Development of Technology for Improving Productivity and Quality of Injection molding.
Park, Hong-Seok ; Dang, Xuan-Phuong
Development of Technology for Improving Productivity and Quality of Injection molding.
1. Introduction
Injection molding is a popular manufacturing technology for making
plastic products. The injection molding process includes three
significant stages: filling and packing stage, cooling stage, and
ejection stage. Among these stages, cooling stage is very important one
because it mainly affects the productivity and molding quality. An
appropriate design of cooling channel reduces cooling time, increases
the productivity, and minimizes undesired defects such as sink marks,
differential shrinkage, thermal residual stress and warpage. Simple and
traditional cooling channels cannot result in an even and effective
cooling performance when the geometry of the molded part is complex.
Conformal cooling channels made by 3D printing method is one of the
solutions for cooling complex part [1].
Conformal cooling channel has drawn great attention to mold
designer and plastic molding researcher. Ferreira and Mateus [2] studied
on rapid soft tooling with conformal cooling channels for plastic
injection molding. Wang et al. [3] introduced an approach to generate
spiral channels for conformal cooling system and concluded that the
cooling channels derived from spiral curves introduce nearly no
reduction of the rate of coolant flow. In literature, there are four
types of conformal cooling channels: spiral conformal cooling channels
[3, 4], zigzag-type conformal cooling channels [4], scaffold type
conformal cooling channels [5], and Voronoi diagram type [6]. Each type
of conformal channel is suitable for a specific case according to the
geometry of the molded part and the decision of the mold designer.
Because of the advancement in metal 3D printing technology, the
application of conformal cooling channels made by solid freeform
fabrication has been becoming popular recently. The conformal cooling
channels system is recognized as one of the best solutions for reducing
cycle time, differential shrinkage, and warpage defects on molded parts
[7, 8]. Jahan and El-Mounayri [9] studied on the way of optimization of
cooling channels parameters for simple cylindrical shape using
simulation and design of experiment. Various researches [9-13] developed
the optimal design for cooling channels that can increase the
effectiveness of cooling system in the injection mold; however, the
optimal design of the cooling channels in the mold has been restricted
by the relatively simple cooling channel configurations. The complex
molded part requires a complicated cooling channel design than simple
mold. In addition, how to design the best conformal cooling channel that
meets the desired requirement has not been address intensively.
The quality of the molded part mainly depends on the skill of the
molding technician. Plasticization, mold filling, and solidification
cooling are invisible processes which take place inside electrical
mechanical components such as the heat barrel, nozzle, and mold [14].
commonly, injection molding parameter selection and adjustments were
based primarily on the experience of the operator. This approach has the
risk of unanticipated outcomes such as short shot, large warpage or sink
mark. Also, the quality of molded part is inconsistent shot to shot. The
technician only gets feedback about the molding quality after the molded
part come out of the injection machine. This means that the only way for
the technician to determine the cause of any molding faults is to check
the molded part after they are produced and then adjust the molding
parameters for the next cycle until an acceptable product is produced.
The incorporation of statistics and the use of design of experiments can
improve the process control setting, but we still didn't know what
is happening in the mold cavity during injection. Therefore, it is
necessary to adopt a real-time smart system that monitors, records, and
controls temperature and pressure signals generated by in-cavity
sensors. The system is integrated with the molding machine control
system. Each molding cycle initiates an accumulation of data which is
stored and refreshed at the start of the next cycle [15].
In this work, we solve a practical problem in injection molding
industry. A complicated plastic car door module as shown in Figure 1 has
been manufacturing. Due to the functionality of the molded part, the
thickness of the molded part is varied. Especially, the thickness in the
two regions with rib (web region) is largest. Therefore, the cooling
time is longest compared to other regions. As the result, the total
cycle time is long. Thus, the product producer wants to reduce the cycle
time. In addition, they also want to ensure the quality and productivity
regardless of the variation of process conditions. Therefore, it is
necessary to develop a monitoring and the intelligent control system
that can automatically find the optimal process parameters and produce a
consistent product quality.
2. The systematic research procedure
To solve the previously mentioned problem, a systematic research
procedure including six steps has been figured out as shown in Fig. 2.
