services, new use of existing
products, new markets for existing products or new marketing methods,
and that is basic creative process". For Devenport (1991)
innovations are: "Complete a task development in a radically new
way". Authors: Covin si Slevin (1991), Lumpkin and Dess (1996),
Knox (2002) defined innovation as "A process that provides added
value and a degree of novelty to the organization, suppliers and
customers, developing new procedures, solutions, products and services
and new ways of marketing". For Rogers (1998):" innovation
involves both knowledge creation and diffusion of existing
knowledge". For European Union innovations are the basis of future
development so main institution such as The European Commission gave
definition (1999) of innovation as: "Successful production,
assimilation and exploitation of novelty in the economic or social
environment".
According to Thrott (2005): "An innovation is an idea that has
been transformed into practical reality" [2]. Authors Tidd &
Bessant state that "Innovation is driven by the ability to see
connections, to spot opportunities and to take advantage of them"
[3]. Many of huge multinational companies all potential for their
development and growth can find in innovation. For example, Siemens
company state: Innovation is our lifeblood"[4], the founder of
Apple company Steve Jobs, is quoted as saying "innovation
distinguishes between a leader and a follower" [5]. Richard
Brenson, the founder of Virgin Group, said, that: "An innovative
business is one which live breathes "outside the box". It is
not just good ideas, it is a combination of good ideas, motivated staff
and an instinctive understanding of what your customers want" [6].
Strong growth and development of the ICT sector (including software and
hardware) has enabled a high degree of change in all spheres, even in
the field of agriculture. One of the reasons for higher development of
agriculture segment is growing of the global population, and that causes
a changed perspective of development. The concept of technological
innovation is particularly important for the development of Precision
Agriculture. OECD gave the next definition of technological innovations:
"Technological innovations comprise new products and processes and
significant technological changes of products and processes. An
innovation has been implemented if it has been introduced on the market
(product innovation) or used within a production process (process
innovation). Innovations therefore involve a series of scientific,
technological, organizational, financial and commercial activities"
[7]. So product and process innovation are associated with the concept
of the technological innovation.
According to Oslo Manual, these two types of innovation are defined
as [8]:
* A product innovation is the introduction of a good or service
that is new or significantly improved with respect to its
characteristics or intended use. This includes significant improvements
in technical specifications, components and materials, incorporated
software, user friendliness or other functional characteristics.
* A process innovation is the implementation of a new or
significantly improved production or delivery method. This includes
significant changes in techniques, equipment and/or software.
The future brings an opportunity for unimaginable development of
Precision Agriculture, using modern technologies and increasing
improvements of mobile platforms which support this kind of managing in
agriculture production and storage process. It is clear that innovation
is the basis for development of Precision Agriculture, therefore it is
very important to study the possibilities that their implementation can
bring.
2. Methodology
This paper presents insight into the area of Precision Agriculture
with modern solutions and systems, and possibilities for innovation for
this purpose. We collected a data through this research by using
relevant literature and other open sources. We used our own experience
too, collected through development of different solutions and
applications in this field. Data which used for this purpose are from
European Parlament Study about Agriculture and Rural development from
2014. This study is the largest European report about Precison
Agriculture, and the name of the study is: Precision Agriculture: An
opportunity for EU farmers, potential support with the CAP 2014-2020.
The study was developed within Directorate--General for internal
policies, Policy department B--structural and cohesion policies.
3. Precision Agriculture--A new era of agriculture innovation
In the middle of 80s, the notion of Precision Agriculture emerged
and began with sensors for soil matter, and have quickly diversified to
include satellites, aerial, and hand held or tractor mounted sensors
[9]. The world's population has reached 7,5 billion people,
therefore food needs are growing. Limited availability of agricultural
resources and capability of supply chain result in a search for new ways
in the production of agricultural products.
Bearing in mind the digital revolution we are witnessing, it is
clear that most of the answers to some important questions can be found
right in this domain. The technological development in Precision
Agriculture has been rapid since the 90s, and it continues through the
development of the ICT sector. This kind of development has
significantly changed the perspectives of agriculture's future.
