E-FINANCE - Statistical Data Included
Peter L. MartinSecond quarter earnings will offer tremendous insight. Yes or no?
In the July column, we concluded that the U.S. corporate e-sector had bottomed but economic pressure still loomed overhead, limiting upside performance until better visibility materialized. The performance of the corporate sector has indeed reflected our thesis, rising nearly 30 percent over the past three months but down roughly 10 percent over the past 30 days (as of this writing). The NASDAQ is up almost 15 percent in three months and down more than 5 percent during June.
Outperformance continues to be led by collaboration companies WebEx and Centra. Both firms offer compelling cost savings and business communication efficiencies that have accelerated their adoption rates. Centra is up 254 percent YTD and WebEx is up 216 percent in the past 90 days.
As second quarter earnings are released, we will receive greater insight into how the U.S. economy is affecting the sales cycle. Key indicators include backlog, deferred revenue, accounts receivable, revenue mix, gross margins, and cash flow from operations. Each metric should give an indication of whether training budgets are strengthening or purchase orders are being reduced or deferred. Second quarter earnings reports are likely to provide greater positive visibility to the back half of 2001, which could generate the basis for price performance improvement over the first half of the year (down 10 percent). If earnings reports lack strong positive indicators, we would expect the group to trade down as portfolio managers wait on the sidelines for the risk-reward ratio to improve.
Another factor within the risk-reward decision that portfolio managers must evaluate is the European market for e-learning. When several of the e-learning companies went public in 1999 and 2000, they touted Europe as being the next big marker for their expansion, as Europe is thought to be 12 to 14 months behind the United States in adoption time. Our research shows that Europe poses significant risk. We believe several factors will impact the adoption of online corporate training systems in Europe. These factors include localization, Internet access, cultural barriers, data security, learning modality, and government support--not to mention the possibility that the current economic pressure in the United States could affect Europe by year-end.
Because of those factors, we believe market estimates by the major consulting groups for the adoption of elearning platforms in Europe have been overstated. Although many providers, most notably Saba, have had tremendous success on a one-off basis, the overall impression we've garnered from our research is that things are going to be tougher than expected due to the above issues. Germany and France in particular have employee data protection rules and cultural issues regarding the "time and place" to learn. Other countries lack the communications build-out to offer reliable Internet access, and most European corporations don't have intranets.
Although English is the language of technology, it often doesn't translate well outside of the tech environment into the educational world. For example, the European Union has 15 member states with 11 official languages and the IAA has 30 countries and 33 official languages. Most foreign accounts will require 2-bit and 1 6-byte architecture by an LMS provider, which is currently offered only by a select group of vendors.
Last, Europeans are hesitant to use "universal approaches that originate in America." Culturally, there's a pushback to the adoption of U.S. business practices. In our opinion, the LMS providers will continue to concentrate on English-speaking countries until the issues I described mitigate. That will make bids more competitive.
We believe several of the issues affecting the European market will be tough to overcome and will limit the growth rate of the e-learning industry and its providers. However, European adoption of e-learning is important and shouldn't be overlooked as a business or an investment. We'll continue to monitor the European market as data becomes available. Watch second quarter earnings reports closely for positive or negative signs of the e-market's next move.