After analysing the problem and the development goal (reduce the cooling
time for improving the productivity), we determined the appropriate
cooling channel type and then designed and optimized of cooling channels
by analytical method. Next, the numerical simulation was done for
verification because the analytical method is based on semi-practical
formulas. After design and simulation, we fabricated the cooling system
with 3D printing technology and then performed the test on the real
injection molding machine. The important steps in the research procedure
for Improvement of cooling efficiency of injection molding are described
in the next sections.
3. Improvement of cooling efficiency of the injection mold by 3D
printing technology
3.1 Analytical calculation
The conformal cooling channel with the spiral form was selected as
the proper cooling channel for previously mentioned injection mold. It
is difficult to determine the cooling channel configuration by intuition
of the designer or by the iteration of simulation. The spiral cooling
channel can be modelled as a simplified equivalent model that can use
the analytical method. In this work, we use the semi-practical formula
to determine the optimal cooling channel configuration. The
configuration including pitch x, depth y and diameter d can be derived
by the equation [16]:
[mathematical expression not reproducible] (1)
where a = [k.sub.p]/[rho][c.sub.p] and Reynolds number [R.sub.e] =
u d/v. The nomenclature of other parameters is listed in Table 1.
[T.sub.E], [T.sub.M], [T.sub.W], [T.sub.C], [k.sub.st], s are ejection
temperature, melt temperature, mold wall temperature, temperature of
water (coolant), thermal conductivity of mold, molded part thickness,
respectively.
It can be seen that the equation (1) shows the relation among
cooling time and geometrical of cooling channel.
Mathematically, with pre-set [T.sub.M], [T.sub.E], [T.sub.W],
[T.sub.C], predefined thermal properties of material, the equation (1)
presents the relation between cooling time [t.sub.c] and the variables
related to cooling channels configuration including pitch x, depthy and
diameter d.
Solving the equation (1) without constraints, multi solutions are
obtained. However, due to the constraint 32.2 - 6x2 [less than or equal
to] x + d [less than or equal to] 32.2 - 5x2 of the design space, the
diameter and the pitch of the cooling channel are selected as 7.0 and
13.9 mm, respectively. We used the analytical results to determine the
geometry of cooling channel. This data was then used to model the
cooling channels for numerical simulation. If the target time to reach
the ejection temperature is not satisfied, the distance from the cooling
channels to the mold surface is fine-tuned and additional simulations
are carried out until the satisfaction is obtained.
3.2 Design and simulation of conformal cooling channels
The conformal cooling system has to be designed based on the
current mold with conventional cooling channels. Because the mold is
large and the molded part is mainly in flat shape, the main cooling
system of the old mold is retained. Two inserts with conformal cooling
channels are added into the mold core (Fig. 4).
To analyse the thermal performance of the original mold as well as
to develop the new cooling system, we used the simulation tool (Moldflow
software). The steady-state cool simulation was used to analyze both the
temperature of the part and cycle averaged temperature distribution in
the mold. The diameter, pitch, and depth of the cooling channels for
building the simulation model were obtained from analytical method.
The simulation results show that the conformal cooling channels
give more even temperature distribution. The temperature in the hot
regions (Fig. 1) is reduced significantly (around 23/28[degrees]C depend
on the position). The time to reach ejection temperature of molded par
is reduced about (23.14-33.57)/33.57 = 31% (when 18 sample points are
taken into account as shown in Fig. 5, the average time to reach
ejection temperature of conventional and conformal cooling channels are
33.57 and 23.14[degrees]C, respectively). This means that the cooling
time can be reduced up to 31%.
3.3 Fabrication of inserts with conformal cooling channels using
metal 3D printing technology
After design and simulation, the two insets were fabricated by
selective laser melting method on MetalSys 150 3D printer with powder
material that has composition as HP 4A(1). One of the insert is shown in
Figure 6. The two inserts were machined and assembled to the mold for
testing their cooling performance.