Precision Agriculture can be understood as: "An integrated
information- and production-based farming system that is designed to
increase long-term, site-specific and whole-farm production efficiency,
productivity and profitability while minimizing unintended impacts on
wildlife and the environment [10]. This definition understood PA in a
context of "whole farm" management strategy, not in terms of
individual farms or crop fields. It's also common definition:
"PA is form whereby decisions on resource application and agronomic
practices are improved to better match soil and crop requirements as
they vary in the field" [10]. According to this definition, the
main idea is that PA involving management strategy and focus is on the
decision making. The main goal of the concept is to improve production
management and to limited impact of environment, especially in
changeable climatic conditions which are typical of today's life.
This kind of agriculture requests using of modem information technology
and technical solutions, with a goal of providing benefits, such as:
economic, environmental and social.
The objectives of PA can be illustrated:
The primary goal for the development of Precision Agriculture is to
make measurements of important parameters such as: temperature,
humidity, soil moisture and acidity, reduction of pesticides and
fertilizers use, in order to get higher yields and a higher level of
quality. It's very important to satisfy requests of economic and
environmental aspects. For farmers are very important to take care about
basic components of PA [11]:
* Background data--means data about crop production fields and help
to make important decisions. The sources of this data can be: grid soil
samples, detailed soil mapping, aerial photography, topographic maps,
yield maps, soil texture maps, environmentally sensitive areas.
* A recordkeeping system--allows the storage of large amounts of
data that are later used in the process and decision making. Usually,
special software or external data warehouses such as clouds are used for
this purpose.
* Analysis and decision making process--this is a crucial step in
developing Precision Agriculture. It is often necessary to analyze huge
amounts of data and do their systematization. With the development of IT
sector, special web and mobile platforms are developed to perform this
complex task and help in making the decision as simple as possible.
* Specialized implementation equipment--this is precondition to
perform tasks within precision agriculture. Development and innovation
of the modern equipment have been always in the progress, and that
providing more precision data with a higher usage value. Equipment
usually includes: GPS guidance systems, equipment for yield monitoring,
variable rate application equipment, special types of sensors, different
cameras and photo equipment, drones, etc.
* Evaluation and revision--Continuing learning and gaining
experience are inseparable part of the process. This is very important,
especially after harvest season, and that help farmers to create
precision and achievable agriculture plan for the next season.
Within these process components, there are continuous improvement
and innovation. This is essential for maintaining the vitality of the
entire concept of Precision Agriculture. This implies monitoring of the
development of modern and applied technologies and analyzing current
trends. Most innovations in precision agriculture are led by big
agriculture companies, smaller innovative agricultural technology
companies and top agriculture universities and institutes [12].
Innovation in this sphere requires a higher level of investment, but
they are very much in demand until their commercialization and return of
investing funds.
Most of the funds are spent in the development and implementation
of adequate equipment and modern services for its functioning. Their
development plays a key role in achieving innovation goal. In the
following table, we will show the most important technologies used in
the field of Precision Agriculture, their purpose and benefits:
Very important part of the Precision Agriculture concept is the
Remote Sensing Technology. This modern technology provides a huge range
of data which are important for agriculture, such as data about:
temperature, soil, moisture analysis, monitoring of crop growth, yield
forecasting, etc.
This data can be used by national governments, in order to make
important decisions and implement them into their agricultural policy.
Individual farmers can also use this valuable data which are collected
by remote sensing technology, when dealing with their individual crops,
about their health status and how to deal with any problems. It is
especially important that this data allows farmers to make rough
estimates to the final crop yield just by looking at the plant and
health status half-way through the season and taking into account the
climatic conditions up until that point.
Introduction of this technology always requests detailed planning
of agricultural business and making decisions for the next period.
Remote sensing can be used for Precision Agriculture in a number of ways
by providing input on soil and plant condition and variability in the
overall management and decision support system [13]. Remote sensing can
significantly contribute to providing a timely and accurate picture of
the agricultural sector, as it is very suitable for gathering
information over large areas with high revisit frequency [14].
