Background

Despite recent developments in post-graduate family medicine training in Japan, the numbers of junior doctors entering family medicine residencies are still limited. The objective of this qualitative study was to investigate the possible factors associated to the career choice of family medicine, especially in the context of the newly established family medicine programs in Japan.

Methods

From December 2010 to January 2011, we distributed a semi-structured questionnaire about career choice to 58 physician members of the Japan Primary Care Association, and 41 of them responded. Four researchers used the Modified Grounded Theory Approach (Kinoshita, 2003) for three-stage conceptualization.

Results

We extracted a conceptual model of the choice of newly established family medicine as a career in Japan, consisting of six categories and 77 subordinate concepts from 330 variations. The subcategories of personal background affecting the family-medicine career choice were characteristics (“self-reliance,” “pioneering spirit”), career direction (“community/rural-orientedness,” “multifaceted orientation”) and experience (e.g., “discomfort with fragmented care”). We divided the influencing factors that were identified for career choice into supporters (e.g., “role model”), conflict of career choice (e.g., “anxiety about diverse/broad practice”), and the dawn of a new era in family medicine in Japan (e.g., “lack of social recognition,” “concern about livelihood,” and “too few role models”).

Conclusions

Although the dawn of a new era seemed a rather negative influencer, it was unique to our study that the dawn itself could attract those with a “pioneering spirit” and an “attitude of self-training.” Unlike previous studies, the positive factors such as lifestyle and the short residency program were not shown to be part of family medicine’s attractiveness. In contrast, “concern about livelihood” was specific among our respondents and was related to career choice in the dawn period. “Community-orientedness” and “multifaceted orientation” (which have aspects in common with previous studies’ findings) would appear to be universal regardless of cultural and medical system differences. In our study, these universal factors were also found to be part of the attractiveness of family medicine from the practitioners’ viewpoints, and these factors may become great influencers for family medicine candidates.