4. The smart mold system development
During the molding process, there may be undesired change of
process parameters and uncontrolled disturbance. These variations can
result in inconsistence of product quality such as sink marks, short
shot, flash, or large warpage. Therefore, the sensor system has be
installed in the mold cavity in order to monitors, records, and controls
temperature and pressure signals. Base these data, smart molding system
integrated with the molding machine control system will be develop. The
diagram of the smart mold system has been figured out as shown in figure
7. Process monitoring criteria are based on maximum value of pressure
and temperature, minimum value of pressure and temperature, integral,
average value, threshold, and window of pressure and temperature. The
control algorithm for the smart mold system can be fuzzy logic, PID
control and neural network.
There are three issues that will be focused on smart mold system:
(1) Control the temperature of barrel and hot runner:
We will control the temperature of barrel and the temperature of
hot runner to obtain the desired plastic's meld temperature inside
the mold.
(2) Control the injection molding machine:
To make the smart mold in order to assure the quality consistency
of the molded part regardless of the change of injection molding machine
or the variation of environment, the system must be integrated with the
molding machine control system (control injection speed and packing
pressure).
(3) Control the mold temperature:
Mold temperature is very important to the cooling time and the
quality of the molded part. To control the mold temperature, we have to
control the coolant (water). There are two ways:
a) Control the inlet water temperature: lower the inlet temperature
can effectively lower the mold temperature.
b) Control the flow rate: increase the flow rate will cool the mold
better.
Method (a) is has large control threshold (large margin), but it is
expensive and more complex than method (b). Method (b) uses a servo
motor to control the speed of coolant pump. This method simple than
method (a) but the threshold is narrow. For example, we can only change
the mold temperature around 2/3[degrees]C.
5. Research results and discussion
After making the inserts, the testing process was done in order to
verify the research results. The molding process was carried out on an
industrial injection molding machine Toshiba IS2500DF with 2500 tons of
clamping force. The result shows that's the real cooling time can
be reduced from 39 sec to 30 sec (equivalent to 23 %) with the new
cooling channel when using the coolant flow rate 2.25 litter/minute.
There is error between simulation and real experiment due to the
simulation error material properties. In addition, the microstructure
and physical properties of 3D printing material is different from those
of the same metal made by metallurgy. When using the conformal cooling
channels, the appearance (a quality criterion) of the molded part also
looks better than the one made with old cooling channels. The cycle time
is 44 seconds. It is clear that the cooling time is reduced
significantly. The error between simulation model and the real result is
the limitation of this work. It is difficult to get the exact thermal
conductivity data of material after 3D printing. I addition, the
equivalent model is also an approximate approach. Therefore, error
always occur.
6. Conclusion and future work
This work studies on a conformal cooling channels applied in a
medium-size injection mold that makes an automotive part. We improved
the cooling system of an existent mold in order to reduce the cycle time
and improve the quality of molded part. In injection molding, cooling
stage is very important because it account for more than two thirds of
the molding cycle. For that reason, we used spiral cooling channels made
by 3D printing method. It is very expensive to make a large mold by 3D
printing method; therefore, local approach was adopted. As the results,
inserts with conformal cooling channels that is used to cool extremely
hot locations in the mold is an intelligent solution.
The design of conformal cooling channels was done using the
combination of analytic and CAE simulation method. Analytic method was
used to roughly identify the cooling channel parameters and the
simulation method was employed to check and fine-tune the design and
visualize the results. We analysed the current state and performance of
the existent mold so that its drawback was drawn. The literature review
method was also used to approach the state of the art and to decide the
optimal solution. The spiral cooling channel was selected as the best
choice. Selective laser melting method was used to fabricate the
inserts. The real testing results show that the cooling time can be
reduced to 23%. This is a significant improvement in the first phase of
this project. In the next phase of this project, we develop the smart
system for the mold as figured out in Section 4. The intelligent mold is
still on the development process. By using the cavity sensor system on
the second phase of our project, the temperature and pressure at
considered (important) locations in the mold will be monitored; the
intelligent molding control system will be developed and implemented
based on the thermal and mechanical behaviour happen in the mold. The
productivity and the quality of the molding process will be consistent
regardless of disturbance and uncontrolled variations.
