Introduction
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
funded the Colorectal Cancer Screening Demonstration Program in 2005. To assess
the feasibility of providing community-based colorectal cancer screening, CDC is
conducting a multiple-case study as part of a larger evaluation effort. This
article highlights key facilitators and challenges common to the five programs
studied during the start-up period.
Methods
The multiple-case study that includes all five program
sites is being conducted during the 3-year program as part of process evaluation
efforts. Data collection for program start-up occurred during August 2005
through September 2006. Data include approximately 70 interviews with program
staff and stakeholders, document review, and observations. Both case-specific
and cross-case analyses were conducted.
Results
On the basis of the cross-case analysis, we identified four
factors that facilitated program start-up and four factors that challenged
program start-up. Facilitating factors included 1) pre-existing program
infrastructure, 2) partnerships, 3) clinical expertise, and 4) program
champions. Factors challenging program start-up included 1) contracts with
endoscopists, 2) resources for treating medical complications of screening and
for cancer treatment, 3) administrative barriers, and 4) resource limitations.
Additionally, preplanning was critical, allowing programs to efficiently
initiate activities once funds became available.
Conclusion
The most important facilitator identified was the
ability to build on pre-existing infrastructure, which provided experienced
staff, partnerships, and provider relationships, as well as aided program
integration with other chronic disease programs. Results also suggest that
substantial planning and partnership development can begin before funds are
secured to implement a colorectal cancer screening program.