This equipment can provide recorded data in real time. Prior to
seeding, air photos, multi-spectral scanners, or high resolution
satellite imagery can be used to translate results from point soil test
samples, acquired using a grid or stratified sampling scheme, to a
spatial coverage for the whole field [13].
Some possibilities of modern solutions of Precision Agriculture are
illustrated on following pictures:
Optimal combination of shown technologies and services leads to the
positive growth of all the most important parameters that are observed.
Some researchers predict that digital data will be getting collected at
the rate of 40 zettabytes (1 ZB = 40 trillion GB) per year by 2020 [17].
This is a huge potential for the Precision Agriculture, and it is to be
expected that these opportunities will be exploited in the best possible
way. The primary goal of Precision agriculture is to enable the
production of enough food for the growing world population, according to
UN data world population will reach 9,6 billion by 2050 [18].
Development of agricultural technologies requires knowledge (ranging
from broad to specific) and talent in science and entrepreneurship [12].
4. The main benefits of agricultural innovation and EU support
PA nowadays is seen as an "environment friendly system
solution that optimizes product quality and quantity while minimizing
cost, human intervention and the variation caused by the unpredictable
nature" [19]. It's very important to understand the
applicability technologies in Precision Agriculture and to gain
knowledge of how to use them in the best way. Their implementation leads
to more efficient: decision-making process, monitoring soil and plant
parameters, collecting real time data, reducing waste and the chemicals
in the production process, automated field management, increase profit,
protection of the environment, use of labor and resources, adapting to
regulations, etc. For a successful business, farms must increase their
arable land, reduce risk of crop failure, minimize operating costs,
reach the highest price for their products, work on expanding their
market, etc.
The precision farming market is expected to grow, at a CAGR
(Compound annual growth rate), of 13.47% between 2016 and 2022 [20].
Some research shows that implementation of digital technology in
agriculture can increase overall profitability by 55$ to 110$ per acre
(1 acre = 0,40 ha) [21]. The global market for Precision Agriculture is
expected to be around 3.7 billion euros in 2018 [22]. By using the
modern applications and management tools, the farmer can easily obtain
data on profitability and the impact that the application of modern
solutions has on his business and the expected returns. This allows
farmers to gain a higher level of competitive advantage and become more
dominant in the market. It's estimated that over 50 percent of
growers currently engage in some form of Precision Agriculture
Technology [23]. Agriculture retailers have the opportunity to help
their customers by providing them with local expertise on how the
various technologies available today, might best be implemented within
their geography and more specifically within their individual operation
to help them improve their return on investment in the most appropriate
ways [23]. The following table shown relationship between costs and
benefits:
The cost types associated with the implementation of PA are [19]:
1) Information costs, related to the necessary investments in the
technology, including rental fees for specific hardware or machinery;
2) Costs which involving data processing, specific license fees,
software and hardware products for data analysis;
3) Learning costs, mainly due to the additional time required for
the farmer to develop management schemes, calibration of the machinery,
as well as 'lost' opportunity costs due to inefficient use of
the PA technology
The potential benefits from PA can be [19]:
1) Crop yield improvement
2) Optimization of inputs
3) Improvement of management and quality of the work.
One of the most important factors which affects the profitability
of a farm is its size. In Europe, there are 4,500 manufacturers with a
mix of large multinational companies and numerous SMEs producing 450
different machine types with an annual turnover of 26 billion [euro] and
employing 135,000 people directly and a further 125,000 in the
distribution and service network.
The European Union continually develops support programs for the
development of agriculture as the main pillar of its development.