DOI: 10.2507/28th.daaam.proceedings.042
7. Acknowledgement
This work is supported by the Ministry of Trade, Industry &
Energy (MOTIE, Korea) under Industrial Technology Innovation Program.
No. 10062677. "For plastic injection molds with 50% improved
cooling efficiency, development of 3D printing equipment & mold
steel powder manufacturing technology having 30 pm grade in
diameter".
8. References
[1] Balc N. C.; Berce P. & Pacurar R (2010). Comparison between
SLM and SLS in producing complex metal parts, Annals of DAAAM for 2010,
Vienna, Austria.
[2] Ferreira, J.C. & Mateus A. (2003). Studies of rapid soft
tooling with conformal cooling channels for plastic injection moulding,
Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 142(2): pp. 508-516.
[3] Wang, Y.; Yu K.-M.; & Wang C.C.L. (2015). Spiral and
conformal cooling in plastic injection molding," Computer- Aided
Design, 63: pp. 1-11
[4] Park, H.S. & Pham N.H. (2009). Design of conformal cooling
channels for an automotive part, International Journal of Automotive
Technology, 10(1): pp. 87-93.
[5] Au, K.M. & Yu K.M. (2007). A scaffolding architecture for
conformal cooling design in rapid plastic injection moulding, The
International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 34(5): pp.
496-515.
[6] Wang, Y., et al. (2011). Automatic design of conformal cooling
circuits for rapid tooling, Computer-Aided Design, 43(8): pp. 1001-1010.
[7] Shayfull, Z., et al. (2014). Potential of Conformal Cooling
Channels in Rapid Heat Cycle Molding: A Review," Advances in
Polymer Technology, 33(1), 2014.
[8] Rahim, S.Z.A., et al. (2016). Improving the Quality and
Productivity of Molded Parts with a New Design of Conformal Cooling
Channels for the Injection Molding Process," Advances in Polymer
Technology, 35(1).
[9] Jahan, S.A. and Mounayri H. El (2016). Optimal Conformal
Cooling Channels in 3D Printed Dies for Plastic Injection Molding,
Procedia Manufacturing, 5: pp. 888-900.
[10] Ahn, D.-G., Park, S.-H. & Kim H.-S. (2010). Manufacture of
an injection mould with rapid and uniform cooling characteristics for
the fan parts using a DMT process, International Journal of Precision
Engineering and Manufacturing, 11(6): pp. 915-924.
[11] Khan, M., et al. (2014). Cycle Time Reduction in Injection
Molding Process by Selection of Robust Cooling Channel Design, ISRN
Mechanical Engineering, 2014: pp. 8.
[12] Rannar, L.E.; Glad A.; & Gustafson C.G. (2007). Efficient
cooling with tool inserts manufactured by electron beam melting, Rapid
Prototyping Journal, 13(3): pp. 128-135.
[13] Park H. & Pham N. (2008). A new approach to conformal
cooling channels in injection molding process. DAAAM International
Scientific Book 2008, pp. 587-602
[14] Miyamoto, S. & Yukutomo H. (2011). Smart Molding
Simplifies Molding Jobs--New Si-V Series Electric Injection Molding
Machines, Hitachi Review, 60(5).
[15] Chrystal, S. (2013). Ensuring Injection Molded Part
Consistency and Conformance through In-Mold Cavity Sensor Technology, in
Precision Engineered Products 2013.
[16] Dang, X.-P. & H.-S. Park (2011), Design of U-shape milled
groove conformal cooling channels for plastic injection mold,
International Journal of Precision Engineering and Manufacturing, 12(1):
pp. 73-84.
Caption: Fig. 1. The plastic door module (for automotive component)
and the temperature distribution of the molded part
Caption: Fig. 2. The research procedure
Caption: Fig. 3. The layout, structure and assembly of insert with
conformal cooling channels in the mold
Caption: Fig. 4. Comparison of time to reach the ejection
temperature between conformal and conventional cooling channels
Caption: Fig. 5. Insert with conformal cooling channel inside was
made by 3D printing technology
Caption: Fig. 6. The diagram of the smart mold system
COPYRIGHT 2018 DAAAM International Vienna
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2018 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.