Peter L. Martin, CFA, is a senior vice president with Jefferies & Co., San Francisco. He follows various segments within the knowledge services industry, which are broadly categorized under a-learning and traditional education and training.
Price 52 Week Company Rating Ticker Price High eLeaming Centra Software Ince NR CTRA $16.99 $17.31 Vcampus Corp NR VCMP $1.58 $10.38 Skillsoft Corp NR SKIL $34.25 $38.94 insightful Corp NR IFUL $2.70 $3.25 Itc Learning Corp NR ITCC $0.25 $2.22 Webex Inc NR WEBX $26.66 $58.00 Wiley (john) & Sons -cl A NR JW.A $23.65 $26.00 Rwd Tecnologies Inc NR RWDT $3.20 $8.75 Harcourt General Inc NR H $58.19 $62.81 Zi Corp NR ZICA $7.45 $9.44 Saba Software Ince Buy SABA $16.41 $38.81 Smartforce Pub Ltd -sp Adr Buy SMTF $35.23 $57.25 Adobe Systems lnc NR ADBE $47.00 $87.31 Docent Inc NR DCNT $10.00 $27.13 Raindance Communications Inc NR FNDC $1.44 $12.75 Eloquent Inc NR ELOQ $1.23 $9.63 Intranet Solutions Inc NR INRS $38.05 $64.00 Hearme NR HEAR $0.41 $9.25 Polycom Inc NR PLCM $23.09 $72.25 Innodata Corp NR INOD $3.08 $9.25 Interwoven Inc NR IWOV $1 6.90 $68.47 Vignette Corp NR VIGN $8.87 $54.13 Learn2.com Inc NR LTWO $0.20 $3.13 Mentergy Ltd NR MNTE $1.00 $20.50 Digitalthink Inc NR DTHK $7.02 $60.00 Macromedia Inc NR MACR $18.00 $120.88 Documentum Inc NR DCTM $12.92 $63.88 Click2Learn Inc Hold CLKS $1.62 $20.38 Prosofttraining.com inc Hold POSO $1.25 $18.50 Corporate eLearning Average Traditional Airs Corp/wa NR ARSC $2.60 $4.50 New Horizons Worldwide Inc NR NEWH $14.94 $25.88 Learining Tree Intl Inc NR LTRE $22.96 $78.88 Provant Inc Hold FOVT $1.80 $9.00 Corporate Traditiona Ave 110,202 Total Corporate Average 695,603 Indices Russell 2000 $512.47 $545.71 S&p 500 Composite $1,225.1 1 $1,530.01 Nasdaq Composite index $2,161.67 $4,289.06 Mkt 3-Mon Avg Company Low Cap (mm) Trdg Vol eLeaming Centra Software Ince $2.75 $341.6 568,712 Vcampus Corp $0.38 #16.9 10,665 Skillsoft Corp $10.13 $452.1 94,703 insightful Corp $1.25 $29.2 33,043 Itc Learning Corp $0.15 $0.9 2,003 Webex Inc $5.06 $958.7 467,246 Wiley (john) & Sons -cl A $17.90 $1,135.5 44,657 Rwd Tecnologies Inc $2.35 $48.9 18,812 Harcourt General Inc $49.80 $3,214.5 508,157 Zi Corp $3.13 $266.9 66,478 Saba Software Ince $3.56 $632.2 482,094 Smartforce Pub Ltd -sp Adr $18.13 $1,726.7 728,752 Adobe Systems lnc $24.56 11,274.9 4,299,44 Docent Inc $2.75 $277.4 267,871 Raindance Communications Inc $0.94 $59.3 159,311 Eloquent Inc $0.50 $22.5 88,468 Intranet Solutions Inc $14.75 $722.8 553,208 Hearme $0.25 $11.5 175,492 Polycom Inc $10.75 $1,670.3 1,451,54 Innodata Corp $1.88 $70.3 252,232 Interwoven Inc $5.84 $1,812.8 3,844,08 Vignette Corp $3.63 $2,102.6 5,316,10 Learn2.com Inc $0.16 $10.06 175,591 Mentergy Ltd $0.80 $8.2 30,654 Digitalthink Inc $5.34 $200.6 263,095 Macromedia Inc $13.38 $1,012.4 1,378,19 Documentum Inc $5.88 $464.0 779,291 Click2Learn Inc $1.00 $30.8 105,502 Prosofttraining.com inc $1.10 $26.8 348,695 Corporate eLearning Average $986.3 776,348 Traditional Airs Corp/wa $1.10 $29.4 New Horizons Worldwide Inc $11.00 $139.1 47,951 Learining Tree Intl Inc $14.50 $443.0 302,229 Provant Inc $1.72 $39.1 46,877 Corporate Traditiona Ave $162.7 110,202 Total Corporate Average $886.4 695,603 Indices Russell 2000 $419.70 S&p 500 Composite $1,081.19 Nasdaq Composite index $1,619.58 1-Mo. 3-Mo. 6-Mo. 12-Mo. YTD -9.7 121.7 299.1 48.3 254.1 -10.5 49.3 105.3 -82.1 82.5 9.0 63.6 73.1 152.3 80.0 25.9 89.2 61.2 4.9 70.7 15.0 4.5 48.4 -88.5 27.8 29.0 216.2 33.5 NA 23.5 7.9 25.9 7.1 -7.1 7.8 -24.7 -6.9 4.5 -13.2 4.5 0.9 3.1 1.9 3.9 1.8 2.9 12.9 -2.4 -20.0 -9.6 -3.8 97.2 -9.4 -29.8 -10.8 8.3 47.9 -12.8 -34.3 -13.4 4.8 37.9 -24.0 -24.9 -19.5 -22.1 70.6 -23.4 NA -24.5 -13.1 -16.0 -8.4 NA -28.0 56.3 66.7 -1 6.7 -86.1 -31.0 -16.3 45.3 -38.3 -2.3 -34.8 -38.5 -20.0 -36.0 -92.0 -36.0 -30.2 44.4 -38.7 -59.3 -37.5 -52.8 -35.8 -33.0 59.0 -39.5 -18.0 63.9 -53.1 -25.2 -46.6 -13.7 31.2 -55.9 -83.1 -52.4 -32.1 -13.1 -66.2 -90.8 -53.2 -51.4 -47.3 -55.5 -94.9 -55.5 -34.8 -26.5 -67.9 -85.2 -66.6 -30.8 12.7 -72.2 -82.2 -72.0 -24.5 -3.3 -78.5 -68.3 -75.2 0.0 13.3 -82.9 -90.7 -82.6 -53.3 -84.7 -91.4 -92.9 -90.6 -11.0 29.8 -8.0 -37.9 -11.3 68.8 108.0 51.3 -11.5 46.0 -22.8 -9.1 -02 -24.7 0.7 -8.2 12.0 -52.0 -62.0 -53.5 -33.3 -70.0 -59.4 -65.3 -58.0 1.1 10.2 -15.1 -40.9 -16.2 -9.6 27.4 -8.9 -38.3 -11.9 -1.1 13.7 1.8 -3.5 4.0 -4.0 6.3 -8.1 -15.7 -7.1 -5.6 14.6 -16.9 -46.1 -14.0
[Graph omitted]
COPYRIGHT 2001 American Society for Training & Development, Inc.
COPYRIGHT 2001 Gale Group