Support programs for development of PA and innovation in this area are
contained in Regulation (EU) No 1305/2013 of the European Parliament and
of the Council of 17 December 2013. Several of them are available for
Member States to support PA development through their R&D programs
[19]:
* Article 17 (Investments in physical assets)
* Article 28 (Agri-environment-climate)
* Article 35 (Co-operation)
* Article 14 (Knowledge transfer and information actions)
* Article 15 (Advisory services, farm management and farm relief
services)
The European Innovation Partnership for Agricultural Productivity
and Sustainability (EIP-AGRI) can play an important role in both
developing and mainstreaming precision farming in the EU. This program
includes: Article 55 (Aims), Article 56 (Operational groups), Article 57
(Tasks). The stated EU report confirmed that Precision Agriculture could
play a substantial role in meeting the increasing demand for food while
ensuring sustainable use of natural resources and the environment. The
Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) is Europe's answer to the need for
a decent standard of living for 22 million farmers and agricultural
workers and a stable, varied and safe food supply for its 500 million
citizens [24]. As a common policy for all 28 EU countries, the CAP
strengthens the competitiveness and sustainability of EU agriculture by
providing Direct Payments aimed at stabilizing farm revenues and
finances projects responding to countryspecific needs through national
(or regional) Rural Development Programs, which also cover the wider
rural economy [24]. The CAP also provides a range of market measures,
including tools to address market difficulties, and other additional
elements such as quality logos, promotion for EU farm products which
complete CAP action to support farmers [24]. The CAP budget fixed for
the period from 2014-2020 provides a total of EUR 408.31 billion, with
EUR 308.73 billion intended for direct payments and market measures (the
so-called First Pillar) and EUR 99.58 billion for Rural Development (the
so-called Second Pillar) [23]. The European Commission promotes
precision farming, mostly via its EUR 78 billion through Horizon 2020
program for research.
5. Conclusion
Innovation potentials in precision agriculture are enormous,
therefore all countries in the world will have to work on strengthening
them, in order to achieve greater competitive advantage in this area, as
one of the main promoters of growth and development. If we take into
account the rapid growth of the population on the planet and the
increased need for food, it is clear that any investment in agricultural
production will be very profitable but also necessary. Accelerated
changes lead to an increase in the number of innovations in all areas of
life, even in agriculture that we know today, as it becomes increasingly
digital. It is very important to manage these innovations effectively in
order to achieve appropriate positive effects in terms of social,
economic and environmental aspects. Innovation usually relates to the
development of new technologies and equipment, development of new seed
types, decision support systems, automation of the business process,
introduction of new methods, education of process participants,
development of management and new business models, etc. A special
subject of research can be to determine the relationship between
investment and yielded benefits, based on detailed analysis and creation
of cause-consequence models. The specific role in the development of
Precision Agriculture has innovation in Remote Sensing Technology. This
technology provides a huge range of data, which can be used for
improvement of agriculture business. These technologies are becoming
more precise, and the quality of the data obtained is increasing. The
growing use of these technologies (especially sensor systems with base
stations and drones) in agriculture is noticeable in all developed
market economies as well as in emerging countries. In further research,
it will be necessary to determine the impact of the application of these
technologies on the observed parameters in the multi-annual framework,
taking into account the changing conditions. Our predictions are that
the development of this area will be very dynamic, with almost automatic
effects on the economy and society, at the level of one country, region
or the whole world. The European Union is a good example of how much
attention needs to be given to the development of agriculture. This
process is followed by the number of regulations, development and
support programs without which the entire system would not be functional
and that requires the investment of enormous assets in order to achieve
the set goals. All Member States have an important role in this project.
It is necessary to establish a clear mechanism for overcoming the
obstacles that accompany this complex process. It will be very
interesting to see which further moves will be in terms of defining
agriculture policy and their effects in the future. We expect to see in
the future: the emergence of new and improved software and hardware
systems to support all operations within precision agriculture, the
emergence of new partnerships, the development of new agricultural
crops, new harvesting approaches, etc.
DOI: 10.2507/28th.daaam.proceedings.111
6. Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge the financial support of the Ministry of
Education and Science of the Republic of Serbia, within the Project No.
47028.
7. References
[1] Popa, L. I.; Preda, G. & Boldea, M. (2010). A theoretical
approach of the concept of innovation, Managerial Challenges of the
Contemporary Society, Vol.1, pp. 151-156, ISSN: 2069-4229.
[2] Trott, P. (2008). Innovation management and new product
development, Prentice Hall, ISBN: 9780273713159, London.
[3] Tidd, J. Bessant, J. (2016). Managing innovation: Integrating
technological, market and organizational change, Wiley, ISBN:
978-1-118-36063-7, London.
[4] http://www.siemens.dz/en/about/innovation.htm, (2017). Accessed
on: 2017-07-07.
[5] http://www.denverleadership.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/AR10_11.pdf, (2011). Accessed on: 2017-07-07.
[6] Fitzgerald, B. Wynn, E. (2004). IT innovation for adaptability
and competitiveness, Kluwer Academic Publisher, ISBN: 978-1-4020-7999-3,
Boston.
[7] OECD, Oslo manual. (1993). The Measurement of Scientific and
Technical Activities, ISSN: 1990-0414, Available from:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/19900414, Accessed on: 2017-07-07.
[8] Palcic, I.; Koren, R & Buchmeister, B. (2014). Technical
Innovation Concepts is Slovenia Manufacturing Companies, 25th DAAAM
International Symposium on Intelligent Manufacturing and Automation,
DAAAM 2014, Procedia Engineering 100 (2015), Katalinic, B. (Ed),
Published by DAAAM International, pp.141-149, Vienna, Austria.
[9] Mulla, J. D. (2013). Twenty five years of remote sensing in
precision agriculture: Key advances and remaining knowledge gaps,
Biosystems engineering, Vol. 114, Issue 4, pp. 358-371, ISSN: 1537-5110.
[10] Whelan, B. Taylor, J. (2013). Precision Agriculture for Grain
production systems, CSIRO PUBLISHING, ISBN: 978-0643107472, Collingwood
VIC.
[11] USDA, NRCS, East National Support Center, Soil Quality
National Technology Development team. (2007), Precision Agriculture:
NRCS Support for Emerging Technologies, Agronomy Technical Note No.1,
Available from https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/Internet/FSE_DOCUMENTS/stelprdb1043474.pdf, Accessed on: 2017-09-07.
[12] Es Van, H. Woodard, J. (2017). Innovation in Agriculture and
Food Systems in the Digital Age, In: The Global Innovation Index 2017-
Innovation Feeding the World, pp. 97-104. Cornell University, INSEAD,
and the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), ISBN:
979-10-95870-04-3.
[13] Brisco, B. Brown, R.J. Hirose, T. McNairn, H. & Staenz, K.
(2014). Precision Agriculture and the Role of Remote Sensing: A Review,
Canadian Journal of Remote Sensing, pp. 315-327
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/07038992.1998.10855254
[14] Atzberger, C. (2013). Advances in Remote Sensing of
Agriculture: Context Description, Existing Operational Monitoring
Systems and Major Information Needs, Remote Sensing, pp. 949-981, ISSN
2072-4292.
[15] http://www.homburg-holland.com/nieuws/homburg-holland-on-tour-2016, (2016). Accessed on: 2017-09-27.
[16] http://panamaadvisoryinternationalgroup.com/blog/news-from-panama/drones-in-agriculture/, (2017). Accessed on: 2017-09-27.
[17] Tien, J. M. (2013). Big Data: Unleashing Information, Journal
of Systems Science and Systems Engineering, Vol. 22, No.2, pp. 127-151,
ISSN: 1004-3756.
[18] Roser, M. Ortiz-Ospina, E. (2017). World population growth,
Our world in data, Available from:
https://ourworldindata.org/world-population-growth/, Accessed on:
2017-09-27.
[19] European Parlament (2014). Precision agriculture: An
opportunity for EU farmers--potential support with the CAP 2014-2020,
Publication office, ISBN: 978-92-823-5575-6.
[20] http://www.marketsandmarkets.com/Market-Reports/precision-farming-market-1243.html, (2017). Accessed on: 2017-09-29.
[21] https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/Accenture/ConversionAssets/DotCom/Documents/Global/PDF/Digital_3/
Accenture-Digital-Agriculture-Point-of-View.pdf, (2017). Accessed on:
2017-09-29.
[22] https://www.statista.com/statistics/720062/market-value-smart-agriculture-worldwide/, (2017). Accessed on: 201730- 09.
[23] http://inthefurrow.com/benefits-precision-agriculture/ ,
(2017). Accessed on : 2017-09-30.
[24] https://ec.europa.eu/agriculture/sites/agriculture/files/cap-in-your-country/pdf/cz_en.pdf , (2016). Accessed on: 2017-09-30.
Aleksandar Vekic (a), Jelena Borocki (a), Stevan Stankovski (a)
& Gordana Ostojic (a)
(a) University of Novi Sad, Faculty of Technical Sciences, Trg
Dositeja Obradovica 6, 21000 Novi Sad, Republic of Serbia
Caption: Fig. 1. Objectives of Precision Agriculture (PA) [10]
Caption: Fig. 2. The use of sensors and drones (with spectral
camera) on the crop filed for Geothermal analysis [15] [16]
Table 1. Enabling technologies for Precision Agriculture [12]
Type of technology Purpose and benefits
Computational Use data to develop
decision tools recommendations for management
and optimize multitudes of
farm tasks.
Provide efficient,
The cloud inexpensive, and centralized
data storage, computation, and
communication to support farm
management.
Sensors Gather information on the
functioning of equipment and
farm resources to support
management decisions
Robots Implement tasks with
efficiency and minimal human
labour.
Digital communication Allow frequent, real-time
tools (mobile, communication between farm
broadband, LPWAN) resources, workers, managers,
and computational resources in
support of management
Provide precise location of
Geo-locationing farm resources (field
(GPS, RTK) equipment, animals, etc.),
often combined with
measurements (yield, etc.), or
used to steer equipment to
locations.
Use computerized mapping to
Geographic information aid inventory management and
systems to make geographical crop
input prescriptions
(fertilizer, etc.).
Employ sensors and GPS on
Yield monitors harvesters to continually
measure harvest rate and make
yield maps that allow for
identification of local yield
variability.
Precision soil Sample soil at high spatial
sampling resolution (in zones) to
detect and manage fertility
patterns in fields.
Measure light reflectance of
Spectral reflectance soil or crop using satellite,
sensing (proximal airplane, or UAS, imaging, or
and remote) field equipment/mounted
sensors, to make
determinations on soil
patterns, crop, or Animal
performance, or on nutrient/
pest problems.
Reduce labour or fatigue with
Auto-steering and self-driving technology for
guidance farm equipment (including
robots); can also precisely
guide equipment in fields to
enable highly accurate crop
input placement and
management.
Allow continuous adjustment of
Variable rate application rates to precisely
technology match localized crop needs in
field areas with field
applicators for crop inputs
(chemicals, seed, etc.).
Collect and process field data
On-board computers with specialized computer
hardware and software on
tractors, harvesters, etc.,
often connected to sensors or
controllers.
Transmit identity data with
Radio frequency ID tags attached to production
units (mostly animals) that
allow data collection on
performance as well as
individualized management.
Perform milking or feeding
operations automatically with
Automated milking, robotic systems, often
feeding, and monitoring combined with sensors that
systems collect basic biometric data
on animals, thereby reducing
labour needs and facilitating
individualized animal
management.
Table 2. Relationship between costs and benefits, according to basic
components of PA [11]
Costs Benefits
Time is required to Data may identify
collect data or pay a problems and
consultant for the opportunities the farmer
Background data service. Soil sampling was unaware of. This can
generally costs $3-7/a, be particularly true of
but can be considerably low-yielding areas or
more for the more environmentally sensitive
intensive collection. areas where application
Other services from a of crop inputs may cause
crop consultant are problems.
generally based on an
hourly charge.
Software can range from
very little for shareware
Recordkeeping or public domain packages Organized data allow the
to several thousand farmer to make logical
dollars for commercial decisions.
mapping or geographic
information system
programs.
Crop consultants The analysis allows the
Analysis and generally charge $40-80/ farmer to make the right
decision-making ha. economic and
environmental decisions.
Auto-steer: $30,000-
40,000 Light bar Crop inputs can be
Equipment guidance: $3,000-5,000 reduced and the
Yield monitors: $4,000- environment protected.
7,000 Variable rate
spray-fertilizer
controller: $2,000-3,000
COPYRIGHT 2018 DAAAM International Vienna
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2018 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.